Homicide and suicide are intentional acts of violence that disproportionately involve firearms. Much more effort has been devoted to the ecological study of homicide; methods that have been developed to better understand and subsequently prevent homicide may be applicable to suicide. The purpose of the present study was to compare the occurrence of firearm homicide and firearm suicide using routine activity theory as a framework for analysis.
Methods.
Detailed mortality data pertaining to decedents, their neighborhoods, and use of firearms were collected from 1994 to 1998 for the counties containing and surrounding three small to medium-sized U.S. cities. Data from a total of 468 neighborhoods that collectively experienced 1,025 intentional deaths from firearms (396 firearm homicides and 629 firearm suicides) were analyzed.
Results.
Firearm homicide was consistently associated with out-of-home, nighttime activity in neighborhoods where many people were likely to be coming and going. In an opposite-but-equal fashion, firearm suicide was consistently associated with in-home, daytime activity in out-of-the-way neighborhoods.
Conclusions.
Firearm homicide and firearm suicide were found to be consistently associated with markers of routine activity in all three cities, albeit in an opposite-but-equal manner. Because firearm suicides very often occur as lonely events in lonely neighborhoods, they may go under-noticed relative to firearm homicides. More awareness and additional public health studies of firearm suicide, in tandem with firearm homicide, should be pursued to better identify individuals and neighborhoods that are at greatest risk of experiencing each event.
References
1.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (US), National Center for Injury Prevention and Control. Scientific data, statistics, surveillance, and mapping. Interactive statistics and mapping systems. WISQARS™ [Web-based Injury Statistics Query and Reporting System] [cited 2003 Jul 17]. Available from: URL: http://www.cdc.gov/ncipc/osp/data.htm
2.
PokornyAD. Human violence: a comparison of homicide, aggravated assault, suicide, and attempted suicide. In: WeinerNAZahnMASagiRJ, editors. Violence: patterns, causes, public policy. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich; 1990. p. 69–79.
3.
Institute for Scientific Information. ISI Web of Science cited literature search [cited 2003 Jun 15]. Available from: URL: http://wos.isiglobalnet2.com/
4.
CohenLEFelsonM. Social change and crime rate trends: a routine activity approach. Am Sociol Rev1979;44:588–608.
5.
BirkbeckCLaFreeG. The situational analysis of crime and deviance. Annu Rev Sociol1993;19:113–37.
6.
FelsonM. Crime and everyday life: insights and implications for society. Thousand Oaks (CA): Pine Forge Press; 1994.
7.
FelsonM. The ecology of crime. In: KadishSH, editor. Encyclopedia of crime and justice. New York: Free Press; 1983. p. 665–70.
8.
EckJEWeisburdD. Crime and place. Monsey (NY): Criminal Justice Press; 1995.
9.
CaywoodT. Routine activities and urban homicides: a tale of two cities. Homicide Stud1998;2:64–82.
10.
TardiffKMarzukPMLeonACHirschCSStajicMPorteraLHartwellN. A profile of homicides on the streets and in the homes of New York City. Public Health Rep1995;110:13–7.
11.
MessnerSFTardiffK. The social ecology of urban homicide: an application of the routine activities approach. Criminology1985;23:241–67.
12.
MasseyCRMcKeanJ. The social ecology of homicides: a modified lifestyle/routine activities perspective. J Criminal Justice1985;13:417–28.
13.
Medical College of Wisconsin. Firearm fatalities: the 1999 annual statistical report of the Firearm Injury Reporting System (FIRS). Milwaukee: Medical College of Wisconsin Firearm Injury Center; 1999.
14.
MohlerBEarlsF. Trends in adolescent suicide: misclassification bias?Am J Public Health2001;91:150–3.
15.
MillerMHemenwayD. The relationship between firearms and suicide: a review of the literature. Aggression Violent Behav1999;4:59–75.
16.
MercyJAIkedaRPowellKE. Firearm-related injury surveillance: an overview of progress and the challenges ahead. Am J Prev Med1998;15Suppl 3:6–16.
17.
CattaneoCDiMartinoSScaliSCraigOEGrandiMSokolRJ. Determining the human origin of fragments of burnt bone: a comparative study of histological, immunological and DNA techniques. Forensic Sci Int1999;102:181–91.
18.
GrevinGBailetPQuatrehommeGOllierA. Anatomical reconstruction of fragments of burned human bones: a necessary means for forensic identification. Forensic Sci Int1998;96:129–34.
19.
