The chemical and crystallographic events associated with the caries process can be described based on the results from the following studies: (a) effects of carbonate, magnesium, fluoride, and strontium on the physicochemical properties—lattice parameters, crystallinity (crystal size and strain); dissolution properties of synthetic apatites; (b) factors influencing the in vitro formation and transformation of DCPD, OCP, AP (Ca-deficient apatites), FAP, β-TCMP (Mg-substituted), and CaF2; and (c) studies on properties (crystallinity, composition, chemical, and thermal stabilities) of enamel, dentin, and bone.
The dissolution of CO3-rich/Mg-rich/F-poor dental apatite crystals and re-precipitation of CO3-poor/Mg-poor/F-rich apatite in the presence of F- ions in solution contribute to a more acid-resistant surface layer of the caries lesion. Fluoride promotes the formation of less Ca-deficient and more stable apatite crystals. The presence of Ca, P, and F in solution inhibits dissolution of apatite more than does the presence of F alone. Low levels of F in solution promote the formation of (F, OH)-apatite, even under very acid conditions; an increase in F levels causes the formation of CaF2 at the expense of DCPD or apatite, especially in acid conditions. F in apatite and/or in solution suppresses extensive dissolution of dental apatite and enhances the formation of (F, OH)-apatite crystals which are more resistant against acid-dissolution than are F-free apatite crystals.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
APOSTOLOPOULOSA.X., and BUONOCOREM.G. (1966): Comparative Dissolution Rates of Enamel, Dentin, and Bone. I. Effect of the Organic Matter, J Dent Res45: 1093–1100.
2.
ARENDSJ. (1982): Mechanism of Dental Caries. In: Biological Mineralization and Remineralization, NancollasG.H., Ed., Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag, pp. 303–324.
3.
ARENDSJ., and CHRISTOFFERSENJ. (1986): The Nature of Early Caries Lesions in Enamel, J Dent Res65: 2–11.
4.
ARENDSJ., and DAVIDSONC.L. (1975): HPO42- Content in Enamel and Artificial Carious Lesions, Calcif Tissue Res18: 65–79.
5.
ARENDSJ., and JONGEBLOEDW.L. (1980): Apatite Single Crystals: Formation, Dissolution and Influence of CO3- Ions, Red Trav Chim Pays-Bas100: 3–9.
6.
BAUDC.A., and VERYJ.M. (1975): Ionic Substitutions in vivo in Bone and Tooth Apatite Crystals. In: Physicochimie et Cristallographie des Apatites D'Interet Biologique, CNRS 230, Paris, 1973, pp. 405–410.
7.
BONELG., and MONTELG. (1974): Sur une Nouvelle Apatite Carbonatée Synthetique, CR Acad Sci258: 923–927.
8.
BROWNW.E.; GREGORYT.M.; and CHOWL.C. (1977): Effects of Fluoride on Enamel Solubility and Cariostasis, Caries Res11 (Suppl 1):118–141.
9.
BROWNW.E.; MATTHEWM.; and TUNGM.S. (1981): Crystal Chemistry of Octacalcium Phosphate, Prog Crystal Growth Charact4: 59–87.
10.
BRUDEVOLDF. (1962): Chemical Composition of Teeth in Relation to Caries. In: Chemistry and Prevention of Dental Caries, Chap. 2, SognnaesR.F., Ed., Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas, pp. 32–88.
11.
BRUDEVOLDF., and SÖREMARKR. (1967): Chemistry of the Mineral Phase of Enamel. In: Structural and Chemical Organization of Teeth, Vol. II, Chap. 18, MilesA.E.W., Ed., New York: Academic Press, p. 247.
12.
CHOWL.C., and BROWNW.E. (1973): Reaction of Dicalcium Phosphate Dihydrate with Fluoride, J Dent Res52: 1220–1227.
13.
COLLINSR.L. (1959): Strontium-Calcium Hydroxylapatite Solid-solution Preparation and Lattice Constants Measurements, J Am Chem Soc82: 5067–5069.
14.
COOLIDGET.B., and JACOBSM.H. (1957): Enamel Carbonate in Caries, J Dent Res36: 765–768.
15.
CRAWFORDA.W., and DeBRUINH.J. (1983): Concentration Changes in Surface Ca, P, F, Zn, Fe, and Sr During White Spot Formation, J Dent Res62: 964–968.
16.
CURZONM.E.J. (1984): Influence on Caries of Trace Metals Other Than Fluoride. In: Cariology Today, GuggenheimB., Ed., Basel: Karger, pp. 125–135.
17.
