Gender and Crime among Felony Offenders: Assessing the Generality of Social Control and Differential Association Theories

Abstract

Although often tested empirically on high school samples, differential association and social control theories have only infrequently been used to explain offending by felons. Based on a sample of 1,153 newly incarcerated felons, the authors examine the ability of differential association and social control theories to explain self-reported offending across types of crime and gender groups. Overall, the analyses lend support to both perspectives and suggest that they are “general” theories of crime. It also appears, however, that differential association theory has more consistent effects, especially for men. Parental attachment is a significantly stronger predictor of female than male participation in violent crime. These results indicate that future studies of criminal behavior risk being misspecified if they do not include measures of these “traditional” theories of crime.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adler, Freda . 1975. Sisters in Crime: The Rise of the New Female Offender. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Agnew, Robert . 1985. “Social Control Theory and Delinquency: A Longitudinal Test.” Criminology 23:47-61.

Akers, Ronald L. 1996. “Is Differential Association/Social Learning Cultural Deviance Theory?” Criminology 34:229-247.

Akers, Ronald L. 1998. Social Learning and Social Structure: A General Theory of Crime and Deviance. Boston: Northeastern University Press.

Akers, Ronald L. , Marvin Krohn , Lonn Lanza-Kaduce , and Marcia Radosevich . 1979. “Social Learning and Deviant Behavior: A Specific Test of a General Theory.” American Sociological Review 44:636-655.

Akers, Ronald L. , and Anthony LaGreca . 1988. “Alcohol, Contact with the Legal System, and Illegal Behavior among the Elderly.” In Older Offenders, edited by Belinda Mccarthy and Robert Langworthy . New York: Praeger.

Akers, Ronald L. , and Anthony LaGreca . 1991. “Alcohol Use among the Elderly: Social Learning, Community Context, and Life Events.” In Society, Culture, and Drinking Patterns Re-Examined, edited by David J. Pittman and Helene Raskin White . New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers Center of Alcohol Studies.

Akers, Ronald L. , Anthony LaGreca , John Cochran , and Christine Sellers . 1989. “Social Learning Theory and Alcohol Behavior among the Elderly.” Sociological Quarterly 30:625-638.

Alarid, Leanne Fiftal , Velmer S. Burton , James W. Marquart , Francis T. Cullen , and Steven J. Cuvelier . 1996. “Women's Roles in Serious Offenses: A Study of Adult Felons.” Justice Quarterly 13:431-454.

10.

Andrews, D. A. , and James Bonta . 1994. The Psychology of Criminal Conduct. Cincinnati, OH: Anderson.

11.

Benda, Brent B. 1994. “Testing Competing Theoretical Concepts: Adolescent Alcohol Consumption.” Deviant Behavior 15:375-396.

12.

Boeringer, Scot , Constance L. Shehan , and Ronald L. Akers . 1991. “Social Contexts and Social Learning in Sexual Coercion and Aggression: Assessing the Contribution of Fraternity Membership.” Family Relations 40:558-564.

13.

Burton, Velmer S. 1991. “Explaining Adult Criminality: Testing Strain, Differential Association, and Control Theories.” Ph.D. dissertation, University of Cincinnati.

14.

Burton, Velmer S. , Francis T. Cullen , T. David Evans , Leanne Fiftal Alarid , and R. Gregory Dunaway . 1998. “Gender, Self-Control, and Crime.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 35:123-147.

15.

Burton, Velmer S. , Francis T. Cullen , T. David Evans , and R. Gregory Dunaway . 1994. “Reconsidering Strain Theory: Operationalization, Rival Theories, and Adult Criminality.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology 10:213-240.

16.

Burton, Velmer S. , Francis T. Cullen , T. David Evans , R. Gregory Dunaway , Sesha R. Kethineni , and Gary L. Payne . 1995. “The Impact of Parental Controls on Delinquency.” Journal of Criminal Justice 23:111-126.

17.

Burton, Velmer S. , James W. Marquart , Steven J. Cuvelier , Robert J. Hunter , and Leanne Fiftal . 1993. “The Harris County CRIPP Program: An Outline for Evaluation, Part 1.” Texas Probation 8:1-8.

