The study investigated the effects of structured and unstructured cooperating groups on students' behaviours, discourse and learning in junior high school. One hundred and sixty-four grade 9 students participated in the study. The students were videotaped as they worked in three to four person, mixed-gender and ability groups on a science-based categorization activity. The results show that the students in structured cooperating groups demonstrated more cooperative and helping behaviours such as giving more elaborated help and guided directions to assist understanding than their peers in the unstructured groups. Moreover, they demonstrated more complex thinking and problem-solving skills both in their discourse and their responses on the follow-up learning probe. These findings are discussed in the context of the importance of structuring cooperative learning experiences if students are to attain the benefits widely attributed to this approach to learning.
Abram, P., Scarloss, B., Holthuis, N., Cohen, E., Lotan, R. and Schultz, S. (2002) `The Use of Evaluation Criteria to Improve Academic Discussion in Cooperative Groups', Asia Pacific Journal of Education22: 16-27.
2.
Antil, L., Jenkins, J., Wayne, S. and Vadsay, P. (1998) `Cooperative Learning: Conceptualizations, and the Relation Between Research and Practice', American Educational Research Journal35: 419-54.
3.
Baines, E., Blatchford, P. and Kutnick, P. (2003) `Changes in Grouping Practices Over Primary and Secondary School', International Journal of Educational Research39: 9-34.
4.
Bloom, B. (1956) Taxonomy of Educational Objectives. Handbook 1Cognitive Domain. London: Longman.
5.
Cohen, E.G. (1994) `Restructuring the Classroom: Conditions for Productive Small Groups', Review of Educational Research64: 1-35.
6.
Cohen, E., Lotan, R., Abram, P., Scarloss, B. and Schultz, S. (2002) `Can Groups Learn?', Teachers College Record104: 1045-68.
7.
Cohen, E., Lotan, R. and Holthuis, N. (1997) `Organizing the Classroom for Learning', in E. Cohen and R. Lotan (eds) Working for Equity in Heterogeneous Classrooms: Sociological Theory in Practice, pp. 32-43. New York: Teachers' College Press.
8.
Cowie, H. and Berdondini, L. (2001) `Children's Reactions to Cooperative Group Work: A Strategy for Enhancing Peer Relationships Among Bullies, Victims, and Bystanders', Learning and Instruction11: 517-30.
9.
Gillies, R. (2003) `The Behaviors, Interactions, and Perceptions of Junior High School Students During Small-Group Learning', Journal of Educational Psychology95: 137-47.
10.
Gillies, R. and Ashman, A. (2000) `The Effects of Cooperative Learning on Children with Learning Difficulties in the Lower Elementary School', The Journal of Special Education34: 19-27.
11.
Gillies, R. and Ashman, A. (1998) `Behavior and Interactions of Children in Cooperative Groups in Lower and Middle Elementary Grades', Journal of Educational Psychology90: 746-57.
12.
Gillies, R. and Ashman, A. (1996) `Teaching Collaborative Skills to Primary School Children in Classroom-Based Work Groups', Learning and Instruction6: 187-200.
13.
Johnson, D.W. and Johnson, F.P. (2003) Joining Together: Group Theory and Group Skills , 8th edn. Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon.
14.
Johnson, D.W. and Johnson, R. (1990) `Cooperative Learning and Achievement', in S. Sharan (ed.) Cooperative Learning: Theory and Research, pp. 23-37. New York: Praeger.
15.
Johnson, D.W. and Johnson, R. (2002) `Learning Together and Alone: Overview and Meta-Analysis' , Asia Pacific Journal of Education22: 95-105.
16.
Johnson, D.W. and Johnson, R. (2000) `Cooperative Learning, Values, and Culturally Plural Classrooms', in M. Leicester, C. Modgil and S. Modgil (eds) Education, Culture and Values, pp. 15-28. London: Falmer Press.
17.
Johnson, D.W., Johnson, R., Dudley, B., Mitchell, J. and Fredrickson, J. (1997) `The Impact of Conflict Resolution Training on Middle School Students', The Journal of Social Psychology137: 11-21.
18.
Kamps, D., Dugan, E., Leonard, B. and Daoust, P. (1994) `Enhanced Small Group Interaction Using Choral Responding and Student Interaction for Children with Autism and Developmental Disabilities', American Journal of Mental Retardation99: 60-73.
19.
Kenny, D., Manetti, L., Pierro, A., Livi, S. and Kashy, D. (2002) `The Statistical Analysis of Data from Small Groups' , Journal of Personality and Social Psychology83: 126-37.
20.
King, A. (2002) `Structuring Peer Interaction to Promote High-Level Cognitive Processing', Theory into Practice41: 33-40.
21.
King, A. (1999) `Discourse Patterns for Mediating Peer Learning' , in A. O'Donnell and A. King (eds) Cognitive Perspectives on Peer Learning, pp. 87-152. London: Lawrence Erlbaum.
22.
