Effectively screening-out candidates who have potential to become “liability-prone” officers is crucial to any police agency. The critical nature of appropriate selection is readily apparent when we consider the serious ramifications that the inappropriate actions of even a single officer can have for the agency itself as well as for the community as a whole. The present paper contends that assessment centers are a viable option for selection of entry-level police officers. The literature on the use of assessment centers is reviewed, and arguments are made regarding the potential utility of employing this technique with police applicants. Recommendations are offered for implementation of an assessment center program for selection of entry-level police officers.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
American Psychological Association.“EEOC ADA policy still pending.”Psychological Science Agenda5, November/December 1992, 13.
2.
AnshacherH.L.“History of the leaderless group discussion technique.”Psychological Bulletin48 (1951): 383–391.
3.
ArnoldDavid W.ThiemannAlan J.“To test or not to test: The status of psychological testing under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).”Journal of Business and Psychology6 (1992): 503–506.
4.
AshPhilipSloraKaren B.BrittonCynthia F.“Police agency officer selection practices.”Journal of Police Science and Administration17 (1990): 258–269.
5.
BernardinH. John. “Police officer job analysis.” in GaelSidney, The job analysis handbook for business, industry, and government. vol. 2, New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1988, 1242–1254.
6.
BormanWalter C.“Validity of behavioral assessment for predicting military recruiter performance.”Journal of Applied Psychology67 (1982): 3–9.
7.
BradleyDanny E.PursleyRobert D.“Behaviorally anchored rating scales for patrol officer performance appraisal: Development and evaluation.”Journal of Police Science and Administration15 (1987): 37–45.
8.
BurbeckElizabethFurnhamAdrian“Police officer selection: A critical review of the literature.”Journal of Police Science and Administration13 (1985): 58–69.
9.
BurroughsWayne A.CookDavidJr.. “Court rules on assessment center case.”The Industrial/Organizational Psychologist27 (1990): 57–61.
10.
BylinskyGene. “The marvels of ‘virtual reality'.”Fortune 3 June 1991, 138–146, 150.
11.
CascioWayne F.Applied psychology in personnel management.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1987.
12.
CascioWayne F.Costing human resources: The financial impact of behavior in organizations.3d. ed., Boston: PWS-Kent, 1991.
13.
ChenowethJames H.“Situational tests: A new attempt at assessing police candidates.”Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science52 (1961): 232–238.
14.
City of Richmond v. Richmond Black Police Officers' Association. Fair Employment Practices Cases 14 (1977): 391–395.
15.
ColemanJohn L.Police assessment testing: Assessment center handbook.Springfield, IL: Thomas, 1987.
16.
CoultonGary F.WoltersRoger S.“Employee and management rights and responsibilities under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA): An overview.”Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal, 6 (1993): 55–67.
17.
CronbachLee J.Essentials of psychological testing.4th. ed., New York: Harper and Row, 1984.
18.
DunnetteMarvin D.MotowidloStephen J.Police selection and career assessment.Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1976.
19.
EpsteinSeymour. “The stability of behavior: II. Implications for psychological research.”American Psychologist, 35 (1980): 790–806.
20.
FabricatoreJoseph M.“Pre-entry assessment and training: Performance evaluation of police officers.” in SpielbergerCharles D., ed., Police selection and evaluation.New York: Hemisphere, 1979, 77–85.
21.
FarmerRichard E.“Clinical and managerial implications of stress research on the police.”Journal of Police Science and Administration17 (1990): 205–218.
22.
FelthamRob. “Assessment centre decision making: Judgmental vs. mechanical.”Journal of Occupational Psychology61 (1988): 237–241.
23.
FelthamRob. “Validity of a police assessment centre: A 19-year follow-up.”Journal of Occupational Psychology61 (1988): 129–144.
24.
FilerRobert J.“The assessment center method in the selection of law enforcement officers.” in SpielbergerCharles D., ed., Police selection and evaluation.New York: Hemisphere, 1979, 211–229.
25.
FisherScott S.TazelaarJane M.“Living in a virtual world.”Byte, July, 1990, 215–221.
26.
FitzgeraldLouise F.QuaintanceMarilyn K.“Survey of assessment center use in state and local government.”Journal of Assessment Center Technology5 (1982): 9–21.
27.
FriedmanAlan F.WebbJamesLewakRichard. Psychological Assessment with the MMPI.Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum, 1989.
GauglerBarbara B.RosenthalDouglas B.ThortonGeorge C.IIIBentsonCynthia. “Meta-analysis of assessment center validity.”Journal of Applied Psychology72 (1987): 93–511.
30.
GavinJames F.HamiltonJohn W.“Selecting police using assessment center methodology.”Journal of Police Science and Administration3 (1975): 166–176.
31.
HiattDeidreHargraveGeorge E.“Predicting job performance problems with psychological screening.”Journal of Police Science and Administration16 (1988): 122–125.
32.
HurleyKaren“Legal aspects of assessment and assessment centers.” in MoreHarry W.UnsingerPeter C.UnsingerPeter C., eds., The police assessment center.Springfield, IL: Thomas, 1987, 23–48.
33.
JohnsonEdward E.“Problems in assessing police and fire fighter candidates.”Journal of Police Science and Administration12 (1984): 404–406.
34.
JohnsonMarson H.FawcettCharles T.“Interactive video disc training in criminal justice.”The Police Chief November, 1989, 27–28.
35.
JoinerDennis A.“Assessment centers in the public sector: A practical approach.”Public Personnel Management13 (1984): 435–450.
