Abstract
Coping affects somatic and psychological outcomes. This article explores narratives in a book, Kamikaze Diaries: Reflections of Japanese Student Soldiers, which report on the ways of coping used by each kamikaze participant before and during military service. The purpose of this study is to observe the possibility of a trend in coping strategies and consider how these trends inform us about other populations facing imminent death. This study analyzed data and extracted meaning from the narratives in the book (thematic content analysis). Within the thematic content analysis, the Ways of Coping scale was used, which describes the coping strategies people use when facing problems. The most frequently used coping strategies before they entered the military were “Accept Responsibility,” “Endurance/Obedience/Effort,” and “Self-Control,” while once in the military, they were “Accept Responsibility” and “Endurance/Obedience/Effort.” All the coping strategies used by kamikaze pilots appeared to focus on the passive self, which may be the type of coping in other populations facing death.
Keywords
Introduction
There have been several studies done examining coping strategies as a major factor mediating the relationship between stressful events and various outcomes such as depression (Baron & Kenny, 1986; Peter, Christopher, William, John, & Alicia, 2002), psychological outcomes (Hocking et al., 2010), somatic illness (Morley, Selai, Schrag, Jahanshahi, & Thompson, 2011; Steck, Amsler, Kappos, & Burgin, 2001), and well-being (Folkman & Moskowitz, 2000). Coping is defined as a process a person uses when dealing with stress, solving a problem, or making decisions (Folkman, Lazarus, Dunkel-Schetter, DeLongis, & Gruen, 1986). Stress is defined as a relationship between a person and their environment in a way that the person perceives or appraises as taxing or exceeding their resources, subsequently threatening their well-being (Man, 2009; Taylor, 1983). Facing imminent death can be considered stress, and several populations exist that face imminent death. For example, patients with terminal cancer often face high amounts of stress (Manuel, Roth, Keefe, & Brantley, 2010), with each person responding differently and using different coping strategies to reduce their emotional distress (Man, 2009). Nurses working in AIDS care must deal with the imminent death of their patients. These nurses experiencing stress were more likely to utilize positive appraisal and acceptance to cope with their stress (Kalichman, Gueritault-Chalvin, & Demi, 2000). Loss of comrades during battle reinforces social bonds and exhibits itself in coping strategies that are related to social support (Bryant, 2003). It is evident that there are varied trends in coping under stress. It is therefore relevant to better understand the individual’s context in understanding what may be the most helpful coping strategies for them.
This study focuses on a sample of narratives from Japanese kamikaze [tokkōtai] pilots during World War II. This term is used to describe suicide pilots who were forced to fulfill this position (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006). Their coping strategies during this period are of interest, to better understand the individual’s experience and context as related to their most commonly used coping strategies. These observations will be important in finding potentially better alternative coping strategy for application in comparable populations. Given that it is not often easy to access the intimate thoughts and feelings of people facing imminent death, the study of these diary entries are of great value in better understanding coping processes.
Population History
Kamikazes were military aviators initiating suicide attacks from Japan. Tokkōtai is an abbreviated form of Tokubetsu Kōgekitai, which is the official name of the kamikaze pilots. The literal translation of Tokubetsu Kōgekitai (Tokkōtai) is “Special Attack Unit,” which refers to the Japanese Imperial Navy and Army (Sasaki, 1997). Ohnuki-Tierney proposed the use of the term tokkōtai instead of kamikaze because, especially in the United States, kamikaze is synonymous with fanatical chauvinists, inscrutable and untrustworthy “Other,” reckless people and suicide bombers (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006).
The tokkōtai operation occurred toward the end of World War II when American invasions were arguably unavoidable. This operation was invented by Ōnishi Takijirō who was a navy vice admiral at the time (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006). The tokkōtai operation included airplanes, gliders, and submarine torpedoes. None of these weapon systems were equipped with means of returning to base (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2002). Ōnishi Takijirō thought that the Japanese soul was unique in the way that they possess the strength to face death without second thought and that this was the only way that the Japanese could bring about a miracle and save their nation. This operation was established in October 1944. Note that no one trained in the military volunteered to be a tokkōtai pilot because among many, it was believed that the operation was meaningless (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2002). There were approximately 4,000 tokkōtai pilots, and 3,000 of them were “boy pilots.” Although an age range is not available, this group consisted of boys younger than late teens and early 20s because that age range was classified as “student soldiers.” These boy pilots were drawn and newly enlisted as soldiers in a special program that trained young boys. The other 1,000 were “student soldiers” who were university students for whom the government granted early graduation to include them in the draft. While the “boy pilots” did not keep diaries at the time, the “student soldiers” left an abundant amount of handwritten transcripts expressing their thoughts and feelings in forms of letters, poems, essays, and diaries.
A collection of diaries from these pilots have been collected in the book Kamikaze Diaries: Reflections of Japanese Student Soldiers by Emiko Ohnuki-Tierney. This book encompasses seven different Japanese soldiers’ diaries. Some were kamikaze pilots, and some were in the army, but all of them died during World War II. Tokkōtai pilots did not commit suicide. Rather, they were “pilots sent on bombing missions in planes not equipped to return, but they did not volunteer in the same way contemporary suicide bombers do” (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006). The more appropriate description would be “killed in action.” In contrast, contemporary suicide bombers are often civilians who consciously volunteer to die by turning themselves into weapons. The timeline of these diaries are a few years before World War II, depending on when they started writing, but all end at 1945 when World War II ended. The narratives portray these seven Japanese soldiers’ feelings, from getting into university, being drafted into the military, and witnessing first person what it is like to be in the military as they waited to die.
