The Use of English Textbooks for Teaching English to 'Vocational' Students in Singapore Secondary Schools

Abstract

■ This study explores teachers' beliefs in the use of English textbooks for teaching English in the upper secondary Normal Technical (NT) stream in Singapore. The NT stream in Singapore is a form of `vocational' pathway; pupils streamed into the NT classes are considered to be academically 'weakest' amongst all three streams in the secondary level. Using a semi-structured questionnaire, the study aims to identify factors influencing teachers' perceptions toward the roles the textbook plays in language teaching and learning. The findings are used to infer a relationship between teachers' use of textbooks and their attitudes towards the less academically - inclined' NT pupils. The results show that teachers' beliefs are related to factors that exist within and beyond the classroom. Among the factors identified, those related to the institution and classroom tended to have a greater influence in the way teachers used their textbooks. In particular teachers refer to the demands of meeting the stipulated pass rate in English examinations and NT students' cognitive weakness and behavioural problems. Besides pointing to the need for further research, the discussion brings out implications for curriculum and assessment review and teacher education in the technical-vocational streams in Singapore.

Keywords

English teaching NT stream Singapore teachers perceptions technical-vocational stream text books.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Brophy, J.E. 1982 ` How Teachers Influence What is Taught and Learned in Classrooms ', The Elementary School Journal 83(1): 1-12.

Burns, A. 1992 ` Teacher Beliefs and their Influence on Classroom Practice ', Prospect 7(3): 56-66.

Chan, G.L.P. 1987 `Curriculum Innovation: A Study of the CLUE Programme with Reference to Teachers' Attitudes and Concerns' (Masters Thesis in Applied Linguistics, National University of Singapore ).

Cheah, Y.M. 1996 `Language Learning or Culture Learning: English Literacy Lessons in a Singapore Classroom', in J. James (ed.), The Language-Culture Connection (RELC Anthology Series, 37; Singapore: SEAMEO Regional Language Centre).

1997 `Shaping the Classrooms of Tomorrow: Lessons from the Past ', in J. Tan et al. 1997: 129-44.

1998 ` The Examination Culture and its Impact on Literacy Innovations: The Case of Singapore ', Language and Education 12(3): 192-209.

2003 `English Language Teaching in Singapore Today', in W.K. Ho and R.Y.L. Wong (eds.), English Language Teaching in East Asia Today: Changing Policies and Practices (Singapore: Eastern University Press): 351-73.

Chandran, S. 2003 `Where Are the ELT Textbooks?', in W.A. Renandya (ed.), Methodology and Material Design in Language Teaching: Current Perceptions and Practice and their Implications (RELC Anthology Series, 44: Singapore: SEAMEO Regional Language Centre): 161-69.

Crawford, J. 1995 ` The Role of Materials in the Language Classroom: Finding the Balance ', TESOL in Context 5(1): 25-33.

10.

Cunningsworth, A. 1995 Choosing your Coursebook (Great Britain: Heinemann ).

11.

Hutchinson, T. , and E. Torres 1994 ` The Textbook as Agent of Change ', ELT Journal 48(4): 315-26.

12.

Hutchinson, T. , and A. Waters 1987 English for Specific Purposes (Cambridge : Cambridge University Press).

13.

Johnson, K.E. (ed.) 1989 The Second Language Curriculum (New York: Cambridge University Press).

14.

Lanier, B. , J., Buschman , J.Confrey , R.Prawat , C.Weisbeck , P.Coe and B. Mitchell 1981 The Ecology of Failure in Ninth-Grade Mathematics. Progress Report for July 1, 1980-September 30, 1981 ( Michigan State University, Institute for Research on Teaching ). Quoted in Brophy 1982: 1-12.

15.

Larsen-Freeman, D. 2000 Techniques and Principles in Language Teaching (Oxford : Oxford University Press).

16.

Lee , H. , and C. Davis 1996 ` Towards Functional Literacy—Topics, Methods and Materials to Replicate Social Practice ' (RELC Seminar, April in RELC working paper; Singapore: SEAMO Regional Language Centre).

17.

Lim, S. 1981 Evaluation of English Language Textbooks for Secondary Schools in Singapore: a Focus on Communicative Competence ( Singapore ).

18.

Littlejohn, A. , and S. Windeatt 1989 `Beyond Language Learning: Perspectives on Materials Design ', in Johnson 1989 : 175.

19.

Lockhart, C. 1996 `Teachers' Beliefs about Writing in Hong Kong Secondary schools', in Perspectives: Working Papers ( City University of Hong Kong , Department of English ) 8(2): 45-79.

20.

Moo, S.N. 1997 `Teachers' Perceptions of Normal Technical Students' Motivation and Classroom Behaviour', in A.S.C., Chang , S.C. Goh , S.N. Moo and A.Y. Chen (eds.), Report on Motivation and Classroom Behaviour of Normal Technical Students (Singapore: National Institute of Education, Centre for Educational Research).

21.

McDonough, J. , and S. McDonough 1997 Research Methods for English Language Teachers (London: Arnold).

22.

Ng, C.F. 1999 `The Learning Style of Normal (Technical) Students in a Neighbourhood School' (Masters dissertation in Applied Psychology, Singapore: National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University).

23.

Oei, K. 1997 `An Inquiry Into the Normal (Technical) Secondary Students' Language Learning In the Context of an IT-Enriched Curriculum' (Masters dissertation in Education, Singapore: National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University).

24.

Pennington, M. , V. Costa , S. So , J. Shing , K. Hirose and K. Niedzielski 1996 The Teaching of ESL Writing in the Asia-Pacific Region: A Cross-country Comparison (submitted for publication). Quoted in C. Lockhart, `Teachers' Beliefs about Writing in Hong Kong Secondary Schools ', in Perspectives: Working Papers ( City University of Hong Kong , Department of English ) 8(2): 45-79.

25.

Pelly, C.P. , and D. Allison 2000 ` Investigating the Views of Teachers on Assessment of English Language Learning in the Singapore Education System ', Hong Kong Journal of Applied Linguistics 5(1): 81-107.

26.

Prabhu, N.S. 1988 ` Materials as Support; Materials as Constraint', RELC Working Papers on Materials for Language Learning and Teaching: Trends and Developments, 1 (April) (Singapore: SEAMEO).

27.

Richards, J.C. 1998 `Textbooks: Help or Hindrance in Teaching', in Beyond Training: Perspectives on Language Teacher Education ( Cambridge: Cambridge University Press): 125-41.

28.

Richards, J. , and D. Mahoney 1996 ` Teachers and Textbooks: A Survey of Beliefs and Practices ', in Perspectives: Working Papers ( City University of Hong Kong , Department of English ) 8(1): 40-61.

29.

Tan, J. , S. Gopinathan and W.K. Ho (eds.) 2001 Challenges Facing the Singapore Education System Today (Singapore: Prentice Hall).

30.

1997 Education in Singapore: A Book of Readings ( Singapore: Prentice Hall).

31.

Tay-Koay, S.L. 1999 ` Teacher Development: Understanding the Struggles of Classroom Teachers ', Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education & Development 2(1): 15-28.

32.

Yim, L.W. 1993 `Relating Teachers' Perceptions of the Place of Grammar to their Teaching Practices' (Masters Dissertation in Applied Linguistics, National University of Singapore ).

33.

Yip, J.S.K. , S.P. Eng and J.Y.C. Yap 1997 `25 Years of Educational Reform', in J. Tan et al. 1997: 1-32.

34.

Zeichner, K.M. , and D.P. Liston 1996 Reflective Teaching: An Introduction ( New Jersey: Lawrence Elbaum).