36.
JoinerDennis A.“Testing for knowledge, skills and abilities.” in MoreHarry W.UnsingerPeter C., eds., The police assessment center.Springfield, IL: Thomas, 1987, 67–89.
37.
JonesAlan. “Inter-rater reliability in the assessment of group exercises at a UK assessment centre.”Journal of Occupational Psychology54 (1981): 79–86.
38.
KeilE.C.Assessment centers: A guide for human resource management.Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 1981.
39.
Kirkland v. New York Correctional Services, 711 F. 2d 1117 (1983).
40.
KleimanLawrence S.GordonMichael E.“An examination of the relationship between police academy training and job performance.”Journal of Police Science and Administration14 (1986): 293–299.
41.
KroesWilliam H.Society's victim—the policeman: An analysis of job stress in policing.Springfield, IL: Thomas, 1976.
LynchRonald G.The police manager: Professional leadership skills.3d ed., New York: Random House, 1986.
46.
McEvoyGlenn M.BeattyRichard W.BernardinH. John. “Unanswered questions in assessment center research.”Journal of Business and Psychology2 (1987): 97–111.
47.
McLaughlinVanceBingRobert L.III. “Law enforcement personnel selection: A commentary.”Journal of Police Science and Administration15 (1987): 271–276.
48.
MeierNicholas. “Sworn internship program: Cooperation between university and police agency.”The Police Chief56, November, 1989, 29, 32–34.
49.
MillsRobert B.“Simulated stress in police recruit selection.”Journal of Police Science and Administration4 (1976): 179–186.
50.
MillsRobert B.“Use of diagnostic small groups on police recruit selection and training.”Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science60 (1969): 238–241.
51.
MillsRobert B.McDevittRobert J.TonkinSandra. “Situational tests in metropolitan police recruit selection.”Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science57 (1966): 99–106.
52.
MullinsWayman C.KimbroughWilson W.“Group composition as a determinate of job analysis outcomes.”Journal of Applied Psychology73 (1988): 657–664.
53.
MurphyJoseph J.“Current practices in the use of psychological testing by police agencies.”Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science, 63, (1972): 570–576.
54.
Newsweek (May 11, 1992). “The siege of L.A.” 30–32, 33–38.
55.
O'HaraKirkLoveKevin G.“Accurate selection of police officials within small municipalities: ‘Et tu assessment center?'”Public Personnel Management16 (1987): 9–14.
56.
O'LearyLawrence R.The selection and promotion of the successful police officer.Springfield, IL: Thomas, 1979.
57.
Office of Strategic Services Assessment Staff.Assessment of men.New York: Rinehart, 1948.
58.
OstrovEric O.“Police/law enforcement and psychology.”Behavioral Sciences and the Law4 (1986): 353–370.
59.
PolandJames M.“Police selection methods and the prediction of police performance.”Journal of Police Science and Administration6 (1978): 374–393.
60.
PughGeorge. “Situation tests and police selection.”Journal of Police Science and Administration13 (1985): 30–35.
61.
PynesJoan E.BernardinH. John. “Predictive validity of an entry-level police assessment center.”Journal of Applied Psychology74 (1989): 831–833.
62.
PynesJoan E.BernardinH. JohnBentonArthur L.McEvoyGlenn M.“Should assessment center dimension ratings be mechanically-derived?”Journal of Business and Psychology2 (1988): 217–227.
63.
PynesJoan E.BernardinH. John. “Entry-level police selection: The assessment center as an alternative.”Journal of Criminal Justice20 (1992): 41–52.
64.
PynesJoan E.BernardinH. John. “Mechanical vs. consensus-derived assessment center ratings: A comparison of job performance validities.”Public Personnel Management21 (1992): 17–28.
65.
RossJoyce D.“Determination of the predictive validity of the assessment center approach to selecting police managers.”Journal of Criminal Justice8 (1980): 89–96.
66.
SackettPaul R.WilsonMark A.“Factors affecting the consensus judgment process in managerial assessment centers.”Journal of Applied Psychology67 (1982): 10–17.
SwansonCharles R.TerritoLeonardTaylorRobert W.Police administration: Structures, processes and behavior.2d ed., New York: MacMillan, 1988.
69.
TargatzG.E.HessL.R.Police entry tests and their predictability score in police academy and subsequent job performance.Milwaukee: The Center for Criminal Justice, 1972.
70.
ThortonGeorge C.IIIAssessment centers in human resource management.New York: Addison-Wesley, 1992.
71.
TielschGeorge P.WhisenandPaul M.The assessment center approach in the selection of police personnel.Santa Cruz, CA: Davis, 1977.
72.
U.S. v. City of Chicago 416 F. Supp. 788 (1976).
73.
WernimontPaul F.CampbellJohn P.“Signs, samples and criteria.”Journal of Applied Psychology52 (1968): 372–376.
74.
WhitakerGordon P., Mastrofski, Stephen, Ostrom, Elinor, Parks, Roger B. and Percy.
75.
StephenL.Basic issues in police performance.Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice, 1980.
76.
WojcikJoanne. “L.A. riot damage costliest in history.”Business Insurance May 4, 1992, 1, 50.
77.
YoungstromNina. “ADA is super advocate for those with disabilities.”APA Monitor July, 1992, 26.
78.
ZedeckSheldonCascioWayne F.“Psychological issues in personnel decisions.”Annual Review of Psychology35 (1984): 461–518.