VesterbyAPoulsenLW. The diagnosis of a murder from skeletal remains: a case report. Int J Legal Med1997;110:97–100.
20.
LaMacchiaRAMarxRWSobelJ. Census tracts and block numbering areas. In: Census Bureau (US). Geographic areas reference manual. Washington: Department of Commerce (US); 1994. p. 1–15.
MausnerJSKramerS. Measurement of morbidity and mortality. In: MausnerJSKramerS. Epidemiology: an introductory text. 2nd ed.Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders; 1985. p. 49–50.
25.
BohningDDietzESchlattmannP. Zero-inflated count models and their applications in public health and social science. In: RostJLangeheineR, editors. Applications of latent trait and latent class models in the social sciences. New York: Waxmann Publishing; 1997. p. 333–44.
26.
CameronACTrivediPK. Regression analysis of count data. New York: Cambridge University Press; 1998.
27.
GreeneWH. Accounting for excess zeros and sample selection in Poisson and negative binomial regression models. Working Paper EC-94-10. New York: New York University, Stern School of Business Economics Department; 1994 Mar.
28.
SchlattmannPBohningD. Mixture models and disease mapping. Stat Med1993;12:1943–50.
29.
VuongQ. Likelihood ratio tests for model selection and non-nested hypotheses. Econometrica1989;57:307–34.
30.
SorensenJB. Zero-inflated Poisson and negative binomial regression models. Stata Tech Bull1998;46:24–8.
31.
PeduzziPConcatoJKemperEHolfordTRFeinsteinAR. A simulation study of the number of events per variable in logistic regression analysis. J Clin Epidemiol1996;49:1373–9.
32.
ReissAJJrRothJA. Understanding and preventing violence. Washington: National Academy Press; 1993.
33.
MladenkaKHillK. A re-examination of the etiology of urban crime. Criminology1976;13:491–506.
34.
WolfgangMEZahnMA. Homicide and aggravated assault. In: WeinerNAZahnMASagiRJ, editors. Violence: patterns, causes, public policy. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich; 1990. p. 51–4.
35.
SingRFBranasCCMacKenzieEJSchwabCW. Geographic variation in serious nonfatal firearm injuries in Pennsylvania. J Trauma1997;43:825–30.
36.
GoveWRHughesM. Reexamining the ecological fallacy: a study in which aggregate data are critical in investigating the pathological effects of living alone. Soc Forces1980;58:1157–77.
37.
SainsburyP. The social relations of suicide: the value of a combined epidemiological and case study approach. Soc Sci Med1972;6:189–98.
38.
RoncekDWMaierPA. Bars, blocks, and crimes revisited: linking the theory of routine activities to the empiricism of “hot spots.”Criminology1991;29:725–53.
39.
RickettsTCSavitzLAGeslerWMOsborneDN. Using geographic methods to understand health issues. NTIS No. PB97-137707. Rockville (MD): Agency for Health Care Policy and Research (US); 1997. AHRQ Pub. No. 97-N013.
40.
ParkerRNRebhunLA. Alcohol and homicide: a deadly combination of two American traditions. New York: State University of New York Press; 1995.
41.
FoxJAZawitzMW. Homicide trends in the United States: 1998 update. Bureau of Justice Statistics Crime Data Brief2000; March:1–4.
42.
MoscickiEK. Identification of suicide risk factors using epidemiologic studies. Psychiatr Clin North Am1997;20:499–517.
43.
MurphyGE. Why women are less likely than men to commit suicide. Comprehensive Psychiatr1998;39:165–75.
44.
HarriesKPowellA. Juvenile gun crime and social stress: Baltimore, 1980–1990. Urban Geography1994;15:45–63.
45.
SampsonRJWilsonWJ. Toward a theory of race, crime, and urban inequality. In: HaganJPetersonRD, editors. Crime and inequality. Stanford (CA): Stanford University Press; 1995. p. 37–54.
46.
GibbsJT. African-American suicide: a cultural paradox. Suicide Life-Threatening Behav1997;27:68–79.
47.
ScribnerRAMacKinnonDPDwyerJH. The risk of assaultive violence and alcohol availability in Los Angeles County. Am J Public Health1995;85:335–40.
48.
SampsonRJRaudenbushSWEarlsF. Neighborhoods and violent crime: a multilevel study of collective efficacy. Science1997;277:918–24.
49.
HarriesK. The ecology of homicide and assault: Baltimore City and County, 1989–1991. Stud Crime Crime Prevent1995;4:44–59.
50.
