From model validation to production of reference simulations: how to increase reliability and applicability of building and HVAC simulation models

Abstract

Validation of simulation models appears from a long time as a key issue in order to promote a more intensive and more efficient use of simulation models in the field of building and HVAC simulation. IEA Annex 34/43 originally targeted a number of specific applications where a more advanced validation was required: ground coupling problems, multizone building, shading, day lighting and cooling load interaction, HVAC components and ventilated facades. These validation exercises were built on the large methodological experience obtained in previous projects and address sometimes very fundamental problems of heat transfer in buildings. Consulting engineers and practitioners might see these exercises as a bit too far from their objectives and it is the reason why an additional activity was proposed with the specific aim of producing, based upon the results of the validation of models, a set of reference simulations. These applications cover a range of building types (residential, commercial) and systems (production, distribution emission) and run in a variety of climates. The paper will describe how models dedicated to these applications were developed, starting from validation results, going through the selection and consolidation of simulation hypothesises and ending with a number that might be considered as reference for the concerned applications. The paper will concentrate on models required by a residential building application (multizone building equipped with a heat pump or a condensing boiler, heat emitted by radiators or floor heating systems). Simulations make use of both EES and TRNSYS software and both software are applied in parallel as far as possible in the different applications in order to get a better judgment of their potential advantages and drawbacks. The use of reference simulations in view of qualifying normative methods currently in development in the frame of the European Energy Performance in Buildings Directive is also addressed and demonstrated in the paper.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adam C. , André P. Validation exercise applied to some TRNSYS components in the context of IEA34/43 . Proceedings EPIC 2006 conference, Lyon, 2006.

Klein et al. TRNSYS, a Transient System Simulation Program, University of Madison-Wisconsin , USA, 2004.

Braun J. TRNSYS Type 46 component. Multizone Building Dynamic Simulator, Laboratory of Building Physics, University of Liège , Belgium, 1984.

Seem JE Modeling of heat transfer in buildings. Thesis, University of Madison-Wisconsin, USA, 1987.

Transsolar. TRNBUILD, an interface for creating the building description of Type 56 (Multizone Building) . In TRNSYS 16 Manual, volume 16, University of Madison-Wisconsin, USA, 2004a.

Transsolar. TRNFLOW, a model of an air-flow network for coupled simulation with Type 56 (multizone building) of TRNSYS , TRANSSOLAR, Germany, 2004b.

Masy, G. Dynamic Simulation on Simplified Building Models and Interaction with Heating Systems. Proceedings SSB 2006 Conference, Liège, 2006.

Winandy E. Contribution to the performance analysis of reciprocating and scroll refrigeration compressors. PhD Thesis, University of Concepción, Chile, 1999.

Loutzenhiser P. , Manz H. , Maxwell G. Empirical Validations of Shading/ Daylighting/Load Interactions in Building Energy Simulation Tools. A report for the International Energy Agency's SHC Task 34/ECBCS Annex 43 Project C, February 2007.