On the issue of abortion, Ireland and Poland have been among the most conservative countries in Europe. Their legal and cultural approaches to this issue have been deeply influenced by the institution of the Catholic Church and its purported role as a defender of an authentic national identity. However, their political climates for abortion reform are increasingly divergent: Ireland has liberalised its abortion law substantially since 2018, while Poland is moving towards further criminalisation with the repeated introduction of restrictive laws in parliament. Both have seen active pro-choice movements who mobilise for reform and widespread non-compliance with their restrictive abortion laws, but the policy impact of these trends varies significantly. What accounts for this difference? This article draws on comparative analysis of Ireland and Poland to assess their divergent trajectories on abortion reform, arguing that the most significant driver of change between the two is the disparity in influence of the Catholic Church on politics and policymaking.
AndersenK., 2010. Irish secularization and religious identities: evidence of an emerging new Catholic habitus. Social Compass, 57(1), pp. 15–39.
2.
AndersonJ., 2003. Catholicism and democratic consolidation in Spain and Poland. West European Politics, 26(1), pp. 137–156.
3.
BacikI., 2015. Abortion and the law in Ireland. In QuiltyA.KennedyS.ConlonC., eds. The Abortion Papers Ireland: Volume 2. Cork: Cork University Press, pp. 104–117.
4.
BarryU., 1988. Abortion in the Republic of Ireland. Feminist Review, 29, pp. 57–63.
5.
BreenM.J.ReynoldsC., 2011. The rise of secularism and the decline of religiosity in Ireland: the pattern of religious change in Europe. The International Journal of Religion and Spirituality in Society, 1(2), pp. 195–212.
6.
BrowneK.NashC., 2020. In Ireland we ‘love both’?: Heteroactivism In Ireland’s anti-repeal ephemera. Feminist Review, 124. DOI: 10.1177/0141778919895262.
7.
BrubakerR., 2012. Religion and nationalism: four approaches. Nations and Nationalism, 18(1), pp. 2–20.
8.
CastlesF., 1994. On religion and public policy. European Journal of Political Research, 25(1), pp. 19–40.
9.
CaytasJ.D., 2013. Women’s reproductive rights as a political price of post-communist transformation in Poland. Amsterdam Law Forum, 5(2), pp. 64–89.
10.
CBOS [Public Opinion Research Center Foundation], 2016a. Polacy o prawach kobiet, ‘czarnych protestach’ i prawie aborcyjnym [Poles on Women’s Rights, ‘Black Protests’ and Abortion Law
]. Warsaw: CBOS [in Polish].
11.
CBOS [Public Opinion Research Center Foundation], 2016b. Jakiego prawa aborcyjnego oczekuja Polacy [What Abortion Law Do Poles Expect?]. Warsaw: CBOS [in Polish].
12.
Central Statistics Office of Ireland (CSO), 2017. Census 2016 – Profile 8 Irish travellers, ethnicity and religion. Central Statistics Office, 12 October. Cork: Central Statistics Office. Available at: https://www.cso.ie/en/releasesandpublications/ep/p-cp8iter/p8iter/ [last accessed 30 October 2019].
13.
ChałubińskiM., 1994. Polityka, kościół, aborcja [Politics, church, abortion]. In ChałubińskiM., ed. Polityka i Aborcja [Politics and Abortion].Warsaw: Scholar, pp. 89–153 [in Polish].
14.
ChełstowskaA., 2009. Krótka historia aborcji [A brief history of abortion]. In CzerwińskaA.PiotrowskaJ., eds. Raport: 20 lat – 20 zmian. Kobiety w Polsce w okresie transformacji 1989–2009 [Report: 20 Years – 20 Changes. Women in Poland in the Transformation of 1989–2009]. Warsaw: Fundacja Fminoteka, pp. 11–30 [in Polish].
15.
ChidgeyR., 2011. Abortion democracy: an interview with Sarah Diehl. Feminist Review, 99, pp. 106–112.
16.
CiaputaE.2019. Abortion and the Catholic Church in Poland. In SethnaC.DavisG., eds. Abortion Across Borders: Transnational Travel and Access to Abortion Services. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, pp. 278–309.
