DNA Fiber Mapping Techniques for the Assembly of High-resolution Physical Maps

Abstract

High-resolution physical maps are indispensable for directed sequencing projects or the finishing stages of shotgun sequencing projects. These maps are also critical for the positional cloning of disease genes and genetic elements that regulate gene expression. Typically, physical maps are based on ordered sets of large insert DNA clones from cosmid, P1/PAC/BAC, or yeast artificial chromosome (YAC) libraries. Recent technical developments provide detailed information about overlaps or gaps between clones and precisely locate the position of sequence tagged sites or expressed sequences, and thus support efforts to determine the complete sequence of the human genome and model organisms. Assembly of physical maps is greatly facilitated by hybridization of non-isotopically labeled DNA probes onto DNA molecules that were released from interphase cell nuclei or recombinant DNA clones, stretched to some extent and then immobilized on a solid support. The bound DNA, collectively called “DNA fibers,” may consist of single DNA molecules in some experiments or bundles of chromatin fibers in others. Once released from the interphase nuclei, the DNA fibers become more accessible to probes and detection reagents. Hybridization efficiency is therefore increased, allowing the detection of DNA targets as small as a few hundred base pairs. This review summarizes different approaches to DNA fiber mapping and discusses the detection sensitivity and mapping accuracy as well as recent achievements in mapping expressed sequence tags and DNA replication sites. (J Histochem Cytochem 49:939–948, 2001)

Keywords

physical mapping DNA fibers hybridization FISH digital image analysis

High-resolution physical maps are indispensable for large-scale, cost-effective gene discovery. The construction of such maps of the human genome and model organisms therefore has been one of the major goals of the human genome project (Collins and Galas 1993). The most common physical mapping strategies implement a bottom-up approach for organizing individual inserts from large genomic libraries into a high-resolution map of contiguous overlapping fragments (contigs). The progress in cloning large, megabasepair (Mbp)-sized genomic DNA fragments in yeast artificial chromosomes (YACs) (Cohen et al. 1993; Olson 1993) has made it possible to rapidly construct low-resolution framework maps based on overlapping YAC clones. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) has proved indispensable for identification of non-chimeric YAC clones and for physical mapping of individual YAC clones onto metaphase chromosomes (Selleri et al. 1992). To generate physical maps with a resolution of 1 Mbp or better, the YAC clones are ordered by combining different complementing analytic techniques: pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) (Vetrie et al. 1993), FISH with interphase cell nuclei or metaphase spreads (Trask et al. 1989; Brandriff et al. 1992; Ashworth et al. 1995), sequence tagged site (STS) content mapping (Green and Olson 1990; Coffey et al. 1992; Weissenbach et al. 1992; Lu–Kuo et al. 1994; Locke et al. 1996), and/or DNA repeat fingerprinting (Bellanné–Chantelot et al. 1992; Zucchi and Schlessinger 1992; Waterston and Sulston 1995; Bell et al. 1995).

High-resolution maps providing ordered sets of cloned DNA fragments at the 100-kb level of resolution are assembled with smaller, more manageable DNA fragments isolated from other libraries. Most groups prefer cloning of genomic DNA in vectors that maintain relatively large DNA fragments without rearrangements, are non-chimeric, and allow easy DNA purification. In general, high-resolution maps are composed of overlapping cosmids (Stallings et al. 1992; Tynan et al. 1992; Nizetic et al. 1994), P1/PAC clones (Pierce et al. 1992; Ioannou et al. 1994), or bacterial artificial chromosomes (BACs) (Shizuya et al. 1992). Assembly of the high-resolution maps requires identification of cloned DNA sequences that contain overlapping regions of the genome (Cheng and Weier 1997). To minimize the effort invested in assembling a contiguous set of clones, clone overlaps need to be determined quickly and accurately. This has been accomplished by various forms of clone fingerprinting [e.g., by identification of common restriction fragment or inter-Alu PCR patterns (Branscomb et al. 1990; Nelson 1991; Patil et al. 1994), by hybridization to bound filter clone arrays (Hoheisel and Lehrach 1993; Locke et al. 1996) or oligonucleotide arrays (Sapolsky and Lipshutz 1996), and by identification of overlapping sequence tagged sites (Green et al. 1991; Aburatani et al. 1996). The development of radiation hybrid mapping (Cox et al. 1990), the availability of large numbers of STS markers, and the construction of extensive bacterial clone resources provide additional means to accelerate the process of mapping a chromosome and preparing clone contigs ready for sequencing. These techniques, although effectively used by the genome community, are limited because they do not readily yield information about contig orientation, extent of deletions or rearrangements in clones, overlap of contig elements, or their chimerism status, nor do they provide information about the extent of gaps in the maps. The precise localization of cloned DNA fragments within much larger genomic fragments and knowledge about the extent of overlap between two clones is needed to assemble high-resolution physical maps. Techniques to rapidly identify minimally overlapping clones and to determine the extent and orientation of overlap expedite the construction of minimal tiling paths and facilitate the sequence assembly process. As demonstrated in this review, FISH can provide this critical information. Furthermore, FISH-based mapping is one of the few mapping procedures without requirements for different clones to overlap to be positioned and ordered (Horelli–Kuitunen et al. 1999).

