Protective Fabrics: A Comparison of Laboratory Methods for Evaluating Thermal Protective Performance in Convective/Radiant Exposures

Abstract

Two laboratory methods used to evaluate the ability of fabrics to provide protective insulation against high intensity thermal exposures are compared. These procedures are ASTM D4108-82, a method that uses a single laboratory gas burner as the heat source, and a more versatile method that combines two gas burners and quartz heaters to provide a different mixture of radiant and convective heat. Comparisons are based on a series of tests made on a large group of specialized fabrics that might be used in the construction of protective apparel. Among the fabrics tested are samples made with flame resistant cotton, rayon, and wool, fabrics from glass and ceramic fibers, and fabrics from polyaramids, cross-linked phenolics, modacrylics, polybenzimidazole, and stabilized acrylic fibers. Differences in materials comparisons caused by the test procedure are discussed, especially the difference made by the balance of radiant to convective energy provided by the heat sources. Correlations are made with fiber and fabric properties. Special emphasis is placed on observing the performance of alu minized samples.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ASHRAE Handbook of Fundamentals—American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air Conditioning Engineers, Inc., 345 East 47th Street, New York, NY 10017.

ASTM D-4108-82, TPP of Materials for Clothing by Open Flame Method, American Society for Testing and Materials.

ASTM D-1518-1977, Thermal Transmittance of Textile Fabric and Batting Between Guarded Hot-Plate and Cool Atmosphere, American Society for Testing and Materials.

Backer, S. , Tesoro, G.C. , Toong, T.Y. , and Moussa, N.A. , "Textile Fabric Flammability," MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1976, pp. 124-127.

Baitinger, W.F. , Product Engineering and Safety Apparel Fabrics: Insulation Characteristics of Fire-Retardant Cottons, Textile Res. J. 49, 221-225 (1979).

Behnke, W.P. , Thermal Protective Performance Test for Clothing , Fire Technol. 13, 6-12 (1977).

Bingham, M.A. , and Hill, B.J. , Comparison of Thermal Characteristics of Materials Examined by Thermogravimetry and Flammability Tests, J. Thermal Anal. 9, 71-81 (1976).

Braun, E. , Cobble, V.B. , Knansky, J.F. , and Peacock, R. , Development of a Proposed Flammability Standard for Commercial Transport Flight Attendant Uniforms, report no. FAA-RD-75-176, NTIS no. ADA-033-740 , National Technical Information Service, Springfield, VA, 1976.

BS 3791:1970, Specification for Clothing for Protection Against Intense Heat for Short Periods, British Standards Institution.

10.

Chen, N.Y. , Transient Heat and Moisture Transfer to Skin Through Thermally Irradiated Cloth, Doctoral thesis, Dept. of Chemical Engineering , MIT, Cambridge, MA, 1959.

11.

Derksen, W.L. , Monahan, T.I. , DeLhery , G.P. , The Temperature Associated with Radiant Energy Skin Bums, in "Temperature: Its Measurement and Control in Science and Industry," vol. 3, part III, C. M. Herzfeld , Ed., Reinhold, NY, 1961, pp. 171-175.

12.

DIN 4842, Determination of the Degree of Thermal Transparency of Fabrics for Heat Protective Clothing, Deutsches Institut fur Normung eV, November 1977.

13.

Hassenboehler, C.B. , Jr., and Vigo , T.L. , A Mixed Flow Thermal Transmittance Tester for Textiles, Textile Res. J. 52, 510-517 (1982).

14.

Holcombe, B.V. , and Hoschke, B.N. , Dry Heat Transfer Characteristics of Underwear Fabrics, Textile Res. J. 53, 368-374 (1983).

15.

IS 7612-1974, Functional Requirements for Flame Resistant and Heat Resistant Suits, Indian Standards Institution.

16.

Kalelkar, A.S. , and Kung, H.C. , Pre-ignition Heat Transfer In Fabric Skin Systems: Dry Fabrics, Textile Chem. Colour. 4, 200-203 (1972).

17.

Morse, H.L. , et al., Analysis of the Thermal Response of Protective Fabrics, technical report AFML-TR-73-17, NTIS no. AD-759 525, National Technical Information Service, Springfield, VA, 1973.

18.

NF S 74-106, Personal Equipment for Protection Against Heat, Method for Measuring the Heat Transmission Factor of Fabrics or Fabric Assemblies Exposed to a Radiant Heat Source, Association Francaise de Normalization, 1979.

19.

Pelanne, C.M. , Experiments on the Separation of Heat Transfer Mechanisms in Low-Density Fibrous Insulations, in "Thermal Conductivity-Proceedings of 8th Conference," C. Y. Ho and R. E. Taylor , Eds. Plenum Press, NY, 1969, pp. 897-911.

20.

Pintauro, E.M. , and Buchanan, D.R. , Ignition Process ' in Single and Multicomponent Polyester/Cotton Textile Structures, Textile Res. J. 49, 326-334 (1979).

21.

Ross, J.H. , Thermal Conductivity of Fabrics as Relates to Skin Bum Damage, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. Appl. Polym. Symp. 31, 293-312 (1977).

22.

Shalev, I. , and Barker, R.L. , Analysis of the Heat Transfer Characteristics of Fabrics in an Open Flame Exposure, Textile Res. J. 53, 475-482 (1983).

23.

Stoll, A.M. , and Chianta, M.A. , Heat Transfer through Fabrics as Related to Thermal Injury, Trans. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 33, 649-670 (1971).

24.

Verschoor, J.D. , and Greebler , P. , Heat Transfer by Gas Conduction and Radiation in Fibrous insulations, Trans. ASME 74, 961-968 (1952).