17.
ConnollyL.O’TooleT., 2005. Documenting Irish Feminisms: The Second Wave. Dublin: Woodfield Press.
CSIOZ [Center for Health Information Systems], 2018. Sprawozdania Programu Badań Statystycznych Statystyki Publicznej [Reports of the Statistical Research Program of Official Statistics]. MZ-24; MZ-29. Warsaw: Statistics Poland [in Polish].
20.
CzajkowskaA., 2012. O dopuszczalności przerywania ciąży [On the admissibility of termination of pregnancy]. In BarańskiP.CzajkowskaA.FiedotowA.Wochna-TyminńskaA.Kłopoty z seksem w PRL [Troubles with Sex in the Polish People's Republic]. Warsaw: WUW, pp. 99–186 [in Polish].
21.
de LondrasF., 2020. ‘A hope raised and then defeated’? The continuing harms of Irish abortion law. Feminist Review, 124. DOI: 10.1177/0141778919897582.
22.
de LondrasF.EnrightM., 2018. Repealing the 8th: Reforming Irish Abortion Law. Bristol: Policy Press.
23.
de ZordoS.MishtalJ.AntonL., eds., 2016. A Fragmented Landscape: Abortion Governance and Protest Logics in Europe. Oxford: Berghahn Books.
24.
DohertyC.RedmondS., 2015. The radicalisation of a new generation of abortion rights activists. In QuiltyA.KennedyS.ConlonC., eds. The Abortion Papers Ireland: Volume 2. Cork: Cork University Press, pp. 270–274.
25.
DuffyD., 2020. From feminist anarchy to decolonisation: health activism before and after the repeal of the 8th Amendment. Feminist Review, 124. DOI: 10.1177/0141778919895498.
26.
EngeliI.Green-PedersenC.Thorup LarsenL., 2012. Morality Politics in Western Europe: Parties, Agendas and Policy Choices. Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan.
EnrightM., 2019. Abortion law in Ireland: reflecting on reform. In BlackL.DunneP., eds. Law and Gender in Modern Ireland: Critique and Reform. Oxford: Hart Publishing, pp. 55–70.
29.
EnrightM., 2020. Four pieces on Repeal: notes on art, aesthetics and the struggle against Ireland’s abortion law. Feminist Review, 124. DOI: 10.1177/0141778919897583.
30.
EnrightM.de LondrasF., 2020. ‘The only lawyer on the panel’: anti-abortion legal discourse in the referendum on the 8th Amendment. In BrowneK.CalkinS., eds. After Repeal: Rethinking Abortion Politics. London: Zed Books, pp. 53–72.
31.
Federation for Women and Family Planning (FWFP), 2018. Annual Report 2018. Warsaw: Federation for Women and Family Planning. Available at http://en.federa.org.pl/annual-report-2018/ [last accessed 30 October 2019].
32.
FieldL., 2018. The abortion referendum of 2018 and a timeline of abortion politics in Ireland to date. Irish Political Studies, 33(4), pp. 608–628.
33.
FinkS., 2009. Churches as societal veto players: religious influence in actor-centred theories of policy-making. West European Politics, 32(1), pp. 77–96.
34.
FletcherR., 2001. Post-colonial fragments: representations of abortion in Irish law and politics. Journal of Law and Society, 28(4), pp. 568–579.
35.
GarvinT., 2005. Preventing the Future: Why Was Ireland So Poor for So Long?Dublin: Gill & Macmillan.
36.
GaudynM., 2011. Lata dwudzieste, lata współczesne [The twenties and the contemporary years]. In Snochowska-GonzalezC., ed. A jak hipokryzja. Antologia tekstów o aborcji, władzy, pieniądzach i sprawiedliwości [‘A’ as Hypocrisy: Anthology of Texts on Abortion, Power, Money and Justice]. Warsaw: O Matko!, pp. 106–123 [in Polish].
37.
