Comments on the quality of working life (QWL) under lean production have varied from
devastating criticism on the one hand, to eulogistic praise on the other. These
contrasting positions can be related to researchers’ opposing societal
stances and resulting interpretations, which are reinforced by the methodologies
used and the absence of an external framework to judge QWL. Using
Karasek’s job demand–job control model, the authors investigate
a Dutch plant operating under a lean production (LP) regime in an attempt to resolve
the controversy. The jobs in this plant can be placed in Karasek’s
quadrant of low job demands and low job control, which means that antagonists of LP
are right in claiming that the work is monotonous and repetitive, while the
advocates’ claim that workers have sufficient job decision latitude also holds.
Adler, P.
and
R.E. Cole
(1993)
‘Designed for Learning; A Tale of Two Auto Plants’
, California Management Review36(1):
85–94
.
2.
Ashby, W.R.
(1969) ‘Self-Regulation and Requisite
Variety’, pp. 105–124 in
F.E. Emery
(ed.) Systems Thinking; Selected Readings.
Harmondsworth: Penguin
.
3.
Babson, S.
(1995) ‘Whose Work? Lean Production at Mazda
USA’, pp. 235–246 in
S. Babson
(ed.) Lean Work; Empowerment and Exploitation in the Global Auto
Industry.
Detroit: Wayne State University Press
.
4.
Benders, J.
(1995)
‘Output Characteristics as Input for the Skilling Debate’
, Work, Employment and Society9(2):
329–342
.
5.
Benders, J.
and
M. van Bijsterveld
(2000)
‘Leaning on Lean; The Reception of a Management Fashion in Germany’
, New Technology, Work and Employment15(1):
50–64
.
6.
Besser, T.
(1996) Team Toyota: Transplanting the Toyota Culture to the
Camry Plant in Kentucky.
Albany: State University of New York Press
.
7.
Brenner, M.D.
,
D. Fairris
and
J. Ruser
(2004)
‘ ‘‘Flexible’’ Work
Practices and Occupational Safety and Health: Exploring the Relationship
Between Cumulative Trauma Disorders and Workplace Transformation’
, Industrial Relations43(1):
242–266
.
8.
Burns, T.
and
G.M. Stalker
(1961) The Management of Innovation.
London: Tavistock Publications
.
9.
Burrell, G.
and
G. Morgan
(1979) Sociological Paradigms and Organisational Analysis:
Elements of the Sociology of Corporate Life.
London: Heinemann
.
10.
Christis, J. (1998) Arbeid, Organisatie en Stress. Een visie vanuit de
sociotechnische arbeids-en organisatiekunde. Amsterdam: Het Spinhuis.
11.
Conti, R.
and
M. Warner
(1993)
‘Taylorism, New Technology and Just-in-Time Systems in Japanese Manufacturing’
, New Technology, Work and Employment8(1):
31–42
.
12.
Delbridge, R.
,
P. Turnbull
and
B. Wilkinson
(1992)
‘Pushing Back the Frontiers: Management Control and Work
Intensification under JIT/TQM Factory Regimes’
, New Technology, Work and Employment7(2):
97–106
.
13.
Dhondt, S. and I. Houtman (1996) De WEBA-Methode. NOVA-WEBA handleiding. Een
vragenlijst om welzijnsknelpunten op te sporen. Leiden: TNO Preventie en Gezondheid.
14.
Dohse, K.
,
U. Jurgens
and
T. Malsch
(1985)
‘From ‘‘Fordism’’ to
‘‘Toyotism’’; The Social
Organization of the Labour Process in the Japanese Automobile Industry’
, Politics and Society14(2):
115–146
.
15.
Easton, G.S.
and
S.L. Jarrell
(2000) ‘Patterns in the Deployment of Total
Quality Management: An Analysis of 44 Leading Companies’, pp.
89–130 in
R.E. Cole
and
W.R. Scott
(eds) The Quality Movement and Organization Theory.
Thousand Oaks, CA, London and New Delhi: Sage
.
16.
Elger, T.
and
C. Smith
(1994) ‘Introduction’, pp.
1–24 in
T. Elger
and
C. Smith
(eds) Global Japanization? The Transnational Transformation of the
Labour Process.
London and New York: Routledge
.
17.
Fairris, D.
and
H. Tohyama
(2002)
‘Productive Efficiency and the Lean Production System in Japan
and the United States’
, Economic and Industrial Democracy23(4):
529–554
.
