Drawing on an evaluative framework inspired by the capability approach, the article assesses the nature and implications of company responses to the British legislation transposing Directive 2002/14/EC on information and consultation rights of employees. Evidence from five case studies in the business services and the financial sectors suggests that the introduction of the Information and Consultation of Employees Regulations 2004 drove the spread of voluntary arrangements. However, the legislation has not promoted so far an effective framework for the development of deliberative procedures between management and labour with the aim of advancing a ‘capability for voice’. This is attributed to its institutional design and the limited degree to which extra-legal ‘conversion factors’ are available in the British industrial relations system.
Barnard C., Deakin S. ( 2002) Market access and regulatory competition. In: Barnard C, Scott J (eds) The Law of the Single European Market: Unpacking the Premises. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 197-224.
2.
Barnard C., Deakin S., and Hobbs R. ( 2003) Opting out of the 48-hour week - employer necessity or individual choice? An empirical study of the operation of article 18(1)(b) of the working time directive in the UK. Industrial Law Journal32(4): 223-252.
3.
Beaumont PB, Hunter LC ( 2007) The process of consultation: Responding to challenge. The International Journal of Human Resource Management18(7): 1228-1245.
4.
Blanke T. ( 1999) European works councils as an institution of European employees’ information and consultation. Transfer5(3): 366-383.
5.
Bogg AL ( 2006) Representation of employees in collective bargaining within the firm: Voluntarism in the UK. Electronic Journal of Comparative Law10(3). Available at: www.ejcl.org/103/art103-3.pdf
6.
Bonvin JM ( 2008) Capacités et démocratie. In: de Munck J, Zimmermann B (eds) La Liberté au Prisme des Capacités - Amartya Sen au-delà du Libéralisme. Paris : Editions de l’École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales (EHESS), 237-261.
7.
Bonvin JM, Farvaque N. ( 2006) Promoting capability for work: The role of local actors . In: Deneulin S, Nebel M, and Sagowsky N (eds) Transforming Unjust Structures: The Capability Approach. Amsterdam: Springer-Verlag, 121-142.
8.
Brown W., Deakin S., Nash D., and Oxenbridge S. ( 2000) The employment contract: From collective procedures to individual rights. British Journal of Industrial Relations38(4): 611-629.
9.
Browne JS, Deakin S., and Wilkinson F. ( 2004) Capabilities, social rights, and european integration . In: Salais R, Villeneuve R (eds) Europe and the Politics of Capabilities . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 205-221.
10.
Charlwood A., Terry M. ( 2007) 21st-century models of employee representation: Structures, processes and outcomes. Industrial Relations Journal38(4): 320-337.
11.
Danford A., Richardson M., Stewart P., Tailby S., and Upchurch M. ( 2005) Workplace partnership and employee voice in the UK: Comparative case studies of union strategy and worker experience. Economic and Industrial Democracy26(4): 593-620.
12.
Deakin S., Wilkinson F. ( 2005) The Law of the Labour Market: Industrialisation, Employment and Legal Evolution. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
13.
De Munck J., Ferreras I. ( 2004) Collective rights, deliberation and capabilities: An approach to collective bargaining in the Belgian retail industry. In: Salais R, Villeneuve R (eds) Europe and the Politics of Capabilities. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 222-238.
14.
De Munck J., Orianne JF ( 2008) Droits sociaux et mondes possibles. In: de Munck J, Zimmermann B (eds) La Liberté au Prisme des Capacités - Amartya Sen au-delà du Libéralisme. Paris : Editions de l’École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales (EHESS), 263-280.
15.
Dickens L., Hall M. ( 2005) Review of Research into the Impact of Employment Relations Legislation, Employment Relations Research Series No. 45. London: Department for Business, Innovation and Skills .
16.
Gilman M., Marginson P. ( 2002) Negotiating European works councils. Industrial Relations Journal33(1): 36-51.
17.
Godard J. ( 2002) Institutional environments, employer practices, and states in liberal market economies. Industrial Relations41(2): 249-286.
18.
Gumbrell-McCormick R., Hyman R. ( 2006) Embedded collectivism? Workplace representation in France and Germany. Industrial Relations Journal37(5): 473-491.
19.
Hall M., Hoffmann A., Marginson P., and Muller T. ( 2003) National influences on European works councils in the UK- and US-based companies. Human Resource Management Journal13(4): 75-92.
