Anti-mite Covers: Potential Criteria for Materials Used Against Dust Mites

Abstract

There are many types of material used to construct bedding encasing for dust mite and allergen protection, but relatively few have been evaluated for their anti-mite properties. This study surveyed the anti-mite/allergen properties and physical characteristics of covers with a view towards establishing potential parameters for evaluating the efficacy of such encasings. Fifty-three covers advertised as mite-proof were randomly purchased from local markets found in ten different countries. All fabrics were evaluated for their ability to block the movement of allergens and live mites. Air permeability, dust leakage, and thread count, where applicable, were also measured. The major finding was that plastic and the tightly woven covers completely prevented mite penetration while exhibiting > 99 % allergen impenetrability. The film-coated fabrics, the mixed type, and the acaricidal-coated non-woven were successful in blocking allergens, but were commonly observed to allow some mite penetration. For the tightly woven fabrics, dust leakage and air permeability were minimal, while thread count was uniformly high. Cotton bed sheets were completely penetrable by mites and allergens. Overall, allergen impenetrability was negatively associated with dust leakage, thread count, and air permeability. Thread count also exhibited inverse relationships between dust leakage and air permeability. Dust leakage and air permeability were positively associated. The optimal characteristics for effective encasings include tightly woven covers with allergen impenetrability > 99 %, resistance to live mite penetration, dust leakage of < 4 %, air permeability between 2 and 6 cm³/sec/cm², a thread count ≥ 246/in², and a pore size of 2—10 µm.

Keywords

Allergen/mite-proof encasements fabric/material characteristics

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Tovey, E.R. , and Marks, G. , Current Reviews of Allergy and Clinical Immunology. Methods and Effectiveness of Environmental Control, J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 103, 179-191 (1999).

Tovey, E.R. , Chapman, M.D. , and Platts-Mills, T.A. , Mite Faeces are a Major Source of House Dust Allergens, Nature 289(5798), 592-593 (1981).

Custovic, A. , Simpson, B.M. , Simpson , A. , Hallam, C. , Craven, M. , Brutsche, M. , and Woodcock, A. , Manchester Asthma and Allergy Study : Low-allergen Environment can be Achieved and Maintained During Pregnancy and in Early Life, J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 105, 252-258 (2000).

Rijssenbeek-Nouwens, L.H.M. , Oosting, A.J. , de Bruin-Weller , M.S. , Bregman, I. , de Monchy, J.G. , and Postma, D.S. , Clinical Evaluation of the Effect of Anti-allergic Mattress Covers in Patients with Moderate to Severe Asthma and House Dust Mite Allergy: a Randomized Double Blind Placebo Controlled Study, Thorax 57, 784-790 (2002).

van den Bemt, L. , van Knapen, L. , de Vries , M.P. , Cloosterman, S. , and van Schayck , C.P. , Clinical Effectiveness of a Mite Allergen-impermeable Bed-covering System in Asthmatic Mite-sensitive patients, J. Allergy Clin. Immunol . 114, 858-862 (2004).

van Strien, R.T. , Koopman, L.P. , Kerkhof , M. , Oldenwening, M. , de Jongste, J.C. , Gerritsen, J. , Neijens, H.J. , Aalberse, R.C. , Smit, H.A. , and Brunekreef , B. , Prevention and Incidence of Asthma and Mite Allergy Study, Mattress Encasings and Mite Allergen Levels in the Prevention and Incidence of Asthma and Mite Allergy Study, Clin. Exp. Allergy 33, 490-495 (2003).

Kadolph, S. , and Langford, A.L. , "Textiles (9th Edn.)," Prentice Hall, New Jersey, USA, p. 243 (2002).

Vaughan, J.W. , McLaughlin, T.E. , Perzanowski , M.S. , and Platts-Mills , T.A.E. , Evaluation of Materials used for Bedding Encasement: Effect of Pore Size in Blocking Cat and Dust Mite Allergen, J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 103, 227-231 (1999).

Burr, M.L. , St. Leger, A.S. , and Neale, E. , Anti-mite Measurements in Mite-sensitive Adult Asthma. A Controlled Trial , Lancet 14, 333-335 (1976).

10.

Sarfield, J.K. , Gowland, G. , Toy , R. , and Norman, A. , Mite-sensitive Asthma of Childhood. Trial of Avoidance Measures, Arch. Dis. Child. 49, 716-721 (1974).

11.

Niekraszewicz, A. , Lebioda, J. , Hoffman, J. , Ruszkowski, K. , and Struszczyk, H. , Anti-mite Modified Polypropylene Fibres and Bedding Inserts Containing such Fibres, Fibres Textiles East. Eur. 13(6), 24-27 (2005).

12.

Jarupaiboon, S. , Rungsardthong, K. , Sramala, I. , Kangwansupamonkon, W. , Puttipipatkhachorn, S. , and Ruktanonchai, U. , Improved Anti-dust Mite Properties of Textiles by Eugenol Loaded Chitosan Nanoparticles, in " Proceedings of the 2nd IEEE International Conference of Nano/Micro Engineered and Molecular Systems," pp. 1016-1019 (2007).

13.

Mahakittikun, V. , Boitano, J.J. , Tovey , E. , Bunnag, C. , Ninsanit, P. , Matsumoto, T. , and Andre, C. , Mite Penetration of Different Types of Material Claimed to be Mite-proof by the Siriraj Chamber Method, J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 118, 1164- 1168 (2006 ).

14.

Mahakittikun, V. , Kolmoltri, C. , Nochot , H. , Angus, A.C. , and Chew, F.T. , Laboratory Assessment of the Efficiency of Encasing Materials against House Dust Mites and their Allergens, Allergy 58, 981-985 (2003).

15.

ISO, Textiles, Woven Fabrics, Construction , Methods of Analysis: Determination of Number of Threads per Unit Length, Part 2, pp. 7211-7212 (1984).

16.

http://www.en.wikepedia.org/Thread_Count.

17.

ASTM , International Standard Test Method for Air Permeability of Textile Fabrics D737, pp. 217-219 (1996).

18.

Mahakittikun, V. , Jirapongsananuruk , O. , Boitano, J.J. , Nochot, H. , and Tongtrongchitr, A. , Woven Material for Bed Encasement Prevents Mite Penetration, J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 112, 1230-1241 (2003 ).

19.

Oosting, A.J. , de Bruin-Weller , M.S. , Terreehorst, I. , Tempels-Pavlica , Z. , Aalberse, R.C. , de Monchy, J.G.R. , van Wijk, R.G. , and Bruijnzeel-Kooman, C.A.F.M. , Effect of Mattress Encasings on Atopic Dermatitis Outcome Measures in a Double-blind, Placebo-controlled Study: the Dutch Mite Avoidance Study, J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 110, 500-506 (2002).

20.

Woodcock, A. , Forster, L. , Matthews , E. , Martin, J. , Letley, L. , Vickers, M. , Britton, J. , Strachan, D. , Howarth, P. , Altmann, D. , Frost, C. , and Custovic, A. , Control of Exposure to Mite Allergen and Allergen-impermeable Bed Covers for Adults with Asthma, N. Engl. J. Med. 349, 225-236 (2003).

21.

Terreehorst, I. , Hak, E. , Oosting , A.J. , Tempels-Pavlica , Z. , de Monchy, J.G.R. , Bruijnzeel-Koomen, C.A.F.M. , Aalberse , R.C. , and van Wijk, R.G. , Evaluation of Impermeable Covers for Bedding in Patients with Allergic Rhinitis, N. Engl. J. Med. 349, 237-246 (2003).

22.

Rijssenbeek-Nouwens, L.H. , Oosting, A.J. , de Monchy, J.G. , Bregman, I. , Postma, D.S. , and Bruin-Weller , M.S. , The Effect of Anti-allergic Mattress Encasings on House Dust Mite-induced Early- and Late-airway Reactions in Asthmatic Patients. A Double-blind, Placebo-controlled Study, Clin. Exp. Allergy 32, 117-125 (2002).

23.

Halken, S. , Host, A. , Niklassen, U. , Hansen, L.G. , Nielsen, F. , Pedersen, S. , Osterballe, O. , Veggerby, C. , and Poulsen, L.K. , Effect of Mattress and Pillow Encasings on Children with Asthma and House Dust Mite Allergy, J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 111, 169-176 (2003).

24.

Brehler, R. , and Kniest, F. , Encasing Study in Mite-allergic Patients: One-year, Double-blind, Placebo and Environment-controlled Investigation , Allergy Clin. Immunol. Int. - J. Worlds Allergy Org. 18, 15-19 (2006).

25.

Kniest, F.M. , Blank, K.U. , and Bischoff , E.R.C. , Water-vapor Permeability (WVP) Values of Mite-allergen Proof Encasings in View of Sweatability , J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 99(Suppl. 2), S162 (1997).

26.

McLaughlin, T. , Vaughan, J.W. , Perzanowski , M. , and Platts-Mills , T.A.E. , Effect of Fabric Pore Size in Blocking Cat and Dust Mite Allergen, J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 101(Abstr. 690), 167 (1998 ).

27.

Dharmage, S. , Walters, E.H. , Thien , F. , Bailey, M. , Raven, J. , Wharton, C. , Rolland, J. , Light, L. , Freezer, N. , and Abramson, M. , Encasement of Bedding does not Improve Asthma in Atopic Adult Asthmatics, Int. Arch. Allergy Immunol. 139, 132-138 (2006).

28.

Tobias, K.R. , Ferriani, V.P. , Chapman , M.D. , and Arruda, L.K. , Exposure to Indoor Allergens in Homes of Patients with Asthma and/or Rhinitis in Southeast Brazil: Effect of Mattress and Pillow Covers on Mite Allergen Levels, Int. Arch. Allergy Immunol. 133, 365-370 (2004).