18.
Fish, S.
(1980) Is There a Text in This Class? The Authority of
Interpretative Communities.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
19.
Frese, M.
and
D. Zapf
(1988) ‘Methodological Issues in the Study of
Work Stress: Objective vs Subjective Measurement of Work Stress and the Question
of Longitudinal Studies’, pp.
375–411 in
C.L. Cooper
and
R. Payne
(eds) Causes, Coping and Consequences of Stress at Work.
Chichester: John Wiley
.
20.
Fucini, J.T.
and
S. Fucini
(1990) Working for the Japanese: Inside Mazda’s
American Auto Plant.
New York: Free Press
.
21.
Graham, L.
(1995) On the Line at Subaru-Isuzu; The Japanese Model and
the American Worker.
Ithaca, NY: ILR Press
.
22.
Hacker, W. (1989) ‘Vollstandige vs. unvollstandige
Arbeitstatigkeiten’, pp. 463–6 in S. Greif, H. Holling and N.
Nicholson (eds) Arbeits-und Organisationspsychologie, Munich: Psychologie Verlags Union.
23.
Hackman, J.R.
and
G.R. Oldham
(1980) Work Redesign.
Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley
.
24.
Hamde, K.
(2002)
‘Teamwork: Fashion or Institution?’
, Economic and Industrial Democracy23(3):
389–420
.
25.
Kamata, S. (1986) Japan aan de lopende band. Amsterdam: Uitgeverij Jan Smets.
(Orig. pub in Japanese, Jidosha zetsubo kojo, 1973.)
26.
Kammeraat, R. (2000) ‘Welzijn bij Giant Europe Manufacturing B.V.
Een onderzoek naar het verbeteren van het welzijn en het verhogen van de
betrokkenheid van de medewerkers op de assemblage-afdeling van een
.etsenfabriek’, Master thesis, University of Groningen.
Karasek, R.
and
T. Theorell
(1990) Healthy Work: Stress, Productivity, and the
Reconstruction of Working Life.
New York: Basic Books
.
29.
Kenney, M.
and
R. Florida
(1993) Beyond Mass Production: The Japanese System and its
Transfer to the US.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
30.
Kieser, A.
(1997)
‘Rhetoric and Myth in Management Fashion’
, Organization4(1):
49–76
.
31.
Klein, J.A.
(1991)
‘A Reexamination of Autonomy in Light of New Manufacturing Practices’
, Human Relations44(1):
21–38
.
32.
Kompier, M.A.J. and F.H.G. Marcelissen (1993) Handboek werkstress.
Systematische aanpak voor de bedrijfspraktijk. Amsterdam: NIA.
33.
Krafcik, J.F.
(1988)
‘Triumph of the Lean Production System’
, Sloan Management Review30(1):
41–52
.
34.
Landsbergis, P.
,
J. Cahill
and
P. Schnall
(1999)
‘The Impact of Lean Production and Related New Systems of Work on
Organization of Worker Health’
, Journal of Occupational Health Psychology4(3):
108–130
.
35.
Landy, F.J.
(1992) ‘Work Design and
Stress’, pp. 119–158 in
G.P. Keita
and
S.L. Sauter
(eds) Work and Well-Being: An Agenda for the 1990s.
Washington, DC: American Psychological Association
.
36.
Lewchuk, W.
,
P. Stewart
and
C. Yates
(2001)
‘Quality of Working Life in the Automobile Industry: A
Canada–UK Comparative Study’
, New Technology, Work and Employment16(1):
72–87
.
37.
Malloch, H.
(1997)
‘Strategic and HRMA spects of Kaizen: A Case Study’
, New Technology, Work and Employment12(2):
108–122
.
38.
Molleman, E.
,
B. van Delft
and
J. Slomp
(2001)
‘The Application of an Empowerment Model’
, Human Factors and Ergonomics in Manufacturing11(4):
339–354
.
39.
Monden, Y.
(1983) Toyota Production System.
Norcross, GA: Industrial Engineering and
Management Press
.
40.
Morita, M.
(2001)
‘Have the Seeds of Japanese Teamworking Taken Root Abroad?’
, New Technology, Work and Employment16(3):
178–190
.
41.
Morris, J.
,
B. Wilkinson
and
M. Munday
(2000)
‘Farewell to HRM? Personnel Practices in Japanese Manufacturing
Plants in the UK’
, International Journal of Human Resource Management11(6):
1047–1060
.
