Who Leads the Party? On Membership Size,Selectorates and Party Oligarchy

Abstract

We examine the degree to which party leaders dominate their parties over time and across countries and analyse how leadership domination relates to formal aspects of party organisation. Moreover, we analyse whether antidotes against leadership domination – widening the selectorate and increasing the membership – explain change in leadership domination. For this purpose, we use a new dataset that brings together different sources of party data over time and between countries. We find that leadership domination indeed has increased over time, but still a lot of variation exists between parties. We also demonstrate that widening the selectorate – for example, letting members elect the party leader – and increasing membership boosts leadership domination. In other words, the antidotes against leadership domination do not work.

Keywords

party organisation party leadership selectorate members

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allern

Pedersen

(2007) The Impact of Party Organisational Changes on Democracy. West European Politics 30(1): 68–92.

Armingeon

Knöpfel

Weisstanner

. (2013) Comparative Political Data Set I 1960–2011. Bern: Institute of Political Science, University of Berne.

Bille

(2001) Democratizing a Democratic Procedure. Myth or Reality? Candidate Selection in Western European Parties, 1960–1990. Party Politics 7(3): 363–380.

Blyth

Katz

(2005) From Catch-All Politics to Cartelisation: The Political Economy of the Cartel Party. West European Politics 28(1): 33–60.

Bolleyer

(2012) New Party Organization in Western Europe: Of Party Hierarchies, Stratarchies and Federations. Party Politics 18(3): 315–336.

Brambor

Clark

Golder

(2006) Understanding Interaction Models: Improving Empirical Analyses. Political Analysis 14(1): 63–82.

Bueno de Mesquita

Morrow

Siverson

. (2002) Political Institutions, Policy Choice and the Survival of Leaders. British Journal of Political Science 32(4): 559–590.

Cross

Blais

(2011) Who Selects the Party Leader? Party Politics 18(2): 127–150.

Cross

Young

(2004) The Contours of Political Party Membership in Canada. Party Politics 10(4): 427–444.

10.

Dahl

Tufte

(1973) Size and Democracy. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

11.

Dalton

Wattenberg

(2002) Parties without Partisans: Political Change in Advanced Industrial Democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

12.

Döring

Manow

(2015) Parliaments and Governments Database (ParlGov): Information on Parties, Elections and Cabinets in Modern Democracies. Available at: http://www.parlgov.org/ (accessed 26 October 2015).

13.

Duverger

(1964) Political Parties: Their Organization and Activity in the Modern State. London: Methuen Books.

14.

Ennser-Jedenastik

Schumacher

(2015) Why Some Leaders Die Hard (and Others Don’t): Party Goals, Party Institutions, and How They Interact. In: Cross

Pilet

(eds) The Politics of Party Leadership: A Cross-National Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.107–127.

15.

Epstein

(1967) Political Parties in Western Democracies. Westport, CT: Praeger Publishers.

16.

Gallagher

Marsh

(2004) Party Membership in Ireland: The Members of Fine Gael. Party Politics 10: 407–425.

17.

Gauja

(2014) The Construction of Party Membership. European Journal of Political Research 54(2): 232–248.

18.

Giger

Schumacher

(2015) Integrated Party Organization Dataset (IPOD): V2. Available at: https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.7910/DVN/PE8TWP (accessed 26 October 2015).

19.

Harmel

Janda

(1994a) An Integrated Theory of Party Goals and Party Change. Journal of Theoretical Politics 6(3): 259–287.

20.

Harmel

Janda

(1994b) Longitudinal Study of Party Change, 1950–1990. Available at: http://janda.org/ICPP/ICPP1990/index.htm (accessed 26 October 2015).

21.

Hazan

Rahat

(2010) Democracy within Parties: Candidate Selection Methods and Their Political Consequences. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

22.

Heidar

(1994) The Polymorphic Nature of Party Membership. European Journal of Political Research 25: 61–86.

23.

Heidar

Saglie

(2003) A Decline of Linkage? Intra-Party Participation in Norway, 1991–2000. European Journal of Political Research 42: 761–786.

24.

Hopkin

Paolucci

(1999) New Parties and the Business Firm Model of Party Organization: Cases from Spain and Italy. European Journal of Political Research 35(3): 307–339.

