The interactions of adolescent peers are the subject of both parental angst and scholarly attention. Peer influence is the most consistent predictor of adolescent drinking patterns when controlling for other background characteristics. This study extends these findings to incorporate a theoretical argument derived from status characteristics theory. Using 2,980 best-friend dyads constructed from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health (“Add Health”), I show that the peer influence process differs by the gender structure of the friendship. Adolescents in same-sex best friendships influence one another mutually, consistent with prior theoretical and empirical approaches to adolescent problem behavior. By contrast, boys in mixed-sex best friendships have influence over their female friends' drinking patterns, while the girls do not have any effect on their male friends' drinking behavior, a finding consistent with status characteristics theory. The results indicate that peer influence models that do not take gender into account in the structure of the friendship misrepresent the unequal influence dynamics between boys and girls.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AseltineRobert1995.
“A Reconsideration of Parental and Peer Influences on Adolescent Deviance.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior36:
103–21
2.
BachmanJ. G.WallaceJ. M.O'MalleyP. M.JohnstonL. D.KurthC. L.NeighborsH. W.1991.
“Racial/Ethnic Differences in Smoking, Drinking, and Illicit Drug Use Among American High School Seniors 1976–89.”American Journal of Public Health81:
372–377
3.
BahrStephen J.HawksRicky D.GabeWang1993.
“Family and Religious Influences on Adolescent Substance Abuse.”Youth and Society24:
443–65
4.
BaileySusan L.RachalJ. Valley1993.
“Dimensions of Adolescent Problem Drinking.”Journal of Studies on Alcohol54:
555–65
5.
BalkwellJames W.1991.
“From Expectations to Behavior: An Improved Postulate for Expectation States Theory.”American Sociological Review56:
355–69
6.
BalkwellJames W.JosephBerger1996.
“Gender, Status, and Behavior in Task Situations.”Social Psychology Quarterly59:
273–83
7.
BanduraAlbert1986.
Social Foundations of Thought and Action: A Social Cognitive Theory.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice Hall
8.
BarnesGrace M.FarrellMichael P.1992.
“Parental Support and Control as Predictors of Adolescent Drinking, Delinquency, and Related Problem Behaviors.”Journal of Marriage and the Family54:
763–76
9.
BarnesGrace M.FarrellMichael P.SarbaniBanerjee1994.
“Family Influences on Alcohol Abuse and Other Problem Behaviors among Black and White Adolescents in a General Population Sample.”Journal of Research on Adolescence4:
183–201
10.
BaumanKarl E.EnnettSusan T.1994.
“Peer Influence on Adolescent Drug Use.”American Psychologist49(9):
820–22
11.
BearmanPeter S.JoJonesUdryJ. Richard1997.
‘The National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health: Research Design.’
Retrieved July 18, 1999 (http://www.cpc.unc.edu/addhealth)
12.
BergerJosephCohenBernard P.MorrisZelditchJr1966.
“Status Characteristics and Expectation States.”
Pp. 2946
in Sociological Theories in Progress,
vol. 1,
edited by JosephBergerMorrisZelditchBoAndersonBoston, MA:
Houghton Mifflin
13.
BergerJoseph M.HamitFisekNormanRobert Z.MorrisZelditchJr1977.
Status Characteristics and Social Interaction.New York:
Elsevier
14.
BollenKenneth A.1980.
“Issues in the Comparative Measurement of Political Democracy.”American Sociological Review45:
370–90
15.
BollenKenneth A.HoyleR. H.1990.
“Perceived Cohesion: A Conceptual and Empirical Examination.”Social Forces69:
479–504
16.
BrowneM. W.CudeckR.1993.
“Alternative Ways of Assessing Model Fit.”
Pp. 136162
in Testing Structural Equation Models,
edited by BollenKenneth A.LongJonathan S.Newbury Park, CA:
Sage Publications
17.
CohenE. G.1982.
“Expectation States and Interracial Interaction in School Settings.”Annual Review of Sociology8:
209–35
18.
DonovanJohn E.RichardJessor1983.
“Problem Drinking and the Dimension of Involvement with Drugs: A Guttman Scalogram Analysis of Adolescent Drug Use.”American Journal of Public Health73:
543–52
19.
DuncanOtis DudleyHallerArchibald O.AlejandroPortes1968.
“Peer Influences on Aspirations: A Reinterpretation.”American Journal of Sociology74:
119–37
20.
EnnettS. T.BaumanK. E.1994.
“The Contribution of Influence and Selection to Adolescent Peer Group Homogeneity: The Case of Adolescent Cigarette Smoking.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology67(4):
653–63
21.
FisherL. A.BaumanK. E.1988.
“Influence and Selection in the Friend-Adolescent Relationship: Findings from Studies of Adolescent Smoking and Drinking.”Journal of Applied Social Psychology18(4):
289–314
22.
GaughanMonica2003.
“Predisposition and Pressure: Mutual Influence and Adolescent Drunkenness.”Connections25:
17–31
23.
GerberGwendolyn L.2001.
Women and Men Police Officers: Status, Gender, and Personality.Westport, CT:
Praeger
24.
GonzalezRichardDaleGriffin1996.
“On the Statistics of Interdependence: Treating Dyadic Data with Respect.”
Pp. 271302
in Handbook of Personal Relationships: Theory, Research, and Interventions,
2nd ed.,
edited by SteveDuckNew York:
John Wiley & Sons
25.
HaynieDana2001.
“Delinquent Peers Revisited: Does Network Structure Matter?”American Journal of Sociology106:
1013–57
26.
HaysRobert B.1988.
“Friendship.”
Pp. 391408
in Handbook of Personal Relationships: Theory, Research, and Interventions,
edited by SteveDuckNew York:
John Wiley & Sons
27.