Methods of Understanding Stress and Coping: Coping Theory, Thematic Content Analysis
One of the major coping theories was developed by Lazarus. His theory of psychological stress and coping contains two processes: their cognitive appraisal and subsequent coping. These two processes act as mediators for a person’s stressful environment along with short- and long-term outcomes. Lazarus defines cognitive appraisal as the person’s way of defining whether the current environment is relevant to his well-being. Cognitive appraisal branches into primary and secondary appraisal. Primary appraisal is the person’s evaluation of the risk of environment, whether there is any harm or benefit in this situation and how will this harm or benefit the person’s goals, values, or commitments. Secondary appraisal is the person’s evaluation of anything that can be done to improve benefits or prevent or overcome harm. Using different coping strategies can alter the situation, such as seeking more information and changing one’s situation. Taken together, primary and secondary appraisal determine whether the transaction between the person and environment is significant for their well-being (Park, 1997) and whether this significance is threatening harm or challenging benefits (Folkman et al., 1986).
The method of interest in this study is thematic content analysis, using coping strategies as the main focus. The Ways of Coping scale describes the coping strategies people use when facing problems. Coping focuses on what were the individual’s thoughts and actions in a specific situation. Their demands and resources can influence their thoughts and actions. Therefore, individual differences and situational differences together shape coping efforts. Simply put, coping is defined as a person’s effort to manage demands, whether or not it is successful (Carver, Weintraub, & Scheier, 1989).
There are two different sub categories of coping: (a) problem solving coping and (b) emotional coping. The coping strategies that fall under “Problem Solving Coping” are Confrontation, Planful Problem Solving, Seeking Social Support, Escape/Avoidance, and Endurance/Obedience/Effort. The coping strategies that fall under “Emotional Coping” are Distancing, Self-Control, Accept Responsibility, Positive Reappraisal, Compartmentalization, Denial, Supernatural Protection, and Luck (Della-Rossa, 2014). (1) Confrontation is the effort to resolve the situation through assertive or aggressive interaction with another person, which can suggest a degree of hostility and risk-taking. (2) Distancing is the effort to detach oneself emotionally from the situation. (3) Self-Control is the effort to regulate one’s own feelings or actions. (4) Accepting responsibility is to acknowledge that one has a role in the problem and trying to fix the problem. (5) Escape/Avoidance is the effort to escape or avoid the problem physically, which hints on wishful thinking. (6) Planful Problem Solving is the effort to change or escape the situation but with deliberate problem-focused efforts to alter the situation coupled with an analytic approach to solving the problem. (7) Positive Reappraisal is the effort to see a positive meaning in the situation, which hints on creating positive meaning by focusing on personal growth. (8) Seeking Social Support is the effort to obtain information, help, sympathy, or emotional support from another person. (9) Endurance/Obedience/Effort is the effort to submit, survive, persevere, or comply with demands. (10) Compartmentalization is the effort to capture the problem psychologically and isolating it from other aspects of life. (11) Denial is to ignore the problem and not believing in its reality. (12) Supernatural Protection is to attribute survival to superstitious or religious practices, to gain protection. (13) Luck is to attribute survival to good fortune (Della-Rossa, 2014).
There have been several studies that have implemented the use of the thematic content analysis method. These examples have included analyses on the website texts of Canadian medical tourism brokers (Penney, Snyder, Crooks, & Johnston, 2011) and on the memoirs of astronauts (Suedfeld & Weiszbeck, 2004). Similar to the current analysis, the astronaut study separated the narratives by the astronauts into premission, during, and postmission. Thematic content analysis was used similarly as it was in this study to identify themes, observing the frequency of the themes at different time points and comparing these trends with other literature.
The use of thematic content analysis is justified as a descriptive, qualitative method. While research knowledge in coping has been relatively extensive (Folkman et al., 1986), the use of thematic content analysis is a good entry-level descriptive method. This method identifies common themes through the unanalyzable information. Doing so allows us to group information into categorical themes from other, unrelated information. Interpretation is kept to a minimum, but the intent of bringing out the information out onto the surface from the massive entries is sufficient to organize the information (Anderson, 2007).
Research Question
The research questions of this study are (a) what are the possible trends in coping strategies for these tokkōtai pilots who were students during World War II? and (b) how do these trends inform us about other populations facing imminent death? These questions will be addressed using the book as the main source, Kamikaze Diaries: Reflections of Japanese Student Soldiers, by Emiko Ohnuki-Tierney. Within this book, the narratives are divided into six chapters, five of them being single soldiers and one of them being brothers in the war. The method used in this study is the thematic content analysis, coding for coping strategies in the narratives, which may have a possibility to upheave critical information by transforming unanalyzable information to analyzable data.
Method
One of the most important research techniques in the social science field is thematic content analysis (Folkman et al., 1986), which is the method of use in this study. This method analyzes data using transcripts and, through trained raters, extracts meaning from the transcript about the group, person, or culture. Observable events are different from transcripts, as the exchange of information in the transcripts has the ability to reveal properties and cognitive inferences for related people. Thematic content analysis detaches from the observable events and relies on symbolism to extract the antecedent, consequences of the transcript as well as finding correlates within each transcript, therefore making transcript data analyzable. There are several meanings of analyzable data. One is quantitative analysis using statistics. The one this study will focus on is interpretation of the data, bringing rich information about each individual. There are several steps that define the technique procedurally. These are design, sampling, coding, drawing inferences, and validation (Krippendorff, 1989).
