“Why Wouldn’t I Have Asked Him?”: Herbert Gans,Chapter 9 of the Kerner Report,and the Resolution of a Dilemma

Abstract

There are always a number of stories involved in any group report. The 700-page Kerner Report, which sought to explain the causes of the rioting that had occurred in 1967, is no exception. Some of these stories have been previously discussed in other works. However, given the magnitude of the Kerner Commission’s assignment, it is not surprising that many of its stories have not yet been told. One such example is the story behind the writing of the report’s Chapter 9 that concluded that the black and European immigrant experiences were not comparable. Not originally contemplated, the chapter’s need surfaced only about a month before the Commission completed its work. How it came to be, how one of the nation’s foremost sociologists became involved, and how it helped the Commission keep its breakneck pace is what one former staff member calls a “fascinating backstory” and further increases our knowledge of the Commission.

Keywords

Kerner report urban policy civil rights assimilation decision-making

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

J. T.

(1931). The epic of America. New York, NY: Little Brown.

Allen

(2018, November). Urban legend. The University of Chicago Magazine, pp. 26-27.

Banfield

Wilson

J. Q.

(1963). City politics. New York, NY: Vintage Books.

Blauner

(1972). Racial oppression in America. New York, NY: Harper & Row.

Brown

(2010, May 24). David Ginsburg, Washington lawyer and director of a 1960s panel on race relations, dies at 98. The Washington Post. Retrieved from http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/05/23/AR2010052304125.html

Califano

J. A.

Jr. (2015). The triumph and tragedy of Lyndon Johnson. New York, NY: Touchstone.

Chambers

(2018a, June 16). Interview with author.

Chambers

(2018b, August 3). Email to author.

Coates

T.-N.

(2009, March 23). Why do black immigrants do better than native blacks? The Atlantic. Retrieved from https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2009/03/why-do-black-immigrants-do-better-than-native-blacks/6891/

10.

Dallek

(1998). Flawed giant: Lyndon Johnson and his times. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

11.

Edwards

G. F.

(1965). Communities and class realities: The ordeal of change. In Talcott

Clark

K. B.

(Eds.), The Negro American. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin, pp. 280-302.

12.

Ferdinand

(2016). Exploring the American dream in action through Horatio Jr. Alger’s Ragged Dick. International Journal on Studies in English Language and Literature, 4(6), 75-84.

13.

Gans

H. J.

(1967a, October 27). Letter to Charles Thornton. National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders Collection (File: Herbert J. Gans, Series 50, Box 2). LBJ Library, Austin, TX.

14.

Gans

H. J.

(1967b, December 4). Letter to Victor Palmieri. National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders Collection (File: Herbert J. Gans, Series 50, Box 2). LBJ Library, Austin, TX.

15.

Gans

H. J.

(1967c, October 6). Testimony before the National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders (NACCD). NACCD Collection (File: Hearings, Series 49, Box 1). LBJ Library, Austin, TX.

16.

Gans

H. J.

(1968a, January 24). Escaping from poverty: A comparison of the immigrant and negro experience. National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders Collection (File: Herbert J. Gans, Series 50, Box 2). LBJ Library, Austin, TX.

17.

Gans

H. J.

(1968b, January 25). Letter to Victor Palmieri. National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders Collection (File: Herbert J. Gans, Series 50, Box 2). LBJ Library, Austin, TX.

18.

Gans

H. J.

(1969, September 22). Letter to Andrew (Andy) Kopkind (Herbert Gans Papers, 1944-2004, Box 39). Columbia University, New York, NY.

19.

Gans

H. J.

(1982). The urban villagers. New York, NY: Macmillan.

20.

Gans

H. J.

(1991). People, plans, and policies. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

21.

Gans

H. J.

(2017a, June 1). Email to author.

22.

Gans

H. J.

(2017b, June 3). Interview with author.

23.

Gans

H. J.

(2018, June 18). Interview with author.

24.

Gewen

(2009, September 18). Irving Kristol, godfather of modern conservatism, dies at 89. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/19/us/politics/19kristol.html

25.

Gillon

S. M.

(2018). Separate and unequal: The Kerner commission and the unraveling of American liberalism. New York, NY: Basic Books.

26.

Ginsburg

(1988a, September 19). Interview by Michael Gillette. LBJ Library Oral History.

27.

Ginsburg

(1988b, November 11). Interview by Michael Gillette. LBJ Library Oral History.

28.

Glaab

C. N.

Brown

A. T.

(1967). A history of urban America. New York, NY: Macmillan.

29.

Glazer

(1963, February 1). West end story. New York: New York Review of Books.

30.

Glazer

Moynihan

D. P.

(1963). Beyond the melting pot. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

31.

Graham

H. D.

(1980). On riots and riot commissions: Civil disorders in the 1960s. The Public Historian, 2(4), 1-124.

32.