HaysRon D.EllicksonPhyllis L.1996.
“What is Adolescent Alcohol Misuse in the United States According to the Experts?”Alcohol and Alcoholism31:
297–303
28.
HeimerKaren1996.
“Gender, Interaction, and Delinquency: Testing a Theory of Differential Social Control.”Social Psychology Quarterly59:
39–61
29.
HindelangM.1973.
“Causes of Delinquency: A Partial Replication and Extension.”Social Problems21:
471–87
30.
HirschiT.1969.
Causes of Delinquency.Berkeley:
University of California Press
31.
HumphreysPaulJosephBerger1981.
“Theoretical Consequences of the Status Characteristics Formulation.”American Journal of Sociology86:
953–83
32.
HuselidRebecca FarmerCooperM. Lynne1992.
“Gender Roles as Mediators of Sex Differences in Adolescent Alcohol Use and Abuse.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior33:
348–62
33.
JoreskogKarl G.DagSorbom1993.
Structural Equation Modeling with the SIMPLIS Command Language.Hillsdale, NJ:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers
JoynerKaraUdryJ. Richard2000.
“You Don't Bring Me Anything but Down: Adolescent Romance and Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior41:
369–91
36.
KandelDenise B.1978.
“Homophily, Selection, and Socialization in Adolescent Friendships.”American Journal of Sociology84:
427–36
37.
KandelDenise B.1980.
“Drug and Drinking Behavior among Youth.”Annual Review of Sociology6:
235–85
38.
KaplanHoward B.MartinSteven S.CynthiaRobbins1984.
“Pathways to Adolescent Drug Use: Self-Derogation, Peer Influence, Weakening of Social Controls, and Early Substance Abuse.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior25:
270–89
39.
KennyDavid A.1988.
“The Analysis of Data from Two-Person Relationships.”
Pp. 5777
in Handbook of Personal Relationships: Theory, Research, and Interventions,
edited by SteveDuckNew York:
John Wiley & Sons
LazarsfeldP. F.MertonR. K.1954.
“Friendship as a Social Process: A Substantive and Methodological Analysis.”
Pp. 1866
in Freedom, and Control in Modern Society,
edited by BergerM.AbelT.PageC.New York:
Van Nostrand
42.
MarcosAnastasios C.BahrStephen J.JohnsonRichard E.1986.
“Test of a Bonding/Association Theory of Adolescent Drug Use.”Social Forces65:
136–61
43.
McPhersonMillerLynnSmith-Lovin1987.
“Homophily in Voluntary Organizations: Status Distance and the Consequences of Face-to-Face Groups.”American Sociological Review52:
370–79
44.
MeekerB. F.Weitzel-OP. A. 'Neill1977.
“Sex Roles and Interpersonal Behavior in Task-Oriented Groups.”American Sociological Review42:
91–105
45.
MezzichA. C.TarterR. E.GiancolaP. R.LuS.KirisciL.ParksS.1997.
“Substance Use and Risky Sexual Behavior in Female Adolescents.”Drug and Alcohol Dependence14:
157–66
46.
ReskinBarbara F.2003.
“Including Mechanisms in Our Models of Ascriptive Inequality.”American Sociological Review68:
1–21
47.
RidgewayCecilia1991.
“The Social Construction of Status Value: Gender and Other Nominal Characteristics.”Social Forces70:
367–86
48.
RidgewayCecilia L.BalkwellJames W.1997.
“Group Processes and the Diffusion of Status Beliefs.”Social Psychology Quarterly60:
14–31
49.
RidgewayCecilia L.CorrellShelley J.2004.
“Unpacking the Gender System: A Theoretical Perspective on Gender Beliefs and Social Relations.”Gender and Society18:
510–31
50.
RidgewayCecilia L.LynnSmith-Lovin1999.
“The Gender System and Interaction.”Annual Review of Sociology25:
191–216
51.
RobbinsCynthiaMartinSteven S.1993.
“Gender, Styles of Deviance, and Drinking Problems.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior34:
302–21
52.
RobinsL. N.McEvoyL. T.1989.
“Conduct Problems as Predictors of Substance Abuse.”
Pp. 182204
in Straight and Devious Pathways from Childhood to Adulthood,
edited by RobinsL.N.RutterM.Cambridge, England:
Cambridge University Press
53.
RoomRobin1996.
“Gender Roles and Interactions in Drinking and Drug Use.”Journal of Substance Abuse8:
227–39
54.
Smith-LovinLynnCharlesBrody1989.
“Interruptions in Group Discussions: The Effects of Gender and Group Composition.”American Sociological Review54:
424–35
55.
WebsterMurrayJr.HysomStuart J.1998.
“Creating Status Characteristics.”American Sociological Review63:
351–78
56.
WerkingKathy J.1996.
“Cross-Sex Friendship Research as Ideological Practice.”
Pp. 391410
in Handbook of Personal Relationships: Theory, Research, and Interventions,
2nd ed.,
edited by SteveDuckNew York:
John Wiley & Sons
57.
WhiteHelene Raskin1987.
“Longitudinal Stability and Dimensional Structure of Problem Drinking in Adolescence.”Journal of Studies on Alcohol48:
541–50
58.
WilcoxS.UdryJ. Richard1986.
“Autism and Accuracy in Adolescent Perceptions of Friends' Sexual Attitudes and Behavior.”Journal of Applied Social Psychology16:
361–74
59.
WinshipChristopherLarryRadbill1994.
“Sampling Weights and Regression Analysis.”Sociological Methods & Research23:
230–57
60.
YamaguchiKazuoDeniseKandel1997.
“Influence of Spouses' Behavior on Marital Dissolution and Marijuana Use: Causation or Selection.”Journal of Marriage and the Family59:
22–36
