Bilbao and Barcelona ‘in Motion’. How Urban Regeneration ‘Models’ Travel and Mutate in the Global Flows of Policy Tourism

Abstract

This paper explores how the so-called Bilbao effect and Barcelona Model are diffused internationally through what may be called urban policy tourism: short trips made to Bilbao and Barcelona by policy-makers to learn from their regeneration in the past 15 years. The paper reveals for the first time the substantial extent of this practice and contextualises it within a wider phenomenon of urban policy transfer and the international ‘motion’ of urban policies. Although both models are internationally known for a set of elements, this research shows that in fact the messages mutate and shift as they circulate through the policy circuits. Ultimately, however, the popularity of the Bilbao and Barcelona models suggests a process of global urban policy convergence.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abrahamson

(1996) Management fashion, The Academy of Management Review, 21, pp. 254–285.

Ajuntament de Barcelona (1991) Barcelona en el mundo. Cooperacion y Solidaridad Internacional, Barcelona.

Ajuntament de Barcelona (2004) Barcelona en el mundo 1995–2004. Ajuntament de Barcelona.

Balibrea

(2001) Urbanism, culture and the post-industrial city: challenging the ‘Barcelona model’, Journal of Spanish Cultural Studies, 2, pp. 187–210.

Bilbao Turismo (2008) Estadisticas ( http://www.bilbao.net/bilbaoturismo/ ).

Böhme

(2002) Much ado about evidence: reflections from policy making in the European Union, Planning Theory & Practice, 3, pp. 98–10.

Booth

(2007) The hanging gardens of Croydon? Plan to turn ‘concrete hell’ into a new Barcelona, The Guardian, 13 November ( http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2007/nov/13/communities.society ).

Borja

(2007) Revolución y contrarevolución en la ciudad global: las expectativas frustradas por la globalización de nuestras ciudades, EURE, 33, pp. 35–50.

Campbell

(2002) ‘Evidence-based policy’: the continuing search for effective policy processes, Planning Theory & Practice, 3, pp. 89–90.

10.

Capel

(2005) El modelo Barcelona: un examen crítico. Barcelona: Serbal.

11.

Capel

(2007) El debate sobre la construcción de la ciudad y el llamado ‘modelo Barcelona’, Scripta Nova, Revista Electrónica de Geografía y Ciencias Sociales, 11 ( http://www.ub.es/geocrit/sn/sn-233.htm ).

12.

Carnoy

Castells

(2001) Globalization, the knowledge society, and the network state: Poulantzas at the millennium, Global Networks, 1, pp. 1–18.

13.

Casellas

(2007) Gobernabilidad, participación ciudadana y desarrollo economico: adaptaciones locales a estrategias globales, Scripta Nova, Revista Electrónica de Geografía y Ciencias Sociales, 11, ( http://www.ub.es/geocrit/sn/sn-243.htm ).

14.

Clarence

(2002) Editorial. Technocracy reinvented: the new evidence based policy movement, Public Policy and Administration, 17, pp. 1–11.

15.

Compans

(2005) Empreendedorismo urbano: entre o discurso e a prática. UNESP, São Paulo.

16.

Cook

I. R.

(2008) Mobilising urban policies: the policy transfer of US business improvement districts to England and Wales, Urban Studies, 45, pp. 773–795.

17.

Czarniawska-Joerges

(1996) Travels of ideas, in: Czarniawska-Joerges

Sevón

(Eds) Translating Organizational Change, pp. 13–48. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.

18.

Degen

García

(Eds) (2008) La Metaciudad: Barcelona. Transformación de una Metrópolis. Barcelona: Anthropos.

19.

Degen

García

(forthcoming) Barcelona: the breakdown of a model?, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research.

20.

Del Cerro

(2006) Bilbao: Basque Pathways to Globalization. Amsterdam: Elsevier.

21.

Delgado

(2007) La Ciudad Mentirosa: Fraude y Miseria del ‘Modelo Barcelona’. Madrid: Catarata.

22.

DiMaggio

P. J.

Powell

(1983) The iron cage revisited: institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields, American Sociological Review, 48, pp. 147–160.

23.

Dolowitz

D. P.

Marsh

(2000) Learning from abroad: the role of policy transfer in contemporary policy-making, Governance: An International Journal of Policy Administration and Institutions, 13, pp. 5–24.

24.

The Economist (1999) Homage to Catalonia, 19 June, US edition.

25.

Edensor

(2007) Mundane mobilities, performances and spaces of tourism, Social and Cultural Geography, 8, pp. 199–215.

26.

Esteban

(2000) Bilbao, luces y sombras del titanio: el proceso de regeneración del Bilbao metropolitano. Leioa: Servicio editorial de la Universidad del Pais Vasco.

27.

García-Ramón

M. D.

Albet

(2000) Pre-Olympic and post-Olympic Barcelona: a ‘model’ for urban regeneration today?, Environment and Planning A, 32, pp. 1331–1334.

28.

González

(2004) The role of the Guggenheim Museum in the development of urban entrepreneurial practices in Bilbao, International Journal of Iberian Studies, 16, pp. 177–186.

29.

González

(2006) Scalar narratives in Bilbao: a cultural politics of scales approach to the study of urban policy, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 30, pp. 836–857.

30.

González

(forthcoming) Neoliberal urbanism in Europe, in: Pike

Rodríguez-Pose

Tomaney

(Eds) Handbook of Local and Regional Development, ch. 38. London: Routledge.

31.

Gregory

(1999) Scripting Egypt: orientalism and the cultures of travel, in: Duncan

Gregory

(Eds) Writes of Passage: Reading Travel Writing, pp. 114–150. London: Sage.

32.

Jensen

(2007) Culture stories: understanding cultural urban branding, Planning Theory, 6, pp. 211–236.

33.

Jessop

(1997) The entrepreneurial city: re-imaging localities, redesigning economic governance, or restructuring capital?, in: Jewson

MacGregor

(Eds) Realising Cities: New Spatial Divisions and Social Transformation, pp. 28–41. London: Routledge.

34.

de Jong

Edelenbos

(2007) An insider’s look into policy transfer in transnational expert networks, European Planning Studies, 15, pp. 687–706.

35.

Kelly

(2006) Speech. Core Cities Summit, Bristol ( http://www.communities.gov.uk/speeches/corporate/summit-bristol ).

36.

Larner

(2003) Neoliberalism?, Environment and Planning D, 21, pp. 509–512.

37.

Larner

Laurie

(2010) Travelling technocrats, embodied knowledges: globalising privatisation in telecoms and water, Geoforum, 41, pp. 218–226.

38.

Larner

Le Heron

(2002) From economic globalization to globalizing economic processes: towards post-structural political economies, Geoforum, 33, pp. 415–419.

39.

Leal de Oliveira

(2003) Strategic planning and urban competition: the agenda of multilateral agencies in Brazil, Progressive Planning, September/October ( http://www.plannersnetwork.org/publications/2000_143/oliveira.html ).

40.

Lord

G. D.

(2007) The ‘Bilbao effect’ from poor port to must-see city, The Art Newspaper, 184, pp. 32–33.

41.

March Pujol

J. A.

(2003) Iberoamérica: el rol del CIDEU en la construcción del nuevo mapa de ciudades en el siglo XXI, in: CIDEU (Ed.) 10 años de planificación estratégica en Iberoamérica, pp. 61–65. Barcelona: CIDEU.

42.

Marsh

(2003) Leeds proves that it is no longer grim up North, The Times, 13 September, p. 9.

43.

Marshall

(Ed.) (2004) Transforming Barcelona. London: Routledge.

44.

McCann

E. J.

(2008) Expertise, truth, and urban policy mobilities: global circuits of knowledge in the development of Vancouver, Canada’s ‘four pillar’ drug strategy, Environment and Planning A, 40, pp. 885–904.

45.

McCann

E. J.

(forthcoming) Urban policy mobilities and global circuits of knowledge: toward a research agenda, Annals of the Association of American Geographers.

46.

McNeill

(2000) McGuggenisation? National identity and globalisation in the Basque Country, Political Geography, 19, pp. 473–494.

47.

McNeill

(2003) Mapping the European urban left: the Barcelona experience, Antipode, 35, pp. 74–94.

48.

Monclús

F. J.

(2003) The Barcelona model: an original formula? From ‘reconstruction’ to strategic urban projects (1974–2004), Planning Perspectives, 18, pp. 399–421.

49.

Norwood

(2007) Plymouth rocks! New developments have made the Devon port truly shipshape, Daily Mail, 14 September, p. 74.

50.

Ong

(2007) Neoliberalism as a mobile technology, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 32, pp. 3–8.

51.

Pascual-Molinas

Ribera-Fumaz

(2009) Gentrification and retail in Ciutat Vella, Barcelona, in: Porter

Shaw

(Eds) Whose Urban Renaissance? An International Comparison of Urban Regeneration Policies, pp. 181–190. London: Routledge.

52.

Peck

(2004) Geography and public policy: constructions of neoliberalism, Progress in Human Geography, 28, pp. 392–405.

53.

Peck

(2009) Conceptualizing fast-policy space, embedding policy mobilities. Department of Geography, University of British Columbia (mimeograph).

54.

Peck

Theodore

(2010) Mobilizing policy: models, methods, and mutations, Geoforum, 41, pp. 169–174.

55.

