Assessing the performance of domestic heating controls in a whole house test facility

Abstract

The energy consumed by domestic space heating systems represents a considerable share of the energy consumed in the UK. At the same time up to a quarter of English homes have inadequate controls on the central heating systems. Current modelling tools, and results from the limited field trials that have been carried out, are problematic due to the influence of the behaviour of occupants and variability of weather conditions. The Salford Energy House is a full-sized end terrace house built within a climate controlled laboratory. This allows a house of typical construction to be extensively analysed while completely disconnected from the unpredictability of weather conditions and human behaviour. This paper presents a series of tests carried out in the Salford Energy House into the effectiveness of installing room thermostats and thermostatic radiator valves. Savings of 40% in terms of energy consumption, cost and CO₂ were achieved. The results should be regarded with caution in terms of their extent and application to real homes, but represent a significant contribution to the gap in current knowledge due to the ability to isolate the performance of homes from uncooperative variables, and a potential base for the development of more effective modelling tools.

Practical application: This research provides evidence to support installation and use of room thermostats and thermostatic radiator valves as an effective means of reducing domestic energy consumption and overheating.

Keywords

Heating controls space heating thermostatic radiator valves Salford Energy House

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adolph

Kopmann

Lupulescu

. Adaptive control strategies for single room heating. Energ Build 2014; 68: 771–778.

Department for Communities and Local Government. English housing survey: HOMES annual report on England’s housing stock, 2010, London: DCLG, 2012.

Department for Energy and Climate Change. Energy consumption in the UK, London: DECC, 2014.

Shipworth

Firth

S K

Gentry

. Central heating thermostat settings and timing: building demographics. Build Res Inform 2010; 38: 50–69.

Building Research Establishment. The government’s standard assessment procedure for energy rating of dwellings (SAP 2012), Watford: BRE, 2013.

Building Research Establishment. Energy follow up survey mean house temperatures. BRE Report Number 283078, 2011. Watford: BRE.

Summerfield

Lowe

Bruhns

. Milton Keynes energy park revisited: changes in internal temperatures and energy usage. Energ Build 2007; 39: 783–791.

Fabi

Andersen

Corgnati

. Occupants’ window opening behaviour: a literature review of factors influencing occupant behaviour and models. Build Environ 2012; 58: 188–198.

Munton

Wright

Mallaburn

. How heating controls affect domestic energy demand: a rapid evidence assessment. Report for the department of energy and climate change, London: DECC, 2014.

10.

British Electromechanical Manufacturers Association. Technical report – energy savings from the addition of a TPI room thermostat and TRVs to a domestic heating system, www.beama.org.uk/en/product-areas/heating-hot-water–air-movement/heating-controls/ (2014, accessed 17 October 2014).

11.

Stafford A, Bell M and Gorse C. Building Confidence - A working paper 2012. Leeds: The Centre for Low Carbon Futures.

12.

Hens

. Building physics: heat, air and moisture: fundamentals and engineering methods with examples and exercises, Berlin: Ernst & Sohn, 2012.

13.

Lomas

. Carbon reduction in existing buildings: a transdisciplinary approach. Build Res Inform 2010; 38: 1–11.

14.

Huebner

McMichael

Shipworth

. The reality of English living rooms – a comparison of internal temperatures against common model assumptions. Energ Build 2013; 66: 688–696.

15.

Huebner

Cooper

Jones

. Domestic energy consumption – What role do comfort, habit, and knowledge about the heating system play? Energ Build 2013; 66: 626–636.

16.

Peffer

Pritoni

Meier

. How people use thermostats in homes: a review. Build Environ 2011; 46: 2529–2541.

17.

Meier A, Aragon C, Hurwitz B, et al. How people actually use thermostats. In: Proceedings of the 2010 ACEEE summer study on energy efficiency in buildings. Pacific Grove, CA, 15–20 August, 2010, pp.2-193–2-206. Pacific Grove, CA: American Council for an Energy Efficient Economy.

18.

Meier

Aragon

Peffer

. Usability of residential thermostats: Preliminary investigations. Build Environ 2011; 46: 1891–1898.

19.

Crosbie

Baker

. Energy-efficiency interventions in housing: learning from the inhabitants. Build Res Inform 2010; 38: 70–79.

20.

Chetty M, Tran D and Grinter RE. Getting to green: understanding resource consumption in the home. In: UbiComp ‘08 proceedings of the 10th international conference on ubiquitous computing, New York, 2008, pp.242–251. New York, NY: ACM.

21.

Department of Communities and Local Government. Approved document L1a, London: DCLG, 2014.

22.

HM Government. Domestic building services compliance guide, 2013 ed. [For use in England]. London: RIBA, 2014.

23.

Department for Communities and Local Government. English housing survey: energy efficient of English housing 2012, London: DCLG, 2014.

24.

Jenkins

. The value of retrofitting carbon‐saving measures into fuel poor social housing. Energ Policy 2010; 38: 832–839.

25.

National Audit Office. The decent homes programme: report by the comptroller and auditor general, London: NAO, 2010.

26.

Critchley

Gilbertson

Grimsley

. Living in cold homes after heating improvements: evidence from Warm‐Front, England’s home energy efficiency scheme. Appl Energ 2007; 84: 147–158.

27.

Gilbertson

Stevens

Stiell

. Home is where the hearth is: grant recipients’ views of England’s home energy efficiency scheme (Warm Front). Soc Sci Med 2006; 63: 946–956.

28.

Guertler

. Can the green deal be fair too? Exploring new possibilities for alleviating fuel poverty. Energ Policy 2012; 46: 91–97.

29.

Rosenow J and Eyre N. The green deal and the energy company obligation – will it work. In: 9th BIEE academic conference – European energy in a challenging world: the impact of emerging markets. Oxford, 2012.

30.

Fitton

Swan

. Assessing overheating of the UK existing dwellings – a case study of replica Victorian end terrace house. Build Environ 2014; 77: 1–11.

31.

Peeters

Van der Veken

Hens

. Control of heating systems in residential buildings: current practice. Energ Build 2008; 40: 1446–1455.

32.

Nicol

Stevenson

. Adaptive comfort in an unpredictable world. Build Res Inform 2013; 41: 255–258.