25.

Janda

(ed.) (1980) Political Parties: A Cross-National Survey. New York: The Free Press.

26.

Katz

(2001) The Problem of Candidate Selection and Models of Party Democracy. Party Politics 7: 277–296.

27.

Katz

Mair

(1992) Party Organizations: A Data Handbook. London: SAGE.

28.

Katz

Mair

(1994) How Parties Organize: Change and Adaptation in Party Organizations in Western Democracies. London: SAGE.

29.

Katz

Mair

(1995) Changing Models of Party Organization and Party Democracy: The Emergence of the Cartel Party. Party Politics 1(1): 5–28.

30.

Katz

Mair

(2002) The Ascendancy of the Party in Public Office: Party Organizational Change in Twentieth-Century Democracies. In: Gunther

Montero

Linz

(eds) Political Parties. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.113–135.

31.

Katz

Mair

(2009) The Cartel Party Thesis: A Restatement. Perspectives on Politics 7(4): 753–766.

32.

Katz

Mair

Bardi

. (1992) The Membership of Political Parties in European Democracies, 1960–1990. European Journal of Political Research 22: 329–345.

33.

Kenig

(2009a) Classifying Party Leaders’ Selection Methods in Parliamentary Democracies. Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties 19(4): 433–447.

34.

Kenig

(2009b) Democratization of Party Leadership Selection: Do Wider Selectorates Produce More Competitive Contests? Electoral Studies 28(2): 240–247.

35.

Kirchheimer

(1966) The Transformation of Western European Party Systems. In: LaPalombara

Weiner

(eds) Political Parties and Political Development. Merchantville, NJ: Yale University Press, pp.177–200.

36.

Kitschelt

(1988) Organization and Strategy of Belgian and West German Ecology Parties: A New Dynamic of Party Politics in Western Europe? Comparative Politics 20(2): 127–154.

37.

Kitschelt

(2000) Citizens, Politicians, and Party Cartellization: Political Representation and State Failure in Post-Industrial Democracies. European Journal of Political Research 37(2): 149–179.

38.

Kitschelt

(2013) Dataset of the Democratic Accountability and Linkages Project (DALP). Available at: https://sites.duke.edu/democracylinkage/ (accessed 26 October 2014).

39.

Kölln

A-K

(2015) The Effects of Membership Decline on Party Organisations in Europe. European Journal of Political Research. Epub ahead of print 20 August 2015. DOI: 10.1111/1475-6765.12110.

40.

Kölln

A-K

(2016) Party Membership in Europe Testing Party-Level Explanations of Decline. Party Politics 22: 465–477.

41.

Koole

(1996) Cadre, Catch-All or Cartel? A Comment on the Notion of the Cartel Party. Party Politics 2(4): 507–523.

42.

Krouwel

(2003) Otto Kirchheimer and the Catch-All Party. West European Politics 26(2): 23–40.

43.

Laver

Hunt

(1992) Policy and Party Competition. London: Routledge.

44.

LeDuc

(2001) Democratizing Party Leadership Selection. Party Politics 7(3): 323–341.

45.

Loxbo

(2013) The Fate of Intra-Party Democracy: Leadership Autonomy and Activist Influence in the Mass Party and the Cartel Party. Party Politics 19: 537–554.

46.

Lundell

(2004) Determinants of Candidate Selection. The Degree of Centralization in Comparative Perspective. Party Politics 10(1): 25–47.

47.

Mair

(1994) Party Organizations: From Civil Society to the State. In: Katz

Mair

(eds) How Parties Organize. London: SAGE Publishing, pp.1–22.

48.

Mair

(2013) Ruling the Void: The Hollowing of Western Democracy. London: Verso.

49.

Mair

Van Biezen

(2001) Party Membership in Twenty European Democracies, 1980–2000. Party Politics 7(1): 5–21.

50.

May

(1973) Opinion Structure of Political Parties: The Special Law of Curvilinear Disparity. Political Studies 21: 135–151.

51.

Michels

(1915) Political Parties: A Sociological Study of the Oligarchical Tendencies of Modern Democracy. New York: Hearst’s International Library Co.

52.

Olson

(1965) The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

53.

Ostrogorski

(1902) Democracy and the Organization of Political Parties. New York: Macmillan Publishers.

