Modelling a complex biological system: the human cardiovascular system — 2. Model validation,reduction and development

Abstract

Model valadity is a multi-faceted concept which is expressed as a set of validity criteria related to different modelling objectives. These criteria form the basis of a validation methodology for biological models - an integral part of the modelling methodology presented in the preceding paper. This is applied to the model of the human cardiovascular system. By means of model decomposition and reconstruction, validation occurs at a number of levels and includes empirical, theoretical and heuristic tests. In general, the model is shown to have reasonable validity in terms of its objectives; it is an adequate representation of the human cardiovascular system under certain conditions. Although some defects may be traced to the modelling of neural control, the model has an important role in the conception and testing of different hypotheses for such control. In conclusion, the two papers support the thesis that mathematical models, used wisely, are effective and necessary tools in complex systems research.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Berlinski, D. 1976. On system analysis, MIT Press .

Burgen, A. V. S. and Mitchell, J. F. (eds). 1978. Gaddum's pharmacology, 4th edn, Oxford University Press.

Carson, E.R. and Finkelstein, L. 1977. 'General problems of validation of control system models in physiology', IFA C Symposium on Control Mechanisms in Bio- and Eco-systems, Leipzig 1977 , 1, pp 16-33.

Carson, E.R. , Cobelli, C. and Finkelstein, L. 1983. Mathematical modeling of metabolic and endocrine systems , John Wiley & Sons Inc, New York.

Dijkastra, E.W. 1972. Structured programming, Academic Press , New York.

Eykhoff, P. 1974. System identification: parameter and state estimation , John Wiley & Sons Inc, New York.

Fishman, G.S. and Kiviat, P.J. 1968. 'The statistics of discrete-event simulation', Simulation, 10, 185-195.

Frank, P.M. 1978. Introduction to system sensitivity theory, Academic Press, New York.

Guyton, A.C. 1971. Textbook of medical physiology, W. B. Saunders, Philadelphia.

10.

Hawker, R.W. 1979. Notebook of medical physiology: cardiopulmonary , Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh ,

11.

Hermann, C.F. 1967. 'Validation problems in games and simulations, with special reference to models of international politics', Behavioural Science, 12, 216 -231.

12.

Katona, P.G. , Barnet, O. and Jackson, W. 1967. 'Computer simulation of the blood pressure control ofheart period', in Baroreceptors and hypertension, P. Kezdi (ed), Pergamon, Oxford, pp 191-199.

13.

Leaning, M.S. 1980. The validity and validation of mathematical models, PhD Thesis, The City University, London .

14.

Leaning, M.S. , Uttamsingh, R.J. , Carson, E.R. , Cobelli, C. and Finkelstein, L. 1982. 'Methodological aspects of model validation: a model of the human renal —artificial kidney system', in A general survey of systems methodology (Proc 26th Annual Meeting of the SGSR), L. Troncale (ed), Society for General Systems Research, Louisville, Kentucky, pp 508-516.

15.

Lippold, O.C.J. and Winton, F.R. 1979. Human physiology, 7th edn, Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh .

16.

Macieowski, J.M. 1981. 'Model evaluation', in Systems modelling and optimisation, P. Nash (ed), Peter Peregrinus, London.

17.

Mehra, R.K. 1980. 'Nonlinear system identification: selected survey and recent trends', in Proc 5th IFAC Symposium on Identification and System Parameter Estimation

Darmstadt

1979, R. Isermann (ed), Pergamon, Oxford, pp 77-83.

18.

Mihram, G.A. 1972. Simulation -statistical foundations and methodology , Academic Press, New York.

19.

Mountcastle, V. B. (ed) 1974. Medical physiology, 13th edn, vol. II, C. V. Mosby Co, St Louis, Missouri.

20.

Pullen, H.E. 1976. Studies in the modelling and simulation of the human cardiovascular system with application to the effect of drugs, PhD Thesis , The City University, London.

21.

Rajkumar, N. 1978. Reduction of a mathematical model of the human cardiovascular system, MSc Thesis, The City University , London.

22.

Sarhan, N. , Carson, E.R. and Finkelstein, L. 1982. 'The role of sensitivity analysis in the validation of a mathematical model of the human respiratory system', Research Memorandum, DSS/NS-ERC-LF/230, The City University, London.

23.

Sharpey-Schafer, E.P. 1965. 'Effect of respiratory acts on circulation', in Handbook of physiology, W. F. Hamilton and P. Dow (eds), section 2, vol. 3, pp 1875-1886, American Physiological Society, Bethesda, Maryland .

24.

Tomović, R. 1963. Sensitivity analysis of dynamic systems, McGraw Hill, New York.

25.

Wingate, P. 1976. The Penguin medical encyclopaedia, Penguin Books, Hammondsworth.

26.

Zwart, A. , Smith, N.T. and Beneken, J.E.W. 1972. 'Multiple model approach to uptake and distribution of halothane', Computers and Biomedical Research, 5, 228-238.