Controversy in the Determination of Death: The Definition and Moment of Death

Abstract

This essay reviews recent controversy in the determination of death, with particular attention to the definition and moment of death. Definitions of death have evolved from the intuitive to the pathophysiologic and the medicolegal. Many United States jurisdictions have codified the definition of death relying on guidance from the Uniform Determination of Death Act (UDDA). Flaws in the structure of the UDDA have led to misunderstanding of the physiologic nature of death and methods for the determination of death, resulting in a bifurcated concept of death as either circulatory/respiratory or neurologic. The practice of organ donation after circulatory determination of death (DCDD) raises a number of ethical questions, most prominently revolving around the moment of death and manifested as an expedited time to determination of death, a departure from the unitary concept of death, a violation of the dead donor rule, and a challenge to the standard of irreversibility. Attempts to redefine the determination of death from an irreversibility standard to a permanence standard have significant impact on the social contract upon which deceased donor organ transplantation rests, and must entail broad societal examination. The determination of death is best reached by a clear, strict, and uniform irreversibility standard. In deceased donor organ transplantation, the interests of the donor as a person are paramount, and no interest of organ recipients or of the greater society can justify negation of the rights and bodily integrity of the person who is a donor, nor conversion of the altruism of giving into the calculus of taking.

Keywords

Brain death DCDD Dead donor rule Definition of death Determination of death Moment of death Organ donation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Academy of Royal Medical Colleges. 2008. A Code of Practice for the Diagnosis and Confirmation of Death. London, UK: Academy of Royal Medical Colleges. http://aomrc.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Code_Practice_Confirmation_Diagnosis_Death_1008-4.pdf.

Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School to Examine the Definition of Brain Death. 1968. “A Definition of Irreversible Coma.” Journal of the American Medical Association 205: 337–40.

Alexander

Moore

.. 2016. “Deontological Ethics.” In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2016 edition), edited by Zalta

E. N

.. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2016/entries/ethics-deontological/.

Asher

Navarro

.. 2009. “Supplemental Cryopreservation of the Donor by Peritoneal Cooling.” In Organ Donation and Transplantation after Cardiac Death, edited by Talbot

D’Alessandro

A. M. D

., 117–19. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

Bernat

J. L

. 2010. “How the Distinction between “Irreversible” and “Permanent” Illuminates Circulatory-Respiratory Death Determination.” Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 35: 242–55.

Bernat

J. L

. 2013. “The Definition and Criterion of Death.” In Ethical and Legal Issues in Neurology, Handbook of Clinical Neurology, 3rd Series, vol. 118, edited by Bernat

J. L.

Beresford

., 419–35. Edinburgh, UK: Elsevier.

Bernat

J. L.

Capron

A. M.

Bleck

T. P.

Blosser

Bratton

S. L.

Childress

J. F.

DeVita

M. A

., et al. 2010. “The Circulatory-Respiratory Determination of Death in Organ Donation.” Critical Care Medicine 38: 963–70.

Bernat

J. L.

D’Alessandro

A. M.

Port

F. K.

Bleck

T. P.

Heard

S. O.

Medina

Rosenbaum

S. H

., et al. 2006. “Report of a National Conference on Donation after Cardiac Death.” American Journal of Transplantation 6: 281–91.

Black

H. C

. 1891. A Dictionary of Law: Containing Definitions of the Terms and Phrases of American and English Jurisprudence, Ancient and Modern. 1st. Comp. H. C. Black. St. Paul, MN: West.

10.

British Transplantation Society. 2013. Transplantation from Deceased Donors after Circulatory Death . https://bts.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/15_BTS_Donors_DCD-1.pdf.

11.

Capron

A. M

. 1999. “The Bifurcated Legal Standard for Determining Death: Does It Work?” In The Definition of Death: Contemporary Controversies, edited by Youngner

S. J.

Arnold

R. M.

Schapiro

., 117–36. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

12.

Childress

J. F.

Liverman

C. T

., and the Institute of Medicine, Committee on Increasing Rates of Organ Donation. 2006. Organ Donation: Opportunities for Action. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.

