Eccentric Viewing Training and Its Effect on the Reading Rates of Individuals with Absolute Central Scotomas: A Meta-analysis

Abstract

Introduction

Eccentric viewing training has been a strategy, used by rehabilitation professionals, to help individuals with central vision loss move their eyes in such a way that they focus the incoming light on parts of the retina located away from the center area that has been damaged and improve visual functioning. A number of studies have shown that this type of training can be associated with improved reading rates.

Method

A meta-analysis was conducted on data generated from 17 studies that reported the effect of appropriate magnification and eccentric viewing training on the reading rate of trainees with central scotomas.

Results

Almost all eccentric viewing training methodologies were found to be associated with comparable final reading speeds, and no significant differences in final reading speed were found between eccentric viewing training methodologies with comparable age participants. A negative relationship between age and final reading speed was found through correlation analysis, and a correlation was found between visual acuity and the percentage of change in reading speed. Regression models using combinations of age, acuity, and treatment hours were found that could be used to predict the final reading rate using age and number of training hours.

Discussion

This analysis provided no statistical basis to determine if one of the treatment protocols described in these studies was more effective in improving the reading rate than another, and there was quite a bit of variability in the protocols described.

Implications for practice

Eccentric viewing is an effective way for individuals with central scotomas to improve the use of the vision that they have. Evidence from this meta-analysis suggests that a wide range of training protocols would be effective, and the personal preferences of the instructor and consumer can be given significant consideration during program planning.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Altaweel

(2010). Best disease. Retrieved from http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/1227128-overview

Altpeter

, Mackeben

, & Trauzettel-Klosinski

(2000). The importance of sustained attention for patients with maculopathies. Vision Research, 40, 1539–1547.

Bishop

V. E.

(1996). Causes and functional implications of visual impairment. In Corn

A. L.

, & Koenig

A. J.

(Eds.), Foundations of low vision. New York: AFB Press.

Blind Babies Foundation. (1999). Optic nerve atrophy pediatric visual diagnosis fact sheet. See/Hear, 4(1). Retrieved from http://www.tsbvi.edu/Outreach/seehear/spring99/ona.htm

Brantlinger

, Jimenez

, Klingner

, Pugach

, & Richardson

(2005). Qualitative studies in special education. Exceptional Children, 72, 195–207.

Bullimore

M. A.

, Bailey

I. L.

, & Wacker

R. T.

(1991). Face recognition in age-related maculopathy. Ophthalmology and Visual Science, 32, 2020–2029.

Cheong

, Lovie-Kitchen

, & Bowers

(2005). Short-term in-office practice improves reading performance with stand magnifiers for people with AMD. Investigations in Optometry and Vision Science, 82, 114–127.

Chung

S. T.

, Levi

D. M.

, & Li

R. W.

(2006). Learning to identify contrast-defined letters in peripheral vision. Vision Research, 46, 1038–1047.

Crossland

M. D.

, Culham

L. E.

, & Rubin

(2004). Fixation stability and reading speed in patients with newly developed macular disease. Ophthalmic and Physiological Optics, 24, 327–333.

10.

Crossland

M. D.

, Culham

L. E.

, Kabanarou

S. A.

, & Rubin

(2005). Preferred retinal locus development in patients with macular disease. Ophthalmology, 112, 1579–1585.

11.

Cummings

, Whittaker

, Watson

, & Budd

(1985). Scanning characters and reading with a central scotoma. American Journal of Optometry & Physiological Optics, 62, 833–843.

12.

Deruaz

, Goldschmidt

, Whatham

A. R.

, Mermoud

, Lorincz

E. N.

, Schnider

, & Safran

A. B.

(2006). A technique to train new oculomotor behavior in patients with central macular scotomas during reading-related tasks using scanning laser ophthalmoscopy: Immediate functional benefits and gains retention. BMC Ophthalmology, 6. Retrieved from http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2415/6/35

13.

Duret

, Issenhuth

, & Safran

(1999). Combined use of several preferred retinal loci in patients with macular disorders when reading single words. Vision Research, 39, 873–879.

14.

Fitzmaurice

, & Clarke

(2000). Training children in eccentric viewing: A case study. Journal of Visual Impairment & Blindness, 102, 160–166.

15.

Fletcher

, & Schuchard

(1997). Preferred retinal loci relationship to macular scotomas in a low-vision population. Ophthalmology, 104, 632–638.

16.

Fletcher

D. C.

, Schuchard

R. A.

, & Watson

(1999) Relative locations of macular scotomas near the PRL: Effect on low vision reading. Journal of Rehabilitation Research Development, 36, 356–364.

17.

Fornos

A. P.

, Sommerhalder

, Rappaz

, Pelizzone

, & Safran

(2006). Processes involved in oculomotor adaptation to eccentric reading. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, 47, 1439–1447.

18.

Frennesson

, Jakobsson

, & Nilsson

U. L.

(1995). A computer and video display-based system for training eccentric viewing in macular degeneration with an absolute central scotoma. Documenta Ophthalmologica, 91, 9–16.

19.

Frennesson

, Nilsson

U. L.

, Peebo

B. B.

, & Nilsson

S. E. G.

(2010). Significant improvements in near vision, reading speed, central visual field and related quality of life after ranibizumab treatment of wet age-related macular degeneration. Acta Ophthalmologica, 88, 420–425.

20.

Fuller

, & Schmiedecke

(2006). Rehabilitation of functional vision using eccentric viewing training in advanced ocular disease. Optometry, 77, 280.

21.

Glantz

S. A.

(2002). Primer in biostatistics. New York: McGraw-Hill.

22.

Goldschmidt

, Déruaz

, Lorincz

, & Whatham

(2010). Reading strategies in Stargardt's disease with foveal sparing. BMC Research Notes, 3, 1–19.

23.

Goodrich

(1986). Eccentric viewing training and low vision aids: Current practice and implications of peripheral retinal research. American Journal of Optometry & Physiological Optics, 63, 119–126.

24.

Graessley

, & Kirby

(1996). Literature review of current programs for training eccentric viewing. Journal of Vision Rehabilitation, 10, 19–21.

25.

Gustafsson

, & Inde

(2004). The Movi-Text method: Efficient pre-optical reading training in persons with central visual field loss. Technology & Disability, 16, 211–221.

26.

Hatlen

(2000). Historical perspectives. In Holbrook

M. C.

, & Koenig

A. J.

(Eds.), Foundations of education: Theory and history of teaching children and youth with visual impairments (pp. 1–54). New York: AFB Press.

27.

Holcomb

J. G.

, & Goodrich

G. L.

(1976). Eccentric viewing training. Journal of the American Optometric Association, 47, 1438–43

28.

(2004). Classroom strategies for improving and enhancing visual skills in students with disabilities. Teaching Exceptional Children, 36, 38–42.

29.

Logan

(2005). New view—community based training in eccentric viewing and steady eye strategy for reading. International Congress Series, 1282, 631–634.

30.

Messias

, Reinhard

, Cruz

, Dietz

, MacKeben

, & Trauzettel-Klosinski

(2007). Eccentric fixation in Stargardt's disease assessed by Tubingen perimetry. Investigations in Ophthalmology and Vision Science, 48, 5815–5822.

31.

National Eye Institute. (2010). National Eye Institute, National Institutes of Health, home page. Retrieved from http://www.nei.nih.gov

32.

Nhung

, Nguyen

, Stockum

, Hahn

, & Trauzettel-Klosinski

(2011). Training to improve reading speed in patients with juvenile macular dystrophy: A randomized study comparing two training methods. Acta Ophthalmologica, 89, e82–e88.

33.

Nilsson

U. L.

(1989). Visual rehabilitation of patients with advanced stages of glaucoma, optic atrophy, myopia or retinitis pigmentosa. Documenta Ophthalmology, 70, 363–83.

34.

Nilsson

U. L.

(1990). Visual rehabilitation with and without educational training in the use of optical aids and residual vision: A prospective study of patients with advanced age-related macular degeneration. Clinical Vision Sciences, 6, 3–10.

35.

Nilsson

U. L.

, & Nilsson

(1986). Rehabilitation of the visually handicapped with advanced macular degeneration. Documenta Ophthalmology, 62, 345–367.

36.