The first step, design, allows the researcher to operationally define the context of the source and the goal of the analysis. For sampling, there is a need to minimize statistical biases that come with analyzing symbolic methods. Statistical bias can occur with thematic content analysis due to the people of interest themselves. For example, celebrities report their attitudes more often than the average population not because there is something inherent happening but because they are portrayed more in mass media than the population (Krippendorff, 1989). Also, it is important to ensure that the chosen sample is representative of the population of interest if one is trying to generalize for that population. The sample needs to be as representative as possible relative to the population to generalize the results. If the sample were composed of only undergraduate students, the results of their problem (facing stress during exams) might not be able to generalize to other populations who face other types of stress. Undergraduate students might, for example, face their stress levels by partying or by pulling all-nighters significantly more than the rest of the population (Krippendorff, 1989). The next step, coding, can be accomplished by explicit instructions for trained human coders. There are two aspects for coding, one of them being reliability measured by intercoder agreement and the other being the meaningfulness of the analysis. Human coders have inherent biases and are good at interpreting complex texts, which is difficult for technology to achieve (Krippendorff, 1989). The phase of drawing inferences is arguably the most important one. It connects the knowledge learned through the coded data from the transcripts to how it relates with the phenomena of the researcher’s interest. The frequency of references can indicate the attention the source is paying more attention to. However, there are also deeper levels of interpretation than just counting (Krippendorff, 1989). The final phase is validation. Validating evidence gathered by content analysis is limited. This limitation is due to the nature of the transcripts being unobservable behavior, which subsequently validates evidence through inference. A trained human rater for thematic content analysis conducted the coding and analyses in this study. Training was done through coping-analysis tests with multiple narratives. The problem and solution of the narrative, as well as the specific coping strategies for each of the problems, needed to be identified. For each coping test, a successful identification of at least 85% reliability with an expert-rater was required to be certified to code the data. The rater for this study received 100% reliability with an expert-rater. To code the data, the paragraphs with no problem or solution were systematically ignored. There would be no coping strategy if there was no problem or solution. After identifying both the problem and solution, the solution was matched with the corresponding coping strategy.
Source Transcript
Throughout the book, the author has incorporated “quotes” from the diaries of tokkōtai pilots in addition to the longer narratives that are written out in the book. They are embedded within the author’s own paragraphs, separate from the diary entries. These “quotes” are one-sentence (or one-word) diary entries that are not extensive enough to put in the book by itself and incorporate with the author giving the context. That being said, the author has stated that she will want to freely, and with no bias, write the diary entries out (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006).
The study investigated each participant individually, assessing their coping strategies at different time points (if applicable) and assessing each participant’s most common coping strategy in the context of their own individual experience. Therefore, an in-depth understanding is achieved of the individual’s most common coping strategy, rather than a particular overarching generalization. See Appendices A to G for brief descriptions of each of the participants.
Results
The narratives of the aforementioned participants were coded for 13 different potential coping strategies. These coping strategies are outlined in Appendix H along with their corresponding identifying number (Della-Rossa, 2014).
The distribution of coping strategies over time is presented in the following 14 tables (Appendix I–V).
The following summary table identifies the total frequency of coping strategies used by all participants for Time 1 and Time 2. Subsequent time points have not been considered in this analysis. The summary table can be found in Appendix W.
Discussion
The study investigated each participant individually, assessing their coping strategies at different time points, if applicable, and assessing each participant’s most commonly used coping strategy. Note that many of the student soldiers were political liberals, even radicals and would not have volunteered to be tokkōtai pilots (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006). For example, one of the participants was actively trying to find other jobs, in the field of science, as to avoid being picked into the military. If the people were in the field of science, they would not be picked and instead would work on creating technology for the military (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006). Refer to Appendix X for significant coping strategies for all participants grouped to two timeframes, before being drafted and during the army.
Participant 1
The first participant, Sasaki Hachirō, has only one time point. The timeframe was before he was drafted for the army. At this time, the most common coping strategy was coping strategy 4, 6, 9, with 4, 5, and 4, times, respectively, for 17 diary entries. There were three coping strategies that were more frequently used than the rest. Converting the coping strategy number back into labels, the most used coping strategy was #6, which is “Planful Problem Solving,” used five times. The two coping strategies used four times each were #4 and #9, which are “Accept Responsibility” and “Endurance/Obedience/Effort.” Out of these three coping strategies, two of them fall under “Problem Solving Coping,” which are “Planful Problem Solving” and “Endurance/Obedience/Effort.” The third coping strategy falls under “Emotional Coping.” This is to say that Participant 1, Sasaki Hachirō, before he was drafted to become a soldier, used more problem solving coping to deal with his situation before being drafted. He placed more effort to change or escape the situation, using problem-focused efforts to alter the situation coupling with an analytic approach to solving the problem. One example on December 15, 1941, is “I would not refuse to be drafted if it is his order. I am not so weak as to be crushed by the war. However, I resolutely declare my anti-war stance. I will attempt to eliminate wars” (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 55). Here, although he is being drafted, he focused on changing the situation, by focusing on efforts of another aspect of sacrificing, to eliminate wars. At the same time, he placed more effort to persevere and comply with the demands. One example on April 4, 1940, Leaves of larch and birch are reflecting the morning sun and it is like looking at a scroll painting. I found my absolute authority here. If man did not possess a political nature, I would not mind sacrificing my life for this absolute authority [beauty and nature]. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 52)
Once he found absolute authority, his quest for beauty in nature, he did not mind sacrificing his own life for nature, though not for the emperor. In his own way, he was obeying his absolute quest, and once found, he was content dying for that beauty. The other most common coping strategy was “Accept Responsibility.” It was evident here between June 27 and July 1, 1942, when he stated, “perhaps it is better to go to war; things will be more clear-cut” (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 62). Here, he was accepting responsibility that he had a role in the problem and that he thought going to the war will make things more clear-cut, clearing up the problem of whether he should die for the war or not. Overall, the first participant has used two problem solving coping strategies and one emotional coping strategy as his most common coping strategies.
