In this review and critique of mentoring theory and research, the authors identify persistent problems in the development of mentoring theory. Their conceptual analysis highlights these problems with a “thought experiment” illustrating the inability of mentoring theory and research to resolve certain fundamental issues, the resolution of which is a prerequisite for the advancement of explanatory theory. They conclude with ideas about demarcating “mentoring” from the sometimes confounding concepts “training” or “socialization.” Absent an ability to distinguish mentoring from related activities, progress in explanatory theory will remain impeded.
Allen, J. , & Johnston, K. (1997). Mentoring . Context, 14(7), 15 .
2.
Allen, T.D. , Eby, L. , Poteet, M. , Lentz, E. , & Lima, L. (2004). Career benefits associated with mentoring for protégés: A meta-analysis . Journal of Applied Psychology, 89(1), 127-136 .
3.
Auster, D. (1984). Mentors and protégés: Power-dependent dyads . Sociological Inquiry, 54(2), 142-153 .
4.
Balzer, W. (1986). Theoretical terms: A new perspective . Journal of Philosophy, 83(2), 71-90 .
5.
Bozionelos, N. (2004). Mentoring provided: Relation to mentor's career success, personality, and mentoring received . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 64(1), 24-46 .
6.
Burke, R.J. , & McKeen, C.A. (1996). Do women at the top make a difference? Gender proportions and the experiences of managerial and professional women . Human Relations, 49(8), 1093-1105 .
7.
Burke, R.J. , & McKeen, C.A. (1997). Benefits of mentoring relationships among managerial and professional women: A cautionary tale . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 51(1), 43-57 .
8.
Burke, R.J. , McKenna, C. , & McKeen, C.A. (1991). How do mentorships differ from typical supervisory relationships ? Psychological Reports, 68, 459-466 .
9.
Carr, D. (1981). Knowledge in practice . American Philosophical Quarterly, 18, 53-61 .
10.
Chao, G.T. (1997). Mentoring phases and outcomes . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 51(1), 15-28 .
11.
Chao, G.T. , Walz, P.M. , & Gardner, P.D. (1992). Formal and informal mentorships: A comparison on mentoring functions and contrast with non-mentored counterparts . Personnel Psychology, 45(3), 619-637 .
12.
Collins, E.G.C. , & Scott, P. (1978). Everyone who makes it has a mentor . Harvard Business Review, 56(4), 89-110 .
13.
Dansky, K.H. (1996). The effect of group mentoring on career outcomes . Group and Organization Management, 21, 5-21 .
14.
Dirsmith, M.W. , & Covaleski, M.A. (1985). Informal communications and mentoring in public accounting firms . Accounting, Organizations and Society, 10, 149-169 .
15.
Dreher, G.F. , & Ash, R.A. (1990). A comparative study of mentoring among men and women in managerial, professional, and technical positions . Journal of Applied Psychology, 75(5), 539-546 .
16.
Eby, L.T. (1997). Alternative forms of mentoring in changing organizational environments: A conceptual extension of the mentoring literature . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 51(1), 125-144 .
17.
Eby, L.T. , & Allen, T.D. (2002). Further investigation of protégés' negative mentoring experiences: Patterns and outcomes . Group & Organization Management, 27(4), 456-479 .
18.
Eby, L.T. , Butts, M. , Lockwood, A. , & Simon, S.A. (2004). Protégés' negative mentoring experiences: Construct development and nomological validation . Personnel Psychology , 57(2), 411-447 .
19.
Eby, L.T. , McManus, S.E. , Simon, S.A. , & Russell, J.E.A. (2000). The protégé's perspective regarding negative mentoring experiences: The development of a taxonomy . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 57(1), 1-21 .
20.
Fagenson, E.A. (1989). The mentor advantage: Perceived career/job experiences of protégés versus non-protégés . Journal of Organizational Behavior, 10, 309-320 .
Friedman, M. (1962). Capitalism and freedom. Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
23.