GraffA.KorolczukE., 2017. “Worse than communism and Nazism put together”: war on gender in Poland. In KuharR.PaternotteD., eds. Anti-Gender Campaigns in Europe: Mobilizing Against Equality. London: Rowman and Littlefield, pp. 175–193.
38.
Grzymała-BusseA., 2015. Nations Under God: How Churches Use Moral Authority to Influence Policy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
39.
Grzymała-BusseA., 2016. Weapons of the meek: how churches influence public policy. World Politics, 68(1), pp. 1–36.
40.
GrzywaczA.JawieńA.KacpuraK., 2013. 20 lat tzw. ustawy antyaborcyjnej w Polsce [20 Years of Anti-Abortion Law in Poland]. Warsaw: Federacja na rzecz Kobiet i Planowania Rodziny [Federation for Women and Family Planning] [in Polish].
41.
HeinenP.J.PortetS., 2010. Reproductive rights in Poland: when politicians fear the wrath of the Church. Third World Quarterly, 31(6), pp. 1007–1021.
42.
HirschmanA., 1970. Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
43.
ImmergutE.M.1992. Health Politics: Interests and Institutions in Western Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
44.
InglisT., 1998. Moral Monopoly: The Rise and Fall of the Catholic Church in Modern Ireland. Dublin: University College Dublin Press.
45.
InglisT., 2003. Truth, Power and Lies: Irish Society and the Case of the Kerry Babies. Dublin: University College Dublin Press.
46.
InglisT., 2007. Catholic identity in contemporary Ireland: belief and belonging to tradition. Journal of Contemporary Religion, 22(2), pp. 205–220.
JankowskaH., 1991. Abortion, church and politics in Poland. Feminist Review, 39, pp. 174–181.
49.
KissaneB., 2003. The illusion of state neutrality in a secularising Ireland. West European Politics26(1), pp. 73–94.
50.
KnillC., 2013. The study of morality policy: analytical implications from a public policy perspective. Journal of European Public Policy, 20(3), pp. 309–317.
51.
KnillC.PreidelC., 2015. Institutional opportunity structures and the Catholic Church: explaining variation in the regulation of same-sex partnerships in Ireland and Italy. Journal of European Public Policy, 22(3), pp. 374–390.
52.
KnillC.AdamC.HurkaS., 2015. On the Road to Permissiveness? Change and Convergence of Moral Regulation in Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
53.
KnillC.PreidelC.NebelK., 2014. Brake rather than barrier: the impact of the Catholic Church on morality policies in Western Europe. West European Politics, 37(5), pp. 845–866.
54.
Konstytucja Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej [Constitution of Poland], 1997. Dziennik Ustaw No. 78, Item 483. Warsaw: SEJM. Available at: http://www.sejm.gov.pl/prawo/konst/polski/kon1.htm [last accessed 30 October 2019] [in Polish].
55.
KorolczukE., 2016. Explaining mass protests against abortion ban in Poland: the power of connective action. Zoon Politikon, 7, pp. 91–113.
56.
KozłowskaI.BélandD.LecoursA., 2016. Nationalism, religion, and abortion policy in four Catholic societies. Nations and Nationalism, 22(4), pp. 824–844.
57.
KrólA.PustułkaP., 2018. Women on strike: mobilizing against reproductive injustice in Poland. International Feminist Journal of Politics, 20(3), pp. 366–384.
58.
KulaM., 2012. Wstęp [Introduction]. In BarańskiP.CzajkowskaA.FiedotowA.Wochna-TyminńskaA., eds. Kłopoty z seksem w PRL [Troubles with Sex in the Polish People's Republic]. Warsaw: WUW, pp. 7–10 [in Polish].
59.
LentinR., 2013. A woman died: abortion and the politics of birth in Ireland. Feminist Review, 105, pp. 130–136.
60.
McAvoyS., 2015. The Catholic Church and fertility control in Ireland: the making of a dystopian regime. In QuiltyA.KennedyS.ConlonC., eds. The Abortion Papers Ireland: Volume 2. Cork: Cork University Press, pp. 47–62.
61.
