High rates of tenancy turnover in social rented housing have increasingly been identified as problematic both in the UK and elsewhere. High turnover has been variously associated with management failings, individual vulnerability or (absence of) tenant choice. Drawing on original research into ‘prematurely terminated’ tenancies in Glasgow, we investigate explanatory factors associated with tenancy sustainment rates. In doing so, we interrogate the (managerialist) rationale which positions such residential mobility as potentially ‘excessive’ and therefore ‘problematic’. The empirical findings demonstrate evidence for all three posited explanations for high tenancy turnover but also suggest that some tenants vacating their homes after only a short time may be making a positive choice. They also emphasise that, in seeking to reduce early tenancy termination, social landlords should recognise the importance of improving mainstream housing management services and the condition of the housing stock, as well as attempting to address individual vulnerability through targeted support.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Anderson, I. and Christian, J. ( 2003) Causes of homelessness in the UK: a dynamic analysis, Journal of Community and Applied Psychology, 13(2), pp. 105-118.
2.
Audit Commission (2006) Choosing well: analysing the costs and benefits of choice in local public services ( http://www.audit-commission.gov.uk/Products/NATIONAL-REPORT/8B6F5C44-4A4F-49bc-ABAB-5D151D3379FD/ChoosingWell.pdf ).
3.
Balchin, P. (Ed.) (1996) Housing Policy in Europe. London: Routledge .
4.
Bontje, M. ( 2005) Facing the challenge of shrinking cities in East Germany: the case of Leipzig, GeoJournal, 61(1), pp. 13-21.
5.
Bramley, G., Munro, M. and Pawson, H. ( 2004) Key Issues in Housing: Policies and Markets in 21st Century Britain. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
6.
Bramley, G., Pawson, H. and Parker, J. ( 2000a) Tackling low demand housing and unpopular neighbourhoods: a guide to good practice. Department of Transport, Environment and the Regions, London.
7.
Bramley, G., Pawson, H. and Third, H. ( 2000b) Low demand housing and unpopular neighbourhoods. Research Report, Department of Transport, Environment and the Regions, London.
8.
Brown, T. and Yates, N. ( 2005) Allocations and lettings: taking forward allocations in England?, European Journal of Housing Policy, 5(3), pp. 343-357.
9.
Brown, T., Hunt, R. and Yates, N. ( 2000) Lettings: a question of choice. Chartered Institute of Housing, Coventry.
10.
Burrows, R. ( 1999) Residential mobility and residualisation in social housing in England, Journal of Social Policy, 28(1), pp. 27-52.
11.
Busch-Geertsema, V. ( 2002) When homeless people are allowed to decide by themselves: rehousing homeless people in Germany, European Journal of Social Work, 5(1), pp. 2-19.
12.
Carter, M. and El-Hassan, A.A. ( 2003) Between NASS and a hard place. Housing Associations Charitable Trust, London.
13.
Clark, W.A.V. ( 1982) Recent research on migration and mobility: a review and interpretation, Progress in Planning, 18(1), pp. 1-56.
14.
Clark, W.A.V. and Huang, Y. ( 2003) The life course and residential mobility in British housing markets, Environment and Planning A, 35(2), pp. 323-339.
Cooper, L. and Morris, M. ( 2005) Sustainable tenancy for indigenous families: what services and policy supports are needed? Final report. Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute, Melbourne, Victoria (http://www.ahuri.edu.au/global/docs/doc786.pdf?CFID=25863&CFTOKEN=73080004).
17.
Cowan, D. and Marsh, A. ( 2005) From need to choice, welfarism and advanced liberalism? Problematics of social housing allocation, Legal Studies, 25(1), pp. 22-48.
18.
Crane, M. ( 1999) Understanding Older Homeless People: Their Circumstances, Problems and Needs. Buckingham: Open University Press.
19.
Crane, M. and Warnes, A. ( 2007) The outcomes of rehousing older homeless people: a longitudinal study, Ageing and Society, 27(6), pp. 891-918.
20.
Crane, M., Warnes, A. and Fu, R. ( 2006) Developing homelessness prevention practice: combining research evidence with professional knowledge, Health and Social Care in the Community, 14(2), pp. 156-166.
21.
Dane, K. ( 1998) Making it last: a report on research into tenancy outcomes for rough sleepers. Broadway, London .
22.
DETR (Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions) (2000) Quality and choice: a decent home for all: the housing Green Paper. DETR, London.
23.
Dieleman, F.M. ( 2001) Modelling residential mobility: a review of recent trends in research, Journal of Housing and Built Environment, 16(3/4), pp. 249-265.
24.
Dillane, J., Hill, M., Bannister, J. and Scott, S. ( 2001) Evaluation of the Dundee families project. Centre for the Child and Society and Department of Urban Studies, University of Glasgow.
25.
DoE (Department of the Environment) (1981) Difficult to let investigation (Vols 1 and 2), Housing Development Department Occasional Papers Nos 4/80 and 5/80, DoE, London.
26.