In early applications of FISH-based clone ordering and assembly of physical maps, Brandriff and colleagues (1991a) took advantage of the high hybridization efficiency and enhanced spatial resolution obtained with decondensed human sperm DNA. In their approach, individual human sperm nuclei were fused with hamster eggs and probes were hybridized to the decondensed DNA of human pronuclei (Brandriff et al. 1991b). The example in Figure 1B demonstrates such decondensation in form of a cloud or network of green signals produced by a biotin-labeled probe directed towards the repeated satellite III DNA in the heterochromatic region of chromosome 9q11. The probe visualized with avidin–FITC fluoresced in green (Figure 1B), and the DNA was counterstained with DAPI emitting blue fluorescence (Figure 1A). The human sperm–hamster egg fusion technique was used successfully to order cosmid clones in preparing high-resolution physical maps for human chromosome 19 (Brandriff et al. 1992; Ashworth et al. 1995).

Figure 1

DNA fiber mapping. (A,B) Hybridization to decondensed sperm nuclei DNA allows probes to be ordered with high resolution. (B) Results of hybridizing a biotinylated probe specific for the chromosome 9-specific satellite III DNA and detection of bound probe molecules with avidin-FITC. (A) DAPI-counterstained DNA. (C) DNA released from cell nuclei can be hybridized very efficiently with non-isotopically labeled probes. A biotinylated DNA probe specific for α-satellite repeats on chromosomes 13 and 21 generated hybridization signals that appear yellow due to overlap between the green probe fluorescence and the red fluorescence of propidium iodide, which was used to counterstain the DNA. (D-G) High-resolution mapping of α-satellite DNA domains using surface spreads of DNA fibers. Unfixed human white blood cells were spread on glass slides, fixed with acetic acid:methanol, and hybridized with a biotinylated probe for chromosome 13/21-specific alphoid DNA. Green signal (D,F) delineating the alphoid tandem repeats appear as beads-on-a-string in the more extended chromatin parts. Images of the propidium iodide-counterstained DNA (E,G) demonstrate hybridization tracks located in DNA fibers of very different size. (H) Lambda DNA molecules bound to an APS-derivatized glass slide were straightened by the receding meniscus during drying and hybridized with biotin- or digoxigenin-labeled restriction fragments which were detected with avidin-FITC (green) and rhodamine-conjugated antibodies against digoxigenin (red). (I) Circular DNA molecules were excised from a PFGE gel and purified by agarose digestion. A small plasmid probe of about 2 kb was mapped onto a single, closed circular BAC DNA molecule. An FITC-labeled probe mix (green) delineates the BAC vector. A small probe (∼200 bp) binds within the vector part near the T7 promoter (red). The BAC molecule was counter-stained by hybridization of a probe detected with avidin conjugated to AMCA (blue). (J,K) The extent of overlap between clones can be determined rapidly by hybridizing one clone onto DNA fibers prepared from the other clone. Here, a BAC clone (red) was mapped onto a partially overlapping circular PAC molecule (blue). The vector part of about 16 kb was counterstained with green/red probe combination. The results are summarized schematically in K. (L) Hybridization of labeled cDNA (red signals on top of blue signals) onto DNA fibers prepared from genomic clones such as BACs reveals the position and genomic organization of expressed sequences. The BAC molecule was counterstained by hybridization of a probe detected with avidin conjugated to AMCA (blue). The vector part of about 8 kb was counter-stained with green/red probe combination. Bars = 10 μm.

The procedure, however, had two obvious problems. Fusion of human sperm with hamster eggs and fixation of pronuclei is a time-consuming, laborious process and might not scale well enough to meet the high-throughput requirements of most genome projects. The second shortfall of the procedure was a complete lack of control over the extent of DNA decondensation and orientation of pronuclei. This spurred efforts in the 1990s to manipulate chromatin or purified DNA molecules that could serve as a template for high-resolution physical mapping of DNA probes. The optimal procedure would be inexpensive, rapid, reproducible, and deliver mapping data limited only by the resolution of the light microscope. A decade later, we find ourselves equipped with an arsenal of complementary FISH-based mapping procedures that cover a very broad range of mapping intervals. Furthermore, the simultaneous development of more sensitive fluorescence detection reagents has pushed the limits of detection down to a few hundred base-pairs (bp).

DNA Fiber Mapping

The expression “DNA fiber mapping” has become a collective name for quite different mapping techniques. As indicated in Figure 2, the diameter of DNA fibers increases as DNA molecules with a diameter of 2 nm are packed into chromatin ranging from 10 nm for histone-packed DNA molecules and 30 nm for chromatin fibers all the way to chromatids of 700 nm diameter. Chromatin can be released from interphase cell nuclei by various chemical or mechanical methods, and investigators tried to coin names that reflect their individual approach. Isolation of DNA from cell nuclei, extension, and preparation of chromatin or DNA fibers with diameters ranging in size from a few to several hundred nm (Figure 2) improves the accessibility of the DNA targets for both probes and detection reagents. Accordingly, the hybridization efficiencies increase, and DNA targets of less than 1 kb can be detected routinely using procedures normally applied in metaphase and interphase cell FISH.

In 1992, Heng et al. described the use of chemicals to release chromatin from interphase cell nuclei. The results look somewhat similar to the propidium iodide-stained free chromatin shown in Figure 1C. Heng et al. (1992) used the drug N-[4-(9-acridinylamino)-3-methoxyphenyl]-methanesulfonamide (m-AMSA) and an alkaline lysis procedure to release the DNA from interphase cells and demonstrated mapping of DNA sequences in distances ranging from 21 kb to 350 kb onto the extended chromatin. The authors speculated that, with multicolor FISH, free chromatin mapping would readily resolve gene sequences separated by as little as 10 kb (Heng et al. 1992). Soon thereafter, Senger et al. (1994) and Fidlerova et al. (1994) demonstrated the use of a sodium hydroxide/ethanol mixture or 70% formamide to prepare chromatin fibers which they called “free DNA.” Hybridization signals from cosmid probes appeared as extended lines and overlaps between clones were determined using the lengths of the probe signals and their known kilobase size as an internal standard. Typical experiments calculated averages from 30 or more signals (Senger et al. 1994).