CUTRESST.W. (1972): The Inorganic Composition and Solubility of Dental Enamel from Several Specified Population Groups, Arch Oral Biol17: 93–98.
18.
DACULSIG., and LeGEROSR.Z. (1986): Central Dark Lines in Synthetic and Biological Apatites, J Dent Res65:802, Abst. No. 684.
19.
DACULSIG.; LeGEROSR.Z.; JEANA.; and KEREBELB. (1987): Possible Physico-Chemical Processes in Human Dentin Caries, J Dent Res66: 1356–1359.
20.
DARLINGA.I. (1956): Studies of the Early Lesion of Enamel Caries With Transmitted Light, Polarised Light and Radiotherapy, Br Dent J101: 289–297 and 329-341.
21.
DAWESC. (1984): Inorganic Constituents of Saliva in Relation to Caries. In: Cariology Today, GuggenheimB., Ed., Basel: Karger, pp. 70–74.
22.
DEANH.T.; ARNOLD F.A., Jr.;, and ELVOVEE. (1942): Domestic Water and Dental Caries. V. Additional Studies of the Relation of Fluoride in Domestic Waters to Dental Caries Experience in 4,425 White Children Aged 12 to 14 Years, of 13 Cities in 4 States, Publ Hlth Rep57: 1155–1179.
23.
DEDHIYAM.G.; YOUNGF.; and HIGUCHIW.I. (1974): Mechanisms of Hydroxyapatite Dissolution: The Synergistic Effects of Solution Fluoride, Strontium and Phosphate, J Phys Chem78: 1273–1279.
24.
DRIESSENSF.C.M., and VERBEECKR.M.H. (1982): The Probable Phase Composition of the Mineral in Sound Enamel and Dentin, Bull Soc Chim Belg9: 573–596.
25.
DYKESE., and ELLIOTTJ.C. (1971): The Occurrence of Chloride Ions in the Apatite Lattice of Holly Springs Hydroxyapatite and Dental Enamel, Calcif Tissue Res7: 241–248.
26.
ELLIOTTJ.C. (1964): The Crystallographic Structure of Dental Enamel and Related Apatites, PhD Thesis, University of London.
27.
FEATHERSTONEJ.D.B.; DUNCANJ.F.; and CUTRESST.W. (1979): A Mechanism for Dental Caries Based on Chemical Processes and Diffusion Phenomena During in vitro Caries Simulation on Human Tooth Enamel, Arch Oral Biol24: 101–112.
28.
FRANCISM.D., and WEBBN.C. (1971): Hydroxyapatite Formation from a Hydrated Calcium Monohydrogen Phosphate Precursor, Calcif Tissue Res6: 335–342.
29.
GeeA., and DEITZF.R. (1965): Pyrophosphate Formation Upon Ignition of Precipitated Basic Calcium Phosphates, J Am Chem Soc77: 2692–2700.
30.
GRAYJ.A. (1977): Chemical Events during Cariogenesis. In: Proceedings of the Symposium on Incipient Caries of Enamel, RoweN.H., Ed., Ann Arbor: University of Michigan, pp. 19–28.
31.
GRØNP.; SPINELLIM.; TRAUTZO.; and BRUDEVOLDF. (1963): The Effect of Carbonate on the Solubility of Hydroxyapatite, Arch Oral Biol8: 251–263.
32.
GROSSR. (1926): Die Kristalline Struktur von Dentin und Zahnschmelz, Festschr Zahnärztl Inst Univ Greifswald, pp. 59–69.
33.
HALLSWORTHA.S.; ROBINSONC.; and WEATHERELLJ.A. (1972): Mineral and Magnesium Distribution Within the Approximal Carious Lesion of Dental Enamel, Caries Res6: 156–168.
34.
HALLSWORTHA.; WEATHERELLJ.A.; and ROBINSONC. (1973): Loss of Carbonate During the First Stages of Enamel Caries, Caries Res7: 345–349.
35.
HEIJLIGERSH.J.M.; DRIESSENSF.C.M.; and VERBEECKR.M.H. (1979): Lattice Parameters and Cation Distribution of Solid Solutions of Calcium and Strontium Hydroxyapatite, Calcif Tissue Int29: 127–131.
36.
HIGUCHIW.I.; GRAYJ.A.; HEFFERRENJ.J.; and PATELP.R. (1965): Mechanisms of Enamel Dissolution in Acid Buffers, J Dent Res44: 330–341.
37.
