The Earnings and Income Mobility Consequences of Attending a Historically Black College/University: Matching Estimates From 2015 U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard Data
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online September, 2019
The Earnings and Income Mobility Consequences of Attending a Historically Black College/University: Matching Estimates From 2015 U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard Data
This article considers the labor market consequences of attending a Historically Black College/University (HBCU). With 2015 U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard Data, we use a matching estimator to identify and estimate the treatment effect of HBCU attendance on median earnings, earnings relative to a high school graduate, and income relative to that of the household at the time of initial enrollment, 6 and 10 years after attendance. Our treatment effect parameter estimates suggest that once we account for the differential return to college majors, the urban wage premium, and the proportionality/dependence of the labor market return of Black student college attendees on the share of a college/university’s student population that is Black, there is a long-run earnings premium associated with HBCU attendance. In addition, for HBCUs in general, we find that there is a population of students who would realize a positive labor market premium—as high as approximately 42%—and earn more than a high school graduate if they were to attend an HBCU. With respect to intergenerational income mobility, we find that HBCU attendance enables their actual and potential attendees to move to a higher quantile of income relative to their households in the long run.
AbadieA.DrukkerD.HerrJ. L.ImbensG. W. (2004). Implementing matching estimators for average treatment effects in Stata. The Stata Journal, 4, 290-311.
2.
AbadieA.ImbensG. (2006). Large sample properties of matching estimators for average treatment effects. Econometrica, 74, 235-267.
3.
AbadieA.ImbensG. W. (2011). Bias-corrected matching estimators for average treatment effects. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 29, 1-11.
4.
AllenW. R.JewellJ. O.GriffinK. A.WolfD. S. (2007). Historically Black colleges and universities: Honoring the past, engaging the present, touching the future. Journal of Negro Education, 76, 263-280.
5.
AltonjiJ. G.BlomE.MeghirC. (2012). Heterogeneity in human capital investments: High school curriculum, college major, and careers. Annual Review of Economics, 4, 185-223.
6.
Baum-SnowN.PavanR. (2011). Understanding the city size wage gap. Review of Economic Studies, 79, 88-127.
7.
BennettP. R.XieY. (2003). Revisiting racial differences in college attendance: The role of historically Black colleges and universities. American Sociological Review, 68, 567-580.
8.
BilkicN.GriesT.PilichowskiM. (2012). Stay in school or start working?—The human capital investment decision under uncertainty and irreversibility. Labour Economics, 19, 706-717.
9.
BitzanJ. D. (2009). Do sheepskin effects help explain racial earnings differences?Economics of Education Review, 28, 759-766.
10.
BlackD. A. (2015). Matching as a regression estimator. IZA World of Labor, 186, 1-10.
11.
BrintS.RiddleM.Turk-BicakciL.LevyC. S. (2005). From the liberal to the practical arts in American colleges and universities: Organizational analysis and curricular change. Journal of Higher Education, 76, 151-180.
12.
BurnimM. L. (1980). The earnings effect of Black matriculation in predominantly White colleges. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 33, 518-524.
13.
ButlerD. (2010). Ethno-racial composition and college preference: Revisiting the perpetuation of segregation hypothesis. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 627, 36-58.
14.
ChengLi. (2013). Little’s Test of Missing Completely at Random, Stata Journal, 13, 795-809.
15.
ConstantineJ. (1995). The effect of attending historically Black colleges and universities on future wages of Black students. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 48, 531-546.
16.
CreponB.Van den BergG. J. (2016). Active labor market policies. Annual Review of Economics, 8, 521-546.
17.
DaleS. B.KruegerA. B. (2002). Estimating the payoff to attending a more selective college: An application of selection on observables and unobservables. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 117, 1491-1527.
18.
DaleS. B.KruegerA. B. (2014). Estimating the effects of college characteristics over the career using administrative earnings data. Journal of Human Resources, 49, 323-358.
19.
EhrenbergR. G.RothsteinD. S. (1994). Do historically Black institutions of higher education confer unique advantages on Black students? An initial analysis. In EhrenbergR. (Ed.), Choices and consequences: Contemporary policy issues in education (pp. 89-147). Ithaca, NY: ILR Press.
20.
EspinosaL. L.KelchenR.TaylorM. (2018). Minority serving institutions as engines of upward mobility. Washington, DC: American Council on Education.
21.
FitzgeraldR. A. (2000). College quality and the earnings of recent college graduates (Research and Development Report). Washington, DC: National Center For Education Statistics.
22.
FreemanK.ThomasG. E. (2002). Black colleges and college choice: Characteristics of students who choose HBCUs. Review of Higher Education, 25, 349-358.
23.
FryerR. G.GreenstoneM. (2007). The changing consequences of attending historically Black colleges and universities (Working Paper No. 13036). Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
24.