Wiegant et al. (1992) and Lawrence et al. (1992) applied a different chemical method to release DNA from cells producing so-called “DNA halos.” The procedure was based on detergent and high salt extraction followed by intercalating dye/UV treatment (Cook et al. 1976; Vogelstein et al. 1980). Using multicolor hybridizations, these investigators were able to determine relative map positions and to detect 10-kb overlap between individual cosmid clones. Wiegant et al. (1992) noted cosmid-specific signals that appeared as linear beaded signals of about 10 μm (i.e., about 3.5–4 kb/μm), and the authors concluded that their DNA halo preparations produced “essentially linearized” DNA. The map configuration of α-satellite DNA arrays or single-copy DNA could typically be derived from analysis of only 5–10 cells. These findings were confirmed independently by the work of Lawrence et al. (1992). But as Gerdes et al. pointed out in their publication in 1994, “many procedures can be used to decondense DNA for in situ hybridization, however many of these result in highly variable and apparently random threads of DNA smeared erratically across the slide, with little if any retention of native morphology” (Gerdes et al. 1994). As the images in Figures 1D-1G illustrate, DNA halo preparations often show residual nuclei containing compact hybridization domains, while the direction, extent, and straightness of hybridization tracks on the extended chromatin appear to be highly variable.

If DNA molecules could be stretched uniformly in one direction, they might provide linear templates for visual FISH mapping. Parra and Windle (1993) described a procedure they termed “direct visual hybridization” (DIRVISH), in which 100–5000 cells in phosphate buffer were placed on a one end of a slide and air-dried. The slide was then immersed in a lysis solution containing detergent, removed after 5 min, and tilted to allow the drop of DNA to run down the slide. The procedure produced some linear arrangements of DNA but, on the basis of the extent of hybridization signals, the authors estimated that the DNA was extended to a length ranging from 40% to 200% of the length of relaxed duplex DNA, i.e., 3.4 nm/bp (Parra and Windle 1993).

In the following year, Heiskanen et al. (1994) published a protocol to stretch genomic DNA embedded in agarose. The DNA was melted on a microscope slide by heating the slide, then distributed and stretched manually using a coverslip. Major drawbacks of this manual procedure were heterogeneous stretching and a rather low abundance of informative signals on the slides.

Figure 2

Packaging of DNA into chromatin and chromosomes. Several levels of packing of DNA can be discriminated. Two-nanometer-wide DNA molecules are folded into 11-nm chromatin segments which, when tightly packed with nucleosomes, appear as 30-nm chromatin fibers. Further packing leads to chromosomal sections with a diameter of about 300 nm and the 700-nm-thick chromatids of metaphase chromosomes.

Procedures published by 1995 allowed FISH for most preparations of decondensed nuclear or isolated cloned DNA and visualization of probe overlap to provide some information about the existence and size of gaps between clones (Parra and Windle 1993; Florijn et al. 1995; Heiskanen et al. 1995, 1996). However, none of these techniques provided sufficiently accurate information about the extent of clone overlap or the separation between elements in the map because the chromatin onto which clones were mapped was condensed to various degrees from site to site in these preparations (Rosenberg et al. 1995).

We demonstrated that cloned DNA fragments can readily be mapped by FISH onto DNA molecules straightened by the hydrodynamic action of a receding meniscus and, referring to its quantitative nature, we termed our technique “Quantitative DNA Fiber Mapping (QDFM)” (Weier et al. 1995). In QDFM, a solution of purified DNA molecules is placed on a flat surface prepared so that the DNA molecules slowly attach at one or both ends. The DNA solution is then spread over a larger area by placing a coverslip on top. DNA molecules are allowed to bind to the surface. During drying, the molecules are straightened and uniformly stretched by the hydrodynamic action of the receding meniscus. Molecules prepared in this manner are stretched with remarkable homogeneity. We estimated that a properly stretched molecule should extend about ∼2.3 kb/μm, i.e., approximately 30% over the length predicted for a double-stranded DNA molecule of the same size (Bensimon et al. 1994; Weier et al. 1995) (Figure 1H). We also showed that QDFM can be applied to linear or circular DNA molecules ranging in size from a few kb to more than 1 Mbp, which enabled us to determine clone overlaps or to map small probes with near-kilobase resolution onto entire yeast chromosomes and mega-YAC clones from the CEPH/Genethon library (Wang et al. 1996) (Figures 1J-1K).

The subsequent studies of Hu et al. (1996) and Yokota et al. (1997) presented rapid protocols to prepare DNA fibers on 3-aminopropyl-triethoxysilane-coated glass or mica slides. In their studies imaging λ DNA molecules by atomic force microscopy, Hu et al. (1996) let coverslipped DNA molecules bind to the surface for only a few minutes. When the coverslip was removed for imaging, the molecules were straightened by the moving meniscus. Yokota et al. (1997) developed a protocol in which the meniscus motion was controlled mechanically, which provided advantages in speed and uniformity of the straightened molecules.

Overcoming Challenges in Mapping Tandemly Repeated DNA Sequences

Most mammalian genomes contain very large blocks of heterochromatin. Certain regions such as the (near)-centromeric heterochromatin seem to be involved in karyokinesis and chromosome association during meiosis (Dozortsev et al. 2000), but the overall role of these clusters of “junk DNA” remains largely unknown (Epplen et al. 1998). Physical map assembly in heterochromatic regions by more conventional methods, i.e., clone fingerprinting or STS content mapping, has proved less efficient, and initial releases of maps of the human, Drosophila, and other complex genomes might suffer from the presence of major gaps.

