Unlike other major adult social roles in the United States, parenthood does not appear to confer a mental health advantage for individuals. However, while research has examined parental status differences in emotional well-being, relatively little is known about variations in emotional distress among parents. In this article, we clarify the relationship between parenthood and current symptoms of depression using data from the National Survey of Families and Households. The analyses provide support for our first hypothesis: Parenthood is not associated with enhanced mental health since there is no type of parent who reports less depression than nonparents. We also find support for our second hypothesis: Certain types of parenthood are associated with more depression than others. Additionally, although we find marital status differences in symptoms among parents, there are no gender differences in the association between parenthood and depression. We discuss the implications of our findings for ongoing theoretical debates about the advantages of social role involvement for mental health as well as the meaning of contemporary parenthood in the United States.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndrewsF. M.WitheyS. B.1976.
Social Indicators of Well-Being: American's Perceptions of Life Quality.New York:
Plenum
2.
AneshenselCarol S.FrerichsRalph R.ClarkVirginia A.1981.
“Family Roles and Sex Differences in Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior22:
379–93
3.
BirdChloe E.RogersMichelle L.1998.
‘Parenting and Depression: The Impact of the Division of Labor within Couples and Perceptions of Equity.’
PSTC Working Paper #98–09. Population Studies and Training Center. Brown University, Providence, RI
4.
BlakeJudith1979.
“Is Zero Preferred? American Attitudes toward Childlessness in the 1970s.”Journal of Marriage and the Family41:
245–57
5.
BrownGeorge W.TirrilHarris1978.
Social Origins of Depression.New York:
Free Press
6.
BurtonRussell1998.
“Global Integrative Meaning as a Mediating Factor in the Relationship between Social Roles and Psychological Distress.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior39:
201–15
7.
CampbellAngusConversePhilip E.RogersWillard L.1976.
The Quality of American Life.New York:
Sage
8.
CherlinAndrew1978.
“Remarriage as an Incomplete Institution.”American Journal of Sociology84:
634–50
9.
CherlinAndrewFrankFurstenbergJr1994.
“Step-families in the United States: A Reconsideration.”Annual Review of Sociology20:
359–81
10.
ChodorowNancy1978.
The Reproduction of Mothering: Psychoanalysis and the Sociology of Gender.Berkeley:
University of California Press
11.
ClearyPaul D.DavidMechanic1983.
“Sex Differences in Psychological Distress Among Married People.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior24:
111–21
12.
GlennNorval D.SaraMcLanahan1981.
“The Effects of Children on the Psychological Well-Being of Older Adults.”Journal of Marriage and the Family43:
409–21
13.
GoreSusanMangioneThomas W.1983.
“Social Roles, Sex Roles, and Psychological Distress.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior24:
300–312.
14.
GoveW. R.GeerkenM. R.1977.
“The Effect of Children and Employment on the Mental Health of Married Men and Women.”Social Forces56:
66–76
15.
HewlettSylviaNancyRankinCornelWest2002.
Taking Parenting Public: The Case for a New Social Movement.New York:
Rowman and Littlefield
16.
HewlettSylvia AnnCornelWest1998.
The War against Parents.New York:
Houghton Mifflin
17.
HuberJoan1980.
“Will U.S. Fertility Decline toward Zero?”Sociological Quarterly21:
481–92
18.
HughesMichael1989.
“Parenthood and Psychological Well-Being among the Formerly Married: Are Children the Primary Source of Psychological Distress?”Journal of Family Issues10:
463–82
19.
KandelDenise B.MarkDaviesRaveisVictoria H.1985.
“The Stressfulness of Daily Social Roles for Women.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior26:
64–78
20.
KesslerRonald C.McGonagleKatherine A.MarvinSchwartzBlazerDan G.NelsonChristopher B.1993.
“Sex and Depression in the National Co-morbidity Study I: Lifetime Prevalence, Chronicity, and Recurrence.”Journal of Affective Disorders25:
85–96
21.
McLanahanSara1983.
