Cerebellar Tests Differentiate Between Groups of Poor Readers With and Without IQ Discrepancy

Abstract

A comprehensive test battery, including phonological, speed, motor and cerebellar tasks, was administered to the entire cohort of two schools for children with learning disabilities. Testing was undertaken blind without accessing the psychometric data on the children. Children were then allocated to a discrepancy group on the basis of their IQ, with the majority (n = 29) classified as nondiscrepant (IQ < 90) and a smaller set (n = 7), with IQ of at least 90, classified as discrepant (with dyslexia). Both groups showed significant deficits relative to age-matched controls on almost all the tests. On phonological, speed, and motor tasks, the nondiscrepant group were at least as severely impaired as the discrepant group. By contrast, on the cerebellar tests of postural stability and muscle tone, the nondiscrepant group performed significantly better than the children with dyslexia and close to the level of the controls. The findings indicate that cerebellar tests may prove a valuable method of differentiating between poor readers with and without IQ discrepancy. The findings are interpreted in terms of the cerebellar deficit hypothesis for dyslexia.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aaron, P.G. (1997). The impending demise of the discrepancy formula . Review of Educational Research, 67, 461-502.

Allen, G. , Buxton, R.B. , Wong, E.C. , & Courchesne, E. (1997). Attentional activation of the cerebellum independent of motor involvement. Science , 255, 1940-1943.

American Psychiatric Association (1987). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (3rd ed.). Washington, DC: Author .

Boder, E. (1973). Developmental dyslexia: A diagnostic approach based on three atypical spelling-reading patterns. Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology, 15, 663-687.

Bradley, L. (1988). Making connections in learning to read and to spell. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 2, 3-18.

Bradley, L. , & Bryant, P.E. (1983). Categorizing sounds and learning to read: A causal connection. Nature, 301, 419-421.

Castles, A. , & Holmes, V.M. (1996). Subtypes of developmental dyslexia and lexical acquisition. Australian Journal of Psychology, 48, 130-135.

Clark, M.M. , & Plante, E. (1998). Morphology of the inferior frontal gyrus in developmentally language-disordered adults. Brain and Language, 61, 288-303.

Cohen, J. (1969). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. New York: Academic Press .

10.

Denckla, M.B. , & Rudel, R.G. (1976). Rapid 'automatized' naming (RAN). Dyslexia differentiated from other learning disabilities. Neuropsychologia, 14, 471-479.

11.

Denckla, M.B. , Rudel, R.G. , Chapman, C. , & Krieger, J. (1985). Motor proficiency in dyslexic children with and without attentional disorders. Archives of Neurology, 42, 228-231.

12.

Dow, R.S. , & Moruzzi, G. (1958). The physiology and pathology of the cerebellum . Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

13.

Eccles, J.C. , Ito, M. , & Szentagothai, J. (1967). The cerebellum as a neuronal machine. New York: Springer Verlag .

14.

Eden, G.F. , Van Meter, J.W. , Rumsey, J.M. , Maisog, J.M. , Woods, R.P. , & Zeffiro, T.A. (1996). Abnormal processing of visual motion in dyslexia revealed by functional brain imaging. Nature, 382, 66-69.

15.

Elbro, C. , Nielsen, I. , & Petersen, D.K. (1994). Dyslexia in adults—Evidence for deficits in non-word reading and in the phonological representation of lexical items. Annals of Dyslexia, 44, 205-226.

16.

Ellis, A.W. , McDougall, S. , & Monk, A. (1996). Are dyslexics different? I. A comparison between dyslexics, reading age controls (poor readers), and precocious readers. Dyslexia, 2, 31-58.

17.

Fawcett, A.J. , Chattopadhyay, A.K. , Kandler, R.K. , Jarratt, J.A. , Nicolson, R.I. , & Proctor, M. (1993). Event-related potentials and dyslexia. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 682, 342-345.

18.

Fawcett, A.J. & Nicolson, R.I. (1992). Automatisation deficits in balance for dyslexic children. Perceptual and Motor Skills , 75, 507-529.

