Quality versus Quantity: The Case of Forward-Looking Disclosure

Abstract

Empirical studies do not make a clear distinction between the quantity and quality of disclosure. As it is generally assumed that the quantity of information has an implication in determining its quality, quantity measures are often used as proxy for disclosure quality. Nonetheless, the measurement of the quality of disclosure is recognized as a relevant question that is still open and the importance of developing measures of disclosure quality is emphasized in literature.

This paper disputes the idea that the quantity of disclosure is a sound proxy for the quality of disclosure. The adoption of multidimensional frameworks for the appreciation of disclosure is discussed and an index for quality disclosure is proposed. Moving from the assumption that high-quality information should usefully support external users in the judgment of past and future performance, we hypothesize that high-quality disclosure is positively associated with accuracy and negatively associated with the dispersion of analysts' earnings forecasts.

We show analytically that the proposed framework captures dimensions of annual report disclosure that are considered useful by financial analysts in forecasting earnings and that the proposed measure of disclosure quality has a stronger positive statistical association with accuracy and a stronger negative association with the dispersion of financial analysts' earnings forecasts than a simple index of disclosure quantity has.

Keywords

Measures of disclosure annual report disclosure quantity annual report disclosure quality forward-looking information and earnings forecasts

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ahmed

Courtis

J. K.

. 1999. “Association between Corporate Characteristics and Disclosure Levels in Annual Reports: A Meta Analysis”. British Accounting Review, 31 (1): 36–61.

AICPA (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants). 1994. Improving Business Reporting. A Customer Focus. New York: American Institute of Certified Public Accountants.

Amir

Lev

. 1996. “Value Relevance of Non-financial Information: The Wireless Communication Industry”. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 22 (August-December): 3–30.

ASB (Accounting Standard Board). 2005. Reporting Standards No. 1: Operating and Financial Review. London: The Accounting Standard Board.

Baginski

S. P.

Conrad

E. J.

Hassell

J. M.

. 1993. “The Effects of Management Forecast Precision on Equity Pricing and on the Assessment of Earnings Uncertainty”. The Accounting Review, 68 (October): 913–927.

Barron

O. E.

Kile

C. O.

O'Keefe

T. B.

. 1999. “MD&A Quality as a Measure by the SEC and Analysts' Earnings Forecasts”. Contemporary Accounting Research, 16 (Spring): 75–109.

Barth

M. E.

Hutton

A. P.

. 2004. “Analyst Earnings Forecast Revision and the Pricing of Accruals”. Review of Accounting Studies, 9: 59–96.

Beattie

V. A.

McInnes

Fearnley

. 2001. The Analysis of Narratives in Annual Reports: A Multidimesional Framework. Working paper series, University of Stirling.

Beattie

V. A.

McInnes

Fearnley

. 2002a. Narrative Reporting by Listed UK Companies: A Comparative Within-Sector Topic Analysis. Working paper series, University of Stirling.

10.

Beattie

V. A.

McInnes

B.B.

Fearnley

. 2002b. Through the Eyes of Management: A Study of Narrative Disclosures. An Interim Report. London: Centre for Business Performance, Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales.

11.

Beattie

V. A.

McInnes

Fearnley

. 2004. “A Methodology for Analysing and Evaluating Narratives in Annual Reports: A Comprehensive Description Profile and Metrics for Disclosure Quality Attributes”. Accounting Forum, 28: 205–236.

12.

Beaver

W. H.

Demski

J. S.

. 1979. “The Nature of Income Measurement”. The Accounting Review, 54 (January): 38–47.

13.

Bell

T. B.

Marrs

F. O.

Solomon

Thomas

. 1997. Auditing Organizations Through a Strategic-Lens Systems Lens. The KPMG Business Measurement Process. Chicago, IL: KPMG Monograph.

14.

Beretta

Bozzolan

. 2004. A Framework for the Analysis of Firm Risk Communication”. The International Journal of Accounting, 39 (3): 265–288.

15.

Botosan

C. A.

1997. “Disclosure Level and the Cost of Equity Capital”. The Accounting Review, 72 (July): 323–349.

16.

