The Relationship Between Youth and Adult Award Wages from 1930 to 1985

Abstract

The important and sometimes controversial subject of relativities between youth and adult award wages is examined in this paper. For the first time a historical index of award wages applying to youth and adults in Victoria has been constructed. Trends in relative youth/adult wages are shown using the index and explanations of these trends are suggested. Both male and female youth wages have tended to track women's wages from 1930 to 1970, and hence they rose relative to men's wages. Between 1970 and 1975, male youth wages declined relative to all other wage groups, thus more closely paralleling female youth wages. From 1975 a new trend is shown to have appeared, with both types of youth wages continuing to rise relative to men's wages. It is suggested that this break in trend shown in the index is due to the application of different wage principles to women's wage fixation after the equal pay cases of 1969 and 1972. From this time women's wages have no longer been adjusted according to their social needs but according to work value, as with men's wages. The second part of the paper illustrates the wage-fixing principles historically applied and presents some evidence of the social needs principles still being used in youth wage-fixation, leading to unequal pay for equal work for some youth.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Altman, Jon C. & John Nieuwenhuysen (1979), The Economic Status of Australian Aborigines, Cambridge University Press, Melbourne.

Anderson, George (1929), Fixation of Wages in Australia, Macmillan & Co. Limited, Melbourne.

Argus, various editions, Melbourne, Australia.

Award Determinations, 1958-67, Victorian Government Printing Office, Melbourne.

BLMR (Bureau of Labour Market Research) (1983 ), Youth Wages, Employment and the Labour Force, Research Report no. 3, AGPS, Canberra, March.

CDYE (Committee for Development of Youth Employment) (1985), Youth Employment Beating the Barriers, CDYE, Victoria, December.

Gregory, R.G. & R.C. Duncan (1981), 'Segmented labour market theories and the Australian experience of equal pay for women', Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 3 (3), 403-28.

Gregory, R.G. & R.C. Duncan (1983), 'Equal pay for women: a reply', Australian Economic . Papers 22, 60-4.

Isaac, J.E. (1986), 'The meaning and significance of comparative wage justice' in John Niland (ed.), Wage Fixation in Australia, Allen & Unwin Australia Pty Ltd, North Sydney, 15-48.

10.

Kalisch, David & Alan Stretton (1984), Teenage Employment in the Public Sector: Where Have All the Jobs Gone?, Working Paper no. 44, Bureau of Labour Market Research , Canberra.

11.

Lewis, D.E. (1982), 'The measurement of the occupational and industrial segregation of women', Journal of Industrial Relations 21, 406-23.

12.

McGavin, Paul (1983), 'Equal pay for women', Australian Economic Papers 22, 48-59.

13.

Miller, Paul W. (1985), Female Labour Supply and the Consequences of Equal Pay for Females in Australia, Dept of Economics, University of Western Ontario/University of Western Australia, mimeo.

14.

Pitman, David (August 1983), The Determination of Junior Wages in Australia: Needs, Work Value and Employment, BLMR Conference Paper no. 26, AGPS, Canberra.

15.

Plowman, David (1986), 'Developments in Australian wage determination 1953-83: the institutional dimension' in John Niland (ed.), Wage Fixation in Australia, Allen & Unwin Pty Ltd, North Sydney, 15-48.

16.

Snape, R.H. (1981), 'Wages policy and the economy in the seventies and beyond' in K.J. Hancock (ed.), Incomes Policy in Australia, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich , Sydney.

17.

Victorian Government Gazettes, various editions 1900-58, Victorian Government Printing Office, Melbourne.

18.

Windschuttle, Keith (1985), Youth Wages, Employment and Unemployment:A Critique of a Study by the Bureau of Labour Market Research, Working Paper, Department of Industrial Relations, University of New South Whales, Sydney.