HOHLINGH.G., and NEWESELYII (1961): Kristallisationsversuche und Electronenbegung Untersuchungen zur Aufklarung der chemischen Verbindung der ‘Karies-Kristalle’, Dtsch Zahnärztl Z5: 706–710.
38.
INGRAMG.S. (1983): Chemical Changes in the Tooth Surface and Subsurface During Lesion Formation. In: Demineralisation and Remineralisation of Teeth, LeachS.A., and EdgarW.M., Eds., Oxford: IRL Press, Ltd, pp. 243–251.
39.
INGRAMG.S., and SILVERSTONEL.M. (1981): A Chemical and Histological Study of Artificial Caries in Human Dental Enamel in vitro, Caries Res15:393–398.
40.
JOHANSENE. (1963): Ultrastructural and Chemical Observations on Dental Caries. In: Mechanisms of Hard Tissue Destruction, Publ. No. 75, Washington, DC: American Association for the Advancement of Science, pp. 187–211.
41.
KATZS.; BECKC.W.; and MUHLERJ.C. (1969): Crystallographic Evaluation of Enamel from Carious and Noncarious Teeth, J Dent Res48: 1280–1283.
42.
KOULOURIDEST.; KELLERS.E.; MANSON-HINGL.; and LILLEYV. (1980): Enhancement of Fluoride Effectiveness by Experimental Cariogenic Priming of Human Enamel, Caries Res14: 32–39.
43.
LAGERLÖFF. (1983): Effects of Flow Rate and pH on Calcium Phosphate Saturation in Human Parotid Saliva, Caries Res17: 403–411.
44.
LANGDOND.J.; ELLIOTTJ.C.; and FEARNHEADR.W. (1980): Microradiographic Observation of Acidic Subsurface Decalcification in Synthetic Apatite Aggregates, Caries Res14: 359–366.
45.
LEACHS.A. (1959): Some Notes on the Solubility of Enamel and Dentine in Acid, Arch Oral Biol1: 218–232.
46.
LeeD.D., and LeGEROSR.Z. (1985): Microbeam Electron Diffraction and Lattice Fringe Studies of Defect Structures in Enamel Apatites, Calcif Tissue Int37: 651–658.
47.
LeGEROSR.Z. (1967): Crystallographic Studies of the Carbonate Substitution in the Apatite Structure, PhD Thesis, New York University.
48.
LeGEROSR.Z. (1974a): The Unit-cell Dimensions of Human Enamel Apatite: Effect of Chloride Incorporation, Arch Oral Biol20: 63–71.
49.
LeGEROSR.Z. (1974b): Variations in the Crystalline Components of Human Dental Calculus: 1. Crystallographic and Spectroscopic Methods of Analyses, J Dent Res53: 35–40.
LeGEROSR.Z. (1983): Ultrastructural Properties of Human Enamel Apatite. In: Handbook of Experimental Aspects of Oral Biochemistry, LazzariE.P., Ed., Boca Raton: CRC Press, pp. 159–179.
52.
LeGEROSR.Z. (1984): Incorporation of Magnesium in Synthetic and in Biological Apatites. In: Tooth Enamel IV, FearnheadR.W., and SugaS., Eds., Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishers, pp. 32–36.
53.
LeGEROSR.Z.; DACULSIG.; KIJKOWSKAR.; and KEREBELB. (1989): The Effect of Magnesium on the Formation of Apatites and Whitlockites. In: Magnesium in Health and Disease, ItokawaV., and DurlachJ., Eds., London: John Libby and Co., pp. 11–19.
54.
LeGEROSR.Z.; GoP.; VANDEMAELEK.H.; and LeGEROSD.J. (1980a): Transformation of Calcium Carbonates and Calcium Phosphates to Carbonate Apatites: Possible Mechanism for Phosphorite Formation. In: Proc. 2nd International Congress on Phosphorus Compounds, Boston: IMPHOS, pp. 41–53.
55.
LeGEROSR.Z.; KAZIMIROFFJ.; GoP.; and LeGEROSJ.P. (1979a): Characteristics of Human Enamel White Spots, IADR Progr & Abst58: No. 177.
56.
LeGEROSR.Z., and KIJKOWSKAR. (1987): Effect of Solution Composition (Ca, P, Sr, F) on the Dissolution of Human Enamel and Synthetic Apatites, J Dent Res66:276, Abst. No. 1358.
57.
LeGEROSR.Z.; KIJKOWSKAR.; ABERGAST.; LeGEROSJ.P.; and KAZIMIROFFJ. (1986): pH-Temperature Dependence of Calcium Phosphate Formation, J Dent Res65:801, Abst. No. 682.
58.