Botosan

C. A.

2004. “Discussion of a Framework for the Analysis of Firm Risk Communication”. The International Journal of Accounting, 39 (3): 289–295.

17.

Botosan

C. A.

Plumlee

M. A.

Xie

. 2004. “The Role of Information Precision in Determining the Cost of Equity Capital”. Review of Accounting Studies, 9: 233–259.

18.

Breton

Taffler

R. J.

. 2001. “Accounting Information and Analyst Stock Recommendation Decision: A Content Analysis Approach”. Accounting and Business Research, 31 (Spring): 91–101.

19.

Carlon

Loftus

J. A.

Miller

M. C.

. 2000. Risk Reporting: Conceptual Issues, Regulatory Approaches and Voluntary Disclosures. Munich: 23rd Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association.

20.

Chow

C. W.

Wong-Boren

. 1987. “Voluntary Financial Disclosure by Mexican Corporations”. The Accounting Review, 62 (July): 533–541.

21.

CICA (Canadian Institute of Chartered Accountants). 2001. Management's Discussion and Analysis; Guidance on Preparation and Disclosure. Ottawa: Canadian Institute of Chartered Accountants.

22.

Cole

Jones

. 2004. “The Usefulness of MD&A Disclosures in the Retail Industry”. Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance (Fall): 361–368.

23.

Cooke

T. E.

1992. “The Impact of Size, Stock Market Listing and Industry Type on Disclosure in the Annual Report of Japanese Listed Corporations”. Accounting and Business Research, 22 (Summer): 229–237.

24.

Cooke

T. E.

Wallace

R. S. O.

. 1989. “Global Surveys of Corporate Disclosure Practices and Audit Firms: A Review Essay”. Accounting and Business Research, 19 (Winter): 47–57.

25.

Core

J. E.

2001. “A Review of the Empirical Disclosure Literature”. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 31 (3): 441–456.

26.

De Loach

J. W.

2000. Enterprise-wide Risk Management: Strategies for Linking Risk and Opportunities. London: Prentice-Hall.

27.

Eccles

R. G.

Herz

R. H.

Keegan

E. M.

Phillips

D. M. H.

. 2001. The Value Reporting Revolution: Moving beyond the Earnings Game. New York: Wiley.

28.

FASB (Financial Accounting Standard Board). 1980. Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No. 2: Qualitative Characteristics of Accounting Information. Norwalk, CT: Financial Accounting Standard Board.

29.

FASB (Financial Accounting Standard Board). 2001. Improving Business Reporting: Insights into Enhancing Voluntary Disclosures. Steering Committee Report, Business Reporting Research Project. Norwalk, CT: Financial Accounting Standard Board.

30.

Firth

1979. “Impact of Size, Stock Market Listings and Auditors on Voluntary Disclosure in Annual Reports”. Accounting and Business Research, 9 (36): 273–280.

31.

Francis

Schipper

. 1999. “Have Financial Statements Lost Their Relevance?” Journal of Accounting Research, 37 (Autumn): 319–352.

32.

Hackston

Milne

M. J.

. 1996. “Some Determinants of Social and Environmental Disclosures in New Zealand Companies”. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 9 (1): 77–108.

33.

Hausman

J. A.

1978. “Specification Test in Econometrics”. Econometrica, 45: 319–339.

34.

Healy

P. M.

Palepu

K. G.

. 2001. “Information Asymmetry, Corporate Disclosure, and the Capital Markets: A Review of the Empirical Disclosure Literature”. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 31: 405–440.

35.

Hooks

Coy

Davey

. 2002. “The Annual Report in New Zealand Electricity Companies: Assessing Quality”. Pacific Accounting Review, 13 (2): 35–69.

36.

Hope

O. K.

2003a. “Disclosure Practices, Enforcement of Accounting Standards, and Analysts' Forecast Accuracy: An International Study”. Journal of Accounting Research, 41 (May): 235–272.

37.

Hope

O. K.

2003b. “Accounting Policy Disclosures and Analysts' Forecasts”. Contemporary Accounting Research, 20 (Summer): 295–321.

38.

Hussainey

Schleicher

Walker

. 2003. “Undertaking Large Scale Disclosure Studies When AIMR-FAF Ratings Are Not Available: The Case of Price Leading Earnings”. Accounting and Business Research, 33 (4): 275–294.