Sasaki accepted his fate and knew he had little hope for life. He was vocal in opposing against the war, and his views on the Japanese government and military were predominantly negative. He never avoided his fate. Instead, his love for literature had him copy essays during his Higher School time and subsequently, gave it to his brother, knowing that he would not come back after the war. The Japanese government at this time contrasts with the Nazis as Germans were told to kill, not to accept their own death for the nation (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006). His quest for idealism went in the form of beauty in nature, in human beings, and ideas. Because of his quest for beauty, he saw purity in spirit, and his idealism led him to find greater meaning in life than himself. His quest for idealism portrays the three coping strategies, enduring through the military to find beauty in nature, accepting his role in the problem (need to create a new Japan without war, just beauty) and actively seeking more beauty, for reasons to justify his own death for his country. This relates to Lazarus’s stress and coping theory in that he appraises the problem of dying for the country. His primary appraisal of the situation would be harm to himself. Being in the army, he knows he will not survive; yet, he continues as he overcomes his harm by seeking out beauty and idealism not in himself, but for the greater meaning in life, for a new Japan (secondary appraisal).
Participant 2
The second participant, Hayashi Tadao, had four different time points. The diary entries were in a chronological timeframe, starting when he had not been drafted to the army yet. At this time, there were several coping strategies used once throughout that time point, but there were two coping strategies that were used twice out of seven of the diary entries at first time point. These are coping strategies #3 and #9, which are “Self Control” and “Endurance/Obedience/Effort.” “Endurance/Obedience/Effort” falls under problem solving coping and “Self Control” falls under emotional coping. One example of “Self Control” is on October 12, 1941, “I cannot praise Japan any longer. The war is not to protect the country but the inevitable result of the way Japan has developed into a nation” (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 79). The way he was regulating his own feelings about the war is the essence of self-control coping. An example of “Endurance/Obedience/Effort” would be on September 23, 1942, “Bildung - that’s right - human life must be Bildung. We must make effort to reach our goal in life. Author’s context: Bildung refers to self-cultivation, that is, a constant effort to improve oneself” (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 81). Here, he was making an effort to improve himself. At this time point (before being drafted), he has mostly used one problem solving coping strategy and one emotional coping strategy.
At the next time point, where he was drafted as a student soldier, there were five diary entries, of which two coping strategies were used twice. These were coping strategies #4 and #11, which are “Accept Responsibility” and “Denial,” respectively. Both of these coping strategies are under emotional coping. One example of “Accept Responsibility” would be on January 1, 1944, “ . . . we must anticipate their arrival and thus burn all our energy for our goals at the moment . . . Not for the apotheosis of history, but for the realization of world history, we must sacrifice ourselves for its momentary intention” (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 83). One example of “Denial” is on January 3, 1944, … However, I cannot tolerate the reduction of the self to nothingness in the process. I cannot approve it. Martyrdom or sacrifice must be done at the height of self-realization. Sacrifice at the end of self-annihilation, the dissolving of the self to nothingness, has no meaning whatsoever. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 84)
The third time point, chronologically, was when he became a scout pilot after being drafted as a student soldier. Here, out of the 11 diary entries, the three most used coping strategies (which were used twice each) was #2, #9, and #11, “Distancing,” “Endurance/Obedience/Effort,” and “Denial,” respectively. One example of “Distancing” was on February 6, 1944, We felt the tension when we were coming to the point of no return. Now, it is quite the opposite. I have no more passion. The military kills passion and transforms people, making them indifferent, turning them into cogs that turn a wheel mechanically. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 85) … To live or to die - we don’t know … .In this diary, I exposed my weaknesses. This miserable human, in its entirety, is portrayed in the diary. The writing of the diary was a way of finding meaning for me, as I am trying not to be swept away by the vertigoes of the time and trying to live aktiv (actively). (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 89)
The last time point, time point #4, is mostly undated but has happened in the last year, 1945, before he died. Out of the three diary entries for this time point, he mostly used coping strategy #4, “Accept Responsibility,” twice. This example shows that he acknowledged that one has a responsibility in the problem. … Collapse! Japan is following the road to its destruction. We are heading toward the Todesmeer (sea of death). Those who struggle - it is hopeless … .Japan of the past will be destroyed. Destruction, what a sweet project. Decadence! Withering of a comfortable life. Bobbing and sinking. You - you are alive only by the eroticism of death. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 94)
In this last year, he mostly used one emotional coping strategy. Overall, he had used a variety of coping strategies. Before he was drafted, he used “Self-Control” and “Endurance/Obedience/Effort.” While he was a student soldier, he used “Accept Responsibility” and “Denial” mostly. Then, when he became a scout pilot, he mostly used “Distancing,” “Endurance/Obedience/Effort,” and “Denial.” Finally, in his last year, he mostly used “Accept Responsibility.” In the beginning, he used more problem-solving strategies, but as time progressed, he used more emotional coping strategies. This difference may be due to the fact that once drafted into the army, he began to more frequently and intensely contemplate the meaning of the war. Initially, he used to look at life as a way to improve himself. As time progressed, this effort deteriorated and turned into more of a self contemplation of the meaning of war and self, as well as an effort to comply with the military hinting on himself being pessimistic about returning home. Similarly, this is relatable to Lazarus’s stress and coping theory. Although his primary appraisal defines him as being in harm, he overcomes the harm (through his secondary appraisal) by contemplating the meaning of the war and looking at life to improve himself.