19.

Fawcett, A.J. , & Nicolson, R.I. (1994). Naming speed in children with dyslexia. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 27, 641-646.

20.

Fawcett, A.J. , & Nicolson, R.I. (1995a). Persistence of phonological awareness deficits in older children with dyslexia. Reading and Writing, 7, 361-376.

21.

Fawcett, A.J. , & Nicolson, R.I. (1995b). Persistent deficits in motor skill for children with dyslexia. Journal of Motor Behavior, 27,235-241.

22.

Fawcett, A.J. , & Nicolson, R.I. (1996). The dyslexia screening test. London, UK: Psychological Corp.

23.

Fawcett, A.J. , & Nicolson, R.I. (1999). Performance of dyslexic children on cerebellar and cognitive tests. Journal of Motor Behavior, 31, 68-78.

24.

Fawcett, A.J. , Nicolson, R.I. , & Dean, P. (1996). Impaired performance of children with dyslexia on a range of cerebellar tasks. Annals of Dyslexia, 46, 259-283.

25.

Fletcher, J.M. , Shaywitz, S.E. , & Shaywitz, B.A. (1999). Comorbidity of learning and attention disorders—Separate but equal. Pediatric Clinics of North America, 46, 885-897.

26.

Fulbright, R.K. , Jenner, A.R. , Mencl, W.E. , Pugh, K.R. , Shaywitz, B.A. , Shaywitz, S.E. , Frost, S.J. , Skudlarski, P. , Constable, R.T. , Lacadie, C.M. , Marchione, K.E. , & Gore, J.C. (1999). The cerebellum's role in reading: A functional MR imaging study. American Journal of Neuroradiology, 20, 1925-1930.

27.

Fulbright, R.K. , Shaywitz, S.E. , Shaywitz, B.A. , Pugh, K.R. , Skudlarski, P. , Constable, R.T. , Fletcher, J.M. , Liberman, A.M. , Shankweiler, D.P. , Katz, L. , Lacadie, C. , Bronen, R.A. , Marchione, K.E. , & Gore, J.C. (1997). Neuroanatomy of reading and dyslexia. Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 6, 431-446.

28.

Galaburda, A.M. , Menard, M.T. , & Rosen, G.D. (1994). Evidence for aberrant auditory anatomy in developmental dyslexia. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 91, 8010-8013.

29.

Galaburda, A.M. , Sherman, G.F. , Rosen, G.D. , Aboitiz, F. , & Geschwind, N. (1985). Developmental dyslexia—4 consecutive patients with cortical anomalies. Annals of Neurology, 18, 222-233.

30.

Gathercole, S.E. , & Baddeley, A.D. (1990). Phonological memory deficits in language disordered children: Is there a causal connection? Journal of Memory and Language, 29, 336-360.

31.

Georgiewa, P. , Rzanny, R. , Hopf, J.M. , Knab, R. , Glauche, V. , Kaiser, W.A. , & Blanz, B. (1999). fMRI during word processing in dyslexic and normal reading children. Neuroreport, 10, 3459-3465.

32.

Ghaziuddin, M. , & Butler, E. (1998). Clumsiness in autism and Asperger syndrome: A further report. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research , 42, 43-48.

33.

Gustafson, S. , & Samuelsson, S. (1999). Intelligence and dyslexia: Implications for diagnosis and intervention. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology, 40, 127-134.

34.

Haslum, M. (1989). Predictors of dyslexia? Irish Journal of Psychology, 10, 622-630.

35.

Heilman, K.M. , Voeller, K. , & Alexander, A.W. (1996). Developmental dyslexia: A motor-articulatory feedback hypothesis. Annals of Neurology , 39, 407-412.

36.

Holmes, G. (1917). The symptoms of acute cerebellar injuries due to gunshot injuries. Brain, 40, 461-535.

37.

Holmes, G. (1922). Clinical symptoms of cerebellar disease and their interpretation. Lancet, 1, 1177-1237.

