The use of diatoms in the diagnosis of cause of death by drowning is reviewed. The arguments for and against the method are described, and the possible reasons for divergent opinions explored. Attention is drawn to the observations of some workers that the organs of non-drowned subjects may contain diatoms. Important papers in Hungarian, German, Russian and French particularly relevant to this subject have been translated and their essence presented here.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Anon. (1976) Asfixia por sumersion. Medicina30, 61–3.
2.
BöhmerF. (1940) Handwörterbuch der Gerichtlichen Medizin.Jena, Fischer.
3.
BriegerH. (1963) The fate of inhaled particles. Arch. Environ. Health6, 57–60.
4.
BrouardelP.VibertC. (1880) Etude sur la submersion. Ann. Hyg. Publique Med. Leg.4, 452–70.
5.
CampsF. E. (1969) Immersion in fluids, London, Churchill, 70–9.
6.
DarwinC. (1845) An account of the fine dust which often falls on vessels in the Atlantic Ocean. Proc. Geol. Soc.2, 26–30.
7.
DayanA. D.MorganR. J. T.TreftyR. T.PaddockT. B. B. (1978) Naturally occurring diatomaceous pneumoconiosis in sub-human primates. J. Comp. Pathol.88, 321–5.
8.
DelanyA. L.DelanyA. L.ParkinD. W.GriffinJ. J.GoldbergE. D.ReimannB. E. F. (1967) Airborne dust collected at Barbados. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 31, 885–909.
9.
EidlinL. M. (1968) The role of plankton in the diagnosis of drowning — a review. Sud. Med. Ekspert.11, 18–21 (in Russian).
10.
FerrisJ. A. J.StockdaleR. E. (1972) The Bluebell Woods case: a problem in identification. J Forensic Sci. Soc.12, 339- 45.
11.
GameP. M. (1964) Observations on a dustfall in the eastern Atlantic, February 1962. J. Sediment. Petrol.34, 355–9.
12.
GeisslerU.GerloffJ. (1966) Das Vorkommen von Diatomeen in menschlichen Organen und in der Luft. Nova Hedwigia10, 565–77.
13.
GiertsenJ. C. (1977) ‘Drowning’ in Forensic Medicine. Ed.: TedeschiC. A.EckertW. G.TedeschiL. G.Environmental Hazards, Vol. 3. Philadelphia, Saunders, pp. 1817–33.
14.
GualdiG. (1968a) Le diatomee nella diagnosi di annegamento. Zacchia4, 31–4.
15.
GualdiG. (1968b) Le diatomee nella diagnosi di annegamento. Zacchia, 4, 187–244.
16.
GuyW. A. (1861) Principles of Forensic Medicine, 2nd ed.London, Renshaw.
17.
HendeyN. I. (1964) Fishery Investigations Series. An Introductory Account of the Smaller Algae of British Coastal Waters, Part 5, Bacillariophyceae, London, HMSO.
18.
HendeyN. I. (1973) The diagnostic value of diatoms in cases of drowning. Med. Sci. Law13, 23–4.
19.
HoldenH. S.CrosfillJ. W. L. (1955) The significance of foreign bodies in the alveoli of the apparently drowned. J. Forensic Med.2, 141–50.
20.
Home Office (1979a) Drowning Statistics, England and Wales, 1975/6.London, HMSO.
21.
Home Office (1979b) Drowning Statistics, England and Wales, 1977.London, HMSO.
InczeG. (1951) Die Bedeutung der Phytoplankton-Resorption beim Ertrinkungstod. Acta Morphol. Hung.1, 421–30.
24.
InczeG.TamáskaL.GgyöngyösiJ. (1951) A vizbefulás bizonyitása a vér és a szervek plankton-vizsgálatával, Orv. Hetil, 7, 1003 4.
25.
InczeG.GyöngyösiJ. (1955a) Wirkung des Wasserdrucks auf die postmortale Flussigkeit-strömung in die Luftwege. Acta Morphol. Acad. Sci. Hung.5, 349–53.
26.
InczeG.TamáskaL.GgyöngyösiJ. (1955b) Zur Blutplanktonfrage beim Tod durch Ertrinken. Dtsch. Z. Gasamte Gerichtl. Med.43, 517–523.
27.
JanitzkiU. (1964) Zur Frage der Sicherheit des Diatomeen-Nachweises beim Ertrinkungstod. Arch.Kriminol.134, 24–5.
28.
KhattabM. (1975) Diagnosis of death by drowning — a quick method for detection of diatoms in bone marrow and different organs. J. Egypt. Med. Assoc.58, 537–40.
29.
KosekiT. (1968) Fundamental examinations of experimental materials and control animals on the diagnosis of death from drowning by the diatom method. Acta Med. Biol.15, 207–19.
30.
KosekiT. (1969) Investigations on the bone marrow as a material in the diatom method diagnosing death by drowning. Acta Med. Biol.16, 85–90.
31.
Kovacs-NagyZ. (1953) Le trajet du liquide de submersion dans l'organisme, Acta Morphol. Hung.3, 51- 64.
32.
LabruneB. (1972) La noyade. Soins 17, 29–31.
33.
LangerA. H.MacklerA. D.RubinI.HammondE. L.SelikoffI. J. (1971) Inorganic particles in cigars and cigar smoke. Science174, 585–7.
34.