18.

Canter, Rachelle J. 1982. “Family Correlates of Male and Female Delinquency.” Criminology 20:149-167.

19.

Caspi, Avshalom , Terrie E. Moffitt , Phil A. Silva , Magda Stouthamer-Loeber , Robert F. Krueger , and Pamela S. Schmutte . 1994. “Are Some People Crime Prone? Replications of the Personality-Crime Relationship across Countries, Genders, Races, and Methods.” Criminology 32:163-195.

20.

Chesney-Lind, Meda . 1989. “Girls' Crime and Woman's Place: Toward a Feminist Model of Female Delinquency.” Crime and Delinquency 35:5-29.

21.

Chesney-Lind, Meda , and Randall G. Shelden . 1992. Girls, Delinquency, and Juvenile Justice. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole.

22.

Cole, Stephen . 1975. “The Growth of Scientific Knowledge: Theories of Deviance as a Case Study.” In The Idea of Social Structure: Papers in Honor of Robert K. Merton, edited by Lewis A. Coser . New York: Harcourt Brace.

23.

Conger, Rand . 1976. “Social Control and Social Learning Models of Delinquency: A Synthesis.” Criminology 14:17-40.

24.

Costello, Barbara . 1997. “On the Logical Adequacy of Cultural Deviance Theories.” Theoretical Criminology 1:403-428.

25.

Covington, Jeanette . 1985. “Gender Differences in Criminality among Heroin Users.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 22:329-353.

26.

Cressey, Donald . 1953. Other People's Money. Glencoe, IL: Free Press.

27.

Cronbach, Lee J. 1951. “Coefficient Alpha and the Internal Structure of Tests.” Psychometrika 16:297-334.

28.

Daly, Kathleen , and Meda Chesney-Lind . 1988. “Feminism and Criminology.” Justice Quarterly 5:497-538.

29.

Dull, R. Thomas . 1983. “Friend's Use and Adult Drug and Drinking Behavior: A Further Test of Differential Association Theory.” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 74:1608-1619.

30.

Elliott, Delbert S. , and Suzanne S. Ageton . 1980. “Reconciling Race and Class Differences in Self-Reported and Official Estimates of Delinquency.” American Sociological Review 45:95-110.

31.

English, Kim . 1993. “Self Reported Crime Rates of Women Prisoners.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology 9:357-382.

32.

Eve, Raymond . 1978. “A Study of the Efficacy of Interactions of Several Theories for Explaining Rebelliousness among High School Students.” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 69:115-125.

33.

Fiftal, Leanne E. 1993. “Assessing Adult Female Criminality: Testing Differential Association and Social Control Theories.” Master's thesis, Sam Houston State University.

34.

Friedman, Jennifer , and Dennis P. Rosenbaum . 1988. “Social Control Theory: The Salience of Components of Age, Gender, and Type of Crime.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology 4:363-381.

35.

Ginsberg, Irving J. , and James R. Greenley . 1978. “Competing Theories of Marijuana Use: A Longitudinal Study.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior 19:22-34.

36.

Gottfredson, Michael R. , and Travis Hirschi . 1990. A General Theory of Crime. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

37.

Griffin, Brenda S. , and Charles T. Griffin . 1978. “Marijuana Use among Students and Peers.” Drug Forum 7:155-165.

38.

Hagan, John . 1989. Structural Criminology. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.

39.

Heidensohn, Frances M. 1985. Women and Crime. New York: Macmillan.

40.

Hindelang, Michael J. 1973. “Causes of Delinquency: A Partial Replication and Extension.” Social Problems 20:471-487.

41.

Hindelang, Michael J. , Travis Hirschi , and Joseph G. Weis . 1981. Measuring Delinquency. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

42.

Hirschi, Travis . 1969. Causes of Delinquency. Berkeley: University of California Press.

43.

Hirschi, Travis . 1996. “Theory without Ideas: Reply to Akers.” Criminology 34:249-256.

44.