20.
Hall M., Hutchinson S., Parker J., Purcell J., and Terry M. ( 2007) Implementing Information and Consultation: Early Experience under the ICE Regulations, Employment Relations Research Series No. 88. London: Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform.
21.
Hege A., Dufour H. ( 1995) Decentralisation and legitimacy in employee representation: A Franco-German comparison. European Journal of Industrial Relations1(1): 83-97.
22.
Hyman R. ( 1996) Is there a case for statutory works councils in Britain? In: McColgan A (ed.) The Future of Labour Law. London: Cassell , 64-84.
23.
Hyman R. ( 2000) Editorial. European Journal of Industrial Relations6(1): 5-7.
24.
Kahn-Freund O. ( 1954) The legal framework. In: Flanders A, Clegg HA (eds) The System of Industrial Relations in Great Britain. Oxford : Blackwell, 42-127.
25.
Kelly J. ( 1996) Works councils: Union advance or marginalisation? In: McColgan A (ed.) The Future of Labour Law . London: Cassell, 46-63.
26.
Kersley B., Alpin C., Forth J., Bryson A., Bewley H., Dix G., and Oxenbridge S. ( 2006) Inside the Workplace: Findings from the 2004 Workplace Employment Relations Survey. Oxford: Routledge.
27.
Koukiadaki A. ( 2008) Reflexive regulation and the development of capabilities: The impact of the 2002/14/EC Framework Directive on Information and Consultation of Employees in the UK. PhD thesis, University of Warwick .
28.
Lamers J. ( 1998) The Added Value of European Works Councils. Haarlem: Algemene Werkgevers Vereniging Nederland (AWVN).
29.
Lecher W., Nagel B., and Platzer HW ( 1999) The Establishment of European Works Councils. Aldershot: Ashgate.
30.
Lecher W., Platzer HW, Rüb S., and Weiner KP ( 2001) European Works Councils: Developments, Types and Networking . Aldershot: Gower.
31.
Lecher W., Platzer HW, Rüb S., and Weiner KP ( 2002) European Works Councils: Negotiated Europeanisation. Aldershot: Ashgate.
32.
Lloyd C., Newell H. ( 2001) Changing management-union relations: Consultation in the UK pharmaceutical industry. Economic and Industrial Democracy22(3): 357-382.
33.
Marginson P., Gilman M., Jacobi O., and Krieger H. ( 1998) Negotiating European Works Councils: An Analysis of Agreements under Article 13. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities/ European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions.
34.
Marginson P., Hall M., Hoffman A., and Muller T. ( 2004) The impact of European works councils on management decision-making in UK- and US-based multinationals. British Journal of Industrial Relations42(2): 209-233.
35.
Robeyns I. ( 2005) The capability approach: A theoretical survey. Journal of Human Development6(1): 93-114.
36.
Salais R., Villeneuve R. ( 2004) Introduction: Europe and the politics of capabilities . In: Salais R, Villeneuve R (eds) Europe and the Politics of Capabilities . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1-20.
37.
Sen A. ( 1999) Development as Freedom. New York: Oxford University Press.
38.
Sen A. ( 2005) Human rights and capabilities. Journal of Human Development6(2): 151-166.
39.
Sisson K. ( 2002) The Information and Consultation Directive: Unnecessary ‘Regulation’ or an Opportunity to Promote ‘Partnership’? Warwick Papers in Industrial Relations, No. 67. Coventry : Industrial Relations Research Unit, University of Warwick.
40.
Storper M., Salais R. ( 1997) Worlds of Production: The Action Frameworks of the Economy . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
41.
Terry M. ( 1999) Systems of collective employee representation in non-union firms in the UK. Industrial Relations Journal30(1): 16-30.
42.
Terry M. ( 2003) Partnership and the future of trade unions. Economic and Industrial Democracy24(4): 485-507.
43.
Upchurch M., Richardson M., Tailby S., Danford A., and Stewart P. ( 2006) Employee representation and partnership in the non-union sector: A paradox of intention? Human Resource Management Journal16(4): 393-410.
44.
Zimmerman B. ( 2006) Pragmatism and the capability approach: Challenges in social theory and empirical research. European Journal of Social Theory9(4): 467-484.
