Assessing the Real-to-Artificial Generalizability of Multiattribute Attitude Models in Tests of New Product Designs

Abstract

The authors investigate the neglected problem of generalizing from multiattribute attitude models based on data for actual brands of real products to reach conclusions on affective responses toward artificial objects or hypothetical concepts, such as those that might be used to develop new product designs. They propose an approach involving four stages of analysis to examine the intervening role of multiattribute attitude models for real products in accounting for the effects of artificial design features on affective responses. The method decomposes the overall relationship of affect to artificial design features into (1) the mediating effects of a multiattribute attitude model based on real products, (2) other indirect effects, and (3) a residual direct effect. This general approach is illustrated and supported by an application to data on responses to male vocal recordings (real products) and alternative recording mixes (artificial objects). The results suggest the need to proceed with caution in using multiattribute attitude models based on real products to guide the design of artificial objects in laboratory tests oriented toward new product development.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Blalock

Hubert M.

Jr. ed. (1971), Causal Models in the Social Sciences. Chicago: Aldine Publishing Company.

Browne

M. W.

(1975), “Predictive Validity of a Linear Regression Equation,” British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology, 28(May), 79–87.

Duncan

Otis Dudley

(1975), Introduction to Structural Equation Models. New York: Academic Press, Inc.

Green

Paul E.

, and Carmone

Frank J.

(1970), Multidimensional Scaling and Related Techniques in Marketing Research. Boston: Allyn and Bacon, Inc.

Green

Paul E.

, Rao

Vithala R.

, and DeSarbo

Wayne S.

(1978), “Incorporating Group-Level Similarity Judgments in Conjoint Analysis,” Journal of Consumer Research, 5(December), 187–93.

Green

Paul E.

, and Srinivasan

(1978), “Conjoint Analysis in Consumer Research: Issues and Outlook,” Journal of Consumer Research, 5(September), 103–23.

Holbrook

Morris B.

(1981), “Integrating Compositional and Decompositional Analyses to Represent the Intervening Role of Perceptions in Evaluative Judgments,” Journal of Marketing Research, 18(February), 13–28.

Holbrook

Morris B.

, Moore

William L.

, Dodgen

Gary N.

, and Havlena

William J.

(1985), “Nonisomorphism, Shadow Features, and Imputed Preferences,” Marketing Science, 4(Summer), 215–33.

Huber

Joel

(1975), “Predicting Preferences on Experimental Bundles of Attributes: A Comparison of Models,” Journal of Marketing Research, 12(August), 290–7.

10.

Johnson

Richard M.

(1971), “Market Segmentation: A Strategic Management Tool,” Journal of Marketing Research, 8(February), 13–18.

11.

Land

Kenneth C.

(1969), “Principles of Path Analysis,” in Sociological Methodology, Borgatta

Edgar F.

, ed. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers, 3–37.

12.

Land

Kenneth C.

(1973), “Identification, Parameter Estimation, and Hypothesis Testing in Recursive Sociological Models,” in Structural Equation Models in the Social Sciences, Goldberger

Arthur S.

, and Duncan

Otis Dudley

, eds. New York: Seminar Press, 19–49.

13.

Levin

Irwin P.

, Louviere

Jordan J.

, Schepanski

Albeit A.

, and Norman

Kent L.

(1983), “External Validity Tests of Laboratory Studies of Information Integration,” Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 31(2), 173–93.

14.

Lutz

Richard J.

(1977), “An Experimental Investigation of Causal Relations Among Cognitions, Affect, and Behavioral Intention,” Journal of Consumer Research, 3(March), 197–208.

15.

Lutz

Richard J.

(1978), “Rejoinder,” Journal of Consumer Research, 4(March), 276–8.

16.

Moore

William L.

, and Holbrook

Morris B.

(1982), “On the Predictive Validity of Joint-Space Models in Consumer Evaluations of New Concepts,” Journal of Consumer Research, 9(September), 206–10.

17.

Neslin

Scott A.

(1981), “Linking Product Features to Perceptions: Self-Stated Versus Statistically Revealed Importance Weights,” Journal of Marketing Research, 18(February), 80–6.

18.

Parker

Barnett R.

, and Srinivasan

(1976), “A Consumer Preference Approach to the Planning of Rural Primary Health-Care Facilities,” Operations Research, 24(September-October), 991–1025.

19.

Pedhazur

Elazar J.

(1982), Multiple Regression in Behavioral Research: Explanation and Prediction, 2nd ed. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Inc.

20.

Silk

Alvin J.

, and Urban

Glen L.

(1978), “Pre-Test-Market Evaluation of New Packaged Goods: A Model and Measurement Methodology,” Journal of Marketing Research, 15(May), 171–91.

21.

Theil

Henri

(1971), Principles of Econometrics. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

22.

Turner

Malcolm E.

, and Stevens

Charles D.

(1959), “The Regression Analysis of Causal Paths,” Biometrics, 15(June), 236–58.

23.

Tybout

Alice M.

, and Hauser

John R.

(1981), “A Marketing Audit Using a Conceptual Model of Consumer Behavior: Application and Evaluation,” Journal of Marketing, 45 (Summer), 82–101.

24.

Wilkie

William L.

, and Pessemier

Edgar A.

(1973), “Issues in Marketing's Use of Multiattribute Attitude Models,” “Journal of Marketing Research, 10(November), 428–41.

25.

Wittink

Dick R.

, and Montgomery

David B.

(1979), “Predictive Validity of Trade-Off Analysis for Alternative Segmentation Schemes,” Educators’ Conference Proceedings, Series 44, Beckwith

Neil

, eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 69–73.

26.

Wright

Sewall

(1960), “Path Coefficients and Path Regressions: Alternative or Complementary Concepts?” Biometrics, 16(June), 189–202.