42.
Ohno, T.
(1988) Toyota Production System: Beyond Large-Scale
Production.
Cambridge: Productivity Press
.
43.
Oliver, N.
and
B. Wilkinson
(1992) The Japanization of British Industry: New Developments
in the 1990s.
Oxford and Cambridge: Blackwell
.
44.
Ortmann, G. (1995) Formen der Produktion. Organisation und Rekursivität. Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag.
45.
Parker, M.
and
J. Slaughter
(1988) Choosing Sides.
Boston, MA: South End Press
.
46.
Parker, S.K.
(2003)
‘Longitudinal Effects of Lean Production’
, Journal of Applied Psychology88(4):
620–634
.
47.
Psoinos, A.
and
S. Smithson
(2002)
‘Employee Empowerment in Manufacturing: A Study of Organisations
in the UK’
, New Technology, Work and Employment17(2):
132–148
.
48.
Schonberger, R.J.
(1982) Japanese Manufacturing Techniques–Nine
Hidden Lessons in Simplicity.
New York: Free Press
.
49.
Schouteten, R.L.J.
(2001) Balances in Well-Being at Work; Measurements,
Determinants, and Improvements of the Quality of Working Life.
Capelle a/d IJssel: Labyrint Publication
.
50.
Sewell, G.
and
B. Wilkinson
(1992)
‘ ‘‘Someone to Watch over
Me’’; Surveillance, Discipline and the Just-in-Time
Labour Process’
, Sociology26(2):
271–289
.
51.
Shingo, S.
(1983) A Revolution in Manufacturing: The SMED System.
Stamford, CA: Productivity Press
.
52.
Sorge, A.
(1991)
‘Strategic Fit and the Societal Effect: Interpreting
Cross-National Comparisons of Technology, Organization and Human Resources’
, Organization Studies12(2):
161–190
.
53.
Sugimori, Y.
,
K. Kusunoki
,
F. Cho
and
S. Uchikawa
(1977)
‘Toyota Production System and Kanban System; Materialization of
Just-in-Time and Respect-for-Human System’
, International Journal of Production Research15(6):
553–564
.
54.
Toyota
(1992) Toyota Production System.
Toyota: Toyota
.
55.
Trist, E.A.
and
K.W. Bamforth
(1951)
‘Some Special and Psychological Consequences of the Longwall
Method of Coal-Getting’
, Human Relations4(1):
3–38
.
56.
Vaas, S., S. Dhondt, M.H.H. Peeters and J. Middendorp (1995) De WEBA-methode,
Deel 1: WEBA-analyse handleiding. Alphen aan den Rijn/Zaventem: Samsom
BedrijfsInformatie.
57.
Van der Parre, P. (1996) Zonder arbeid geen zegen. Kwaliteit van de arbeid,
arbeidsorientaties, arbeidssatisfactie en het zoekgedrag op de arbeidsmarkt. Delft:
Eburon.
58.
Van Hoof, J.J.
and
R.J. Huiskamp
(1989) ‘New Forms of Work Organization in the
Netherlands’, pp. 155–173 in
P. Grootings
,
B. Gustavsen
and
L. Hethy
(eds) New Forms of Work Organization in Europe.
New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers
.
59.
Van Veldhoven, M.J.P.M. (1996) Psychosociale arbeidsbelasting en werkstress.
Lisse: Swets en Zeitlinger.
60.
Vogel, E.F.
(1979) Japan as Number One: Lessons for America.
Cambridge, MA and London: Harvard University Press
.
61.
Wilkinson, A.
(2002) ‘Empowerment’, pp.
1720–1730 in
M. Warner
(ed.) International Encyclopedia of Business and Management.
London: Thomson Learning
.
62.
Womack, J.P.
,
D.T. Jones
and
D. Roos
(1990) The Machine that Changed the World.
New York: Rawson Associates
.
63.
Yates, C.
,
W. Lewchuk
and
P. Stewart
(2001)
‘Empowerment as a Trojan Horse: New Systems of Work Organization
in the North American Automobile Industry’
, Economic and Industrial Democracy22(4):
517–542
.
64.
Young, S.M.
(1992)
‘A Framework for Successful Adoption and Performance of Japanese
Manufacturing Practices in the United States’
, Academy of Management Review17(4):
677–700
.
