Students’ Sense of Belonging in Technical/Vocational Schools versus Academic Schools: The Mediating Role of Faculty Trust in Students

Abstract

Background

Since the late 1960s, research has demonstrated repeatedly that students in lower tracks achieve less as they develop an antischool culture to overcome the status deprivation resulting from being in a lower track. In quantitative large-scale research, this anti-school culture is usually assessed using poor academic attitudes or study disengagement because antischool norms disengage students from the learning process. The extent to which students in different tracks feel embedded in their school communities—their sense of school belonging—has rarely been examined, although academic engagement and sense of belonging are related to each other and to achievement.

Objective

This article examines students’ sense of belonging in secondary schools that offer different tracks, and the role played by the faculty's trust in the students.

Participants

The study is based on data from 3,475 students and 754 teachers in 28 technical/vocational schools and 3,376 students and 461 teachers in 22 academic schools in Flanders, the northern, Dutch-speaking part of Belgium.

Research Design

Use is made of (stepwise) multilevel analyses (HLM6).

Results

The analyses show that students in technical/vocational schools have a significant lower sense of belonging than students in academic schools. This association disappears if we take into account faculty trust in students. The association between school type and perceived teacher support, a subdimension of the sense of belonging, is not mediated by faculty trust, but is due to the lower GPA of students in technical/vocational schools.

Conclusions

The results indicate that teachers play a crucial role in the divergent nature of students’ social integration across different types of schools. In terms of strengthening students’ connectedness to a technical/vocational school environment, our results indicate that strengthening teachers’ level of trust in students could be crucial.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abraham

(1989). Testing Hargreaves’ and Lacey's differentiation-polarisation theory in a setted comprehensive. British Journal of Sociology, 40, 46–81.

Anderman

L. H.

(2003). Academic and social perceptions as predictors of change in middle school students’ sense of school belonging. Journal of Experimental Education, 72, 5–22.

Araùjo

(2007). “Modernising the comprehensive principle”: Selection, setting and the institutionalisation of educational failure. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 28, 241–257.

Ball

S. J.

(1981). Beachside comprehensive: A case-study of secondary schooling. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

Berends

(1995). Educational stratification and students’ social bonding to school. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 16, 327–351.

Bidwell

C. E.

(2000). School as context and construction. In Hallinan

M. T.

(Ed), Handbook of the sociology of education. (pp. 15–36). New York: Plenum.

Boaler

, William

, & Brown

(2000). Students’ experiences of ability grouping: Disaffection, polarisation and the construction of failure. British Educational Research Journal, 26, 631–646.

Bradach

J. L.

, & Eccles

R. G.

(1989). Price, authority, and trust: From ideal types to plural forms. Annual Review of Sociology, 15, 97–118.

Brutsaert

(2001). Co-educatie. Studiekansen en kwaliteit van het schoolleven.[Coeducation: Educational opportunities and the quality of school life]. Leuven-Apeldoorn, The Netherlands: Garant.

10.

Bryk

A. S.

, Lee

V. E.

, & Holland

P. B.

(1993). Catholic schools and the common good. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

11.

Bryk

A. S.

, & Raudenbush

(1992). Hierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis methods. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

12.

Bryk

A. S.

, & Schneider

(2002). Trust in schools. A core resource for improvement. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.

13.

Carbonaro

(2005). Tracking, students’ effort, and academic achievement. Sociology of Education, 78, 27–49.

14.

Catsambis

, Mulkey

L. M.

, & Crain

R. L.

(1999). To track or not to track? The social effects of gender and middle school tracking. Research in Sociology of Education and Socialization, 12, 135–163.

15.

Caughlan

, & Kelly

(2004). Bridging methodological gaps: Instructional and institutional effects of tracking in two English classes. Research in the Teaching of English, 39(1), 20–62.

16.

Coleman

J. S.

(1988). Social capital in the creation of human capital. American Journal of Sociology, 94(Suppl.), S95–S120.

17.

Coleman

J. S.

(1990). Foundations of social theory. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press.

18.

Coleman

J. S.

, & Hoffer

(1987). Public and private high schools: The impact of communities. New York: Basic Books.

19.

Croninger

R. G.

, & Lee

V. E.

(2001). Social capital and dropping out of high school: Benefits to at-risk students of teachers’ support and guidance. Teachers College Record, 103, 548–581.

20.

Crosnoe

, Johnson

M. K.

, & Elder

G. H.

Jr. (2004). Intergenerational bonding in school: The behavioral and contextual correlates of student-teacher relationships. Sociology of Education, 77, 60–81.

21.

Delrue

(2003). Zure druiven, zoete krenten? Een schooletnografisch onderzoek in het secundair onderwijs.[Sour grapes, sweet currants? School ethnographic research in secondary education]. Ghent, Belgium: Steunpunt Intercultureel Onderwijs, Universiteit Gent.

22.

Department of Education. (2005). Statistisch Jaarboek van het Vlaams Onderwijs.–Schooljaar 2004–2005.[Statistical year book of Flemish education: School year 2004–2005]. Brussels, Belgium: Ministerie van de Vlaamse Gemeenschap.

23.

Duru-Bellat

, & Mingat

(1997). La constitution de classes de niveau dans les colleges: Les effets pervers d'une pratique à visée égalisatrice [Multilevel classrooms in French secondary schools: The perverse effects of a supposedly egalitarian practice]. Revue Française de Sociologie, 38, 759–789.

24.

Ennis

C. D.

, & McCauley

M. T.

(2002). Creating urban classroom communities worthy of trust. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 34, 149–172.

25.

Erikson

, Goldthorpe

J. H.

, & Portocarero

(1979). Intergenerational class mobility in three Western European societies: England, France and Sweden. British Journal of Sociology, 30, 415–441.

26.

Evertson

C. M.

(1982). Differences in instructional activities in higher- and lower-achieving junior high English and math classes. Elementary School Journal, 82, 329–350.

27.

Faircloth

B. S.

, & Hamm

J. V.

(2005). Sense of belonging among high school students representing four ethnic groups. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 34, 293–309.

28.

Fang

(1996). A review of research on teacher beliefs and practices. Educational Research, 38(1), 47–65.

29.

Finn

J. D.

(1972). Expectations and the educational environment. Review of Educational Research, 42, 387–410.

30.

Finn

J. D.

(1989). Withdrawing from school. Review of Educational Research, 59, 117–142.

31.

Fletcher

, Bonell

, Sorhaindo

, & