This paper examines recent responses to ‘problematic street culture’ in England, where increasing pressure has been exerted to prevent people from begging and street drinking in public spaces, with rough sleeping also targeted in some areas. Drawing upon in-depth interviews with enforcement agents, support providers and targeted individuals, it assesses the extent to which the strategies employed are indicative of a ‘revanchist expulsion’ of the deviant Other and/or an expression of ‘coercive care’ for the vulnerable Other. It concludes that, whilst the recent developments appear, at first glance, to be symptomatic of revanchist sanitisation of public space, closer examination reveals that the situation is actually much more complex than a revanchist reading of the situation might suggest, and perhaps not as devoid of compassion.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adler, M., Bromley, C. and Rosie, M. (2000) Begging as a challenge to the welfare state, in: R. Jowell, J. Curtice, A. Park and K. Thomson (Eds) British Social Attitudes: The 17th Report 2000/2001 , pp. 209-237. London: Sage.
2.
Alcohol Concern ( 2003) Street drinking. Alcohol Concern, London.
3.
Amster, R. ( 2003) Patterns of exclusion: sanitizing space, criminalizing homelessness, Social Justice, 30, pp. 195-221.
4.
Anglin, M.D. and Hser, Y. ( 1991) Criminal justice and the drug-abusing offender: policy issues of coerced treatment, Behavioural Sciences and the Law, 27, pp. 243-267.
5.
Arapoglou, V.P. ( 2004) The governance of homelessness in the European south: spatial and institutional contexts of philanthropy in Athens, Urban Studies, 41, pp. 621-639.
6.
Arlington Housing Association (1992) Homelessness and street drinking. Arlington Housing Association , Arlington.
7.
Atkinson, R. ( 2003) Domestication by cappuccino or a revenge on urban space? Control and empowerment in the management of public spaces, Urban Studies, 40, pp. 1829-1843.
8.
Baker, O. with Vision 21 (2001) Streets of London: a study of street culture in Westminster. Vision 21, London.
9.
Ballintyne, S. ( 1999) Unsafe Streets: Street Homelessness and Crime. London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
10.
Bannister, J., Fyfe, N. and Kearns, A. ( 2006) Respectable or respectful? (In)civility and the city, Urban Studies, 43, pp. 919-937.
11.
Benjamin, A. ( 2008) ‘Cleaned out’, The Guardian , 24 September.
12.
Burdett, R. ( 2008) We’re about to see a get-tough attitude to homeless people, West End Extra, 4 July.
13.
Checinski, K. and Ghodse, H. ( 2004) Types of treatment for types of patients, in: P. Bean and T. Nemitz (Eds) Drug Treatment: What Works?, pp. 31-57. London : Routledge.
14.
City of Westminster (n.d.) An integrated approach to reduce begging in Westminster. City of Westminster, London.
15.
Cloke, P., May, J. and Johnsen, S. ( 2008) Performativity and affect in the homeless city, Environment and Planning D, 26, pp. 241-263.
16.
Cloke, P., Milbourne, P. and Widdowfield, R. ( 2001) Making the homeless count? Enumerating rough sleepers and the distortion of homelessness, Policy and Politics, 29(3), pp. 259-279.
17.
Cresswell, T. ( 1996) In Place/Out of Place: Geography, Identity and Transgression . Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
18.
Danczuk, S. ( 2000) Walk on by... Begging, Street Drinking and the Giving Age. London: Crisis.
19.
Davies, R. and Waite, S. ( 2004) Drugs use and begging: a practice guide. Home Office, London.
20.
Davis, M. ( 1990) City of Quartz. London: Vintage.
21.
Dean, H. and Melrose, M. ( 1999) Easy pickings or hard profession? Begging as an economic activity, in: H. Dean (Ed.) Begging Questions: Street-level Economic Activity and Social Policy Failure , pp. 83-100. Bristol: The Policy Press.
22.
Dear, M. and Wolch, J. ( 1987) Landscapes of Despair: From Deinstitutionalization to Homelessness. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
23.