Kohn, A. (1992) `Resistance to Cooperative Learning: Making Sense of its Deletion and Dilution', Journal of Education174: 38-55.
23.
Lopata, C., Miller, K. and Miller, R. (2003) `Survey of Actual and Preferred Use of Cooperative Learning Among Exemplar Teachers', The Journal of Educational Research96: 232-41.
24.
Lou, Y., Abrami, P., Spence, J., Poulsen, C., Chambers, B. and d'Apollonia, S. (1996) `Within-Class Grouping: A Meta-Analysis', Review of Educational Research66: 423-58.
25.
McMaster, K. and Fuchs, D. (2002) `Effects of Cooperative Learning on the Academic Achievement of Students with Learning Disabilities: An Update of Tateyama-Sniezek's Review', Learning Disabilities Research and Practice17: 107-17.
26.
Mercer, N., Wegerif, R. and Dawes, L. (1999) `Children's Talk and the Development of Reasoning in the Classroom', British Educational Research Journal25: 95-112.
27.
Palincsar, A. (1998) `Social Constructivist Perspectives on Teaching and Learning', Annual Review of Psychology49: 345-75.
28.
Palincsar, A. and Herrenkohl, L. (2002) `Designing Collaborative Learning Contexts', Theory into Practice41: 26-35.
29.
Race, K. and Powell, K. (2000) `Assessing Student Perceptions of Classroom Methods and Activities in the Context of Outcomes-Based Evaluation', Evaluation Review24: 635-46.
30.
Rojas-Drummod, S., Perez, V., Velez, M., Gomez, L., Mendoza, A. (2003) `Talking for Reasoning Among Mexican Primary School Students', Learning and Instruction13: 653-70.
31.
Rutherford, R., Mathur, S. and Quinn, M. (1998) `Promoting Social Communication Skills Through Cooperative Learning and Direct Instruction', Education and Treatment of Children21: 231-33.
32.
Shachar, H. and Sharan, S. (1994) `Talking, Relating and Achieving: Effects of Cooperative Learning and Whole-Class Instruction', Cognition and Instruction12: 313-53.
33.
Sharan, S., Shachar, H. and Levine, T. (1999) The Innovative School: Organization and Instruction . Westpoint, CT: Bergin and Garvey .
34.
Sharan, S. and Shachar, H. (1988) Language and Learning in the Cooperative Classroom . New York: Springer-Verlag.
35.
Shaughnessy, J. and Zechmeister, E. (1994) Research Methods in Psychology. New York: McGaw-Hill.
36.
Slavin, R. (1996) `Research on Cooperative Learning and Achievement: What We Know, What We Need to Know', Contemporary Educational Psychology21: 43-69.
37.
Slavin, R. and Cooper, R. (1999) `Improving Intergroup Relations: Lessons Learned from Cooperative Programs', Journal of Special Issues55: 647-63.
38.
Stevahn, L., Johnson, D., Johnson, R., Oberle, K. and Wakl, L. (2000) `Effects on High School Students of Conflict Resolution Training Integrated into English Literature', Child Development71: 772-84.
39.
Stevens, R. (2003) `Student Team Reading and Writing: A Cooperative Learning Approach to Middle School Literacy Instruction', Educational Research and Evaluation9: 137-60.
40.
Turner, J. and Patrick, H. (2004) `Motivational Influences on Student Participation in Classroom Learning Activities', Teachers College Record106: 1759-85.
41.
Veermans, M., Lallimo, J. and and Hakkarainen, K. (2005) `Patterns of Guidance in Inquiry Learning', Journal of Interactive learning Research16: 179-94.
42.
Vygotsky, L. (1978) Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
43.
Webb, N. (2002) `Productive Helping in Cooperative Groups', Theory into Practice41: 13-20.
44.
Webb, N. (1992) `Testing a Theoretical Model of Student Interaction and Learning in Small Groups', in R. Hertz-Lazarowitz and N. Miller (eds) Interaction in Cooperative Groups, pp. 102-19. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
45.
Webb, N. (1985) `Student Interaction and Learning in Small Groups: A Research Summary', in R. Slavin, S. Sharon, S. Kagan, R. Hertz-Lazarowitz, C. Webb and R. Schmuck (eds) Learning to Cooperate, Cooperating to Learn, pp. 5-15. New York : Plenum.
46.
Webb, N., Baxter, G. and Thompson, L. (1997) `Teachers' Grouping Practices in Fifth-Grade Science Classrooms', The Elementary School Journal98: 91-113.
47.
Webb, N. and Farivar, S. (1999) `Developing Productive Group Interaction in Middle School Mathematics', in A. O'Donnell and A. King (eds) Cognitive Perspectives on Peer Learning, pp. 117-49. London: Lawrence Erlbaum.
48.
Webb, N., Troper, J. and Fall, R. (1995) `Constructive Activity and Learning in Collaborative Small Groups', Journal of Educational Psychology87: 406-23.
