Light Deposition in Dental Hard Tissue and Simulated Thermal Response

Abstract

Near-IR (- 1 um) lasers are presently used for a variety of intra-oral applications including dental hard tissue ablation, although the light intensity distribution and subsequent heating of the hard tissue are still poorly understood. This paper presents a detailed numerical study of the scattered light intensity distribution along with the corresponding predicted thermal response. The calculations are based on recently published scattering and absorption data for dental hard tissue around 1 um. Our simulations indicate strongly enhanced energy deposition and concomitant heating near the dentino-enamel junction (DEJ), mainly due to the higher absorption in dentin. We predict from 10 to 20 times higher internal temperatures near the DEJ compared with the surface. For example, for 50-ms pulses of 5-J energy on a 3-mm-diameter spot (- 1 kW/cm2 or - 50 J/cm2), one can expect internal temperatures near the DEJ in excess of 100°C. Elevated temperatures are predicted to extend far into the dentin, endangering the vitality of the pulp several millimeters below the surface. Our results are compared with published experimental data taken under similar conditions and are found to be in good general agreement. The results of this study do not contradict recently reported ablation of dentin with Nd:YAG laser radiation by contact fiber probes. In this case, the irradiation intensities are 3 to 4 orders of magnitude higher, so plasma formation and plasma shielding of the interior of the tooth are likely.

Keywords

tissue optics energy deposition dental hard tissue visible and near-IR Monte Carlo simulations,thermal response

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Arcoria CJ , Steele RE , Wagner MJ , Judy MM , Matthews JL , Hults DF (1991). Enamel surface roughness and dental pulp response to coaxial carbon dioxide-neodymium: YAG laser irradiation. J Dent 19:85-91.

Arcoria CJ , Frederickson C. , Hayes DJ , Wallace DB , Judy MM ( 1993). Dye microdrop assisted laser for dentistry (abstract) . Proc Am Soc Lasers Med Surg (Suppl 6):17.

Arcoria CJ , Frederickson CJ , Judy MM , Jennett E. , Motamedi M. (1994). Jet-assisted laser tool tooth preparation. J Clin Laser Med Surg 12: 153-157.

Balmer JE , Donaldson TP , Seka W. , Zimmermann JA (1978). Self-focusing and the initial stages of plasma generation by short laser pulses. Opt Commun 24:109-124.

Braden M. (1964). Heat conduction in normal human teeth. Arch Oral Biol 9:479-486.

Bradley DK , Boehly T. , Brown DL , Delettrez J. , Seka W. , Smith D. (1991). Early-time "shine-through" in laser-irradiated targets. In: Laser interaction and related plasma phenomena . Hora H , Miley G , editors. New York: Plenum Press, pp. 323-334.

Dixon JA (1988). What's new in general surgery-Current laser applications in general surgery. Ann Surg 207:355-372.

Duplain G. , Boulay R. , Belanger PA (1987). Complex index of refraction of dental enamel at CO2 wavelengths. Appl Opt 26:4447-4451.

Fried D. , Featherstone JDB , Glena RE , Bordyn B. , Seka W. ( 1993). The light scattering properties of dentin and enamel at 543, 632, and 1053 nm. In: Lasers in orthopedic, dental, and veterinary medicine II. Gal D , O'Brien S , Vangsness CT , White J , Wigdor H , editors. Bellingham, WA: SPIE, pp. 240-245.

10.

Fried D. , Featherstone JDB , Glena RE , Seka W. ( 1995). The nature of light scattering in dental enamel and dentin at visible and near-IR wavelengths. Appl Opt 34:1278-1285.

11.

Ishimaru A. (1978). Wave propagation and scattering in random media . New York: Academic Press.

12.

Jennett E. , Motamedi M. , Rastegar S. , Arcoria C. , Frederickson C. (1994a). Dye enhanced Alexandrite laser for ablation of dental tissue (abstract). Proc Soc Lasers Med Surg (Suppl 6):15.

13.

Jennett E. , Motamedi M. , Rastegar S. , Frederickson C. , Arcoria C. , Powers JM (1994b). Dye-enhanced ablation of enamel by pulsed lasers . J Dent Res 73:1841-1847.

14.

Kruer WL (1988). The physics of laser plasma interactions. Redwood City, CA: Addison-Wesley.

15.

Launay Y. , Mordon S. , Cornil A. , Brunetaud JM , Moschetto Y. (1987). Thermal effects of lasers on dental tissues. Lasers Surg Med 7:473-477.

16.

Meyerhofer DD , Chen H. , Chuang Y-H. , Delettrez J. , Epstein R. , Uchida S. , et al. (1990). High-intensity, short-pulse (1-ps), laser-plasma interaction at 1 um. In: Femtosecond to nanosecond high-intensity lasers and applications. Campbell EM , editor. Bellingham, WA: SPIE, pp. 119-127.

17.

Morlock BJ , Pippin DJ , Cobb CM , Killoy WJ , Rapley JW (1992). The effect of Nd:YAG laser exposure on root surfaces when used as an adjunct to root planing: an in vitro study. J Periodontol 63:637-641.

18.

Motamedi M. , Rastegar S. , LeCarpentier G. , Welch AJ (1989). Light and temperature distribution in laser irradiated tissue: the influence of anisotropic scattering and refractive index. Appl Opt 28:2230-2237.

19.

Neev J. , White JM , Goodis HE , Tran KT ( 1994). Ablation characteristics of nanosecond pulsed Nd:YAG laser on dentin (abstract). J Dent Res 73:341.

20.

Von Almen M. (1987). Laser-beam interactions with materials. Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag.

21.

Wang L, Jacques SL (1992). Monte Carlo modeling of light transport in multi-layer tissues in standard C. Houston: University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center.

22.

White JM , Goodis HE , Rose CL ( 1991). Use of the pulsed Nd:YAG laser for intraoral soft tissue surgery. Lasers Surg Med 11:455-461.

23.

White JM , Neev J. , Goodis HE , Berns MW (1992). Surface temperature and thermal penetration depth of Nd:YAG laser applied to enamel and dentin. SPIE 1643:423-436.

24.

White JM , Goodis HE , Marshall GW , Marshall SJ (1993). Identification of the physical modification threshold of dentin induced by neodymium and holmium YAG lasers using scanning electron microscopy. Scanning Microsc 7:239-246.

25.

White JM , Goodis HE , Tran KT , Ho W. , Kuddler JJ (1994). In vivo pulpal response to Nd:YAG laser on dentin (abstract). J Dent Res 73:318.

26.

Wilson BC , Adam G. ( 1989). A Monte Carlo model for the absorption and flux distribution of light in tissue. Med Phys 10:824-830.

27.

Yu D. , Fox JL , Hsu J. , Powell GL , Higuchi WI (1993). Computer simulation of surface temperature profiles during CO2 laser irradiation of human enamel. Opt Eng 32:298-305.

28.

Yu D. , Powell GL , Higuchi WI , Fox JL (1993). Comparison of three lasers on dental pulp chamber temperature change. J Clin Laser Med Surg 11:119-122.