Dear, M., Wolch, J. and Wilton, R. ( 1994) The service hub concept in human services planning, Progress in Planning, 42, pp. 173-271.
24.
DeVerteuil, G. ( 2006) The local state and homeless shelters: beyond revanchism? , Cities, 23, pp. 109-120.
25.
DeVerteuil, G., May, J. and von Mahs, J.(2009) Complexity not collapse: recasting the geographies of homelessness in a ‘punitive’ age, Progress in Human Geography , 33(5), pp. 646-666.
26.
Doherty, J., Busch-Geertsema, V., Karpuskiene, V. et al. (2008) Homelessness and exclusion: regulating public space inEuropean cities, Surveillance and Society, 5, pp. 290-314.
27.
Dugan, E. ( 2007) Soup run ban ‘could cut lifeline to homeless’ , The Independent, 14 November.
28.
Duncan, J. ( 1978) Men without property: the tramp’s classification and use of urban space, Antipode, 10(1), pp. 24-34.
29.
Eick, V. ( 2003) New strategies of policing the poor: Berlin’s neo-liberal security system, Policing and Society, 13, pp. 365-379.
30.
Fitzpatrick, S. and Johnsen, S.(2009) The use of enforcement to combat ‘street culture’ in England: an ethical approach?, Ethics and Social Welfare, 3(3), pp. 284-302.
31.
Fitzpatrick, S. and Jones, A. ( 2005) Pursuing social justice or social cohesion? Coercion in street homelessness policies in England, Journal of Social Policy, 34, pp. 389-406.
32.
Fitzpatrick, S. and Kennedy, C. (2000) Getting By: Begging, Rough Sleeping and the Big Issue in Glasgow and Edinburgh . London: The Policy Press.
33.
Fitzpatrick, S. and Kennedy, C. ( 2001) The links between begging and rough sleeping: a question of legitimacy?, Housing Studies, 16(5), pp. 549-568.
34.
Fitzpatrick, S. and Stephens, M. (2007) An international review of homelessness and social housing policy. Communities and Local Government, London.
35.
Fitzpatrick, S., Kemp, P. and Klinker, S. ( 2000) Single Homelessness: An Overview of Research in Britain . Bristol: The Policy Press.
36.
Fitzpatrick, S., Pleace, N. and Quilgars, D. (Eds) ( 2009) Homelessness in the UK: Problems, Policies and Solutions . Coventry: Chartered Institute of Housing.
37.
Flint, J. and Nixon, J. ( 2006) Governing neighbours: anti-social behaviour orders and new forms of regulating conduct in the UK, Urban Studies, 43, pp. 939-955.
38.
Gossop, M. ( 2004) Developments in the treatment of drug problems, in: P. Bean and T. Nemitz (Eds) Drug Treatment: What Works?, ch. 4. London: Routledge.
39.
Gregoire, T.K. and Burke, A.C. ( 2004) The relationship of legal coercion to readiness to change among adults with alcohol or other drug problems, Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment, 26, pp. 35-41.
40.
The Guardian (2007) A ban on soup runs would only hurt the vulnerable, Letters to the Editor, 12 September .
41.
Harradine, S., Kodz, J., Lemetti, F. and Jones, B. ( 2004) Defining and measuring anti-social behaviour. Development and Practice Report No. 26, Home Office, London.
42.
Hermer, J. ( 1999) Policing compassion: ‘diverted giving’ on the Winchester High Street, in: H. Dean (Ed.) Begging Questions: Street-level Economic Activity and Social Policy Failure, pp. 203-218. Bristol: The Policy Press.
43.
Herring, R. ( 1997) Persistent street drinkers: back on the agenda?, Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy, 4, pp. 187-191.
44.
Holloway, K., Bennett, T. and Farrington, D. ( 2005) The effectiveness of criminal justice and treatment programmes in reducing drug-related crime: a systematic review. On-line Report No. 26/05. Home Office, London.
45.
Homeless Link (2006) A8 nationals in London homelessness services. Homeless Link, London.
46.