13.

Cole

. 1993. “Statutory Definitions of Death and the Management of Terminally Ill Patients Who May Become Organ Donors after Death.” Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 3: 145–55.

14.

Compton

A. C

. 1974. “Telling the Time of Human Death by Statute: An Essential and Progressive Trend.” Washington and Lee Law Review 31: 521–43.

15.

Dalle Ave

A. L.

Bernat

J. L

.. 2016. “Using the Brain Criterion in Organ Donation after the Circulatory Determination of Death.” Journal of Critical Care 33: 114–8.

16.

Dalle Ave

A. L.

Sulmasy

D. P.

Bernat

J. L

.. 2019. “The Ethical Obligation of the Dead Donor Rule.” Medicine, Health Care, and Philosophy. doi: 10.1007/s11019-019-09904-8.

17.

De Vita

M. A.

Snyder

J. V

.. 1993. “Development of the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center Policy for the Care of Terminally Ill Patients Who May Become Organ Donors after Death Following the Removal of Life Support.” Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 3: 131–43.

18.

Dorland

W. A. N

. 1900. The American Illustrated Medical Dictionary. Philadelphia, PA: W. B. Saunders.

19.

Gries

C. J.

White

D. B.

Truog

R. D.

Dubois

Cosio

C. C.

Dhanani

Chan

K. M

., et al. 2013. “An Official American Thoracic Society/International Society for Heart and Lung Transplantation/Society of Critical Care Medicine/Association of Organ and Procurement Organizations/United Network of Organ Sharing Statement: Ethical and Policy Considerations in Organ Donation after Circulatory Determination of Death.” American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine 188: 103–109.

20.

Halley

M. M.

Harvey

W. F

.. 1968. “Medical vs Legal Definitions of Death.” Journal of the American Medical Association 204: 423–25.

21.

Hamlin

. 1964. “Life or Death by EEG.” Journal of the American Medical Association 190: 112–14.

22.

Hossmann

Kleihues

.. 1973. “Reversibility of Ischemic Brain Damage.” Archives of Neurology 29: 375–84.

23.

Institute of Medicine, Division of Health Care Services. 2000. Non-Heart-Beating Organ Transplantation: Practice and Protocols. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.

24.

The Intensive Care Society and the British Transplant Society. 2010. Donation after Circulatory Death: Consensus Meeting Report. National Health Service. https://nhsbtdbe.blob.core.windows.net/umbraco-assets-corp/1360/donation-after-circulatory-death-dcd_consensus_2010.pdf.

25.

Johnson

. 1755. A Dictionary of the English Language: In which the Words Are Deduced from Their Originals, and Illustrated in Their Different Significations by Examples from the Best Writers, to Which Are Prefixed, a History of the Language, vol. I. London, UK: W. Strahan. https://johnsonsdictionaryonline.com/page-view/?i=542.

26.

Kootstra

. 1996. “Ethical Questions in Non-Heart Beating Donorship.” Transplantation Proceedings 28: 3417–18.

27.

Kootstra

Daeman

J. H. C

.. 1996. “The Non-Heart-Beating Donor.” Transplantation Proceedings 28: 16.

28.

Kootstra

Kievit

J. K.

Heineman

.. 1997. “The Non-Heart-Beating Donor.” British Medical Bulletin 53: 844–53.

29.

Kootstra

. 2009. “History of Non-Heart-Beating Donation.” In Organ Donation and Transplantation after Cardiac Death, edited by Talbot

D’Alessandro

A. M

., 1–6. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

30.

Korsgaard

C. M

. 2000. “Teleological Ethics.” In Concise Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 879. London, UK: Routledge.

31.

McGregor

Verheijde

J. I.

Rady

M. Y

.. 2008. “Do Donation after Cardiac Death Protocols Violate Criminal Homicide Statutes?” Medicine and Law 27: 241–57.

32.

McNaughton

. 2000. “Deontological Ethics.” In Concise Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 202. London, UK: Routledge.

33.