Participant 3
The third participant, Takushima Norimitsu, has diary entries split into two timeframes. One of them is before he was drafted. The next time frame is when he was drafted into the Imperial Navy around 1943 and 1944. In the first time frame, before he was drafted, out of his 23 diary entries, he mostly used coping strategy #2 and #4, which are “Distancing” (6 out of 23 times) and “Accept Responsibility” (5 out of 23 times), respectively. One example here of “Distancing” is on May 20, 1940, My feeling, which I thought was love, is gone, it seems. I am, after all, alone. I cannot be proud of the past and cannot believe in the present. Only hope for the future is shining over my head like a star with infinite truth and passion. Baudelaire declared love secular and base … .As Rousseau said, ‘I feel before I think’. I trust and respect intuition. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 112) Author’s context: He meets Yayeko and falls in love, and repeatedly expresses his opposition to nationalism … he realizes that he must give up on Romanticism and all it stands for: ‘I cannot think of my country before I think about myself, because I am not such a purist or a patriot’. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 114)
After he is drafted into the Imperial Navy, the two most used coping strategies are #4 and #8, which are “Accept Responsibility” (7 out of 29 entries) and “Seeking Social Support” (4 out of 29 entries). One example of “Accept Responsibility” here is on March 20, 1944, Remembering the past birthdays, I feel so lonely. Her tender feelings—no one else has such love. Why did I not take care of her better? I am filled with deep regrets. I feel sorry for my little brothers, who are unable to have the splendid childhood I had. My mother never leaves my mind, whenever I remember anything of my past. Mother, Mother, Mother. No matter how old one gets, the most important figure in life is one’s mother. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 119)
Likewise, an example of “Seeking Social Support” is on March 21, 1944, “Continuation of letter above: ‘I am pleased that I ask you to choose Cape jasmine as the offering [to me after death]. My mother loved that flower, too … ’” (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 119). The former is a type of emotional coping strategy where he was accepting responsibility, lecturing himself why he did not take care of his mother better. The latter is a form of problem-solving coping strategy where he sought help from others, in this case, asking his sweetheart to pick the type of flower for his deathbed. At this timeframe, he had used one emotional coping strategy and one problem-solving coping strategy. Overall, he used more emotional coping strategies than problem-solving coping strategies. Even though there was a problem-solving coping strategy, it was focused on the aspect of time when he has died and wants his sweetheart to pick the right flower (Cape jasmine) for him. Most of the coping strategies he had used have had an internal blame. Blaming himself for not taking care of his mother more and having to feel sadness but knowing that he has to break up with his sweetheart because of the war and the fact that he knows that he is not returning home. Even asking for the type of flower when he dies. To reiterate, the coping strategies he mostly used were “Accept Responsibility,” “Distancing,” and “Seeking Social Support.” The former two are emotional coping strategies, and the latter one being a problem-solving coping strategy. According to Lazarus’s stress and coping theory, his coping strategies would prevent future harm by distancing himself from the problem. He perceives that the problem is harmful to his well-being, and he tries to prevent future harm.
Participant 4
The fourth participant, Matsunaga Shigeo, has diary entries only in one time frame, which was before the war actually started. Out of seven diary entries, the mostly used coping strategy was “Self-Control” (three out of seven times). One example is “While the summer heat is still on the street, we hear ‘Banzai’ (Hail) on the street every day. ‘You must be anxious to go [to war]’ people [say]. I remain silent, with a faint smile” (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 138). This passage shows the act of self-control because he regulated his own feelings. This coping strategy, “Self-Control,” is primarily an emotional coping strategy; hence, even before the war started, he had already been using emotional coping to deal with the problem of war. According to Lazarus’s stress and coping theory, he appraised the problem (war) as harmful to his well-being, and he prevented further harm by regulating his own feelings and actions.
Participant 5
The fifth participant, Matsunaga Tatsuki, has diary entries in two different timeframes. One being before he was drafted. The second timeframe is when he was being drafted in the army at the beginning of 1942. In the first timeframe, when he was not drafted yet, the two most used coping strategies were #3 and #8. They were “Self-Control” (6 out of 25 entries) and “Seeking Social Support” (5 out of 25 times). The former, an emotional coping strategy where the participant regulates their own feelings and actions and the latter, a problem-solving coping strategy where he seeks out social support. On August 16, 1941, he showed self control with his feelings in asking his wife out. At night again at Suikosha [a restaurant]. We spent some time in the garden … .I feel that I am loved. I won’t say a word. I just watch her. Just the two of us … .I restrained myself and did not ask when I can see her next, which I regret[ted] in the following days. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 143) Today I raise my white flag [of surrender to Ayako]. At 2 o'clock in the afternoon, you came with my father. Just the two of us spent the time in the room upstairs, first in the back of it and then mov[ing] toward the veranda, where until sunset we talked, feeling the autumn breeze, looking at the clouds in the sky. What a pleasure to be reassured of your youthful and rebellious character. We spent some time with Mother. Then Father called. We looked at the crimson sky over the vegetable garden. And, dinner together. Then, holding hands, we talked as I accompanied you back over the dark road. Then, I was invited into your house for a beer. Enough said. My love toward you is being intensified every moment. Perfect happiness. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 147)
In the second timeframe, out of 17 diary entries, “Endurance/Obedience/Effort” was used the most (5 out of 17 times). This is one of the problem-solving coping strategies, and it was used in the context of complying with the military. The example in this timeframe shows that he has to persevere under the demands of the military. It has been a month since I was made a probationary officer … .I want to make myself clear here in case I fall [die] - as advice for those who succeed me after I fall. I was forced without choice to go through the examination to be a candidate to be an officer … .Yet, the official line is that I volunteered. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 149)
Overall, this participant, Matsunaga Tatsuki has used three different coping strategies, two of which are problem-solving coping strategies and one emotional coping strategy. They are “Seeking Social Support,” “Endurance/Obedience/Effort,” and “Self-Control.” Initially, before being drafted, the use of “Seeking Social Support” and “Self-Control” was to consult his feelings about the war. As time passed and he was drafted, he was forced to comply with the military, losing most of his personal feelings. Although this might have happened, some of his diary entries have hinted in “Endurance/Obedience/Effort” in the aspect of persevering with the military but in his own way, putting effort into creating a unique training for his soldiers. In some aspects, “Endurance/Obedience/Effort” does not have to be in the same direction as the higher authority, but their own direction.