Home Office (2003) Respect and Responsibility: Taking a Stand Against Anti-social Behaviour. London: HMSO.
47.
Home Office (n.d.a) Together tackling anti-social behaviour action plan. Home Office, London.
48.
Home Office (n.d.b) Working together: tackling not tolerating anti-social behaviour. Home Office, London.
49.
Housing Justice (2009) Rough sleeping: compassion v coercion: church, community and government responses . Discussion document, Housing Justice, London.
50.
The Independent (2007) Immoral plan to ban soup runs, Letters to the Editor, 13 November.
51.
Johnsen, S. and Fitzpatrick, S. ( 2007) The Impact of Enforcement on Street Users in England. Bristol: Policy Press.
52.
Johnsen, S. and Fitzpatrick, S. ( 2008) The use of enforcement to combat begging and street drinking in England: a high risk strategy?, European Journal of Homelessness , 2, pp. 191-204.
53.
Jones, A. and Johnsen, S.(2009) Street homelessness, in: S. Fitzpatrick , N. Pleace and D. Quilgars (Eds) Homelessness in the UK: Problems, Policies and Solutions, pp. 228-249. Coventry: Chartered Institute of Housing.
54.
Jones, R. ( 2008) Disciplining the homeless in Exeter? Unpublished MSc thesis , University College London.
55.
Jowett, S., Banks, G., Brown, A. and Goodall, G. ( 2001) Looking for change: the role and impact of begging on the lives of people who beg. London: RSU/DTLR .
56.
Kleinig, J. ( 1993) Policing the homeless: an ethical dilemma, Journal of Social Distress and the Homeless, 2, pp. 289-303.
57.
Laurenson, P. and Collins, D. ( 2007) Beyond punitive regulation? New Zealand local governments’ responses to homelessness, Antipode, 39, pp. 649-667.
58.
Lehman, L.B., Pilich, A. and Andrews, N. ( 1993) Neurological disorders resulting from alcoholism, Alcohol Health and Research World, 17, pp. 305-309.
59.
Lianos, M. and Douglas, M. ( 2000) Dangerization and the end of deviance, British Journal of Criminology, 40, pp. 261-278.
60.
Lipsky, M. (1980) Street-level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
61.
London Councils (2007) London Local Authorities Bill: proposals for a tenth Bill for deposit in November 2007. London Councils.
62.
MacLeod, G. ( 2002) From urban entrepreneurialism to a ‘revanchist city’? On the spatial injustices of Glasgow’s renaissance, Antipode, 34, pp. 603-620.
63.
May, J., Cloke, P. and Johnsen, S. ( 2005) Re-phasing neoliberalism: New Labour and Britain’s crisis of street homelessness, Antipode, 37, pp. 703-730.
64.
May, J., Cloke, P. and Johnsen, S. ( 2006) Shelter at the margins: New Labour and the changing state of emergency accommodation for single homeless people in Britain, Policy and Politics, 34, pp. 711-729.
65.
McNaughton-Nicholls, C. and Quilgars, D. ( 2009) Homelessness amongst minority ethnic groups, in: S. Fitzpatrick, N. Pleace and D. Quilgars (Eds) Homelessness in the UK: Problems, Policies and Solutions, ch. 5. Coventry: Chartered Institute of Housing.
66.
Meert, H., Stuyck, K., Cabrera, P. et al. (2006) The changing profiles of homeless people: conflict, rooflessness and the use of public space. European Federation of National Organisations Working with the Homeless (FEANTSA), Brussels.
67.
Mental Health Foundation (1996) Too many for the road: report of the MHF expert working group on persistent street drinkers. Mental Health Foundation, London.
68.
Mitchell, D. ( 1997) The annihilation of space by law: the roots and implications of anti-homeless laws in the United States, Antipode, 29, pp. 303-336.
69.
Mitchell, D. ( 2001) Postmodern geographical praxis? The postmodern impulse and the war against homeless people in the ‘postjustice’ city , in: C. Minca (Ed.) Postmodern Geography: Theory and Praxis, pp. 57-97. Oxford: Blackwell.