Menikoff

. 2002. “The Importance of Being Dead: Non-Heart-Beating Organ Donation.” Issues in Law and Medicine 18: 3–20.

34.

Mollaret

Goulon

.. 1959. “Le Coma Dépassé.” Revue Neurologique 101: 3–15.

35.

“Moment of Death.” 1963. British Medical Journal 5: 394.

36.

Onions

C. T

., Ed. 1966. The Oxford Dictionary of English Etymology. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

37.

OPTN (Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network). 2013. Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network (OPTN) Policies. http://optn.transplant.hrsa.gov/ContentDocuments/OPTN_Policies_PC_07-2012.pdf.

38.

OPTN (Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network). 2019. Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network (OPTN) Policies. https://optn.transplant.hrsa.gov/media/1200/optn_policies.pdf.

39.

Potts

J. T.

Herdman

., and Division of Health Care Services, Institute of Medicine. 1997. Non-Heart-Beating Organ Transplantation: Medical and Ethical Issues in Procurement. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.

40.

Potter

. 1963, December. “Recent Cases: The Moment of Death”. Medico-Legal Journal 31: 195–96.

41.

President’s Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. 1981. Defining Death: A Report on the Medical, Legal, and Ethical Issues in the Determination of Death. Washington, DC: The Commission.

42.

Revised Uniform Anatomical Gift Act (2006), § 2, 8A U.L.A. 1, 9 (Supp. 2007).

43.

Robertson

J. A

. 1999. “The Dead Donor Rule.” Hastings Center Report 29: 6–14.

44.

Sharpe

. 1920. Diagosis and Treatment of Brain Injuries with and without a Fracture of the Skull. Philadelphia, PA: J. B. Lippincott.

45.

Shemie

S. D.

Hornby

Baker

Teitelbaum

Torrance

Young

Capron

A. M.

Bernat

J. L.

Noel

., and The International Guidelines for Determination of Death phase 1 participants, in collaboration with the World Health Organization. 2014. “International Guideline Development for the Determination of Death.” Intensive Care Medicine 40: 788–97.

46.

Simpson

J. A.

Weiner

E. S. C.

, Comps . 1989. The Oxford English Dictionary, 2nd ed. Oxford, UK: Clarendon Press.

47.

Stiegler

Sereinigg

Puntschart

Seifert-Held

Zmugg

Wiederstein-Grasser

Marte

., et al. 2012. “A 10 Min “No-Touch Time—Is It Enough in DCD? A DCD Animal Study.” Transplant International 25: 481–92.

48.

Tanner

T. H

. 1855. A Manual of Clinical Medicine and Physical Diagnosis. 2nd ed. Philadelphia, PA: Blandchard and Lea.

49.

Taylor

A. S

. 1873. A Manual of Medical Jurisprudence. Philadelphia, PA: Henry C. Lea.

50.

The President’s Council on Bioethics. 2008. Controversies in the Determination of Death. Washington, DC: President’s Council on Bioethics.

51.

Uniform Anatomical Gift Act (1968), § 2, 8A U.L.A. 99, 99, revised 1987 (2003 & Supp. 2010), superseded by Revised Uniform Anatomical Gift Act (2006), 8A U.L.A. 42 (Supp. 2011).

52.

University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. 1993. “Management of Terminally Ill Patients Who May Become Organ Donors after Cardiac Death.” Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 3: A-1–15.

53.

White

F. J

. 2016. “Were the First Transplants Done by Donation after Cardiac Death?” Social History of Medicine 29: 131–53.

54.

Wolstenholme

G. E. W.

O’Connor

., Eds. 1966. “Discussion, Organ Transplants: Practical Possibilities.” In Ethics in Medical Progress: With Special Reference to Transplantation, 65–77. London, UK: J. & A. Churchill.

55.

Zoll

P. M.

Paul

M. H.

Linenthal

A. J.

Norman

L. R.

Gibson

.. 1956. “Termination of Ventricular Fibrillation in Man by Externally Applied Countershock.” New England Journal of Medicine 254: 727–32.