Several groups applied DNA fiber mapping techniques to investigate the interface between euchromatic and heterochromatic regions as well as the organization of tandem DNA repeats in humans (Wiegant et al. 1992; Haaf and Ward 1994b; Shiels et al. 1997), animals (Sjöberg et al. 1997; Li et al. 2000), and plants (Fransz et al. 1996; Jackson et al 1998, 1999; Zhong et al. 1998). The methods applied by these researchers ranged from DNA halo preparations and extended chromatin to highly purified DNA molecules. Published results showed very specific beads-on-a-string patterns and presented convincing cases that DNA fiber mapping is a powerful tool to decipher the organization and extent of centromeric and telomeric DNA repeats.

Mapping of Single-copy DNA

Physical Map Assembly

The assembly of high-resolution physical maps has been a major application of DNA fiber mapping. Successful efforts to construct local maps for delineation of disease genes were mentioned above, but the success of additional investigators deserves proper recognition.

Klockars et al. (1996) used fiber-FISH to construct a physical map of the CLN5 region on 13q22. Duell et al. (1997, 1998) constructed high-resolution physical maps based on QDFM for the immunoglobulin-β region on chromosome 22 and a large region including the 5′ end of the human apolipoprotein B gene on chromosome 2. Theuns et al. (1999) determined the genomic organization of the human presenilin 1 gene, which was localized on chromosome 14q24.3, by fiber-FISH. Although applying different techniques to prepare the DNA fibers, these recent applications of DNA fiber mapping were able to support ongoing mapping efforts by providing physical maps with near-kilobase resolution.

Direct Visualization of Gene Amplifications and Deletions

Linearly extended chromatin or DNA molecules are ideal substrates to study gene amplification or deletions. Parra and Windle (1993) applied the DIRVISH technique to resolve low level amplifications of the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) gene in a hamster cell line. All DNA fiber mapping procedures are single DNA molecule investigations, which permit study of cell-to-cell variations. Parra and Windle (1993) presented evidence that DIRVISH can resolve the diversity in structure and complexity found in the amplified DHFR array, which would normally escape detection and proper characterization.

Michalet et al. (1997) extended human genomic DNA on silanized glass surfaces using a receding meniscus and found that a precise measurement of hybridized DNA probes can be achieved without normalization. Stretching yeast genomic DNA amounts representing hundreds of eukaryotic genomes, the authors performed the high-resolution mapping of cosmid contigs on a yeast artificial chromosome (YAC). Furthermore, stretching of human genomic DNA allowed measurement of gaps between contigs and determination of microdeletions in the tuberous sclerosis 2 gene of patients' DNA.

Mapping of Expressed Sequences

Applications of DNA fiber mapping extend beyond map assembly and can provide valuable information for clone validation, definition of a minimal tiling path, and quality control in the sequence assembly process. Even more exciting, its high hybridization efficiency makes DNA fiber mapping the method of choice for visual mapping of expressed sequences.

Several approaches exist to map expressed sequences or to study the organization of larger genes. Gene fragments or entire cDNAs cloned in plasmid vectors can be amplified by in vitro DNA amplification using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), labeled with reporter molecules, and used as hybridization probes (Wang et al. 1996). Figure 1 shows two examples of this application. A cloned cDNA fragment containing exon 2 of the human protein 4.1 gene (Peters et al. 1998) (Figure 1I) was positioned accurately on a closed circular, co-linear BAC DNA molecule. Counterstaining the BAC vector part with a combination of FITC- and digoxigenin-labeled probes that were detected in green and red, respectively, the position of gene 4.1 exon 2 within the BAC insert (the red signal on top of blue counterstain) can be determined with near-kilobase resolution.

The organization of genes in transcribed sequences interrupted by intronic sequences can be easily demonstrated by DNA fiber–FISH. We used QDFM in an attempt to resolve the structure of a gene from chromosome 20 frequently found amplified in human tumors (Tanner et al. 1994). As Figure 1L shows, a cDNA clone of about 5 kb maps to three distinct positions on a co-linear BAC clone. This result should be considered a rough estimate because exons smaller than 500 bp may not be detectable with this simple method (Weier et al. 1995). On the other hand, QDFM mapping turned out to be a highly reproducible method, so that was sufficient to analyze no more than five to eight BAC molecules (Weier 2001).

Technical developments in recent years have opened the doors to mapping of even smaller exons. In 1996, Florijn et al. demonstrated the use of DNA halo preps for mapping of exons ranging in size from 202 to 778 bp. Co-hybridization of co-linear cosmid clones enabled this group to reproducibly locate exon fragments of about 200 bp on extended genomic DNA in the context of the cognate cosmid signal. Detection efficiencies of 70–90% were found with probes larger than 400 bp, but the detection efficiency decreased to about 30% when fragments of about 200–250 bp were mapped.

More recently, Aaltonen and co-workers (1997; Horelli–Kuitunen et al. 1999) used a tyramide-based method (Raap et al. 1995) for detection of small hybridization targets. By applying this sensitive detection scheme to create a visual transcript map of six genes on chromosome 21q22.3, Horelli–Kuitunen et al. (1999) were able to detect targets ranging from 316 to 956 bp on 25–44% of the fibers. Independent experiments confirmed that an average of 89% of the EST hybridization signals were specific signals. These results suggested that a mere increase in detection sensitivity may not be sufficient to significantly increase the success rates of DNA fiber mapping experiments, i.e., the overall efficiency of hybridization and detection.