Nilsson

U. L.

, Frennesson

, & Nilsson

S. E.

(1998). Location and stability of a newly established eccentric retinal locus suitable for reading, achieved through training of patients with a dense central scotoma. Optometry and Vision Science, 75, 873–878.

37.

Nilsson

U. L.

, Frennesson

, & Nilsson

S. E. G.

(2003). Patients with AMD and a large absolute central scotoma can be trained successfully to use eccentric viewing, as demonstrated in a scanning laser ophthalmoscope. Vision Research, 43, 1777–1787.

38.

Palmer

, Logan

, Dutton

, & Nabili

(2009). Effective rehabilitation of reading by training in the technique of eccentric viewing: Evaluation of a four year programme of service delivery. The British Journal of Ophthalmology, 94, 494–497.

39.

Raasch

T. W.

(2004). What we don't know about eccentric viewing. British Journal of Ophthalmology, 88, 443.

40.

Retina International. (2010). Retina International home page. Retrieved from http://www.retina-international.org/index.php?menuid=38&reporeid=77

41.

Riordan-Eva

, & Whitcher

J. P.

(2004). Vaughan & Asbury's general ophthalmology (16th ed.). New York: Lange Medical Books, McGraw-Hill.

42.

Seiple

, Grant

, & Szlyk

J. P.

(2011). Reading rehabilitation of individuals with AMD: Relative effectiveness of training approaches. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, 52, 2938–2944.

43.

Seiple

, Szlyk

J. P.

, McMahon

, Pulido

, & Fishman

G. A.

(2005). Eye-movement training for reading in patients with age-related macular degeneration. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, 46, 2886–2896.

44.

Stelmack

, Massof

, & Stelmack

(2004). Is there a standard for eccentric viewing training? Journal of Rehabilitation Research & Development, 41, xiv.

45.

Sullivan

, Jovancevic

, Hayhoe

, & Sterns

(2005). Use of gaze in natural tasks in Stargardt's disease: A preferred retinal region. International Congress Series, 1282, 608–612.

46.

Sunness

, Applegate

, Haselwood

, & Rubin

(1996). Fixation patterns and reading rates in eyes with central scotomas from advanced atrophic age-related macular degeneration and Stargardt disease. Ophthalmology, 104, 1458–1466.

47.

Timberlake

G. T.

, Peli

, Essock

E. A.

, & Augliere

R. A.

(1987). Reading with a macular scotoma. II. Retinal locus for scanning text. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, 28, 1268–1274.

48.

Vingolo

E. M.

, Salvatore

, & Cavarretta

(2009). Low-vision rehabilitation by means of MP-1 biofeedback examination in patients with different macular diseases: A pilot study. Applied Psychophysiology Biofeedback, 34, 127–133.

49.

Vukicevic

, & Fitzmaurice

(2005a). Impact of eccentric viewing and magnification interventions on the performance of activities of daily living. International Congress Series, 1282, 544–54.

50.

Vukicevic

, & Fitzmaurice

(2005b). Rehabilitation strategies used to ameliorate the impact of centre field loss. Visual Impairment Research, 7, 79–84.

51.

Vukicevic

, & Fitzmaurice

(2009). Eccentric viewing training in the home environment: Can it improve the performance of activities of daily living? Journal of Visual Impairment & Blindness, 103, 277–290.

52.

Watson

G. R.

, Schuchard

R. A.

, De l'Aune

W. R.

, & Watkins

(2006). Effects of preferred retinal locus placement on text navigation and development of advantageous trained retinal locus. Journal of Rehabilitation Research & Development, 43, 761–770.

53.

Whittaker

(1988). Eccentric fixation with macular scotoma. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, 29, 268–278.

54.

, Cheung

, Legge

, & Chung

(2010). Reading speed in the peripheral visual field of older adults: Does it benefit from perceptual learning? Vision Research, 50, 860–869.

55.

D. Y.

(2010). Development of a training protocol to improve reading performance in peripheral vision. Vision Research, 50, 36–45.

56.

Zeevi

, Peli

, & Stark

(1979). Study of eccentric fixation with secondary visual feedback. Journal of the Optical Society of America, 69, 669–675.