Peck

Tickell

(2004) Neoliberalizing space, in: Brenner

Theodore

(Eds) Spaces of Neoliberalism, pp. 33–57. Oxford: Blackwell.

56.

Pedraforca

(2004) Barcelona marca registrada y banderín del ciudadanismo, in: Unió Temporal d’Escribes (Eds) Barcelona. Marca registrada: Un model per desarmar, ch. 6. Barcelona: Virus ( http://www.investigaccio.org/barcelona2004/ ).

57.

Pitman

(2007) Mister Guggenheim, The Times, 27 October, pp. 60–67.

58.

Plaza

(2006) The return on investment of the Guggenheim Museum Bilbao, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 30, pp. 264–274.

59.

Plaza

(2008) On some challenges and conditions for the Guggenheim to be an effective economic re-activator, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 32, pp. 506–517.

60.

Radaelli

(2000) Policy transfer in the European Union: institutional isomorphism as a source of legitimacy, Governance: An International Journal of Policy Administration and Institutions, 13, pp. 25–44.

61.

Rodríguez

Martínez

Guenaga

(2001) Uneven redevelopment: new urban policies and socio-spatial fragmentation in metropolitan Bilbao, European Urban and Regional Studies, 8, pp. 161–178.

62.

Sanchez Diez

(2002) La internacionalización de la economía española hacia América Latina, Boletin Economico de ICE, 2174, pp. 19–27.

63.

Scott

Urry

(1994) Economies of Signs and Space. London: Sage.

64.

Segre

(2004) America Latina urbana: el colapso de los modelos en la crisis de la modernidad. Paper presented at the 11th International Planning History Conference, Barcelona, July.

65.

Sheldon

(2004) Editorial: learning from abroad or policy tourism?, British Journal of General Practice, June, pp. 410–411.

66.

Sheller

Urry

(2004) Tourism Mobilities: Places to Play, Places in Play. London: Routledge.

67.

Sklair

(2002) The transnational capitalist class and global politics: deconstructing the corporate–state connection, International Political Science Review, 23, pp. 159–174.

68.

Solesbury

(2002) The ascendancy of evidence, Planning Theory & Practice, 3, pp. 90–96.

69.

Steinberg

(2005) Strategic urban planning in Latin America: experiences of building and managing the future, Habitat International, 29, pp. 69–93.

70.

Stone

(2004) Transfer agents and global networks in the ‘transnationalization’ of policy, Journal of European Public Policy, 11, pp. 545–566.

71.

Sudjic

(2002) Can Liverpool be the Bilbao of the North?, The Observer, 15 December, Review, p. 10.

72.

Symon

(2002) Miles better, not complete, The Scotsman, 30 April, p. 19.

73.

Taylor

(2004) World City Network: A Global Urban Analysis. London: Routledge.

74.

Thrift

(1997) Cities without modernity, cities with magic, Scottish Geographical Magazine, 113, pp. 138–149.

75.

Urban Task Force (1999) Towards an urban renaissance. Office of the Deputy Prime Minister, London.

76.

Urry

(1995) Consuming Places. London: Routledge.

77.

Urry

(2002) The Tourist Gaze, 2nd edn. London: Sage.

78.

Vainer

(2000) Light and shadow in the strategies of a consultant on strategies, Progressive Planning, September/October ( http://www.plannersnetwork.org/publications/2000_143/vainer.html ).

79.

Vicario

Martínez-Monje

M. P.

(2003) Another ‘Guggenheim effect’? The generation of a potentially gentrifiable neighbourhood in Bilbao, Urban Studies, 14, pp. 2383–2400.

80.

Ward

(2006) ‘Policies in motion’, urban management and state restructuring: the trans-local expansion of business improvement districts, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 30, pp. 54–75.

81.

Ward

(2007) Business improvement districts: policy origins, mobile policies and urban liveability, Geography Compass, 2, pp. 657–672.

82.

Ward

(2009) Towards a relational comparative approach to the study of cities, Progress in Human Geography, OnlineFirst.

83.

Williams

(1973) Base and superstructure in Marxist cultural theory, New Left Review, 82, pp. 3–16.

84.

Wolman

Page

(2002) Policy transfer among local governments: an information theory approach, Governance: An International Journal of Policy, Administration and Institutions, 15, pp. 477–501.

85.

Zulaika

(1997) Crónica de una seducción: El Museo Guggenheim-Bilbao. Madrid: Nerea.

86.

Zusman

(2004) Activism as a collective cultural praxis: challenging the Barcelona urban model, in: Fuller

Kitchin

(Eds) Radical Theory/Critical Praxis. Making a Difference beyond the Academy, pp. 132–146. Praxis (e)Press ( http://www.praxis-epress.org/rtcp/pz.pdf ).