Participant 6
The sixth participant, Hayashi Ichizo, has one timeframe, which has diaries written while he was at the Naval Base. Out of 28 diary entries, the two mostly used coping strategies are “Accept Responsibility” (8 out of 28 diary entries) and “Positive Appraisal” (5 out of 28 diary entries). Both of these coping strategies are emotional coping strategies. The former is shown here, where he accepted his role in the problem of dying for the emperor and that he accepted the fact that he is not afraid of the moment of his death but how the fear of death will disturb his life. To be honest, I cannot say that the wish to die for the emperor is genuine, coming from my heart. However, it is decided for me that I die for the emperor … .I shall not be afraid of the moment of my death. But I am afraid of how the fear of death will perturb my life. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 170) Mother, I am a man. All men born in Japan are destined to die fighting for the country. You have done a splendid job raising me to become an honorable man … .I will do a splendid job sinking an enemy aircraft. Do brag about me. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 173)
Overall, during his time in the Naval Base, he has used mostly emotional coping, in which one of them (Accept Responsibility) is used in the way of accepting his “fate” of dying for the emperor, and the other (Positive Appraisal) is used in a positive light, looking at his situation in a more positive perspective. Relating to Lazarus’s stress and coping theory, he overcame his problem by utilizing coping strategies in a more positive light, to see the benefits in the problem.
Participant 7
The final participant, Nakao Takenori, has diary entries written in two different timeframes. The first timeframe was before he was drafted and the second timeframe was when he was drafted as a student soldier. In the first timeframe, the most used coping strategy is “Self-Control” (6 out of 17 times). An example is shown here: We are fighting for life against Britain, the great empire on the decline, and America, at its peak for its material culture. Although I am not physically in the battlefield yet, I am already in it. I myself, in pursuit of the infinite and in love with the absolute, too, must sacrifice myself for the nation … .Is the “absolute” to be located in our sacrifice for the nation? … .I cannot help but agonize over the contradiction … .I, who have come to know the depth of life and live that life, must sacrifice my life for our country since my life is destined to be given for the nation? … .I painfully struggle in pursuit of truth. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 201)
In the second timeframe, the mostly used coping strategy is “Compartmentalization” (4 out of 4 diary entries). This coping strategy is also a type of emotional coping strategy and is the effort to capture the problem psychologically and isolate it from other parts of their lives. Here, in this example, Author’s context: Last letter to his parents. At the farewell party, people gave me encouragement. I did my best to encourage myself. I am truly a happy person. I can now meet my death with the belief that I have been treated with sincerity by people when I have not done anything for them. I have nothing to say at this time. I only hope for health for you all. (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006, p. 194)
Refer to Appendix Y for the frequency of coping strategies used by all participants across Timeframe 1 and Timeframe 2.
The coping strategies that are used more than once at Timeframe 1 (before being drafted) are “Self-Control,” “Accept Responsibility,” and “Endurance/Obedience/Effort.” “Endurance/Obedience/Effort” is the only problem-solving coping strategy used before the participants were drafted. This coping strategy was used in the perspective of placing efforts to find their true self, and persevering through their faith in the beauty of nature, which once found, encouraged their ability to sacrifice their self for their nation, family, and others whom they loved. “Self Control” and “Accept Responsibility,” the two other coping strategies are emotional coping strategies. These two coping strategies are used to assimilate their feelings, to feel responsible not just for their nation but for a new Japan, their family, to end all wars, and to be a man according to their cultural gender definitions of the time.
In Timeframe 2 (while they were in the army), the two coping strategies that are used more than once are “Accept Responsibility” and “Endurance/Obedience/Effort.” The problem-solving coping strategy, “Endurance/Obedience/Effort,” is used in the form of complying with the military, and at times, placing effort to create their own unique form of training for their soldiers and to keep their true self attached, by giving education to their soldiers. “Accept Responsibility” is exercised for them to assimilate their feelings and for them to realize that they have a role in the problem, to either sever their ties with their family or loved ones to prevent them from being more emotionally upset. They also acknowledged their role to fulfill their “fate” in dying for their nation, for a new Japan, or to believe that dying will prevent someone else from dying and just that though makes them believe that sacrificing their life is worth it.
The implications of the coping strategies used in both timeframes present strategies in an internal manner. In both timeframes, they used “Endurance/Obedience/Effort,” which is categorized under problem solving coping. This strategy, among the other two emotional coping strategies (Accept Responsibility and Self-Control), focuses on the self. While the participants waited to be drafted into the military, the most common strategy was to be passive about the situation. They accepted their responsibility in the military, regulated their feelings on this issue, and obeyed what Japan wanted them to do. This potentially demonstrates a different subcategory of coping, specifically passive and active coping strategies. All the most common coping strategies focus on the passive self. Further research can explore the possibility of coping strategies with regard to the self, whether the participant utilizes passive or active coping strategies to approach the problem.
Throughout this study, self-control, accepting their responsibility, and persevering with demands are significant coping strategies.
Because these diary entries were intended to be read following the death of their writers, it is important to the reader’s experience while reading these texts. In so doing, it is possible to have a deeper understanding of what sentiments, emotions, and message the participants were portraying. The main text source for analyses, Kamikaze Diaries: Reflections of Japanese Student Soldiers, was full of emotional and compassionate diary entries. The heavy emphasis on romanticism from each participant portrays a different view on life than the current era, where materialism is heavily thought of. Again, the participants were all at a university level and were also well educated in languages. Some of them were in love with purity itself and searched through essays, books, and anecdotal experiences, to find the meaning of life, greater than their current life. With so much knowledge and ambition in life, to read the progress of how each one of them died was touching, in both extremes; sorrow and hate. The feeling of sorrow appeared throughout their struggles coming to terms with their imminent death. In the last few days before they left for the military and even during the military, they thought of their family, giving thanks to them, and addressed each sibling a last message. The soldiers also gave closure to areas of their lives other than their family, such as giving their unfinished work back to their professor, leaving their jobs, and watching their last play. Knowing that they will have to face death in the military, they still acted calmly and gave themselves closure in each aspect of their lives. The act of closure is what struck a chord while reading. The other feeling, hate, was toward their overall lives. In light of their writing, reflections on the current generation being in a world with relative peace were brought to mind, especially as compared with soldiers who were forced to be born in Japan, in 1940s, and consequently, their dreams had to be prematurely shut down.
