Multimodal Enhancement of Culturally Diverse,Young Adult Musicians: A Pilot Study Involving the Tomatis Method

Abstract

Musicians, seeking stress relief and vocal/instrumental enhancement, often turn to the Tomatis Method of sensori-neural integration training, based on the interdependence and interaction between hearing and listening, psychological attitude and speech and language. The paucity of impact studies on musicians, despite its acclaimed efficacy, has prompted the current multidisciplinary pilot study, involving a two group, pre-post experimental design. Listening aptitude, psychological well-being and vocal (voice) quality were assessed in availability samples of culturally diverse young, adult musicians (n=28), recruited from two tertiary institutions and assigned to a control group (n=10) and an experimental group, consisting of sub-experimental group one (n=10) and sub-experimental group two (n=8). Reasonable preprogramme group equivalence was established between the two sub-experimental groups and the control group. A Tomatis programme of 87.5 half hour listening sessions and concomitant counseling was completed by the total experimental group (n=18). Results indicated practically significant enhancement of: (i) listening aptitude on the Listening Test and (ii) psychological well-being, in terms of reduced negative and increased positive mood state (vigor) on the POMS in both sub-experimental groups, together with enhanced behavioural and emotional coping in sub-experimental group 1 on the CTI. (iii) Vocal enhancement, perceived both by singer-participants in both sub-experimental groups and a professional voice teacher, culminated in (iv) distinctly enhanced musical proficiency in 28% of all programme participants. Despite indications of multimodal enhancement, further research, necessitated by current methodological limitations, remains a prerequisite for achievement of definitive results.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Psychiatric Association. 1994. Diagnostic and statistic manual for mental disorders (DSM IV). 4th Edition. Washington DC: APA.

Baken

R.J.

(1987). Clinical measurement of speech and voice. London: Taylor and Francis.

Brodsky

Sloboda

J. A.

(1997). Clinical trial of music generated vibrotactile therapeutic environment for musicians: Main effects and outcome differences between therapy subgroups. Journal of Music Therapy, 34, 2–31.

Burger

(1999). Die effek van 'n gestruktureerde oudiopsigofonologiese program met musikale jong volwassenes. (Skripsie (M.A.)-PU vir CHO).

Campbell

(1997). The Mozart effect. N.Y.: Avon Books.

Coelen

Millio

(1998). Structuring the active phase of the Tomatis stimulation process. Personal communication, Centre Tomatis, Paris, 16 Nov.

Cohen

(1988). Statistical power analysis for behavioural sciences. 2nd ed. Hillsdale, NY: Erlbaum.

Cohen

B.J.

Kupersmith

J.R.F

(1986). The study of SCL 90 scores of 87 performing artists seeking psychotherapy. Medical problems of performing artists, 1, 140–142.

De Bruto

C.M.E.

(1983). Oudiopsigofonologiese opleiding en die erg geestesvertraagde kind: 'n empiriese ondersoek. Potchefstroom (Verhandeling (MA) - PU vir CHO).

10.

De la Roque

(1998). General introduction to Tomatis Method [Available on the internet:] www3.netlink.co.uk.

11.

Dews

C.L.B.

Williams

M.S.

(1989). M.S. Student musicians' personality styles, stressors and coping patterns. Psychology of Music, 17, 37–47.

12.

Du Plessis

W.F.

Van Jaarsveld

P.E.

(1988). Audio-Psycho-Phonology: A comparative outcome study on anxious primary school pupils. South African Journal of Psychology, 18, 144–151.

13.

Du Plessis

W. F.

Wissing

D.P.

Munro

Burger

Nel

(1998). The effect of a structured Audio-Psycho-Phonological programme on a group of young adult musicians. Paper presented to the Tomatis America Conference, Toronto, Canada.

14.

Epstein

(1993). Manual for the Constructive Thinking Inventory. Amherst: Univ. of Massachusetts.

15.

Gilmor

T. M.

Madaule

(1988). Autism: Opening a new perspective on autism. In: Gilmor

T.M.

Madaule

Thompson

, About the Tomatis Method (p. 95–104). Toronto: The Listening Centre.

16.

Kent

R.D.

Read

(1994). The acoustic analysis of speech. San Diego: Singular Publishing Group.

17.