DTLR (Department for Transport, Local Government and the Regions) ( 2003) More than a roof: a report into tackling homelessness . DTLR, London (http://www.communities.gov.uk/index.asp?id=1149818).
27.
Fitzpatrick, S. (2000) Young Homeless People. London: Macmillan.
28.
Fitzpatrick, S., Pleace, N. and Bevan, M. (2005) Final evaluation of the rough sleepers initiative. Scottish Executive, Edinburgh.
29.
Flint, J. ( 2002) Social housing agencies and the governance of anti-social behaviour, Housing Studies, 14(4), pp. 619-637.
30.
Flint, J. (Ed.) (2006) Housing, Urban Governance and Anti-social Behaviour. Bristol: Policy Press.
31.
Gale, A. ( 2003) Successful tenancies: stopping the revolving door. Paper presented at the Australian Federation of Homelessness Organizations 3rd National Homelessness Conference, Brisbane, April (http://www.nationalhousingconference.org.au/downloads/2003/DayOne/27_Gale_ppt.pdf ).
32.
GHA (Glasgow Housing Association) (2006) 30-year business plan 2006/07. GHA ( http://www.gha.org.uk/content/mediaassets/doc/business_plan_final.pdf ).
33.
Gibb, K. ( 2003) Transferring Glasgow’s council housing: financial, urban and housing policy implications, European Journal of Housing Policy, 3(1), pp. 89-114.
34.
Gruis, V., Nieboer, N. and Thomas, A. ( 2004) Strategic asset management in the social rented sector: approaches of Dutch and English housing associations, Urban Studies, 41(7), pp. 1229-1248.
35.
Haffner, M.E.A. and Hoekstra, J. ( 2006) Housing allocation and freedom of movement: aEuropean comparison, Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie, 97(4), pp. 443-451.
36.
Harding, J. and Willett, A. ( 2008) Barriers and contradictions in the resettlement of single homeless people, Social Policy and Society, 7(4), pp. 433-444.
37.
Heijden, H. van der ( 2002) Social rented housing in western Europe: developments and expectations, Urban Studies, 39(2), pp. 327-340.
38.
Henley, A. ( 1998) Residential mobility, housing equity and the labour market , The Economic Journal, 108(447), pp. 414-427.
39.
Hennessy, C. and Grant, D. ( 2006) Developing a model of housing support: the evidence from Merseyside, International Journal of Consumer Studies, 30(4), pp. 337-346.
40.
Hills, J. ( 2007) Ends and means: the future roles of social housing in England. CASE/CLG, London (http://sticerd.lse.ac.uk/dps/case/cr/CASEreport34.pdf ).
41.
Johnsen, S., Jones, A. and Rugg, J. ( 2008) The experience of homeless ex-service personnel in London . Centre for Housing Policy, York .
42.
Jones, A., Pleace, N. and Quilgars, D. ( 2002) Firm foundations: an evaluation of the Shelter homeless to home service. Shelter, London .
43.
Kemp, P.A., Rhodes, D. and Wilcox, S. ( 2002) Housing benefit reform: next steps. Joseph Rowntree Foundation, York.
44.
Kendig, H.L. ( 1984) Housing careers, life cycle and residential mobility: implications for the housing market, Urban Studies, 21, pp. 261-273.
45.
Kintrea, K., Bannister, J., Pickering, J. et al. (2008) Young People and Territoriality in British Cities. Bristol: Policy Press.
46.
Kullberg, J. ( 1997) From waiting lists to adverts: the allocation of social rental dwellings in the Netherlands, Housing Studies, 12(3), pp. 393-403.
47.
Kullberg, J. ( 2002) Consumers’ response to choice based letting mechanisms , Housing Studies, 17(4), pp. 549-579.
48.
Lindblom, E. ( 1991) Towards a comprehensive homelessness-prevention strategy , Housing Policy Debate, 2(3), pp. 957-1025.
49.
Lomax, D. and Netto, G. ( 2007) Evaluation of tenancy sustainment teams: research report . Communities and Local Government, London (http://www.communities.gov.uk/index.asp?id=1505917).
50.
London Housing Unit ( 2003) Housing refugees: good practice in housing management, guidelines for local authorities. London Housing Unit.
51.
Maclennan, D. and O’Sullivan, T. ( 2008) Housing policies for Scotland: challenges and changes . Joseph Rowntree Foundation, York .
52.
Magnusson, L. and Turner, B. ( 2002) Countryside abandoned? Suburbanisation and mobility in Sweden. Institute for Housing and Urban Research, Uppsala University, Sweden (unpublished).
53.
Marsh, A., Cowan, D., Cameron, A. et al. (2004) Piloting choice based lettings: an evaluation. Office of the Deputy Prime Minister, London (http://communities.gov.uk/index.asp?id=1153360).
54.
Monk, S., Clarke, A. and Whitehead, C.M.E. (2008) Understanding the demand for social housing, in: S. Fitzpatrick and M. Stephens (Eds) The Future of Social Housing, ch. 9. London: Shelter.
