The Structure and Nature of Australian Environmental Law 1

Constitutional authority over resources and environmental questions resides principally in the States in Australia, but there are many powers which the Federal Government can develop, either alone or together with the States, in working out national policies in these areas. Although the constitutional issues are important, resolution of land use problems is fundamentally a matter of competition for power and authority within the political system.

Professor Whalan suggests four stages in the development of environmental law: (a) totally resource-oriented statutes with possible overlaps and clashes between separate uses; (b) integration of the separate codes and the introduction into those codes of environmentally oriented protective provisions; (c) the enactment of statutes directed towards a specific environmental problem or problems; and (d) the development of overview bodies with advisory and supervisory functions to which the protective responsibilities may be added.

In these statutory moves towards macro-environmental law in Australia, the Courts have been given a very limited role and it is argued that much of the law is not normative in character but procedural, administrative and discretionary. In very many cases, ultimate control is political rather than judicial.