38.

Holmes, G. (1939). The cerebellum of man. Brain, 62, 1-30.

39.

Ito, M. (1984). The cerebellum and neural control. New York: Raven Press.

40.

Ito, M. (1990). A new physiological concept on cerebellum. Revue Neurologique (Paris), 146, 564-569.

41.

Ivry, R.B. , & Keele, S.W. (1989). Timing functions of the cerebellum. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 1, 136-152.

42.

Jackson, T. , & Plante, E. (1996). Gyral morphology in the posterior Sylvian region in families affected by developmental language disorder. Neuropsychology Review, 6, 81-94.

43.

Leiner, H.C. , Leiner, A.L. , & Dow, R.S. (1989). Reappraising the cerebellum: What does the hindbrain contribute to the forebrain? Behavioural Neuroscience, 103, 998-1008.

44.

Livingstone, M.S. , Rosen, G.D. , Drislane, F.W. , & Galaburda, A.M. (1991). Physiological and anatomical evidence for a magnocellular defect in developmental dyslexia. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America , 88, 7943-7947.

45.

Loftus, G.R. (1996). Psychology will be a much better science when we change the way we analyze data. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 5, 161-171.

46.

Lovegrove, W. (1993). Weakness in the transient visual system: A causal factor in dyslexia? Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences , 682, 57-69.

47.

Lundberg, I. , Frost, J. , & Petersen, O.P. (1988). Long term effects of a pre-school training program in phonological awareness. Reading Research Quarterly, 28, 263-284.

48.

Mody, M. , Studdert-Kennedy, M. , & Brady, S. (1997). Speech perception deficits in poor readers: Auditory processing or phonological coding? Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 64, 199-231.

49.

Nicolson, R.I. (1996). Developmental dyslexia; Past, present and future. Dyslexia: An International Journal of Research and Practice , 2, 190-208.

50.

Nicolson, R.I. , & Fawcett, A.J. (1990). Automaticity: A new framework for dyslexia research? Cognition, 35, 159-182.

51.

Nicolson, R.I. , & Fawcett, A.J. (1994a). Reaction times and dyslexia. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 47A, 29-48.

52.

Nicolson, R.I. , & Fawcett, A.J. (1994b). Comparison of deficits in cognitive and motor skills among children with dyslexia. Annals of Dyslexia, 44, 147-164.

53.

Nicolson, R.I. , & Fawcett, A.J. (1995a). Balance, phonological skill, and dyslexia: Towards the dyslexia early screening test. Dyslexia Review, 7, 8-11.

54.

Nicolson, R.I. , & Fawcett, A.J. (1995b). Dyslexia is more than a phonological disability. Dyslexia: An International Journal of Research and Practice , 1, 19-37.

55.

Nicolson, R.I. , & Fawcett,A.J. (1999). Developmental dyslexia: The role of the cerebellum. Dyslexia: An International Journal of Research and Practice , 5, 155-177.

56.

Nicolson, R.I. , Fawcett, A.J. , Berry, E.L. , Jenkins, I.H. , Dean, P. , & Brooks, D.J. (1999). Association of abnormal cerebellar activation with motor learning difficulties in dyslexic adults. Lancet , 353, 1662-1667.

57.

Nicolson, R.I. , Fawcett, A.J. , & Dean, P. (1995). Time-estimation deficits in developmental dyslexia—evidence for cerebellar involvement. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B-Biological Sciences, 259, 43-47.

58.

Orton, S. (1995). Definition of dyslexia; report from committee of members. Perspectives, 21, 16-17.

59.

Paulesu, E. , Frith, U. , Snowling, M. , Gallagher, A. , Morton, J. , Frackowiak, R.S.J. , & Frith, C.D. (1996). Is developmental dyslexia a disconnection syndrome? Evidence from PET scanning. Brain, 119, 143-157.

60.