55.
Murie, A. (2006) Moving with the times: changing frameworks for housing research and policy , in: P. Malpass and L. Cairncross (Eds) Building on the Past: Visions of Housing Futures, pp. 15-50. Bristol: Policy Press.
56.
NAO (National Audit Office) (2005) More than a Roof: Progress in Tackling Homelessness. London : The Stationery Office.
57.
Neuberger, J. ( 2003) Settling down: preventing family homelessness through tenancy sustainment. Shelter, London .
58.
Newman, T. and Samoiloff, J. ( 2005) Sustaining tenancies. Paper presented at the Australian National Housing Conference, Perth, October (http://www.nationalhousingconference.org.au/downloads/nhc/2005/NewmanT.pdf ).
59.
Page, D. ( 2000) Communities in the Balance: The Reality of Social Exclusion on Housing Estates. York: York Publishing Services.
60.
Pawson, H. ( 2002) Allocations and choice in Scotland: a discussion paper . Chartered Institute of Housing, Coventry.
61.
Pawson, H. ( 2007) Analysis of 2005/06 local authority housing management performance indicators. Housing Quality Network, Scarborough.
62.
Pawson, H., Davidson, E. and Netto, G. ( 2007) Evaluation of homelessness prevention activities in Scotland . Scottish Executive, Edinburgh (http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2007/03/26095144/0).
63.
Pawson, H., Davidson, E., Morgan, J. et al. (2009) Second Generation: The Impacts of Stock Transfer in Urban Britain. York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation.
64.
Pawson, H., Donohoe, A., Munro, M. et al. (2006) Investigating tenancy sustainment in Glasgow . Glasgow Housing Association ( http://www.gha.org.uk/content/mediaassets/doc/full_tenancy_sustainment.pdf ).
65.
Pawson, H., Jones, C., Watkins, D. et al. (2006) Monitoring the longer term impact of choice-based lettings. Department for Communities and Local Government , London (http://www.communities.gov.uk/pub/599/MonitoringtheLongerTermImpactofChoicebasedLettings_id1503599.pdf ).
66.
Pawson, H., Netto, G., Jones, C. et al. (2007) Evaluating homelessness prevention. Department for Communities and Local Government, London (http://www.communities.gov.uk/publications/housing/preventhomelessness ).
67.
Ploeg, J., Hayward, L., Woodward, C. and Johnston, R. ( 2008) A case study of a Canadian homelessness intervention programme for elderly people, Health and Social Care in the Community , 16(6), pp. 593-605.
68.
Randall, G. and Brown, S. ( 2002) Homelessness strategies: a good practice handbook. Department for Transport, Local Government and the Regions, London.
69.
Robinson, D. and Hawtin, M. ( 2001) Preventing homelessness: the role of housing management . Communties Scotland, Edinburgh .
70.
Robson, B., Lymperopoulou, K. and Rae, A. ( 2008) People on the move: exploring the functional roles of deprived neighbourhoods, Environment and Planning A, 40(11), pp. 2693-2714.
71.
Rugg, J. and Rhodes, D. ( 2008) The private rented sector: its contribution and potential . Centre for Housing Policy, University of York.
72.
Scottish Executive (2004) Helping homeless people, delivering the action plan for prevention and effective response (http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2004/01/18820/32288 ).
73.
Slatter, M. and Crearie, M. ( 2003) Sustainable tenancies: from public to private?, Flinders Journal of Law Reform, 7(1), pp. 15-26.
74.
Sprigings, N. and Allen, C. ( 2005) The communities we are regaining but need to lose, Community, Work and Family, 8(4), pp. 389-411.
75.
Stephens, M. ( 2008) The role of the social rented sector, in: M. Stephens and S. Fitzpatrick (Eds) The Future of Social Housing, pp. 27-38. London : Shelter.
76.
Stephens, M., Burns, N. and MacKay, L. ( 2003) The limits of housing reform: British social rented housing in aEuropean context, Urban Studies, 40(4), pp. 767-789.
77.
Stephens, M., Whitehead, C. and Munro, M. (2005) Lessons from the past, challenges for the future for housing policy: an evaluation of English housing policy 1975-2000. Office of the Deputy Prime Minister, London.
78.
Third, H., Pawson, H. and Tate, J. ( 2001) Sustaining young persons tenancies in the social rented sector: the South Clyde experience. Report to Scottish Homes (unpublished).
79.
Thompson, S.J., Pollio, D.E., Eyrich, K. et al. (2004) Successfully exiting homelessness: experiences of formerly homeless mentally ill individuals, Evaluation and Program Planning, 27(4), pp. 423-431.
80.
Torr, G. ( 2002) An evaluation of the effectiveness of a tenancy support service. Housing Corporation, London .
81.
Tosics, I. ( 2004) European urban development: sustainability and the role of housing, Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 19(1), pp. 67-90.
82.
WAG (Welsh Assembly Government) (2004) Advice note on the prevention of homelessness. WAG, Cardiff.