LeGEROSR.Z.; KIJKOWSKAR.; JiaW.; and LeGEROSJ.P. (1988): Fluoride-cation Interactions in the Formation and Stability of Apatites, J Fluor Chem41: 53–64.
59.
LeGEROSR.Z.; KIJKOWSKAR.; and LeGEROSJ.P. (1984): Formation and Transformation of Octacalcium Phosphate, OCP: A Preliminary Report, Scan Electr MicroscIV: 1771–1777.
60.
LeGEROSR.Z.; LeeD.; QUIROLGICOG.; SHIRRAW.P.; and REICHL. (1983a): In vitro Formation of Dicalcium Phosphate Dihydrate, CaHPO4·2H2O (DCPD), Scan Electr MicroscIII: 407–418.
61.
LeGEROSR.Z., and LeGEROSJ.P. (1972): Brushite Crystals Grown by Diffusion, J Cryst Growth13: 476–480.
62.
LeGEROSR.Z.; LeGEROSR.; and BONELG. (1978): Types of ‘H2O’ in Human Enamel and in Precipitated Apatites, Calcif Tissue Res26: 111–116.
63.
LeGEROSR.Z.; LeGEROSJ.P.; TRAUTZO.R.; and KLEINE. (1970): Spectral Properties of Carbonate in Carbonate-containing Apatites, Dev Appl Spec7B: 3–12.
64.
LeGEROSR.Z.; LcGEROSJ.P.; TRAUTZO.R.; and SHIRRAW.P. (1971): Conversion of Monetite, CaHPO4, to Apatites: Effect of Carbonate on the Crystallinity and the Morphology of the Apatite Crystallites, Adv X-ray Anal14: 57–66.
65.
LcGEROSR.Z., and MORALESP. (1973): Renal Stone Crystals Grown in Gel Systems, Invest Urol11: 12–20.
66.
LeGEROSR.Z.; QUIROLGICOG.; and LeGEROSD.J. (1979b): Consequences of Strontium Incorporation in Apatite, IADR Progr & Abst58A: No. 301.
67.
LeGEROSR.Z.; SILVERSTONEL.M.; DACULSIG.; and KEREBELL.M. (1983b): In vitro Caries-like Lesion Formation in F-containing Tooth Enamel, J Dent Res62: 138–144.
68.
LcGEROSR.Z., and SUGAS. (1980): Crystallographic Nature of Fluoride in Enameloid of Fish, Calcif Tissue Int32: 169–174.
69.
LeGEROSR.Z.; TAHERIM.H.; QUIROLGICOG.; and Le-GEROSJ.P. (1980b): Formation and Stability of Apatites: Effects of Some Cationic Substituents. In: Proc. 2nd International Congress on Phosphorus Compounds, Boston: IMPHOS, pp. 89–103.
70.
LcGEROSR.Z., and TUNGM.S. (1983): Chemical Stability of Carbonate- and Fluoride-containing Apatites, Caries Res17: 419–429.
71.
LITTLEM.F.; DIRKSENT.R.; and SCHLUETERG. (1965): The Ca, P, Na, and Ash Content at Different Depths in Caries, J Dent Res44: 362–365.
72.
MARSHALLA.F., and LAWLESSK.R. (1981): TEM Study of the Central Dark Line of Enamel Crystallites, J Dent Res60: 1773–1782.
73.
McCANNH.G. (1953): Reactions of Fluoride with Hydroxyapatite, J Biol Chem201: 247–259.
74.
McCONNELLD. (1952): The Crystal Chemistry of Francolite and Its Relationship to Calcified Animal Tissues. In: Metabolic Interrelations, Trans 4th Conference, ReifensteinE.C., Ed., New York: Josiah Macy, Jr., Foundation, pp. 428–445.
75.
MILLERW.D. (1905): A Study of Certain Questions Relating to the Pathology of the Teeth, Dent Cosmos47: 18–39.
76.
MORENOE.G.; KRESAKM.; and ZAHRADNIKR.T. (1977): Physicochemical Aspects of Fluoride-Apatite Systems Relevant to the Study of Dental Caries, Caries Res11 (Suppl 1): 142–171.
77.
MORENOE.C., and ZAHRADNIKR.T. (1974): Chemistry of Enamel Subsurface Demineralization in vitro, J Dent Res11 (Suppl 2): 226–235.
78.
NAKAHARAH., and KAKEIM. (1984): Central Dark Line and Carbonic Anhydrase. In: Tooth Enamel IV, FearnheadR.W., and SugaS., Eds., Amsterdam: Elsevier-North Holland Biomedical Press, pp. 42–46.
