Giving Time,Not Money: Long-term Impacts of Short-term Mission Trips 1

Abstract

This article expands current knowledge of the impact that brief but intense religious experiences can have on routine behavior by examining the long-term effects of short-term mission travel on both volunteering and charitable giving. Existing literature addresses only the first few years after travel. Using data from the 2005 Religion and Global Issues Survey, I examine how participation in a domestic or international religious mission trip in high school influences adults’ volunteering and giving behavior. I also consider alternate explanations that may account for the relationship between high school mission-trip participation and current giving or volunteering, including demographic factors, religious beliefs and practices, and other forms of civic engagement. I find adolescent participation in a domestic short-term mission trip has a significant, positive influence on the likelihood of volunteering for either a local or an internationally focused organization as an adult. In contrast, adolescent participation in a domestic mission trip has a significant dampening effect on charitable giving to secular organizations. I find no significant associations between international high school trips and adult volunteering and giving when additional factors are taken into account. I discuss the implications of these results for the ways church leaders and scholars think about the mechanisms through which brief, transformative religious experiences influence beliefs and behavior over the course of a lifetime.

Keywords

Short-term mission trips youth charitable giving volunteering civic engagement religious travel

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adeney

(1996) McMissions: short-termers have their place, but not at the expense of career missionaries. Christianity Today (Nov.): 14–15.

Allahyari

(2000) Visions of charity: volunteer workers and moral community. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Bekkers

Wiepking

(2007) Generosity and philanthropy: a literature review. Report sponsored by the John Templeton Foundation.

Beyerlein

. (2011) The effect of religious short-term mission trips on youth civic engagement. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 50(4): 780–95.

Blezein

(2004) The impact of summer international short-term missions experiences on the cross-cultural sensitivity of undergraduate college student participants. Ph.D. thesis, Azusa Pacific University.

Brooks

(2004) What do “don’t know” responses really mean in giving surveys? Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 33(3): 324–434.

Collins

(2004) Interaction ritual chains. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Cornwall

(1989) The determinants of religious behavior: a theoretical model and empirical test. Social Forces 68(2): 572–92.

Crabtree

(1998) Mutual empowerment in cross-cultural participatory development and service learning: lessons in communication and social justice from projects in El Salvador and Nicaragua. Journal of Applied Communication Research 26(2): 182–209.

10.

Frisco

. (2004) Participation in voluntary youth-serving associations and early adult voting behavior. Social Science Quarterly 85(3): 660–76.

11.

Hindmarsh

(2008) The evangelical conversion narrative: spirtual autobiography in early modern England. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

12.

Hoge

O’Connor

(2004) Denominational identity from age sixteen to age thirty-eight. Sociology of Religion 65(1): 77–85.

13.

Hoge

. (1993) Determinants of church involvement of young adults who grew up in Presbyterian churches. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 32: 242–55.

14.

Illich

(1968) To hell with good intentions. Paper, conference on Inter-American Student Projects, Chicago, IL.

15.

Jackson

. (1995) Volunteering and charitable giving: do religious and associational ties promote helping behavior?” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 24(1): 59–78.

16.

Jones

(1998) A study of the differences between the Faith Maturity Scale and the Multidimensional Self Concept Scale score for youth participating in two denominational ministry projects. Ph.D. thesis, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary.

17.

McDonough

Peterson

(1999) Can short-term mission really create long-term missionaries? Minneapolis: STEM Ministries.

18.

Nepstad

(2004) Convictions of the soul: religion, culture, and agency in the Central America solidarity movement. New York: Oxford University Press.

19.

Park

(2008) Researching short-term missions and paternalism. In Priest

(ed.) Effective engagement in short-term missions: doing it right! Pasadena: William Carey Library, pp. 505–30.

20.

Peterson

(1991) Is short-term mission really worth the time and money? Advancing God’s kingdom through short-term mission: results of STEM short-term mission research. Minneapolis: STEM Ministries.

21.

Peterson

. (2003) Maximum impact short-term mission: the God-commanded, repetitive deployment of swift, temporary, non-professional missionaries. Minneapolis: STEM Press.

22.

Priest

(2010) Film makers meet critics: short-term mission travel. Paper, Society for the Scientific Study of Religion, Baltimore, MD.

23.

Priest

(2008) “They see everything, and understand nothing”: short-term mission and service learning. Missiology 36(1): 53–73.

24.

Priest

. (2006) Researching the short-term mission movement. Missiology 34(4): 431–50.

25.

Purvis

(1993) Partnership in cross-cultural mission: the impact of Kentucky Baptist short-term, volunteer missions. Ph.D. thesis, Asbury Theological Seminary.

26.

Regnerus

. (1998) Who gives to the poor? The influence of religious tradition and political location on the personal generosity of Americans toward the poor. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 37: 481–93.

27.

Regnerus

Uecker

(2006) Finding faith, losing faith: the prevalence and context of religious transformations during adolescence. Review of Religious Research 47: 217–37.

28.

Sherkat

(1998) Counterculture or continuity? Competing influences on baby boomers’ religious orientations and participation. Social Forces 76(3): 1087–1114.

29.

Smith

(1996) Resisting Reagan: the US Central America peace movement. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

30.

Smith

Denton

(2005) Soul searching: the religious and spiritual lives of American teenagers. New York: Oxford University Press.

31.

Smith

. (2008) Passing the plate: why American Christians don’t give away more money. New York: Oxford University Press.

32.

Trinitapoli

Vaisey

(2009) The transformative role of religious experience: the case of short-term missions. Social Forces 88(1): 121–46.

33.

Turner

(1967) The forest of symbols: aspects of Ndembu ritual. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.

34.

Ver Beek

(2006) The impact of short-term missions: a case study of house construction in Honduras after Hurricane Mitch. Missiology 34(4): 477–95.

35.

Ver Beek

(2008) Lessons from the sapling: review of quantitative research on short-term missions. In Priest

(ed.) Effective engagement in short-term missions: doing it right! Pasadena: William Carey Library, pp. 469–96.

36.

Ver Beek

(2009) Reanalysis of Purvis (1993) data on reported giving vs. actual missions giving as a result of a STM experience. Available at: www.calvin.edu/academic/sociology/staff/kurt (accessed 16 January 2012).

37.

Wiepking

(2008) For the love of mankind: a sociological study on charitable giving. Ph.D. thesis, VU University Amsterdam, the Netherlands.

38.

Wuthnow

(2009) Boundless faith: the global outreach of American churches. Berkeley: University of California Press.