Gigerenzer, G. (1991). From tools to theories: A heuristic of discovery in cognitive psychology . Psychological Review, 98(2), 254-267 .
24.
Godshalk, V.M. , & Sosik, J.J. (2003). Aiming for career success: The role of learning goal orientation in mentoring relationships . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 63(3), 417-437 .
25.
Goodin, R. (1996). Institutionalizing the public interest: The defense of deadlock and beyond . American Political Science Review , 90(2), 331-342 .
26.
Green, S.G. , & Bauer, T.N. (1995). Supervisory mentoring by advisers—Relationships with doctoral-student potential, productivity, and commitment . Personnel Psychology, 48(3), 537-561 .
27.
Hacking, I. (1983). Representing and intervening: Introductory topics in the philosophy of natural science. Cambridge , UK: Cambridge University Press .
28.
Hempel, C.G. (1952). Fundamentals of concept formation in empirical science (Vol. 2). Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
29.
Higgins, M.C. , & Kram, K.E. (2001). Reconceptualizing mentoring at work: A developmental network perspective . Academy of Management Review, 26(2), 264 .
30.
Hunt, D.M. , & Michael, C. (1983). Mentorship—A career training and development tool . Academy of Management Review, 8(3), 475-485 .
31.
Kahneman, D. , Diener, E. , & Schwarz, N. (Eds.). (1999). Well-being: The foundations of hedonic psychology . New York: Russell Sage .
32.
Kirshenmann, P. (1981). Some thoughts on the ideal of exactness in science and philosophy. In J. Agassi & R. Cohen (Eds.), Scientific philosophy today: Essays in honour of Mario Bunge, Boston studies in philosophy of science (pp. 85-98). New York: Springer .
33.
Kitcher, P. (1993). The advancement of science. New York: Oxford University Press .
34.
Kram, K.E. (1980). Mentoring processes at work: Developmental relationships in managerial careers. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Yale University, New Haven, CT .
35.
Kram, K.E. (1983). Phases of the mentor relationship . Academy of Management Journal, 26(4), 608-625 .
36.
Kram, K.E. (1985). Mentoring at work: Developmental relationships in organizational life. Glenview, IL: Scott, Foresman .
37.
Kram, K.E. , & Isabella, L.A. (1985). Mentoring alternatives: The role of peer relationships in career development . Academy of Management Journal, 28(1), 110-132 .
38.
Lane, R. (2000). The loss of happiness in market democracies. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press .
39.
Laudan, L. (1981). Science and hypothesis. Dordrecht , Netherlands: Reidel .
40.
Levinson, D. , Darrow, C. , Klein, E. , Levinson, M. , & McKee, B. (1978). The seasons of a man's life. New York: Knopf .
41.
Manchester, W. (1982). Goodbye darkness: A memoir of the pacific war . New York: Dell .
42.
McManus, S.E. , & Russell, J.E.A. (1997). New directions for mentoring research: An examination of related constructs . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 51(1), 145-161 .
43.
Merriam, S. (1983). Mentors and protégés: A critical review of the literature . Adult Education Quarterly, 33, 161-173 .
44.
Noe, R.A. (1988). An investigation of the determinants of successful assigned mentoring relationships . Personnel Psychology, 41(3), 457-479 .
45.
Parsons, K. (1971). On criteria of meaning change . British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 22(2), 131-114 .
46.
Payne, S.C. , & Huffman, A.H. (2005). A longitudinal examination of the influence of mentoring on organizational commitment and turnover . Academy of Management Journal, 48(1), 158-168 .
47.
Ragins, B.R. (1989). Barriers to mentoring: The female manager's dilemma . Human Relations, 42, 1-22 .
48.
Ragins, B.R. (1997a). Antecedents of diversified mentoring relationships . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 51(1), 90-109 .
49.
Ragins, B.R. (1997b). Diversified mentoring relationships in organizations: A power perspective . Academy of Management Review, 22(2), 482-521 .
50.