In the experiments conducted by Horelli–Kuitunen et al. (1999), the DNA fibers were prepared from agarose-embedded human genomic lymphocyte chromatin according to the protocol of Heiskanen et al. (1994, 1995), which may have limited the access of probes and detection reagents to the target DNA. As van der Rijke et al. (2000) proposed, the loss of target DNA and limited accessibility due to in situ renaturation and attachment might have a negative impact on the detection efficiency. In the author's opinion, DNA fiber-FISH sensitivity is determined by hybridization efficiency, rather than the ability to generate sufficient signal from small probes (van der Rijke et al. 2000).

High-resolution Studies of DNA Replication

Despite intense efforts, the orderly activation of replication sites in genomes of higher organisms remains largely unexplained. The main reason for this may be the complexity of a process orchestrating the partly parallel activation of an estimated 10⁴ to 10⁶ replication sites.

DNA fiber mapping, with its high resolution and sensitivity, might provide important mapping information about the location and spacing of replication sites. Several groups used fiber mapping techniques to demonstrate replication forks in yeast (Rosenberg et al. 1995), in Xenopus laevis (Herrick et al. 2000), and in humans (Gerdes et al. 1994; Haaf 1996). The approach chosen by Rosenberg et al. (1995) was based on the previously described DIRVISH and DNA halo techniques (Wiegant et al. 1992; Parra and Windle 1993). Hybridizing differentially labeled cosmid probes to yeast and YAC DNA fibers, the authors could provide convincing visual evidence of DNA replication “forks” and “eyes” in YACs containing human DNA (Rosenberg et al. 1995). A rather limited number of experiments enabled the authors to identify two origins of replication in a 400-kb region containing the human dystrophin gene, to present evidence for bi-directional replication and to demonstrate that human DNA cloned in yeast is capable of initiating its own replication.

Studies described by Gerdes et al. (1994), Haaf (1996), and Herrick et al. (2000) used incorporation of non-isotopically labeled nucleotides as markers for replicated DNA. The results of Gerdes et al. (1994) showed pulse-incorporated bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) representing nascent replicating DNA localized with the base of the chromatin loops in halo preparations. At increasing chase times, the replicated DNA was consistently found farther out on the extended region of the halo (Gerdes et al. 1994). Haaf (1996) investigated the timing of replication of α-satellite DNA arrays by incorporation of BrdU into newly synthesized DNA, followed by hybridization of biotinylated chromosome-specific alphoid probes to DNA released from fibroblast or lymphoblast cell nuclei. Using the DNA halo preparations, he was able to demonstrate many independent replication sites within the large clusters of tandemly repeated alphoid DNA and partially hemizygous hybridization patterns in support of the hypothesis that replication of α-satellite DNA on homologous chromosomes is highly asynchronous.

The recent work of Herrick et al. (2000) extended previous applications of DNA fibers produced by the hydrodynamic action of a receding meniscus (Bensimon et al. 1994; Weier et al. 1995). Xenopus sperm nuclei were labeled by incorporation of biotin-dUTP in newly synthesized DNA followed by pulse-labeling with digoxigenin-dUTP at fixed time intervals. Because triphosphate deoxynucleosides do not efficiently traverse the intact cell membrane, all experiments had to be carried out with de-membranated sperm nuclei and activated egg extracts (Hyrien and Mechali 1992). Using red and green fluorescent antibodies directed against biotin and digoxigenin, respectively, the authors were able to discriminate early from late replicating sequences and to obtain estimates of the formation of new replication forks.

Conclusions

Recent research has lead to major improvements in hybridization-based physical mapping procedures. Developments in DNA fiber mapping have reached the point of immediate practical utility: DNA probes as small as 500 bp can be mapped routinely onto immobilized templates composed of linear or circular DNA molecules that range in size from less than 10 kb to more than one Mbp. Uniform stretching facilitates the conversion of measured physical distances into genomic distances. The highly reproducible stretching procedures require analysis of only a few DNA molecules for accurate determination of map positions by multicolor fluorescence microscopy and digital image analysis. A mapping accuracy in the kb range coupled to efficient signal amplification procedures to visualize signals from small targets allows rapid assembly of high-resolution physical maps for large-scale sequencing and map closure as well as high-resolution maps of expressed sequences.

DNA fiber mapping technologies will enhance performance of virtually all mapping and sequencing projects, including ongoing and future sequencing of model organisms and bacterial genomes. Implementation of these technologies will expedite sequencing by increasing parallelism, will lower the overall cost by reducing template redundancies, and will expedite map closure. Furthermore, the techniques will benefit the positional cloning of disease genes and characterization of genomic elements controlling their expression.

Footnotes

Acknowledgments

Supported by a grant from the Director, Office of Science, Office of Biological and Environmental Research, US Department of Energy, under Contract DE-AC03–76SF00098, by the “Training Program in Genome Research” sponsored by the University of California System-wide Biotechnology Research and Education Program (#S96–03), and by a grant from the Breast Cancer Research Program, US Army Medical Research and Materiel Command, United States, Department of the Army (BC98–0937).