54.

Panebianco

(1988) Political Parties: Organization and Power. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

55.

Pedersen

(2010a) Differences and Changes in Party Organisations: Central Party Organisation versus Parliamentary Party Group Power. Journal of Legislative Studies 16(2): 233–250.

56.

Pedersen

(2010b) How Intra-Party Power Relations Affect the Coalition Behaviour of Political Parties. Party Politics 16(6): 737–754.

57.

Pedersen

(2012a) Policy-Seeking Parties in Multiparty Systems: Influence or Purity? Party Politics 18: 297–314.

58.

Pedersen

(2012b) What Do Parties Want? Policy versus Office. West European Politics 35(4): 37–41.

59.

Pedersen

Bille

Buch

. (2004) Sleeping or Active Partners? Danish Party Members at the Turn of the Millennium. Party Politics 10(4): 367–383.

60.

Pilet

Cross

(2014) The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies. London: Routledge.

61.

Poguntke

(2002) Party Organizational Linkage: Parties without Firm Social Roots? In: Luther

Müller-Rommel

(eds) Political Parties in the New Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.43–62.

62.

Poguntke

Webb

(2005) The Presidentialization of Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

63.

Rohrschneider

Whitefield

(2009) Understanding Cleavages in Party Systems: Issue Position and Issue Salience in 13 Post-Communist Democracies. Comparative Political Studies 42(2): 280–313.

64.

Rohrschneider

Whitefield

(2012) The Strain of Representation: How Parties Represent Diverse Voters in Western and Eastern Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

65.

Safran

(2009) The Catch-All Party Revisited: Reflections of a Kirchheimer Student. Party Politics 15(5): 543–554.

66.

Sandri

Pauwels

(2010) Party Membership Role and Party Cartelization in Belgium and Italy: Two Faces of the Same Medal? Politics & Policy 38(6): 1237–1266.

67.

Sartori

(1976) Parties and Party Systems. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

68.

Scarrow

(1999) Parties and the Expansion of Direct Democracy: Who Benefits? Party Politics 5: 341–362.

69.

Scarrow

(2002) Parties without Members? Party Organization in a Changing Electoral Environment. In: Dalton

Wattenberg

(eds) Parties without Partisans: Political Change in Advanced Industrial Democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.79–101.

70.

Scarrow

(2007) Political Finance in Comparative Perspective. Annual Review of Political Science 10: 193–210.

71.

Schumacher

(2012) ‘Marx’ or the Market: Social Democrats. The Intra-Party Balance of Power and When Social Democrats Enact Welfare State Retrenchment. West European Politics 35: 1024–1043.

72.

Schumacher

De Vries

Vis

(2013) Why Do Parties Change Position? Party Organization and Environmental Incentives. Journal of Politics 75(2): 464–477.

73.

Seyd

Whiteley

(2003) British Party Members: An Overview. Party Politics 10: 355–366.

74.

Tan

(1998) The Impacts of Party Membership Size: A Cross-National Analysis. Journal of Politics 60(1): 188.

75.

Van Biezen

Mair

Poguntke

(2012) Going, Going, … Gone? The Decline of Party Membership in Contemporary Europe. European Journal of Political Research 51(1): 24–56.

76.

Van Haute

. (2015) MAPP – Party Membership Figures in 32 Countries 1945–2014. MAPP Project Data Archive. Available at: http://www.projectmapp.eu (accessed 26 October 2015).

77.

Wauters

(2013) Democratising Party Leadership Selection in Belgium: Motivations and Decision Makers. Political Studies 62: 61–80.

78.

Webb

(2000) The Modern British Party System. London: SAGE.

79.

Weber

(2004) The Vocation Lectures. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing.

80.

Weldon

(2006) Downsize My Polity? The Impact of Size on Party Membership and Member Activism. Party Politics 12(4): 467–481.

81.

Whiteley

Seyd

(2002) High-Intensity Participation: The Dynamics of Party Activism in Britain. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.

82.

Wolinetz

(1977) The Dutch Labour Party: A Social Democratic Party in Transition. In: Paterson

Thomas

(eds) Social Democratic Parties in Western Europe. London: Croom Helm, pp.67–98.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.43 MB