70.
National Coalition for the Homeless (2004) Illegal to be homeless: the criminalization of homelessness in the United States. National Coalition for the Homeless, Washington, DC.
71.
National Coalition for the Homeless and National Law Center on Homelessness and Poverty (2006) A dream denied: the criminalization of homelessness in U.S. cities. National Coalition for the Homeless, Washington, DC .
72.
Newburn, T. and Jones, T. ( 2007) Symbolising crime control: reflections on zero tolerance , Theoretical Criminology, 11, pp. 221-243.
73.
Newburn, T. and Rock, P. ( 2005) Living in Fear: Violence and Victimisation in the Lives of Single Homeless People. London: Crisis.
74.
Parker, M. ( 2008) Homeless hosed from sleeping spots, The Big Issue, 27 October.
75.
Pawson, H. and Davidson, E. ( 2006) Fit for purpose? Official measures of homelessness in the era of the activist state, Radical Statistics, 93, pp. 7-29.
76.
Phillips, T. and Smith, P. ( 2006) Rethinking urban incivility research: strangers, bodies and circulations, Urban Studies, 43, pp. 879-901.
77.
Raco, M. ( 2003) Remaking place and securitising space: urban regeneration and the strategies, tactics and practices of policing in the UK, Urban Studies, 40, pp. 1867-1887.
78.
Randall, G. and Brown, S. ( 2002) Helping rough sleepers off the street. A report to the Homelessness Directorate. ODPM, London.
79.
Randall, G. and Brown, S. ( 2006) Steps Off the Street: Solutions to Street Homelessness . London: Crisis.
80.
Ross, A.J., Heim, D., Flatley, K. et al. (2005) An exploration of street drinking in Drumchapel , Scotland, Health Education Research, 20, pp. 314-322.
81.
Ruddick, S. ( 1996) Young and Homeless in Hollywood: Mapping Social Identities . New York: Routledge.
82.
Sennett, R. ( 1992) The Uses of Disorder: Personal Identity and City Life . London: W.W. Norton.
83.
Shapps, G. ( 2007) Roughly sleeping: how a black hole in the street count leads to a systematic underestimate of the number of people sleeping on the streets. Unpublished report (www.shapps.com/reports ).
84.
Shimwell, K. ( 1999) Street substance use and homelessness in Rotherham. Rotherham Community Alcohol Service.
85.
Sibley, D. ( 1995) Geographies of Exclusion. London: Routledge.
86.
Smith, N. ( 1996) The New Urban Frontier: Gentrification and the Revanchist City. New York: Routledge.
87.
Smith, N. ( 1999) Which new urbanism? New York City and the revanchist 1990s , in: R. A. Beauregard and S. Body-Gendrot (Eds) The Urban Moment: Cosmopolitan Essays on the Late 20th Century City, pp. 185-208. London: Sage.
88.
Tosi, A. ( 2007) Homelessness and the control of public space: criminalizing the poor?, European Journal of Homelessness, 1, pp. 224-235.
89.
Turning Point (2005) The crack report. Turning Point, London.
90.
Vision 21 (2000) Time for change: a study of street drinking and begging in Camden and Islington. Vision 21, London.
91.
von Mahs, J. ( 2005) The sociospatial exclusion of single homeless people in Berlin and Los Angeles, American Behavioral Scientist, 48, pp. 928-960.
92.
Wardhaugh, J. ( 1996) ‘Homeless in Chinatown’: deviance and social control in cardboard city, Sociology, 30, pp. 701-716.
93.
Wardhaugh, J. ( 2000) Sub City: Young People, Homelessness and Crime. Aldershot: Ashgate.
94.
Wood, M. ( 2004) Perceptions and experience of antisocial behaviour: findings from the 2003/2004 British Crime Survey. Online Report No. 49/04, Home Office, London.
95.
Wright, J. ( 1997) Out of Place: Homeless Mobilizations, Subcities, and Contested Landscapes. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
96.
Zukin, S. ( 1995) The Culture of Cities. New York: Blackwell.