CubbinCLeClereFBSmithGS. Socioeconomic status and injury mortality: individual and neighbourhood determinants. J Epidemiol Community Health2000;54:517–24.
51.
CubbinCPickleLWFingerhutL. Social context and geographic patterns of homicide among US black and white males. Am J Public Health2000;90:579–87.
52.
WaldronIEyerJ. Socioeconomic causes of the recent rise in death rates for 15–24-yr-olds. Soc Sci Med1975;9:383–96.
53.
WenzFV. Marital status, anomie, and forms of social isolation: a case of high suicide rate among the widowed in an urban sub-area. Dis Nervous Sys1977;38:891–5.
54.
MoscickiEK. Epidemiology of suicide. Inter Psychogeriatrics1995;7:137–48.
55.
MarisRW. Social and familial risk factors in suicidal behavior. Psychiatr Clin North Am1997;20:519–50.
56.
KposowaAJ. Marital status and suicide in the National Longitudinal Mortality Study. J Epidemiol Community Health2000;54:254–61.
57.
HelsingKJComstockGWSzkloM. Causes of death in a widowed population. Am J Epidemiol1982;116:524–32.
58.
RoncekDWBellR. Bars, blocks, and crimes. J Environ Syst1981;11:35–47.
59.
GreenbergMSchneiderD. Violence in American cities: young black males is the answer, but what was the question?Soc Sci Med1994;39:179–87.
60.
ShryockHSSiegelJSLarmonEA. The methods and materials of demography. In: Census Bureau (US). The materials and methods of demography. Washington: Government Printing Office; 1980. Pub. No. 76-609905. p. 142–8.
61.
SpicerRSMillerTR. Suicide acts in 8 states: incidence and case-fatality rates by demographics and method. Am J Public Health2000;90:1885–91.
62.
GrossmanD. On killing: the psychological cost of learning to kill in war and society. London: Little Brown; 1996.
63.
BeamanVAnnestJLMercyJAKresnowMJPollockDA. Lethality of firearm-related injuries in the United States population. Ann Emerg Med2000;35:258–66.
64.
DavisJWRhamesMPKaupsKL. More guns and younger assailants: a combined police and trauma center study. Arch Surg1997;132:1067–70.
65.
PotterL. Influence of homicide on racial disparity in life expectancy—United States, 1998. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep2001;50;780–3.
66.
StewartJQWarntzW. Macrogeography and social science. Geographical Rev1958;48:170.
67.
DuncanODCuzzortRPDuncanB. Statistical geography, problems in analyzing areal data. San Francisco: Free Press; 1961.
68.
FelsonM. Routine activities and crime prevention in the developing metropolis. Criminology1987;25:911–32.
69.
SampsonRJWooldredgeJD. Linking the micro- and macro-level dimensions of lifestyle routine activity and opportunity models of predatory victimization. J Quantitative Criminology1987;3:371–93.
70.
SkoganWG. Disorder and decline: crime and the spiral of decay in American neighborhoods. New York: Free Press; 1990.
71.
SampsonRJRaudenbushSW. Systematic social observation of public spaces: a new look at disorder in urban neighborhoods. Am J Sociol1999;105:603–51.
72.
SampsonRJRaudenbushSW. Disorder in urban neighborhoods—does it lead to crime?NIJ Res in Brief2001;Feb:1–6.
73.
SoobaderMLeClereFBHaddenWMauryB. Using aggregate geographic data to proxy individual socio-economic status: does size matter?Am J Public Health2001;91:632–6.
74.
KirbyRS. Toward congruence between theory and practice in small area analysis and local public health data. Stat Med1996;15:1859–66.
SouthSJCrowderKD. Escaping distressed neighborhoods: individual, community, and metropolitan influences. Am J Sociol1997;102:1040–84.
77.
KriegerN. Overcoming the absence of socioeconomic data in medical records: validation and application of a Census-based methodology. Am J Public Health1992;82:703–10.
78.
HumphryD. Final exit: the practicalities of self-deliverance and assisted suicide for the dying. Secaucus (NJ): Carol Publishing; 1991.
79.
LaFaveWR. Criminal law. 3rd ed.St. Paul (MN): West Group Press; 2000.
80.
Public Health Service (US). The Surgeon General's call to action to prevent suicide. Washington: Department of Health and Human Services (US): 1999.
81.
BranasCCNanceMLElliottMRRichmondTSSchwabCW. Urban-rural shifts in intentional firearm death: different causes, same results. Am J Public Health2004;94(10). In press.