McDonnellO.MurphyP., 2019. Mediating abortion politics in Ireland: media framing of the death of Savita Halappanavar. Critical Discourse Studies, 16(1), pp. 1–20.
MinkenbergM., 2002. Religion and public policy: institutional, cultural, and political impact on the shaping of abortion policies in Western democracies. Comparative Political Studies, 35(2), pp. 221–247.
64.
MishtalJ., 2015. The Politics of Morality: The Church, the State, and Reproductive Rights in Post-Socialist Poland. Columbus: Ohio University Press.
65.
Naczelna Izba Lekarska (NIL), 1991. Uchwala Nadzwyczajnego II Krajowego Zjazdu Lekarzy z dn 14.12.1991 w sprawie Kodeksu Etyki Lekarskiej [Resolution of the Second National Congress of Doctors of December 14, 1991, Regarding the Code of Medical Ethics]. Warsaw: Naczelna Izba Lekarska. Available at: https://www.nil.org.pl [last accessed 30 October 2019] [in Polish].
66.
NebelK.HurkaS., 2015. Abortion: the impossible compromise. In KnillC.AdamC.HurkaS., eds. On the Road to Permissiveness? Change and Convergence of Moral Regulation in Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 58–78.
67.
NowickaW., 1996. Roman Catholic fundamentalism against women’s reproductive rights in Poland. Reproductive Health Matters, 4(8), pp. 21–29.
68.
ObirekS., 2011. Aborcja, Kościół i duch niezgody [Abortion, the church and the spirit of discord]. In Snochowska-GonzalezC., ed. A jak hipokryzja. Antologia tekstów o aborcji, władzy, pieniądzach i sprawiedliwości [And as Hypocrisy:. Anthology of Texts on Abortion, Power, Money and Justice]. Warsaw: O Matko!, pp. 44–54 [in Polish].
69.
O’ReillyE., 1992. Masterminds of the Right. Dublin: Attic Press.
Protection of Life During Pregnancy Act 2013, 2013. No. 25 of 2013. Dublin: Houses of the Oireachtas.
72.
QuiltyA.KennedyS.ConlonC., eds., 2015. The Abortion Papers Ireland: Volume 2. Cork: Cork University Press.
73.
ReidyT., 2020. The 2018 referendum: over before it began! In BrowneK.CalkinS., eds. After Repeal: Rethinking Abortion Politics. London: Zed Books, pp. 21–35.
74.
RobbersG., 2005. State and Church in the European Union. Baden-Baden: Nomos.
75.
ScrivenR., 2020. Placing the Catholic Church: the moral landscape of repealing the 8th. In BrowneK.CalkinS., eds. After Repeal: Rethinking Abortion Politics. London: Zed Books, pp. 191–204.
76.
SheldonS., 2016. How can a state control swallowing? The home use of abortion pills in Ireland. Reproductive Health Matters, 24(48), pp. 90–101.
77.
SmythL., 2005. Abortion and Nation: The Politics of Reproduction in Contemporary Ireland. Abingdon: Routledge.
78.
SzelewaD., 2016. Killing ‘unborn children’? The Catholic Church and abortion law in Poland since 1989. Social & Legal Studies, 25(6), pp. 741–764.
79.
Ustawa z Dnia 7 Stycznia 1993 of Planowaniu Rodziny, Ochronie Plodu Ludzkiego I Warunkah Dopuszcczalnosci I Przerywania Ciazu [Act on Family Planning, Protection of the Human Fetus, and Conditions for Pregnancy Termination], 1993. Dziennik Ustaw No. 17, Item 78. Warsaw: SEJM. Available at: http://dziennikustaw.gov.pl/du/1993/s/17/78/1 [last accessed 9 Ddecember 2019] [in Polish].
ZielińskaE., 2000. Between ideology, politics and common sense: the discourse of reproductive rights in Poland. In GalS.KligmanG., eds. Reproducing Gender: Politics, Publics, and Everyday Life after Socialism. Princeton: Princeton University Press, pp. 23–57.
82.
ZubrzyckiG., 2006. The Crosses of Auschwitz: Nationalism and Religion in Post-Communist Poland. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.