Ragins, B.R. , & Cotton, J.L. (1996). Jumping the hurdles: Barriers to mentoring for women in organizations . Leadership and Organization Development Journal, 17, 37-41 .
51.
Ragins, B.R. , Cotton, J.L. , & Miller, J.S. (2000). Marginal mentoring: The effects of type of mentor, quality of relationship, and program design on work and career attitudes . Academy of Management Journal, 43(6), 1177-1194 .
52.
Ragins, B.R. , & Scandura, T.A. (1997). The way we were: Gender and the termination of mentoring relationships . Journal of Applied Psychology, 82(6), 945-953 .
53.
Ragins, B.R. , & Sundstrom, E. (1989). Gender and power in organizations: A longitudinal perspective . Psychological Bulletin, 105(1), 51-88 .
54.
Roethlisberger, F. , & Dickson, W. (1939). Management and the worker. Cambridge , UK: Cambridge University Press .
55.
Rosenberg, A. (2005). Philosophy of science: A contemporary introduction . London: Routledge .
56.
Russell, J.E.A. , & Adams, D.M. (1997). The changing nature of mentoring in organizations: An introduction to the special issue on mentoring in organizations . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 51(1), 1 .
57.
Scandura, T.A. (1992). Mentorship and career mobility—An empirical-investigation . Journal of Organizational Behavior, 13(2), 169-174 .
58.
Scandura, T.A. (1997). Mentoring and organizational justice: An empirical investigation . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 51(1), 58-69 .
59.
Scandura, T.A. (1998). Dysfunctional mentoring relationships and outcomes . Journal of Management, 24(3), 449 .
60.
Scandura, T.A. , & Ragins, B.R. (1993). The effects of sex and gender role orientation on mentorship in male-dominated occupations . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 43(3), 251 .
61.
Scandura, T.A. , & Schriesheim, C.A. (1994). Leader-member exchange and supervisor career mentoring as complementary constructs in leadership research . Academy of Management Journal, 37, 1588-1602 .
62.
Scandura, T.A. , & Viator, R.E. (1994). Mentoring in public accounting firms—An analysis of mentor protégé relationship, mentorship functions, and protégé turnover intentions . Accounting Organizations and Society , 19(8), 717-734 .
63.
Sen, A. ( 2002). Rationality and freedom. Cambridge, MA: Belknap .
64.
Singh, V. , Bains, D. , & Vinnicombe, S. (2002). Informal mentoring as an organisational resource . Long Range Planning, 35(4), 389-405 .
65.
Smith, W.J. , Howard, J.T. , & Harrington, K.V. (2005). Essential formal mentor characteristics and functions in governmental and non-governmental organizations from the program administrator's and the mentor's perspective . Public Personnel Management, 34(1), 31-58 .
66.
Tepper, B.J. (1995). Upward maintenance tactics in supervisory mentoring and nonmentoring relationships . Academy of Management Journal , 38(4), 1191-1205 .
67.
Tepper, B.J. , & Taylor, E.C. (2003). Relationships among supervisors' and subordinates' procedural justice perceptions and organizational citizenship behaviors. Academy OfManagement Journal, 46(1), 97-105 .
68.
Thomas, D.A. (1990). The impact of race on managers' experiences of developmental relationships (mentoring and sponsorship): An intra-organizational study . Journal of Organizational Behavior, 11, 479-492 .
69.
Whitely, W. , Dougherty, T.W. , & Dreher, G.F. (1991). Relationship of career mentoring and socioeconomic origin to managers' and professionals' early career progress . Academy of Management Journal, 34(2), 331-351 .
70.
Wilson, J. , & Elman, N. (1990). Organizational benefits of mentoring . Academy of Management Executive, 4, 88-94 .
71.
Wolff, T. (1994). In pharaoh's army: Memories of a lost war. London: Bloomsbury .
72.
Young, A.M. , & Perrewe, P.L. (2000). What did you expect? An examination of career-related support and social support among mentors and protégés . Journal of Management, 26(4), 611-632 .