FryerR. G.GreenstoneM. (2010). The changing consequences of attending historically Black colleges and universities. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 2, 116-148.
25.
GasmanM. (2013). The changing face of historically Black colleges and universities. Philadelphia: Center for Minority Serving Institutions, University of Pennsylvania.
26.
HenryW. J.ClossonR. B. (2010). White students at the historically Black university: Toward developing a critical consciousness. Multicultural Education, 17, 13-19.
27.
ImaiKKingG.NallC. (2009). The essential role of pair matching in cluster-randomized experiments, with application to the Mexican universal health insurance evaluation. Statistical Science, 24, 29-53.
28.
ImaiK.KingG.StuartE. (2008). Misunderstandings among experimentalists and observationalists about causal inference. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A Part, 2, 481-502.
29.
ImbensG. (2004). Nonparametric estimation of average treatment effects under exogeneity: A review. Review of Economics and Statistics, 86, 4-29.
30.
KimM. M.ConradC. F. (2006). The impact of historically Black colleges and universities on the academic success of African-American students. Research in Higher Education, 47, 399-427.
31.
KingG.NielsenR. (2016). Why propensity scores should not be used for matching. Cambridge, MA: Institute for Quantitative Social Science, Harvard University.
32.
KirkeboenL. J.LeuvenE.MogstadM. (2016). Field of study, earnings, and self-selection. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 131, 1057-1111.
33.
LiC. (2013). Little’s test of missing completely at random. Stata Journal, 13, 795-809.
34.
LittleR. (1988). A test of missing completely at random for multivariate data with missing value. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 83, 1198-1202.
35.
MarambaD. C.PalmerR. T.YullD.OzunaT. (2015). A qualitative investigation of the college choice process for Asian Americans and Latina/os at a public HBCU. Journal of Diversity in Higher Education, 8, 258-271.
36.
MykereziE.MillsB. F. (2008). The wage earnings impact of historically Black colleges and universities. Southern Economic Journal, 75, 173-187.
37.
OrtegaA.SwintonO. H. (2018). Business cycles and HBCU appropriations. Journal of Economics, Race, and Policy, 1, 176-195. doi:10.1007/s41996-018-0009-5
38.
PriceG. N.SpriggsW.SwintonO. H. (2011). The relative returns to graduating from a historically Black college/university: Propensity score matching estimates from the national survey of Black Americans. Review of Black Political Economy, 38, 103-130.
39.
RobinsonB.AlbertA. (2008). HBCU’s institutional advantage: Returns to teacher education. In GasmanM.BaezB.ViernesC. S. (Eds.), Understanding minority-serving institutions. (pp. 183-202) Albany: State University of New York Press.
40.
RothsteinJ. M. (2004). College performance predictions and the SAT. Journal of Econometrics, 121, 297-317.
41.
RubinD. B. (1979). Using multivariate matched sampling and regression adjustment to control bias in observational studies. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 74, 318-328.
42.
RubinD. B. (2011). Causal inference using potential outcomes. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 100, 322-331.
43.
SharpeR. V. (2016). HBCUs: Efficiencies of creating a scientific workforce outta fifteen Cents. In PrinceC. B.W.FordR. L. (Eds.), Administrative challenges and organizational leadership in historically Black colleges and universities (pp. 199-212). Hershey, PA: IGI Global.
44.
SingellL. D. (2002). Merit, need, and student self selection: Is there discretion in the packaging of aid at a large public university?Economics of Education Review, 21, 445-454.
45.
SolnickL. M. (1990). Black college attendance and job success of Black college graduates. Economics of Education Review, 9, 135-148.
46.
StewartS.LimD. H.KimJ. (2015). Factors influencing college persistence for first-time students. Journal of Developmental Education, 38, 12-16.
47.
StrayhornT. L. (2008). Influences on labor market outcomes of African American college graduates: A national study. Journal of Higher Education, 79, 27-57.
48.
StuartE. A. (2010). Matching methods for causal inference: A review and look forward. Statistical Science: A Review Journal of the Institute of Mathematical Sciences, 25, 1-21.
49.
ThomasS. L.ZhangL. (2005). Post-baccalaureate wage growth within four years of graduation: The effects of college quality and college major. Research in Higher Education, 46, 437-459.
50.
TrostelP.WalkerI. (2004). Sheepskin effects in work behaviour. Applied Economics, 36, 1959-1966.
51.
WoodJ. L.PalmerR. T. (2017). HBCU labor market outcomes: An examination of baccalaureate degree holders earnings and benefits. In BrownM. C.DancyT. E. (Eds.), Black colleges across the diaspora: Global perspectives on race and stratification in postsecondary education (pp. 171-186). West Yorkshire, UK: Emerald Publishing.
52.
YankowJ. J. (2006). Why do cities pay more? An empirical examination of some competing theories of the urban wage premium. Journal of Urban Economics, 60, 139-161.
