Comparison of Test Methods for Measuring Water Vapor Permeability of Fabrics

Abstract

There are a variety of test methods in use to measure the ability of fabrics to transport water vapor. They vary with respect to construction mechanisms, test conditions, and measurement parameters. Five testing instruments plus a new test apparatus were employed to evaluate the water vapor transport properties of fabrics with low, medium, and high vapor permeability. The test results show that the desiccant inverted cup method generated the highest water vapor transmission rate, followed by the new method, the dynamic moisture permeation cell (DMPC), the inverted cup method, and the upright cup method. The statistical analyses indicated that the new method is in good agreement with other standard test methods. Most of the correlations between any two of the methods are strong, except the upright cup method. The new test method offers a short test time and calls for a small sample size.

Keywords

comparison fabric measurement water vapor permeability

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bakkevig, M.K. , and Nielsen, R. , The Impact of Activity Level on Sweat Accumulation and Thermal Comfort Using Different Underwear, Ergonomics , 38(5), 926-939 (1995).

Huang, J. , Review of Test Methods for Measuring Water Vapor Transfer Properties of Fabrics, Cell. Polym., 26(3), 167- 191 (2007).

Dolhan, P.A. , A Comparison of Apparatus Used to Measure Water Vapour Resistance, J. Coat. Fabr., 17, 96-109 (1987).

Lomax, G.R. , Hydrophilic Polyurethane Coatings, J. Coat Fab., 20, 89-107 (1990).

Congalton, D. , Heat and Moisture Transport Through Textiles and Clothing Ensembles Utilizing the Hohenstein Skin Model, J. Coat. Fabr., 28, 183-196 (1999).

Gibson, P.W. , Factors Influencing Steady-state Heat and Water Vapour Transfer Measurements for Clothing Materials, Text. Res. J., 63(12), 749-764 (1993).

Gretton, J.C. , Brook, D.B. , Dyson , H.M. , and Harlock, S.C. , A Correlation Between Test Methods Used to Measure Moisture Vapour Transmission Through Fabrics, J. Coat. Fabr., 25, 301-311 (1996).

Gibson, P.W. , Kendrick, C.E. , Rivin , D. , Charmchi, M. , and Sicuranza, L. , An Automated Water Vapour Diffusion Test Method for Fabrics, Laminates, and Films, J. Coat. Fabr., 24, 322-345 (1995).

Gibson, P.W. , Kendrick, C.E. , Rivin , D. , and Charmchi, M. , An Automated Dynamic Water Vapour Permeation Test Method, Performance of Protective Clothing, 6(1273), 93-107, American Society for Testing and Materials: West Conshohocken, PA, 1997.

10.

McCullough, E.A. , Kwon, M. , and Shim, H. , A Comparison of Standard Methods for Measuring Water Vapour Permeability of Fabrics, Meas . Sci. Technol. , 14(8), 1402-1408 (2003 ).

11.

Gb/T 3820 1997 " Standard Test Methods for Thickness of Textiles". National Standards of People's Republic of China: Beijing (1997).

12.

Iso 11092 1993 " Textiles - Physiological Effects - Measurement of Thermal and Water Vapour Resistance Under Steadystate Conditions (Sweating Guarded Hot Plate Test) ". International Organization for Standardization , Geneva, Switzerland (1993)

13.

Astm E96 1995 Standard Test Methods for Water Vapour Transmission of Materials, in. "Annual Book of ASTM Standards 4.06". American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA, 1995.

14.

Astm F2298 2003 Standard Test Methods for Water Vapor Diffusion Resistance and Air Flow Resistance of Clothing Materials Using the Dynamic Moisture Permeation Cell, in " Annual Book of ASTM Standards 11.03", American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA, 2003.

15.

Iso 15496 2004 "Textiles - Measurement of Water Vapour Permeability of Textiles for the Purpose of Quality Control ". International Organization for Standardization , Geneva, Switzerland, 2004.

16.

Huang, J. , and Qian, X. , A New Test Method for Measuring Water Vapour Permeability of Fabrics, Meas . Sci. Technol., 18(9), 3043-3047 (2007).

17.

Hu, Y. , Topolkaraev, V. , Hiltner, A. , and Baer, E. , Measurement of Water Vapor Transmission Rate in Highly Permeable Films , J. Appl. Polym. Sci., 81(7), 1624-1633 (2001).

18.

Gibson, P.W. , Auerbach, M. , Giblo , J. , Teal, W. , and Endrusick, T. , Interlaboratory Evaluation of a New Sweating Guarded Hot Plate Test Method (ISO 11092), J. Therm. Insul. Build, Envel., 18(10), 182-200 (1994).

19.

McCullough, E.A. , Huang, J. , and Kim , C.S. , An Explanation and Discussion of Sweating Hot Plate Standards, J. ASTM Internat. , 1, 1-13 (2004).

20.

Huang, J. , Sweating Guarded Hot Plate Test Method, Polym. Test. , 25(5), 709-716. (2006).