Limitations
One apparent limitation is a lack of several raters to create an interrater reliability for the coding of coping strategies. Multiple raters and high interrater reliability will provide evidence that the coping strategies coded are agreed upon. Although the study has been coded with a certified thematic content analysis human rater, having more than one rater will increase the reliability of the evidence. Further limitations that can be observed at this point in time relate to the comparability of samples. The samples of interest are comparable with other populations that face imminent death, on the basis that it is not voluntary. Nonetheless, looking into different samples facing death has the ability to bring up information unbeknown to us. Another limitation is the generalizability of the population of interest and the sample the study has used. For example, when comparing tokkōtai pilots and terminal cancer patients, although both are facing inevitable death, important differences exist. The tokkōtai pilots were facing death with respect to having wars. Terminal cancer patients are facing death with respect to their internal cancer consuming them from the inside. Another difference is shown between death being imminent or possible for soldiers. For surviving soldiers, they frequently used social support as a coping strategy to dampen their past trauma, whereas tokkōtai pilots had to accept their role in dying for the nation. In addition, the diary entries are written by Japanese young adults who are all well educated, all having university-level education, when compared with terminal cancer patients that vary in terms of their education, which might affect their production of feelings and thoughts that they might have. Furthermore, the leader of the kamikaze idea itself thought that the Japanese soul was unique in that it can face death without looking back. This idea of a courageous and confident Japanese soul might pertain only to Japan’s culture and decrease the generalizability of the results. Other cultures might not think that they can die without second thought. They might have a different portrayal of their soul and life, subsequently affecting the coping strategies they would utilize. Also, the method used is a retrospective method and to give causality to the results, a prospective method where manipulation can be done should be implicated. The current method is especially relevant for extracting the context and subtleties of the human experience from all the data. Such is especially the case for populations that are difficult to access, such as the tokkōtai pilots. Further studies should also implement a more manipulative method that can bring causality into the equation, subsequently backing up the evidence and its direction of causality (Kleinbaum & Kupper, 1982).
Several issues have surfaced in previous studies that use thematic content analysis, Ways of Coping scale. First, the nature of this method is cross sectional and retrospective, which does not allow us to make causation in the results. The results can be bidirectional, and the observations that seem to have a trend can go in both directions, meaning, for example, depression can lead to an “Accept Responsibility” coping strategy, or “Accept Responsibility” coping strategy can lead to depression. The type of coping strategy can influence the outcome of a situation or vice versa. This issue can be resolved by having a prospective design (Folkman et al., 1986). Another issue involves macroanalytic and microanalytic assessment techniques. Some coping strategies may be more preferred in one situation; therefore, they may vary from one situation to another. Alternatively, macroanalysis can observe coping strategies as a whole, not just isolated situations. The narratives influence the generalizability and specificity of the results (Folkman et al., 1986). Also, thematic content analysis heavily relies on self-report to learn what the sample felt and did during the situation. Although self-report may be the only way to reach into certain kinds of information, it is recommended that self-report needs to be used with other methods such as physiological assessment and observational studies (Folkman et al., 1986).
Future Directions
Future studies should consider the possibility of a better alternative coping strategy for populations facing imminent death such as terminal cancer patients, AIDS patients, or patients with Huntington’s disease. There are also populations who are not facing imminent death, but possible death, such as surviving soldiers, who may turn to more appropriate alternative coping strategies. Investigating these groups’ narratives can provide opportunities to understand how they cope with their situation and how this can affect clinical treatment. This study hints on accepting their fate (Accept Responsibility), persevering with the war in their own positive light (Endurance/Obedience/Effort), and regulating their feelings, which mostly are contemplating why they need to die for their nation (Self-Control). Solidifying these coping strategies using various clinical treatments that target terminal cancer patients’ cognitions and perceptions of their cancer can regulate their feelings, persevering with their cancer in a positive way, and finally accepting their role in the problem and actively trying to fix it, enduring through their cancer (Clayton, Butow, Arnold, & Tattersall, 2005). Another aspect of this study that should be considered in future studies is sample control. The unique Japanese soul and identity described in the diaries of tokkōtai soldiers may affect results in different ways. In future studies, sampling with other samples such as Western cultures or from another time period can observe differences in coping strategies and what those findings may further explain. Further research can be implemented on treatments targeting cognitions and perceptions regarding individuals as a person, their role in the problem and extracting their effort to persevere with their stress, not giving up hope.
Appendix Appendix A. Brief Overview of Participant 1.
Note. Brief description: He was drafted as student soldier and volunteered to be a tokkōtai pilot. His eldest son contracted amoebic dysentery and died. His father never spoke to him after Hachirō did not listen to him and continued to volunteer being a pilot. Hachirō was one of 500 students from University of Tokyo drafted and “volunteered” to be tokkōtai pilots.
Other information: He had a voracious appetite for learning which ranged from Plato and Socrates to Rousseau and those who lived for “art for art’s sake.”
Appendix B. Brief Overview of Participant 2.
Note. Brief description: He was drafted as a student soldier and sought training as a scout pilot, then became a Navy Air Force pilot with the rank of ensign. His plane was shot down by an American fighter plane during a scouting mission. The themes that were central to Hayashi Tadao were the quest for beauty in nature, people, and ideas. He also had an intense desire for intellectual companionship with male friends and to find a real, intellectual friend. He dealt heavily with the issue of dying for the country and the desire to live.