References

Aaltonen

Horelli–Kuitunen

Fan

Bjorses

Perheentupa

Myers

Palotie

Peltonen

(1997) High-resolution physical and transcriptional mapping of the autoimmune polyendocrin-opathy-candidiasis-ectodermal dystrophy locus on chromosome 21q22.3 by FISH. Genome Res 7:820–829

Aburatani

Stanton

Housman

(1996) High-resolution physical mapping by combined Alu-hybridization/PCR screening: construction of a yeast artificial chromosome map covering 31 centimorgans in 3p21-p14. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 93:4474–4479

Ashworth

Batzer

Brandriff

Branscomb

de Jong

Garcia

Garnes

Gordon

Lamerdin

Lennon

Mohrenweiser

Olsen

Slezak

Carrano

(1995) An integrated metric physical map of human chromosome 19. Nature Genet 11:422–427

Bell

Budarf

Nieuwenhuijsen

Barnoski

Buetow

(1995) Integration of physical, breakpoint and genetic maps of chromosome 22. Localization of 587 yeast artificial chromosomes with 238 mapped markers. Hum Mol Genet 4:59–69

Bellanné–Chantelot

Lacroix

Ougen

Billault

Beaufils

Bertrand

Georges

Glibert

Gros

Lucotte

Susini

Codani

Gesnouin

Pook

Vaysseix

Lu-Kuo

Ried

Ward

Chumakov

Le Paslier

Barillot

Cohen

(1992) Mapping the whole human genome by fingerprinting yeast artificial chromosomes. Cell 70:1059–1068

Bensimon

Simon

Chiffaudel

Croquette

Heslot

Bensimon

(1994) Alignment and sensitive detection of DNA by a moving interface. Science 265:2096–2098

Brandriff

Gordon

Trask

(1991a) A new system for high-resolution DNA sequence mapping interphase pronuclei. Genomics 10:75–82

Brandriff

Gordon

Trask

(1991b) DNA sequence mapping by fluorescence in situ hybridization. Environ Mol Mutagen 18:259–262

Brandriff

Gordon

Tynan

Olsen

Mohrenweiser

Fertitta

Carrano

Trask

(1992) Order and genomic distances among members of the carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) gene family determined by fluorescence in situ hybridization. Genomics 12:773–779

10.

Branscomb

Slezak

Pae

Galas

Carrano

Waterman

(1990) Optimizing restriction fragment fingerprinting methods for ordering large genomic libraries. Genomics 8:351–366

11.

Cheng

J-F

Weier

H-UG

(1997) Approaches to high resolution physical mapping of the human genome. In Fox

Connor

Biotechnology International. San Francisco, Universal Medical Press, 149–157

12.

Coffey

Roberts

Green

Cole

Butler

Anand

Giannelli

Bentley

(1992) Construction of a 2.6-Mb contig in yeast artificial chromosomes spanning the human dystrophin gene using an STS-based approach. Genomics 12:474–484

13.

Cohen

Chumakov

Weissenbach

(1993) A first-generation physical map of the human genome. Nature 366:698–701

14.

Collins

Galas

(1993) A new five-year plan for the U.S. human genome project. Science 262:43–46

15.

Cook

Brazell

Jost

(1976) Characterization of nuclear structures containing superhelical DNA. J Cell Sci 22:303–324

16.

Cox

Burmeister

Price

Kim

Myers

(1990) Radiation hybrid mapping: a somatic cell genetic method for constructing high-resolution maps of mammalian chromosomes. Science 250:245–250

17.

Dozortsev

Coleman

Nagy

Diamond

Ermilov

Weier

Liyanage

Ried

(2000) Nucleoli in a pronuclei-stage mouse embryo are represented by major satellite DNA of interconnecting chromosomes. Fertil Steril 73:366–371

18.

Duell

Nielsen

Jones

Young

Weier

H-UG

(1998) Construction of two near-kilobase resolution restriction maps of the 5′ regulatory region of the human apolipoprotein B gene by quantitative DNA fiber mapping (QDFM). Cytogenet Cell Genet 79:64–70

19.

Duell

Wang

Kim

U-J

Weier

H-UG

(1997) High resolution physical map of the immunoglobulin lambda variant gene cluster assembled by quantitative DNA fiber mapping. Genomics 45:479–486

20.

Epplen

Maueler

Santos

(1998) On GATAGATA and other “junk” in the barren stretch of genomic desert. Cytogenet Cell Genet 80:75–82

21.

Fidlerova

Senger

Kost

Sanseau

Sheer

(1994) Two simple procedures for releasing chromatin from routinely fixed cells for fluorescence in situ hybridization. Cytogenet Cell Genet 65:203–205

22.

Florijn

Bonden

LAJ

Vrolijk

Wiegant

Vaandrager

J-W

Baas

den Dunnen

Tanke

van Ommen

G-JB

Raap

(1995) High-resolution DNA fiber-FISH for genomic DNA mapping and colour bar-coding of large genes. Hum Mol Genet 4:831–836

23.

Florijn

van der Rijke

Vrolijk

Blonden

Hofker

den Dunnen

Tanke

van Ommen

Raap

(1996) Exon mapping by fiber-FISH or LR-PCR. Genomics 38:277–282

24.

Fransz

Alonso-Blanco

Liharska

Peeters

AJM

Zabel

de Jong

(1996) High-resolution physical mapping in Arabidopsis thaliana and tomato by fluorescence in situ hybridization to extended DNA fibres. Plant J 9:421–430

25.

Gerdes

Carter

Moen

Jr Lawrence

(1994) Dynamic changes in the higher-level chromatin organization of specific sequences revealed by in situ hybridization to nuclear halos. J Cell Biol 126:289–304

26.

Green

Mohr

Idol

Jones

Buckingham

Deaven

Moyzis

Olson

(1991) Systematic generation of sequence-tagged sites for physical mapping of human chromosomes application to the mapping of human chromosome 7 using yeast artificial chromosomes. Genomics 11:548–564

27.

Green

Olson

(1990) Systematic screening of yeast artificial-chromosome libraries by use of the polymerase chain reaction. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 87:1213–1217

28.