“Family Structure and Stress: A Longitudinal Comparison of Two-Parent and Female-Headed Families.”Journal of Marriage and the Family45:
347–57
22.
McLanahanSaraJuliaAdams1985.
‘Explaining the Decline in Parents' Psychological Well-Being: The Role of Employment, Marital Disruption and Social Integration.’
Center for Demography and Ecology, Working Paper No. 85–25, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI
23.
McLanahanSara1987.
“Parenthood and Psychological Well-Being.”Annual Review of Sociology13:
237–57
24.
McLanahanSara1989.
“The Effects of Children on Adult's Psychological Well-Being: 1957–1976.”Social Forces68:
124–46
25.
MenaghanElizabeth G.1989.
“Role Changes and Psychological Well-Being: Variations in Effects by Gender and Role Repertoire.”Social Forces67:
59–85
26.
MirowskyJohnRossCatherine E.1989.
“Age and Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior33:
187–205
27.
MirowskyJohn2003.
Social Causes of Psychological Distress.2nd Edition.New York:
Aldine de Gruyter
28.
NomaguchiKei M.MilkieMelissa A.2003.
“Costs and Rewards of Children: The Effects of Becoming a Parent on Adults' Lives.”Journal of Marriage and the Family65:
356–74
29.
PearlinLeonard I.JoyceJohnson1977.
“Marital Status, Life Strains, and Depression.”American Sociological Review42:
704–15
30.
PrestonSamuel H.1984.
“Children and the Elderly: Divergent Paths for America's Dependents.”Demography21:
435–57
31.
PrestonSamuel H.1986.
“Changing Values and Falling Birth Rates.”Population and Development Review
(Issue Supplement: ‘Below-Replacement Fertility in Industrial Societies: Causes, Consequences, Policies’)
12:
17695
32.
RadloffLenore S.1975.
“Sex Differences in Depression: The Effects of Occupation and Marital Status.”Sex Roles1:
249–65
33.
RadloffLenore S.1977.
“The CES-D Scale: A Self-Report Depression Scale for Research in the General Population.”Applied Sociological Measurement1:
385–401
34.
RossCatherine E.JoanHuber1985.
“Hardship and Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior26:
312–27
35.
RossCatherine E.JohnMirowsky1988.
“Child Care and Emotional Adjustment to Wives' Employment.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior29:
127–38
36.
RossCatherine E.JohnMirowskyKarenGoldsteen1990.
“The Impact of the Family on Health: The Decade in Review.”Annual Review of Sociology52:
1059–78
37.
RubinLillian B.1979.
Women of a Certain Age: The Midlife Search for Self.New York:
Harper and Row
38.
SieberSam D.1974.
“Toward a Theory of Role Accumulation.”American Sociological Review39:
567–78
39.
SimonRobin W.1992.
“Parental Role Strains, Salience of Parental Identity, and Gender Differences in Psychological Distress.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior33:
25–35
40.
SimonRobin W.1995.
“Gender, Multiple Roles, Role Meaning, and Mental Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior36:
182–94
41.
SimonRobin W.1998.
“Assessing Sex Differences in Vulnerability among Employed Parents: The Importance of Marital Status.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior39:
37–53
42.
SimonRobin W.2002.
“Revisiting the Relationships among Gender, Marital Status, and Mental Health.”American Journal of Sociology4:
1065–96
43.
SweetJamesLarryBumpassVaughnCall1988.
‘The Design and Content of the National Survey of Families and Households.’
Working Paper NSFH-1, Center for Demography and Ecology, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI
44.
ThoitsPeggy A.1983.
“Multiple Identities and Psychological Well-Being.”American Sociological Review48:
174–87
45.
ThompsonLindaWalkerAlexis J.1989.
“Gender in Families: Women and Men in Marriage, Work, and Parenthood.”Journal of Marriage and the Family51:
845–71
46.
UmbersonDebraGoveWalter R.1989.
“Parenthood and Psychological Well-Being: Theory, Measurement, and Stage in the Family Life Course.”Journal of Family Issues10:
440–62
