Mental Health Status of Prisoners in an Urban Jail

Abstract

The mental health status of a group of 486 admissions to the Philadelphia Prisons was systematically examined in a carefully controlled study using multiple indices of psychopathology. In addition to measures of psychopathology, demographic information and descriptive personality and intelligence data were collected on all subjects. Subsets of subjects also received individual psychiatric interviews and psychological evaluations. The results indicate that approximately two-thirds of the subjects were identifiable by relatively stringent criteria as being psychiatrically disturbed and in need of specific mental health treatment services, and 34% were identifiable by all indicators of psychopathology used. Furthermore, 11% were in need of immediate inpatient psychiatric hospital care. Implications for treatment planning in correctional service settings are discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

AMMONS, C. and R. AMMONS (1962) The Quick Test of Intelligence: Manual. Missoula: MO: Psychological Test Specialists.

BONOVITZ, J. and E. GUY (1979) “Impact of restrictive civil commitment procedures on a prison psychiatric service.” Amer. J. of Psychiatry 136: 1045-1048.

BURDOCK, E. I. and A. S. HARDESTY (1968) “Psychological test for psychopathology.” J. of Abnormal Psychology 73: 62-69.

CORMIER, B. M. , G. MORF . and G. MERSERAU (1969) “Psychiatric services in penal institutions.” Laval Medical 40: 939.

DAHLSTROM, W. G. and G. S. WELSH (1965) An MMPI Handbook: A Guide to Use in Clinical Practice and Research. Minneapolis: Univ. of Minnesota Press.

DECATO, C. M. (1982) “Functional efficiency as reflected in Rorschach responses.” Department of Mental Health Sciences, Hahnemann Medical Hospital and College. (unpublished)

DECATO, C. M. and Z. A. PIOTROWSKI (1981) Rorschach Adaptive Efficiency Index (RAEI). (unpublished)

FAULK, M. (1976) “A psychiatry study of men serving a sentence in Winchester Prison.” Medical Sci. and Law 16: 244-251.

GILBERSTADT, H. and J. A. DUKER (1965) A handbook for Clinical and Actuarial MMPI Interpretation. Philadelphia: Saunders.

10.

GLUECK, B. (1918) “A study of 608 admissions to Sing Sing Prison.” Mental Hygiene 2: 85-151.

11.

GROSS, L. R. (1959) “MMPI L-F-K relationships with criteria of behavioral disturbance and social adjustment in a schizophrenic population.” J. of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 23: 319-323.

12.

GUZE, S. B. , D. W. GOODWIN , and J. B. CRANE (1969) “Criminality and psychiatric disorders.” Archives of General Psychiatry 20: 583-591.

13.

GUZE, S. B. , V. B. TUASON , P. D. GATFIELD , M. A. STEWART and B. PICKEN (1962) “Psychiatric illness and crime with particular reference to alcoholism: a study of 223 criminals.” J. of Nervous and Mental Disease 134: 512-521.

14.

HALLECK, S. L. (1980) “Psychiatry and the prisoner.” Amer. J. of Psychiatry 137: 603-604.

15.

JAMES, J. F. , D. GREGORY , R. K. JONES and O. H. RUNDELL (1980) “Psychiatric morbidity in prisons.” Hospital and Community Psychiatry 31: 675-677.

16.

JASTRAK, J. F. , S. W. BIJOU , and S. JASTRAK (1978) WRAT: Wide Range Achievement Test. Wilmington, DE: Guidance Associates of Delaware.

17.

KINCANNON, J. C. (1968) “Predication of the standard MMPI scale scores from 71 items: the Mini-Mult.” J. of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 32: 319-335.

18.

MARKS, P. A. , W. SEEMAN , and D. L. HALLER (1974) The Actuarial Use of the MMPI with Adolescents and Adults. Baltimore: Wilkanis & Wilkins.

19.

McCARTNEY, J. L. (1934) “Intensive psychiatric study of prisoners: The receiving routine in the classification clinic, Elmira Reformatory.” Amer. J. of Psychiatry 90: 1183-1203.

20.

PIOTROWSKI, Z. A. (1977) Perceptanalysis. Cherry Hill, NJ: Postgraduate Post-International.

21.

PIOTROWSKI, Z. A. (1937) “The Rorschach inkblot method in organic disturbances of the central nervous system.” J. of Nervous and Mental Disease 86: 525-537.

22.

REPUCCI, N. D. , and W. G. CLINGENPEEL (1973) “Methodological issues in research with correctional populations.” J. of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 46: 727-746.

23.

STEADMAN, H. J. , J. J. COCOZZA and M. E. MELICK (1978) “Explaining the increased arrest rate among mental patients: the changing clientele of state hospitals.” Amer. J. of Psychiatry 135: 816-820.