Lawrence

(1998). How the Tomatis Method affected my violin playing [Available on the internet:] www.tomatis.com/testimonials.lawrence.html.

18.

Leino

(1993). Long-term average spectrum study on speaking voice quality in male actors. In: Proceedings of the Stockholm Music Acoustics Conference, Jul. 28-Aug. 1, 1993. (Eds. Friberg

Iwarsson

Janson

Sundberg

19.

Leino

Kärkkäinen , (1995). On the effects of vocal training on the speaking voice quality of male student actors. Proceedings of the XIIth International Congress of Phonetics Sciences. Stockholm, Sweden, 13–19 Aug. 1995. (Eds. K. Elenius & P. Branderud).

20.

Madaule

(1994). When listening comes alive. Norval: Moulin.

21.

Manners

D. Jessica

(1996). Professional voice training. In: Music to the ears; Tomatis method case studies (p. 32–34), Lewes: A.A. Tomatis Foundation.

22.

McNair

D.M.

Lorr

Droppleman

L.F.

(1992). Edits manual for the Profile of Mood States - Revised 1992. San Diego: Educational and industrial testing services.

23.

Munro

Larson

(1996). The influence of body integration on voice production. Journal of Singing, 52 (2): 17–24.

24.

Nagel

(1988). In pursuit of perfection: Career choice and performance anxiety in musicians. Medical problems of performing artists, 3, 140–145.

25.

O'Connor

B.P.

Dyce

(1997). Interpersonal rigidity, hostility and complementarity in musical bands. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 72, 362–372.

26.

Pavlicevics

(1999). Music therapy improvisation groups with adults: Towards destressing in South Africa. South African Journal of Psychology, 29, 94–99.

27.

Rietveld

A.C.M.

Van Heuven

V.J.

(1997). Algemene fonetiek. Muiderberg: Coutinho.

28.

Rolf

A. S.

(1998). Die evaluering van 'n oudiopsigofonologiese program vir psigologiestudente. Potchefstroom (Skripsie (M.A.) - PU vir CHO).

29.

Sataloff

R.T.

Sataloff

(1991). Hearing loss in singers In: Sataloff

R. T.

(ed.), Professional Voice: The Science and Art of Clinical Care (p. 219–239). N.Y: Raven Press.

30.

Stutt

H.A.

(1983). The Tomatis method: a review of current research. Montreal: McGill University.

31.

Sundberg

(1987). The science of the singing voice. Dekalb II: Northern Illinois University Press.

32.

Thompson

B.M.

(1996). Description of the Tomatis Method and Listening Test. In Tomatis

A. A.

The Ear and Language, Norval: Moulin.

33.

Tomatis

A.A.

(1973). Introduction to the The Listening Test. (Observations made during the third international congress of Audio-Psycho-Phonology, Anvers. Translated by J.T. Williams, coordinator of research activities for A.E. Sidlauskas, PhD., Director of Child Study Centre, University of Ottowa).

34.

Tomatis

A.A.

(1978). Education and dyslexia, Fribourg: A.I.A.P.P.

35.

Tomatis

A. A.

(1991). The conscious ear. N.Y: Station Hill.

36.

Tomatis

A.A.

(1995) Personal communication. Tomatis International Conference, Neuchatel, Switzerland.

37.

Tomatis

A. A.

(1996). The ear and language. Norval: Moulin.

38.

Van Jaarsveld

P.E.

(1979). Audio-Psycho-Phonology with special reference to music therapy. Unpublished paper presented during a conference on Music Therapy, Potchefstroom.

39.

Weeks

B.S.

(1988). The therapeutic effect of high-frequency audition and its role in sacred music. In Gilmor

T. M.

Madaule

Thompson

(Eds.) About the Tomatis Method. (p. 115–129), Toronto: The Listening Centre.

40.

Weiss

(1985). Long term average spectra before and after Tomatis audio-vocal training, Revue de Phonátique Appliquée, 77, 507–523.

41.

Wissing

M.P.

Van Eeden

(1998). Psychological well-being. A fortigenic conceptualization and empirical clarification. In Schlebusch

(Ed.), South Africa beyond transition: Psychological well-being, Proceedings of the third annual congress of the Psychological Society of South Africa, p. 379–393.