Haaf

(1996) High-resolution analysis of DNA replication in released chromatin fibers containing 5-bromodeoxyuridine. Biotechniques 21:1050–1054

29.

Haaf

Ward

(1994a) High resolution ordering of YAC contigs using extended chromatin and chromosomes. Hum Mol Genet 3:629–633

30.

Haaf

Ward

(1994b) Structural analysis of α-satellite DNA centromere proteins using extended chromatin and chromosomes. Hum Mol Genet 3:697–709

31.

Heiskanen

Hellsten

Kallioniemi

Makela

Alitalo

Peltonen

Palotie

(1995) Visual mapping by fiber-FISH. Genomics 30:31–36

32.

Heiskanen

Kallioniemi

Palotie

(1996) Fiber-FISH: experiences and a refined protocol. Genet Anal Biomol Eng 12:179–184

33.

Heiskanen

Karhu

Hellsten

Peltonen

Kallioniemi

Palotie

(1994) High resolution mapping using fluorescence in situ hybridization to extended DNA fibers prepared from agarose-embedded cells. Biotechniques 17:928–933

34.

Heng

HHQ

Squire

Tsui

(1992) High-resolution mapping of mammalian genes by in situ hybridization to free chromatin. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89:9509–9513

35.

Herrick

Stanislawski

Hyrien

Bensimon

(2000) Replication fork density increases during DNA synthesis in X. laevis egg extracts. J Mol Biol 300:1133–1142

36.

Hoheisel

Lehrach

(1993) Use of reference libraries and hybridisation fingerprinting for relational genome analysis. FEBS Lett 325:118–122

37.

Horelli–Kuitunen

Aaltonen

Yaspo

Eeva

Wessman

Peltonen

Palotie

(1999) Mapping ESTs by fiber-FISH. Genome Res 9:62–71

38.

Wang

Weier

HUG

Frantz

Kolbe

Olgletree

Salmeron

(1996) Imaging of single extended DNA molecules on flat (aminopropyl)triethoxysilane-mica by atomic force microscopy. Langmuir 12:1697–1700

39.

Hyrien

Mechali

(1992) Plasmid replication in xenopus eggs and egg extracts: a 2d gel electrophoretic analysis. Nucleic Acids Res 20:1463–1469

40.

Ioannou

Amemiya

Garnes

Kroisel

Shizuya

Chen

Batzer

De Jong

(1994) A new bacteriophage P1-derived vector for the propagation of large human DNA fragments. Nature Genet 6:84–89

41.

Jackson

Dong

Jiang

(1999) Digital mapping of bacterial artificial chromosomes by fluorescence in situ hybridization. Plant J 17:581–587

42.

Jackson

Wang

Goodman

Jiang

(1998) Application of fiber-FISH in physical mapping of Arabidopsis thaliana. Genome 41:566–572

43.

Klockars

Savukoski

Isosomppi

Laan

Jarvela

Petrukhin

Palotie

Peltonen

(1996) Efficient construction of a physical map by fiber-FISH of the CLN5 region: refined assignment and long-range contig covering the critical region on 13q22. Genomics 35:71–78

44.

Lawrence

Carter

Gerdes

(1992) Extending the capabilities of interphase chromatin mapping. Nature Genet 2:171–172

45.

Lee

Hsu

Lin

(2000) Direct visualization of the genomic distribution and organization of two cervid centro-meric satellite DNA families. Cytogenet Cell Genet 89:192–198

46.

Locke

Rairdan

McDermid

Nash

Pilgrim

Bell

Roy

Hodgetts

(1996) Cross-screening: A new method to assemble clones rapidly and unambiguously into contigs. Genome Res 6:155–165

47.

Lu-Kuo

Le Paslier

Weissenbach

Chumakov

Cohen

Ward

(1994) Construction of a YAC contig and a STS map spanning at least seven megabasepairs in chromosome 5q34–35. Hum Mol Genet 3:99–106

48.

Michalet

Ekong

Fougerousse

Rousseaux

Schurra

Hornigold

van Slegtenhorst

Wolfe

Povey

Beckmann

Bensimon

(1997) Dynamic molecular combing: Stretching the whole human genome for high-resolution studies. Science 277:1518–1523

49.

Nelson

(1991) Applications of polymerase chain reaction methods in genome mapping. Curr Opin Genet Dev 1:62–68

50.

Nizetic

Gellen

Hamvas

Mott

Grigoriev

Vatcheva

Zehetner

Yaspo

Dutriaux

Lopes

Delabar

Van Broeckhoven

Potier

Lehrach

(1994) An integrated YAC-overlap and 'cosmid-pocket' map of the human chromosome 21. Hum Mol Genet 3:759–770

51.

Olson

(1993) The human genome project. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 90:4338–4344

52.

Parra

Windle

(1993) High resolution visual mapping of stretched DNA by fluorescent hybridization. Nature Genet 5:17–21

53.

Patil

Peterson

Rothman

DeJong

Myers

Cox

(1994) A high resolution physical map of 2.5 Mbp of the Down syndrome region on chromosome 21. Hum Mol Genet 3:1811–1817

54.

Peters

Weier

Walensky

Snyder

Parra

Mohandas

Conboy

(1998) Four paralogous protein 4.1 genes map to distinct chromosomes in mouse and human. Genomics 54:348–350

55.

Pierce

Sauer

Sternberg

(1992) A positive selection vector for cloning high molecular weight DNA by the bacteriophage-P1 system—improved cloning efficacy. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89:2056–2060

56.

