This paper evaluates the development and subsequent outcome of the Algerian experience of participative management. In Algeria, participation was seen as an important determinant in the country's socioeconomic development and was constituted under conditions of hope to blend the ideology of the state with the existing social structure through centralized and bureaucratic planning. However, the outcome was not as expected, either by the state, workers or managers. It has been a disappointing experience for all. It is argued here that the failure of participative management in Algeria is the result of introducing views and ideologies alien to the predominant norms and cultural values. Some of the studies that have attempted to explain the outcome of the Algerian experience are presented and criticized, and an alternative explanation is offered.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Akkache, A. (1973) 'Les premieres assembles des travailleurs', Revue Algerienne du Travail 12.
2.
Algerie Actualite'. Alger: FLN (Front de Liberation Nationale), published weekly.
3.
Algerie Economie. Alger: Ministere de l'Economie, published weekly.
4.
Annuaire Statistique de l'Algerie (1990). Alger: Direction Generale des Statistiques.
5.
Benachenhou, A. (1980) Planification et de'veloppement en Algerie 1962-1980. Alger: ed. CREA (Centre de Recherches en Economie Appliquee).
6.
Benamrane, D. (1980) Crise de l'habitat: perspective et developpement socialiste en Algerie. Alger: ed. CREA (Centre de Recherches en Economie Appliquee).
7.
Benhouria, T. (1980) L'economie de l'Algerie. Paris: Maspero.
8.
Benissad, M.E.
(1982) 'Demographie et problemes sociaux en Algerie', The Maghreb Review7(3): 73-82.
9.
Bennoune, M.
(1976) 'The Origins of the Algerian Proletariat', Dialectical Anthropology1(3): 201-223.
10.
Bennoune, M.
(1988) The Making of Contemporary Algeria. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
11.
Blair, T.
(1969) The Land To Those Who Work It. New York: Garden City, Doubleday.
12.
Boumedienne, H. (1976) Les Discours du Pr6sident Boumedienne (1965-1975). Alger: FLN Publications.
13.
Boussoumah, M. (1982) L'entreprise socialiste en Algerie. Paris: Economica.
14.
Boutefnouchet, M. (1982) Le socialisme dans l'entreprise, 2nd edn. Alger: ENAP/ OPU.
15.
Bouyacoub, A. (1987) La gestion de l'entreprise industrielle publique en Algerie. Alger: Office des Publications Universitaires (OPU).
16.
Chaulet, C. (1971) La Mitidja autogeree. Alger: SNED.
17.
Chikhi, S. (1986) 'Greve et societe en Algerie: 1969-1985', Les Cahiers du CREAD (Revue du Centre de Recherches en Economie Appliquee pour le Developpement) 6(2eme trimestre): 85-129.
18.
Clegg, I.
(1971) Workers' Self-management in Algeria. London: Penguin.
19.
El Djeich. Alger: ANP (Armee Nationale Populaire), published weekly in Arabic and French.
20.
El Moudjahid. Alger: FLN, daily official newspaper, in French.
21.
El Moudjahid. Alger: FLN, weekly magazine in Arabic and French.
22.
El-Toura Ul-Amal. Alger: UGTA, weekly newspaper in Arabic.
23.
Ecrement, M. (1986) Ind6pendence politique et libe'ration 6conomique: un quart de siecle du developpement de l'Algdrie, 1962-1985. Alger: ENAP and PU de Grenoble.
24.
Farsoun, K.
(1975) 'State Capitalism in Algeria', Middle East Research and Information Project, Report No. 35: 3-30. Washington DC: University of Washington DC Press.
25.
Gestion Socialiste des Entreprises: Charte et textes d'application (1975) Alger: FLN/EPA.
26.
Ghezali, M. (1981) La participation des travailleurs a la ge'stion socialiste des entreprises, 2nd edn. Alger: Office des Publications Universitaires (OPU).
27.
Jackson, H.F.
(1977) The FLN in Algeria: Party Development in a Revolutionary Society. London: Greenwood Press.
28.
La Charte Nationale (1976) Alger: FLN/NIE. (Translated into English as The National Charter in 1981 by the Ministry of Culture and Information, Algiers.)
29.
Laks, M. (1970) Autoge'stion ouvriere et pouvoir politique en Alge'rie, 1962-1965. Paris: Edition des Etudes et Documentations Internationales de Paris.
30.
Lammers, C.J.
and G. Szell (eds) (1989) International Handbook of Participation in Organisations. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
31.
La Republique. Oran: FLN, daily regional (West Algeria) newspaper.
32.
Lawless, R.I.
(1984) 'Algeria: The Contradictions of Rapid Industrialisation', in R.I. Lawless and A. Findlay (eds), North Africa: Contemporary Politics and Economic Development. New York: Croom Helm.
33.
Lazreg, M.
(1976) The Emergence of Classes in Algeria: A Study of Colonialism and Socio-political Change. Boulder, CO: Westview Press Boulder.
34.
Liabes, D. (1984) 'Structuration economique, emergence des classes sociales et constitution de l'etat-nation: la necessite d'une mise en relation', Les Cahiers du CREA 3.
35.
Nellis, J.R.
(1977) 'Socialist Management in Algeria', Journal of Modern African Studies15(4): 529-554.
36.
Nellis, J.R.
(1980) 'Maladministration: Cause or Result of Underdevelopment? The Algerian Example', Canadian Journal of African Studies13: 407-422.
37.
Niar, K.S. (1982) 'Algerie 1954-1982: forces sociales et blocs au pouvoir', Les Temps Modernes 432/433.
38.
Ottaway, D.
and M. Ottaway (1970) Algeria: The Politics of a Socialist Revolution. California: University of California Press.
39.
Ourabeh, M. (1982) Les transformations e'conomiques de l'Algerie au 20eme anniversaire de l'independence. Alger: ENAP.
40.
Raffinot, M. and P. Jacquemot (1977) Le Capitalisme d'etat Alge'rien. Paris: Maspero.
41.
Rcvolution Africaine. Alger: FLN, weekly political review magazine.
42.
Re'volution et Travail. Alger: UGTA, weekly labour review magazine.
43.
Roberts, H.
(1984) 'The Politics of Algerian Socialism', in R. Lawless and A. Findlay (eds), North Africa: Contemporary Politics and Economic Development. New York: Croom Helm.
44.
Saadi, R.N. (1982) 'Syndicat et relations du travail dans les entreprises socialistes en Algerie', Annuaire de l'Afrique du Nord 21: 123-32.
45.
Saadi, R.N. (1985) La g0stion socialiste des entreprises en Algerie: essai d'evaluation. Alger: Office des Publications Universitaires (OPU).
46.
Said-Amar, T. (1978) L'industrialisation en Algerie: l'entreprise alge'rienne dans le developpement. Paris: Anthropos.
47.
Said-Amar, T. (1981) Le d6veloppement industrial de l'Algefrie. Paris: Anthropos. SME Charter (Charte et Code de la Gestion Socialiste des Entreprises) (1971) Alger: FLN.
48.
Temmar, H.M. (1983) Strategie de developpement independant: le cas de l'Algerie: Un bilan. Alger: Office des Publications Universitaires.