79.
NANCOLLASG.H. (1982): Phase Transformation During Precipitation of Calcium Salts. In: Biological Mineralization and Demineralization, NancollasG.H., Ed., Berlin: Springer-Verlag, pp. 79–99.
80.
NAVIAJ.M. (1972): Prevention of Dental Caries: Agents Which Increase Tooth Resistance to Dental Caries, Int Dent J22: 427–437.
81.
NEUMANW.F., and NEUMANM.W. (1958): The Chemical Dynamics of Bone Mineral, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
82.
NEWESELYH. (1960): Darstellung von “Oktacalcium Phosphat” (Tetracalciumhydrogentriphosphat) durch Homogene Kristallisation, Mh Chem91: 1020–1023.
83.
NIKIFORUKG. (1961): Carbonates and Fluorides as Chemical Determinants of Tooth Susceptibility to Caries. In: Symposium on the Present Status of Caries-preventive Fluorine-containing Dentifrices, Zürich: p. 62.
84.
PALAMARAJ.; PHAKEYP.P.; RACHINGERW.A.; and ORAMSH.J. (1986): Ultrastructure of the Intact Surface Zone of White Spot and Brown Spot Carious Lesions in Human Enamel, J Oral Pathol15: 28–35.
85.
RETIEFD.H.; HARRISB.E.; and BRADLEYE.L. (1987): Relationship Between Enamel Fluoride Concentration and Dental Caries Experience, Caries Res21: 68–78.
86.
RÖLLAG., and ØGAARDB. (1986): How Important is CaF2 in the Cariostatic Mechanism of Fluoride in vivo? In: Factors Relating to Demineralisation and Remineralisation of Teeth, LeachS.A., Ed., Oxford: IRL Press.
87.
ROWLESS.L. (1968): The Precipitation of Whitlockite from Aqueous Solutions, Bull Soc Chim (France): 1797–1802.
88.
SCOTTD.R.; SIMMELINKJ.W.; and NYGAARDV. (1974): Structural Aspects of Dental Caries, J Dent Res53: 165–178.
89.
SILVERSTONEL.M. (1968): The Surface Zone in Caries and in Caries-like Lesions Produced in vitro, Br Dent J125: 145–157.
90.
SILVERSTONEL.M. (1984): Experimental Caries Models and Their Clinical Implications, In: Cariology Today, GuggenheimB., Ed., Basel: Karger, pp. 237–244.
91.
SPINELLIM.A.; BRUDEVOLDF.; and MORENOE.C. (1971): Mechanism of Fluoride Uptake by Hydroxyapatite, Arch Oral Biol16: 187–203.
92.
TAKUMAS.; OGIWARAH.; and SUZUKIH. (1975): Electron Probe and Electron Microscope Studies of Carious Dentinal Lesions with Remineralized Surface Layer, Caries Res9: 278–285.
93.
TEN CATEJ.M. (1984): The Effect of Fluoride on Enamel De- and Remineralization in vivo. In: Cariology Today, GuggenheimB., Ed., Basel: Karger, pp. 231–236.
94.
TRAUTZO.R. (1965): The Crystalline Organization of Dental Mineral. In: Structural and Chemical Organization of Teeth, MilesA.E.W., Ed., New York: Academic Press, p. 165.
95.
TRAUTZO.R., and ZAPANTAR.R. (1961): Experiments with Calcium Carbonate Phosphates and the Effect of Topical Application of Sodium Fluoride, Arch Oral Biol4 (Spec Suppl): 122–133.
96.
TUNGM.S.; CHOWL.C.; and BROWNW.E. (1985): Hydrolysis of Dicalcium Phosphate Dihydrate in the Presence or Absence of Calcium Fluoride, J Dent Res64: 2–5.
97.
VAN DIJKJ.W.E.; BORGGREVENJ.M.P.M.; and DRIESSENSF.C.M. (1979): Chemical and Mathematical Simulation of Caries, Caries Res13: 169–180.
98.
VOEGELJ.C., and FRANKR.M. (1977): Stages in the Dissolution of Human Enamel Crystals in Dental Caries, Calcif Tissue Res24: 19–27.
99.
WEATHERELLJ.A.; ROBINSONC.; and HALLSWORTHA.S. (1974): Variations in the Chemical Composition of Human Enamel, J Dent Res53: 180–192.
100.
YOUNGR.A., and ELLIOTTJ.C. (1966): Atomic Scale Bases for Several Properties of Apatites, Arch Oral Biol11: 699–707.