Pennington, B.F. , Filipek, P.A. , Lefly, D. , Churchwell, J. , Kennedy, D.N. , Simon, J.H. , Filley, C.M. , Galaburda, A. , Alar-con, M. , & DeFries, J.C. (1999). Brain morphometry in reading-disabled twins. Neurology, 53, 723-729.

61.

Pennington, B.F. , Groisser, D. , & Welsh, M.C. (1993). Contrasting cognitive deficits in attention deficit hyperactivity disorder versus reading disability. Developmental Psychology, 29, 511-523.

62.

Pennington, B.F. , Vanorden, G.C. , Smith, S.D. , Green, P.A. , & Haith, M.M. (1990). Phonological processing skills and deficits in adult dyslexics. Child Development, 61, 1753-1778.

63.

Reason, R. (1999). ADHD: A psychological response to an evolving concept (report of a working party of the British Psychological Society). Journal of Learning Disabilities, 32, 85-91.

64.

Reynolds, C.R. (1984). Psychometric characteristics of the Boder Test of Reading-Spelling patterns: Take one giant step backwards. School Psychology Review, 13, 526-528.

65.

Rosner, J. , & Simon, D.P. (1971). The auditory analysis test: An initial report . Journal of Learning Disabilities, 4, 384-392.

66.

Rudel, R.G. (1985). The definition of dyslexia: Language and motor deficits. In F. H. Duffy & N. Geschwind (Eds.), Dyslexia: A neuroscientific approach to clinical evaluation (pp. 33-53). Boston: Little, Brown.

67.

Rumsey, J.M. , Nace, K. , Donohue, B. , Wise, D. , Maisog, J.M. , & Andreason, P. (1997). A positron emission tomographic study of impaired word recognition and phonological processing in dyslexic men. Archives of Neurology, 54, 562-573.

68.

Russell, G. (1982). Impairment of phonetic reading in dyslexia and its persistence beyond childhood—Research note. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines, 23, 459-475.

69.

Shankweiler, D. , Crain, S. , Katz, L. , Fowler, A.E. , Liberman, A.M. , Brady, S.A. , Thornton, R. , Lundquis, T.E. , Dreyer, L. , Fletcher, J.M. , Stuebing, K.K. , Shaywitz, S.E. , & Shaywitz, B.A. (1995). Cognitive profiles of reading-disabled children— comparison of language-skills in phonology, morphology, and syntax. Psychological Science, 6, 149-156.

70.

Shaywitz, B.A. , Fletcher, J.M. , Holahan, J.M. , Shneider, A.E. , Marchione, K.E. , Stuebing, K.K. , Francis, D.J. , Shankweiler, D.P. , Katz, L. , Liberman, I.Y. , & Shaywitz, S.E. (1995). Interrelationships between reading disability and attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder. Child Neuropsychology, 1, 170-186.

71.

Shaywitz, S.E. , Escobar, M.D. , Shaywitz, B.A. , Fletcher, J.M. , & Makuch, R. (1992). Evidence that dyslexia may represent the lower tail of a normal distribution of reading ability. New England Journal of Medicine, 326, 145-150.

72.

Siegel, L.S. (1988). Evidence that IQ scores are irrelevant to the definition and analysis of reading disability. Canadian journal of Psychology, 42, 201-215.

73.

Siegel, L.S. (1989). IQ is irrelevant to the definition of learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 469-478.

74.

Siegel, L.S. (1992). An evaluation of the discrepancy definition of dyslexia. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 25, 618-629.

75.

Siegel, L.S. (1999). Issues in the definition and diagnosis of learning disabilities: A perspective on Guckenberger v. Boston University. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 32, 304-319.

76.

Snowling, M. (1987). Dyslexia: A cognitive developmental perspective. Oxford, UK: Blackwell.

77.

Snowling, M. , & Hulme, C. (1994). The development of phonological skills. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B-Biological Sciences, 346, 21-27.

78.

Stanovich, K.E. (1986). Matthew effects in reading: Some consequences of individual differences in the acquisition of literacy. Reading Research Quarterly, 21, 360-407.