Handlin

(1959). The newcomers. Garden City, NY: Anchor Books.

33.

Harlin

L. R.

(1969). Tell it like it was. Social Education, 38, 390-395.

34.

Harris

(2018, June 26). Email to author.

35.

Hendrickson

(1979, February 20). Irving Kristol, godfather to refugees from liberalism. The Washington Post. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/1979/02/20/irving-kristol-godfather-to-refugees-from-liberalism/071aa40d-5a4d-4c22-b693-332c97e2748a/

36.

Hershberg

Yancey

W. L.

Ericson

E. P.

Greenberg

Burstein

A. N.

(1981). A tale of three cities. In Hershberg

(Ed.), Philadelphia: Work, space, family, and group experience in the nineteenth century. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, pp. 461-491.

37.

Hofstadter

(1955). The age of reform. New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf.

38.

Kanfer

(2000). Horatio Alger: The moral of the story. City Journal. Retrieved from https://www.city-journal.org/html/horatio-alger-the-moral-of-the-story-11933.html

39.

Kinzer

R. H.

Sagarin

(1950). The Negro in American business. New York, NY: Greenberg.

40.

Koskinen

(2018, June 6). Interview with author.

41.

Kristol

(1966, September 11). The Negro today is like the immigrant yesterday. The New York Times Magazine. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/1966/09/11/archives/the-negro-today-is-like-the-immigrant-yesterday-the-negro-today.html

42.

Lipsky

Olson

D. J.

(1977). Commission politics: The processing of racial crisis in America. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books.

43.

Loessberg

(2017). Two societies: The writing of the summary of the report of the National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders. Journal of urban history. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1177/009614421689087

44.

Loessberg

Koskinen

(2018). Measuring the distance: The legacy of the Kerner report. Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences, 4(6), 99-119.

45.

Lupo

(2011). Flak-catchers. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.

46.

McGrath

K. M.

(1968, January 11). Meeting of commission on long-term programs. National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders Collection (File: Notes of Commission Meetings, December 7, 8, and 9, Series 47, Box 8). LBJ Library, Austin, TX.

47.

Moynihan

D. P.

(1965, December 16). Letter to Herbert Gans (Herbert Gans Papers, 1944-2004, Box 39). Columbia University, New York, NY.

48.

Moynihan

D. P.

(1966, January 8). Letter to Herbert Gans (Herbert Gans Papers, 1944-2004, Box 39). Columbia University, New York, NY.

49.

Nuechterlein

J. A.

(1984). Neoconservatism and Irving Kristol. Commentary. Retrieved from https://www.commentarymagazine.com/articles/neoconservatism-irving-kristol/

50.

Palmieri

(1967, September 6). Letter to Herbert Gans (Herbert Gans Papers, 1944-2004, Box 39). Columbia University, New York, NY.

51.

Palmieri

(1968a, January 29). Letter to Herbert Gans (Herbert Gans Papers, 1944-2004, Box 39). Columbia University, New York, NY.

52.

Palmieri

(1968b, January 29). Memo to Jack Rosenthal (Herbert Gans Papers, 1944-2004, Box 39). Columbia University, New York, NY.

53.

Palmieri

(2017, June 2). Interview with author.

54.

Palmieri

(2018, June 21). Interview with author.

55.

Roberts

(1966, August 4). Attack by whites foiled in Chicago. The New York Times.

56.

Robinson

(1966, August 13). Most unscathed in Chicago march. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/1966/08/13/archives/most-unscathed-in-chicago-march-stones-strike-several-of-700-in.html

57.

Robinson

D. E.

(2001). Black nationalism in American politics and thought. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

58.

Rossi

P. H.

(1964). Book review. American Journal of Sociology, 70, 381-382.

59.

Scruggs

D. L.

(1980). Lyndon Baines Johnson and the National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders (The Kerner commission): A study of Johnson policy making systems (Doctoral dissertation). University of Oklahoma, USA.

60.

Stack

(2017, March 17). Debunking a myth: The Irish were not slaves, too. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/17/us/irish-slaves-myth.html

61.

Taeuber

K. E.

Taeuber

(1964). The Negro as an immigrant group: Recent trends in racial and ethnic segregation in Chicago. American Journal of Sociology, 69, 374-382.

62.

United Press International. (1966, August 1). 54 hurt as whites in Chicago hurl bricks at rights marchers. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/1966/08/01/archives/54-hurt-as-whites-in-chicago-hurl-bricks-at-rights-marchers-whites.html

63.

Vitello

(2011, September 23). Oscar Handlin, historian who chronicled U.S. immigration, dies at 95. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/24/us/oscar-handlin-historian-who-chronicled-united-states-immigration-dies-at-95.html

64.

Waters

M. C.

Kasinitz

Asad

L. A.

(2014). Immigrants and African Americans. Annual Review of Sociology, 40, 369-390.