MikamiY.KandaM.KamimuraO.OkuyamaM. (1959) Experimental study and practice on the detection of vegetative planktons in the bone marrow of the drowned dead body. Acta Med. Okayama13, 259–68.
35.
ModellJ. H. (1978) Biology of drowning. Ann. Rev. Med.29, 1–8.
36.
MuellerB. (1963) Zur Frage des Vorkommens von Diatomeen in Organen von Leichen, die nicht in Wasser gelegen haben. Dtsch. Z. Gesamte Gericbtl. Med.54, 267–72.
37.
MuellerB.GorgsD. (1949) Studien über das Eindringen von corpisculären Wasserbestandteilen aus den Lungenalveolen, in des Kreislauf während des Ertrinkungsvorganges. Dtsch. Z. Gesamte Gerichtl. Med.39, 715–25.
38.
MullerM.Marchand (1929) Etude sur l'introduction des corps étranger dans les voies respatoires au cours de la submersion experimentale. Ann. méd. légale9, 142–7.
39.
NaeveW. (1956) Zur praktischen gerichtsmedizinischen Anwendung des Diatomeen nachweises im ‘grossen Kreislauf’, Dtsch. Z. Gesamte Gerichtl. Med.45, 364–9.
40.
NeidhartD. A.GreendykeH. M. (1967) The significance of diatom demonstration in the diagnosis of death by drowning. Am. J. Sci. Path.48, 377–82.
41.
NorthcottD.GreenR. (1979) Personal communication.
42.
OsseltonM. D.HammondM. D.TwitchettP. J. (1977) The extraction and analysis of benzodiazepines in tissue by enzymic digestion and high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Pharm. Pharmac.460–2.
43.
OttoH. (1961) Uber den Nachweis von Diatomeen in menschlichen Lungenstauben. Frankf. Z. Pathol.71, 176–81.
44.
PatrickR.ReimerC. W. (1966) The diatoms of the United States, Vol. 1. Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia.
45.
PeabodyA. J. (1977) Diatoms in forensic science. J. Forensic. Sci. Soc.17, 81–8.
46.
PeabodyA. J.WhittonB. A. (1968) Algae of the River Wear: 1, Diatoms. Naturalist906, 89–96.
47.
PetersohnF. (1963) Diatomeen befunde bei WasserleichenDtsch. Z. Gesamte Gerichtl. Med.54, 370–8.
48.
PorawskiR. (1966) Investigations on the occurrence of diatoms in organs in death from various causes. J. Forensic Med.13, 134–87.
49.
RevenstorfV. (1904) Der Nachweis der aspirierten Ertränkungs flussigkeit als Kriterium des Todes durch Ertrinken, Vierteljahresschs. Geritchtl. Med. Off. Sanitaetswes.28, 274–9.
50.
RushtonD. G. (1961) Drowning — a review. Medicolegal J.29, 90–9.
51.
SchellmannB.SperlW. (1979) Diatomeen-Nachweis im Knochenmark (femur) Nichtertrunkener. Z. Rechtsmed.83, 319–24.
52.
SchneiderV. (1969) Versuch einer Wertung der Diatomeenprobe. Dtsch. Z. Gesamte Gericht. Med.26, 92–6.
53.
SchwärT. G. (1972) Drowning. Its chemical diagnosis. A review. Forensic Sci.1, 411–17.
54.
SpitzW. U. (1963) Diagnose des Ertrinkungstodes durch den Diatomeen-Nachweis in Organen. Dtsch. Z. Gesamte Gerichtl. Med.5, 42–5.
55.
SpitzW. U.SchneiderV. (1964) The significance of diatoms in the diagnosis of death by drowning. J. For. Sci.9, 11–18.
56.
SpitzW. A.SilvermanR. A.MichaelisM. (1969) Biochemical changes in experimental drowning, pulmonary oedema and asphyxia. J. Forensic Med.16, 79–85.
57.
SveshnikovV. A. (1965) Forensic medical examination and criminal law in inquests and enquiries. See Eidlin (1968) (in Russian).
58.
SwannH. G.SpaffordN. R. (1951) Body salt and water changes during fresh and sea water drowning. Texas Rep. Biol. Med.9, 350–84.
59.
TamáskaL. (1949) Vizihullák csontvelöjenék diatomatartalmarol (Diatom content of bone marrow in corpses in water). Orv. Hetil.16, 509–11.
60.
TamáskaL. (1961) Uber den Diatomeen-Nachweis in Knochenmark der Wasserleichen. Dtsch. Z. Gesamte Gerichtl. Med.51, 398–403.
61.
ThomasF.van HeckeW.TimpermanJ. (1961) The detection of diatoms in bone marrow. J. Forensic Med.8, 142–44.
62.
ThomasF.van HeckeW.TimpermanJ. (1963) The medicolegal diagnosis of death by drowning. J. Forensic Sci.8, 1–13.
63.
ThomsenA.ChristensenK. N. (1974) Drukning og naerdrukning, Fyns amt 1964–71. Ugeskr. Laeg.130, 1241–3.
64.
TimpermanJ. (1969) Medicolegal problems in death by drowning. J. Forensic Med.16, 45–75.
65.
TimpermanJ. (1972) The diagnosis of drowning — a review. Forens. Sci.1, 397–409.
66.
TimpermanJ. (1979) personal communication.
67.
UdermanH.SchuhmannG. (1975) Eine verbesserte Methode zum Diatomeen-Nachweis. Z. Rechtsmed.76, 119–22.