39.

IASB (International Accounting Standards Committee Foundation). 1989. The Framework for the Preparation and Presentation of Financial Statements. London: International Accounting Standards Committee Foundation.

40.

ICAEW (Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales). 2000. No Surprises: The Case for Better Risk Reporting. London: Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales.

41.

Kajüter

2003. Risk Reporting in Germany: Evidence from a Longitudinal Study. Working paper, Department of Auditing and Control, Düsseldorf University.

42.

Krippendorf

1980. Content Analysis: An Introduction to Its Methodology. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.

43.

Lajili

Zéghal

. 2005. “Content Analysis of Risk Management Disclosures in Canadian Annual Reports”. Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences, 22: 125–142.

44.

Lang

M. H.

Lundholm

R. J.

. 1993. “Cross-Sectional Determinants of Analysts' Ratings of Corporate Disclosure”. Journal of Accounting Research, 31 (Autumn): 246–271.

45.

Lang

M. H.

Lundholm

R. J.

. 1996. “Corporate Disclosure Policy and Analyst Behaviour”. The Accounting Review, 71 (October): 467–492.

46.

Lev

Zarowin

. 1999. “The Boundaries of Financial Reporting and How to Extend Them”. Journal of Accounting Research, 37 (Autumn): 353–385.

47.

Linsley

Shrives

. 2006. “Risk Reporting: A Study of Risk Disclosures in Annual Reports of UK Companies”. The British Accounting Review, 38 (4): 387–404.

48.

LSE (London Stock Exchange), Committee on Corporate Governance. 1999. The Combined Code, London: London Stock Exchange.

49.

Marston

C. L.

Shrives

P. J.

. 1991. “The Use of Disclosure Indices in Accounting Research: A Review Article”. British Accounting Review, 23: 195–210.

50.

Milne

M. J.

Adler

R. W.

. 1999. “Exploring the Reliability of Social and Environmental Disclosures Content Analysis”. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 12 (2): 237–256.

51.

Naser

Nuseibeh

. 2003. “Quality of Financial Reporting: Evidence from the Listed Saudi Nonfinancial Companies”. The International Journal of Accounting, 38 (1): 41–70.

52.

Raffournier

1995. “The Determinants of Voluntary Financial Disclosure by Swiss Listed Companies”. European Accounting Review, 4 (2): 261–280.

53.

Robb

S. W. G.

Single

L. E.

Zarzeski

M. T.

. 2001. “Non-financial Disclosures across Anglo-American Countries”. Journal of International Accounting, 10 (1): 71–83.

54.

Schleicher

Walker

. 1999. “Share Price Anticipation of Earnings and Management's Discussion of Operations and Financing”. Accounting and Business Research, 29 (4): 321–335.

55.

Shihvi

S. S.

Desai

H. B.

. 1971. “An Empirical Analysis of the Quality of Corporate Disclosure”. The Accounting Review, 39 (January): 129–138.

56.

Shrives

Linsley

. 2002. Communicating Risk to Shareholders and Other Stakeholders: An Empirical Study. Copenhagen: 25th Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association.

57.

Smith

Taffler

R. J.

. 1995. “The Incremental Effect of Narrative Accounting Information in Corporate Annual Reports”. Journal of Business, Finance & Accounting, 22 (December): 1195–1210.

58.

Vanstraelen

Zarzewski

M. T.

Robb

S. W. G.

. 2003. “Corporate Non-financial Disclosure Practices and Financial Analyst Forecast Ability across Three European Countries”. Journal of International Financial Management and Accounting, 14 (3): 249–278.

59.

Wallman

S. M. H.

1995. “The Future of Accounting and Disclosure in an Evolving World: The Need for Dramatic Change”. Accounting Horizons, 9 (September): 81–91.

60.

Wallman

S. M. H.

1996. “The Future of Accounting and Financial Reporting Part II: The Colorized Approach”. Accounting Horizons, 10 (June): 138–148.

61.

Wooldridge

J. M.

2002. Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

62.

Wooldridge

J. M.

2003. Introductory Econometrics. A Modern Approach. Mason, OH: Thompson Learning.