Other interesting information: His eldest son, Hayashi Katsuya, did not agree with the tradition of “Meiji style,” and the feudalistic approach of family and argument caused their (Hayashi family) father’s stroke and subsequent death.
Appendix C. Brief Overview of Participant 3.
Note. Brief description: He was drafted into the Imperial Navy in September 1943. He was in Keiō University which was one of the two top private universities in the country. Takushima perished as a lieutenant. He died by flying a land-based attack bomber which was part of Japanese’s last-minute effort to save the country, but this operation was not part of the tokkōtai operation. His favorite flower is the Cape jasmine, and he interpreted it as a metaphor for the Japanese people during the war, as they could not explicitly express their thoughts in wartime and had to keep them private, with the only possible way of articulating it being in the diaries. The flower was also a metaphor for his mother.
Other information: His father remarried, and Takushima Norimitsu had a hard time feeling positive toward his stepmother without having influence from his intense love for his birth mother.
Appendix D. Brief Overview of Participant 4.
Note. Brief description: Matsunaga Shigeo was not part of the tokkōtai operation, but they were drafted as students and were forced to fight and consequently die. Both he and his brother, Matsunaga Tatsuki, enjoyed a high status in society. Their writings were associated with high social class standards. Their father was a high-ranking officer in the Japanese Navy, and their biological mother (deceased) was a well-educated Christian. Even though their father had a high-ranking position in the Navy, they were still drafted into the army.
Other information: He entered First Higher School as a science major and took a job teaching literature to elementary schoolchildren. He also had a literary career, publishing issues in a literary magazine.
Appendix E. Brief Overview of Participant 5.
Note. Brief description: Married a woman named Ayako. Two months later, he failed the physical examination for the Navy, was drafted by the army, and was sent to China via Korea. He was promoted to the rank of first lieutenant. His view of women was quite progressive, a characteristic that can be seen in other participants’ narratives as well. They discussed “new feminism” where they advocated women’s education and their full realization as human beings. He also wanted his wife to be an independent and rebellious spirit and to grow intellectually during their separation. He was attracted to her physically but restrained his sexual desires out of respect for her, even the night before he left for the army.
Other information: Te is the younger brother of Participant 4, Matsunaga Shigeo.
Appendix F. Brief Overview of Participant 6.
Note. Brief description: He was born into a well-educated Christian family. He was the oldest male child. He had two older sisters named Hiroko and Chiyoko as well as a younger brother, Makio. His father died suddenly after being appointed assistant professor at the University of Tokyo. His father respected people, and even called his daughter “Hiroko-sama,” which is a polite form of addressing people. Hayashi Ichizō’s mother struggled to accept her husband’s sudden death but carried her husband’s belief in enlightenment and civilization. Therefore, she taught farm girls at the local elementary school even though at that time, peasants were thought not to need education, let alone peasant girls.
Other information: Their family was devout Christians, and the Bible united the family spiritually, keeping the children and their mother close.
Appendix G. Brief Overview of Participant 7.
Note. Brief description: His father was the manager of a factory producing silk threads in Gifu. Nakao had an elder brother who went to technical high school specializing in silk thread production. His younger brother became a painter.
Other information: On May 5, 1945, the family went to Takuma Base, hoping to see Nakao Takenori, but the military told them he was not there. What they did not realize was that he had already died, and the military did not say anything. They only knew about his death after the war ended.
List of Coping Strategies, Coded by Their Numbers.
Appendix I. Participant 1, Sasaki Hachirō, Coping Strategies Tallied.
Note. See Appendix J for full analysis.
Full Analysis: Participant 1, Sasaki Hachiro, Diary Entries at One Timeframe, Time 1 Before He Was Drafted Into the Military (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006).
Participant 2, Hayashi Tadao, Coping Strategies Tallied, at Different Timeframes.
Note. See Appendix L for full analysis.
Participant 2, Hayashi Tadao’s, Diary Entries at Four Different Timeframes, Time 1 Before He Was Drafted Into the Military, Time 2 During His Student Soldier Times in the Military, Time 3 During His Scout Pilot Times, and Time 4 During the Last Year of His Life, Undated With Random Thoughts (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006).
Participant 3, Takushima Norimitsu, Coping Strategies Tallied.
Note. See Appendix N for full analysis.
Participant 3, Takushima Norimitsu’s, Diary Entries at Two Timeframes, Time 1 Before He Was Drafted and Time 2 While He Was Drafted Into the Imperial Navy (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006).
Participant 4, Matsunaga Shigeo, Coping Strategies Tallied.
Note. See Appendix P for full analysis.
Participant 4, Matsunaga Shigeo, Diary Entries at One Timeframe, Time 1 From Entering Army Till Death (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006).
Participant 5, Matsunaga Tatsuki, Coping Strategies Tallied.
Note. See Appendix R for full analysis.
Participant 5, Matsunaga Tatsuki, Diary Entries at Two Timeframes, Time 1 Before He Was Drafted and Time 2 While He Was in the Army (Ohnuki-Tierney, 2006).
Participant 6, Hayashi Ichizo, Coping Strategies Tallied.
Note. See Appendix T for full analysis.
Participant 6, Hayashi Ichizo, Diary Entries at One Timeframe, Time 1 Before He Was Drafted.
Participant 7, Nakao Takenori, Coping Strategies Tallied.
Note. See Appendix V for full analysis.
Participant 7, Nakao Takenori, Diary Entries at Two Timeframes, Time 1 Before He Was Drafted and Time 2 While He Was in the Army.
All Coping Strategies for All Participants Tallied.
Significant Coping Strategies for All Participants Grouped to Two Timeframes, Before Being Drafted and During the Army.
Frequency of Coping Strategies Used by All Participants Across Timeframe 1 and Timeframe 2.
Footnotes
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Funding
The author(s) received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