Horney, Julie , and Ineke Haen Marshall . 1992. “Risk Perceptions among Serious Offenders: The Role of Crime and Punishment.” Criminology 30:575-594.

45.

Horney, Julie , D. Wayne Osgood , and Ineke Haen Marshall . 1995. “Criminal Careers in the Short-Term: Intra-Individual Variability in Crime and Its Relation to Local Life Circumstances.” American Sociological Review 60:655-673.

46.

Immarigeon, Russ , and Meda Chesney-Lind . 1993. “Women's Prisons: Overcrowded and Over-used.” In It's a Crime: Women and Justice, edited by Roslyn Muraskin and Ted Alleman . Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Regents/Prentice Hall.

47.

Jaccard, James , Robert Turrisi , and Choi K. Wan . 1990. Interaction Effects in Multiple Regression. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

48.

Jackson, Elton F. , Charles R. Tittle , and Mary Jean Burke . 1986. “Offense-Specific Models of the Differential Association Process.” Social Problems 33:335-356.

49.

Jaquith, Susan M. 1981. “Adolescent Marijuana and Alcohol Use: An Empirical Test of Differential Association Theory.” Criminology 19:271-280.

50.

Johnson, Richard . 1979. Juvenile Delinquency and Its Origins: An Integrated Theoretical Approach. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.

51.

Johnson, Richard E. , Anastasios C. Marcos , and Stephen J. Bahr . 1987. “The Role of Peers in the Complex Etiology of Adolescent Drug Use.” Criminology 25:323-340.

52.

Kandel, Denise , and Mark Davies . 1991. “Friendship Networks, Intimacy, and Illicit Drug Use in Young Adulthood: A Comparison of Two Competing Theories.” Criminology 29:441-469.

53.

Kornhauser, Ruth . 1978. Social Sources of Delinquency. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

54.

Krohn, Marvin . 1995. “Control and Deterrence Theories of Criminality.” In Criminology: A Contemporary Handbook, 2nd ed., edited by Joseph F. Sheley . Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.

55.

Krohn, Marvin , Lonn Lanza-Kaduce , and Ronald Akers . 1984. “Community Context and Theories of Deviant Behavior: An Examination of Social Learning and Social Bonding Theories.” The Sociological Quarterly 25:353-371.

56.

LaGrange, Randy L. , and Helene Raskin White . 1985. “Age Differences in Delinquency: A Test of Theory.” Criminology 23:19-45.

57.

Lasley, James R. 1988. “Toward a Control Theory of White-Collar Offending.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology 4:347-362.

58.

Laub, John H. , Daniel S. Nagin , and Robert J. Sampson . 1998. “Trajectories of Change in Criminal Offending: Good Marriages and the Desistance Process.” American Sociological Review 63:225-238.

59.

Leonard, Eileen B. 1982. Women, Crime, and Society: A Critique of Theoretical Criminology. New York: Longman.

60.

Longshore, Douglas , Susan Turner , and Judith A. Stein . 1996. “Self-Control in a Criminal Sample: An Examination of Construct Validity.” Criminology 34:209-228.

61.

Macdonald, Patrick T. 1989. “Competing Theoretical Explanations of Cocaine Use: Differential Association Versus Control Theory.” Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 5:73-88.

62.

MacKenzie, Doris Layton , and Robert Brame . 1994. “Shock Incarceration and Positive Adjustment during Community Supervision: A Multi-Site Evaluation.” Presented at the annual meeting of the Academy of Criminal Justice Sciences, June, Chicago.

63.

Makkai, Toni , and John Braithwaite . 1991. “Criminological Theories and Regulatory Compliance.” Criminology 29:191-220.

64.

Matsueda, Ross L. 1982. “Testing Control Theory and Differential Association: A Causal Modeling Approach.” American Sociological Review 47:489-504.

65.

Matsueda, Ross L. 1988. “The Current State of Differential Association Theory.” Crime and Delinquency 34:277-306.

66.

Matsueda, Ross L. 1989. “The Dynamics of Moral Beliefs and Minor Deviance.” Social Forces 68:428-457.