79.

Stanovich, K.E. (1988a). Explaining the differences between the dyslexic and the garden-variety poor reader: The phonological-core variable-difference model. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 21, 590-612.

80.

Stanovich, K.E. (1988b). The right and wrong places to look for the cognitive locus of reading disability. Annals of Dyslexia, 38, 154-177.

81.

Stanovich, K.E. (1991). Discrepancy definitions of reading disability: Has intelligence led us astray? Reading Research Quarterly , 26, 7-29.

82.

Stanovich, K.E. (1994). Annotation: Does dyslexia exist? Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 35, 579-595.

83.

Stanovich, K.E. (1999). The sociopsychometrics of learning disabilities . Journal of Learning Disabilities, 32, 350-361.

84.

Stanovich, K.E. , & Siegel, L.S. (1994). The phenotypic performance profile of reading-disabled children: A regression-based test of the phonological-core variable-difference model. Journal of Educational Psychology, 86, 1-30.

85.

Stein, J.F. , & Glickstein, M. (1992). Role of the cerebellum in visual guidance of movement. Physiological Reviews, 72, 972-1017.

86.

Stein, J. , & Walsh, V. (1997). The magnocellular deficit theory of dyslexia—Reply . Trends in Neurosciences, 20, 398.

87.

Talcott, J.B. , Hansen, P.C. , Willis-Owen, C. , McKinnell, I.W. , Richardson, A.J. , & Stein, J.F. (1998). Visual magnocellular impairment in adult developmental dyslexics. Neuro-Ophthalmology, 20, 187-201.

88.

Tallal, P. , Merzenich, M.M. , Miller, S. , & Jenkins, W. (1998). Language learning impairments: Integrating basic science, technology, and remediation. Experimental Brain Research , 123, 210-219.

89.

Thach, W.T. (1996). On the specific role of the cerebellum in motor learning and cognition: Clues from PET activation and lesion studies in man . Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 19, 411-431.

90.

Van der Leij, A. , & van Daal, V.H.P. (1999). Automatization aspects of dyslexia: Speed limitations in word identification, sensitivity to increasing task demands, and orthographic compensation. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 32, 417-428.

91.

Vellutino, F.R. (1979). Dyslexia: Theory and research. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

92.

Vernon, P.A. , & Mori, M. (1992). Intelligence, reaction times, and peripheral nerve conduction velocity. Intelligence, 16, 273-288.

93.

Wagner, R.K. (1988). Causal relations between the development of phonological processing abilities and the acquisition of reading skills: A meta-analysis . Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 34, 261-279.

94.

Wechsler, D. (1976). Wechsler intelligence scale for children-Revised (WISC-R). Slough, UK: NFER.

95.

Wechsler, D. (1992). Wechsler intelligence scale for children-Third edition (WISC-III). Sidcup, UK: Psychological Corp.

96.

Wechsler, D. (1993). Wechsler objective reading dimension (WORD). London, UK: Psychological Corp.

97.

Wimmer, H. , Mayringer, H. , & Raberger, T. (1999). Reading and dual-task balancing: Evidence against the automatization deficit explanation of developmental dyslexia. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 32, 473-478.

98.

Wolf, M. , & Bowers, P.G. (1999). The double-deficit hypothesis for the developmental dyslexias. Journal of Educational Psychology, 91, 415-438.

99.

Wolff, P.H. , Michel, G.F. , & Ovrut, M. (1990). Rate variables and automatized naming in developmental dyslexia. Brain and Language, 39,556-575.

100.

World Federation of Neurology (1968). Report of research group on dyslexia and world illiteracy. Dallas, TX: Author.

101.

Yap, R. , & van der Leij, A. (1993). Word-processing in dyslexics—an automatic decoding deficit. Reading and Writing, 5, 261-279.

102.

Yap, R.L. , & van der Leij, A. (1994). Testing the automatization deficit hypothesis of dyslexia via a dual-task paradigm. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 27, 660-665.