Raap

van de Corput

Vervenne

van Gijlswijk

Tanke

Wiegant

(1995) Ultra-sensitive FISH using peroxidase-mediated deposition of biotin- or fluorochrome tyramides. Hum Mol Genet 4:529–534

57.

Rosenberg

Florijn

Van der Rijke

Blonden

Raap

Van Ommen

den Dunnen

(1995) High resolution DNA fiber-FISH on yeast artificial chromosomes: direct visualization of DNA replication. Nature Genet 10:477–479

58.

Sapolsky

Lipshutz

(1996) Mapping genomic library clones using oligonucleotide arrays. Genomics 33:445–456

59.

Selleri

Eubanks

Giovannini

Hermanson

Romo

Djabali

Maurer

McElligott

Smith

Evans

(1992) Detection and characterization of “chimeric” yeast artificial chromosome clones by fluorescent in situ suppression hybridization. Genomics 14:536–541

60.

Senger

Jones

Fidlerova

Sanseau

Trowsdale

Duff

Sheer

(1994) Released chromatin: linearized DNA for high resolution fluorescence in situ hybridization. Hum Mol Genet 3:1275–1280

61.

Shiels

Coutelle

Huxley

(1997) Analysis of ribosomal and alphoid repetitive DNA by fiber-FISH. Cytogenet Cell Genet 76:20–22

62.

Shizuya

Birren

Kim

Mancino

Slepak

Tachiiri

Simon

(1992) Cloning and stable maintenance of 300-kilobase-pair fragments of human DNA in Escherichia coli using an F-factor-based vector. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89:8794–8797

63.

Sjöberg

Peelman

Chowdhary

(1997) Application of three different methods to analyse fibre-fish results obtained using four lambda clones from the porcine MHC III region. Chromosome Res 5:247–253

64.

Stallings

Doggett

Callen

Apostolou

Chen

Nancarrow

Whitmore

Harris

Michison

Breuning

Saris

Fickett

Cinkosky

Torney

Hildebrand

Moyzis

(1992) Evaluation of a cosmid contig physical map of human chromosome 16. Genomics 13:1031–1039

65.

Tanner

Tirkkonon

Kallioniemi

Collins

Stokke

Karhu

Kowbel

Shadravan

Hintz

Kuo

W-L

Waldman

Isola

Gray

Kallioniemi

O-P

(1994) Increased copy number at 20q13 in breast cancer defining the critical region: exclusion of candidate genes. Cancer Res 54:4257–4260

66.

Theuns

Cruts

Del-Favero

Goossens

Dauwerse

Wehnert

den Dunnen

Van Broeckhoven

(1999) Determination of the genomic organization of human presenilin 1 by fiber-fish analysis and restriction mapping of cloned DNA. Mammal Genome 10:410–414

67.

Trask

Pinkel

van den Engh

(1989) The proximity of DNA sequences in interphase cell nuclei is correlated to genomic distance and permits ordering of cosmids spanning 250 kilobase pairs. Genomics 5:710–717

68.

Tynan

Olsen

Trask

de Jong

Thompson

Zimmermann

Carrano

Mohrenweiser

(1992) Assembly and analysis of cosmid contigs in the CEA-gene family region of human chromosome 19. Nucleic Acids Res 20:1629–1636

69.

van der Rijke

Florijn

Tanke

Raap

(2000) DNA fiber-FISH staining mechanism. J Histochem Cytochem 48:743–745

70.

Vetrie

Bobrow

Harris

(1993) Construction of a 5.2-mega-base physical map of the human X chromosome at Xq22 using pulsed-field gel electrophoresis and yeast artificial chromosomes. Genomics 15:631–642

71.

Vogelstein

Pardoll

Coffey

(1980) Supercoiled loops and eucaryotic DNA replication. Cell 22:79–85

72.

Wang

Duell

Gray

Weier

H-UG

(1996) High sensitivity, high resolution physical mapping by fluorescence in situ hybridization on to individual straightened DNA molecules. Bioimaging 4:1–11

73.

Waterston

Sulston

(1995) The genome of Caenorhabditis elegans. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 92:10836–10840

74.

Weier

H-UG

(2001) Quantitative DNA Fiber Mapping. In Darzynkiewicz

Chrissman

Robinson

Methods in Cell Biology. Vol 64. Part B. San Diego, Academic Press, 33–53

75.

Weier

H-UG

Wang

Mullikin

Zhu

Cheng

J-F

Greulich

Bensimon

Gray

(1995) Quantitative DNA fiber mapping. Hum Mol Genet 4:1903–1910

76.

Weissenbach

Gyapay

Dib

Vignal

Morissette

Millasseau

Vaysseix

Lathrop

(1992) A second-generation linkage map of the human genome. Nature 359:794–801

77.

Wiegant

Kalle

Mullenders

Brookes

Hoovers

Dauwerse

van Ommen

Raap

(1992) High-resolution in situ hybridization using DNA halo preparations. Hum Mol Genet 1:587–591

78.

Yokota

Johnson

Robinson

Belu

Garrison

Ratner

Trask

Miller

(1997) A new method for straightening DNA molecules for optical restriction mapping. Nucleic Acids Res 25:1064–1070

79.

Zhong

Fransz

Wennekes–Eden

Ramanna

van Kammen

Zabel

Hans de Jong

(1998) FISH studies reveal the molecular and chromosomal organization of individual telomere domains in tomato. Plant J 13:507–517

80.

Zucchi

Schlessinger

(1992) Distribution of moderately repetitive sequences pTR5 and LF1 in Xq24-q28 human DNA and their use in assembling YAC contigs. Genomics 12:264–275