67.

Matsueda, Ross L. 1997. “ `Cultural Deviance Theory': The Remarkable Persistence of a Flawed Term.” Theoretical Criminology 1:429-452.

68.

Matsueda, Ross L. , and Karen Heimer . 1987. “Race, Family Structure, and Delinquency: A Test of Differential Association and Social Control Theories.” American Sociological Review 52:826-840.

69.

McGee, Zina T. 1992. “Social Class Differences in Parental and Peer Influence on Adolescent Drug Use.” Deviant Behavior 13:349-372.

70.

Merton, Robert . 1938. “Social Theory and Anomie.” American Sociological Review 3:672-682.

71.

Messerschmidt, James W. 1993. Masculinities and Crime. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

72.

Messner, Steven F. , and Richard Rosenfeld . 1994. Crime and the American Dream. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.

73.

Miller, Eleanor M. 1986. Street Woman. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.

74.

Naffine, Ngaire , and Fay Gale . 1989. “Testing the Nexus: Crime, Gender, and Unemployment.” British Journal of Criminology 29:144-156.

75.

Orcutt, James . 1987. “Differential Association and Marijuana Use: A Closer Look at Sutherland (with a Little Help from Becker).” Criminology 25:341-358.

76.

Paternoster, Raymond , Robert Brame , Paul Mazerolle , and Alex Piquero . 1998. “Using the Correct Statistical Test for the Equality of Regression Coefficients.” Criminology 36:859-866.

77.

Paternoster, Raymond , and Ruth Triplett . 1988. “Disaggregating Self-Reported Delinquency and Its Implications for Theory.” Criminology 26:591-625.

78.

Rand, Alicia . 1987. “Transitional Life Events and Desistance from Delinquency and Crime.” In From Boy to Man: From Delinquency to Crime, edited by Marvin Wolfgang , Terence P. Thornberry , and Robert M. Figlio . Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

79.

Richie, Beth E. 1996. Compelled to Crime: The Gender Entrapment of Battered Black Women. New York: Routledge Kegan Paul.

80.

Rosenbaum, James L. 1987. “Social Control, Gender and Delinquency: An Analysis of Drug, Property and Violent Offenders.” Justice Quarterly 4:117-132.

81.

Sampson, Robert J. , and John H. Laub . 1990. “Crime and Deviance over the Life Course: The Salience of Adult Social Bonds.” American Sociological Review 55:609-627.

82.

Sampson, Robert J. , and John H. Laub . 1993. Crime in the Making. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

83.

Short, James F. 1960. “Differential Association as a Hypothesis: Problems of Empirical Testing.” Social Problems 8:14-24.

84.

Silberman, Matthew . 1976. “Toward a Theory of Deterrence.” American Sociological Review 41:442-461.

85.

Simons, Ronald L. , Martin G. Miller , and Stephen M. Aigner . 1980. “Contemporary Theories of Deviance and Female Delinquency: An Empirical Test.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 17:42-57.

86.

Smart, Carol . 1976. Women, Crime and Criminology: A Feminist Critique. Boston: Routledge Kegan Paul.

87.

Sutherland, Edwin H. 1947. Principles of Criminology. 4th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott.

88.

Sutherland, Edwin H. , and Donald Cressey . 1955. Principles of Criminology. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott.

89.

Tittle, Charles R. 1980. Sanctions and Social Deviance. New York: Praeger.

90.

Tittle, Charles , Mary Jean Burke , and Elton Jackson . 1986. “Modeling Sutherland's Theory of Differential Association: Toward an Empirical Clarification.” Social Forces 65:405-432.

91.

U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics . 1994. Special Report, March, 1994. Washington DC: Government Printing Office.

92.

Warr, Mark , and Mark Stafford . 1993. “Age, Peers, and Delinquency.” Criminology 31:17-40.

93.

Winfree, L. Thomas Curt , T. Griffiths , and Christine Sellers . 1989. “Social Learning Theory, Drug Use and American Indian Youths: A Cross-Cultural Test.” Justice Quarterly 6:395-418.