Qualitative Descriptions of Error Recovery Patterns Across Reading Level and Sentence Type: An Eye Movement Analysis

Abstract

Purposes of the present study included describing a variety of error recovery patterns based on eye movement (EM) measures of sentence parsing across reading level and error type. A qualitative pattern analysis of EM mappings was completed for students with reading disabilities (n = 10) and nondisabled students (n = 10) who were parsing control and erred sentences. Independent variables included error type (syntactically ambiguous, semantically anomalous, and control sentences) and reading proficiency level. Dependent variables consisted of seven eye movement measures. Chi-square analyses were performed to examine group differences across frequencies per pattern. Results suggest that the error recovery strategies deployed by both groups were similar in pattern and frequency; patterns were largely organized, strategic, and efficient, as predicted. Evidence for seven newly defined strategies was found, with indications of multiple strategies within sentences by both groups. Strategies tended to be error "reanalysis" (vs. "recovery") heuristics, in that readers from both groups used regressions to reanalyze regions of inconsistency rather than regions of disambiguation. Earlier conclusions regarding disorganized processing and individual differences among adolescents with reading disabilities are discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Psychiatric Association. (1987). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders-Revised (3rd ed.). Washington, DC: Author.

Baker, L. (1979). Comprehension monitoring: Identifying and coping with text confusions. Journal of Reading Behavior, 11, 363–374.

Baker, L. , & Anderson, R.L. (1982). Effects of inconsistent information on text processing: Evidence of comprehension monitoring. Reading Research Quarterly, 17, 281–293.

Carpenter, P.A. , & Daneman, M. (1981). Lexical retrieval and error recovery in reading: A model based on eye fixations. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 20, 137–160.

Curtis, M.E. (1980). Development of components of reading skill. Journal of Educational Psychology, 72, 656–669.

Durkin, D. (1983). What classroom observations reveal about reading comprehension instruction. In L. Gentile , M. Kamil , & J. Blanchard (Eds.), Reading research revisited (pp. 287–329). Columbus, OH: Merrill.

Erhlich, S.F. , & Rayner, K. (1981). Contextual effects on word perception and eye movements during reading. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 20, 641–645.

Fletcher, J. (in press). Component skill comparisons across reading level and processing demand. Reading Psychology.

Frazier, L. , & Rayner, K. (1982). Making and correcting errors during sentence comprehension: Eye movements in the analysis of structurally ambiguous sentences. Cognitive Psychology, 14, 178–210.

10.

Garner, R. (1982). Resolving comprehension failure through text lookbacks: Direct training and practice effects among good and poor comprehenders in grades six and seven. Reading Psychology, 3, 221–231.

11.

Garner, R. (1987). Metacognition and reading comprehension. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.

12.

Grabe, M. (1985, August). Reading ability, processing load and the detection of intersentence inconsistencies. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Detroit.

13.

Grabe, M. , & Mann, S. (1984). A technique for the assessment and training of comprehension monitoring skills. Journal of Reading Behavior, 16, 131–144.

14.

Hare, V.C. (1981). Readers' problem identification and problem solving strategies for high- and low-knowledge comprehenders. Journal of Reading Behavior, 13, 359–365.

15.

Loeb, P.J. , & Zuber, B.L. (1977). Regressive eye movements in reading. Proceedings of the Goldberg Symposium on Engineering in the Health Sciences, 188–207.

16.

Markman, E.M. (1979). Realizing that you don't understand: Elementary school children's awareness of inconsistencies. Child Development, 50, 643–655.

17.

Myers, M. , & Paris, S.G. (1978). Children's metacognitive knowledge about reading. Journal of Educational Psychology, 70, 680–690.

18.

Nisbett, R.E. , & Wilson, T.D. (1977). Telling more than we can know: Verbal reports on mental processes. Psychology Review, 84, 231–257.

19.

Olshavsky, J.E. (1976-77). Reading as problem solving: An investigation of strategies. Reading Research Quarterly, 12, 654–674.

20.

Olson, R.K. , Kliegl, R. , & Davidson, B.J. (1983). Dyslexic and normal readers' eye movements. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 9, 816–825.

21.

Olson, R.K. , Kliegl, R. , Davidson, B.J. , & Foltz, B. (1984). Individual and developmental differences in reading disability. In T. G.Waller (Ed.), Reading research: Advances in theory and practice (pp. 2–65). New York: Academic Press.

22.

Pavlidis, G. Th. (1981). Do eye movements hold the key to dyslexia? Neuropsychologia, 19, 57–64.

23.

Pavlidis, G. Th. (1983). The “dyslexia syndrome” and its objective diagnosis by erratic eye movements. In K. Rayner. (Ed.), Eye movements in reading: Perceptual and language processes (pp. 441–466). New York: Academic Press.

24.

Pratt, M.W. , & Wickens, G. (1983). Checking it out: Cognitive style, context, and problem type in children's monitoring of text comprehension. Journal of Educational Psychology, 75, 716–722.

25.

Rayner, K. (1978). Eye movements in reading and information processing. Psychological Bulletin, 84, 618–660.

26.

Rayner, K. , & McConkie, G.W. (1976). What guides a reader's eye movements? Vision Research, 16, 829–837.

27.

Reis, R. , & Spekman, N.J. (1983). The detection of reader-based versus text-based inconsistencies and the effects of direct training of comprehension monitoring among upper-grade poor comprehenders. Journal of Reading Behavior, 15, 49–60.

28.

Rothkopf, E.Z. , & Billington, M.J. (1979). Goal-guided learning from text: Inferring a descriptive processing model from inspection times and eye movements. Journal of Educational Psychology, 71, 310–327.

29.

Smith, S.P. (1985). Comprehension and comprehension monitoring by experienced readers. Journal of Reading, 28, 292–300.

30.

Tinker, M.A. (1958). Recent studies of eye movements in reading. Psychological Bulletin, 55, 215–231.

31.

Vellutino, F.R. (1979). Dyslexia: Theory and research. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

32.

Wagoner, S.A. (1983). Comprehension monitoring: What it is and what we know about it. Reading Research Quarterly, 18, 328–346.

33.

Wanat, S.F. (1976). Language behind the eye: Some findings, speculations, and research strategies. In R.A. Monty & J.W. Senders (Eds.), Eye movements and psychological processes. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

34.

Winograd, P.N. , & Johnston, P. (1982). Comprehension monitoring and the error detection paradigm. The Journal of Reading Behavior, 14, 61–76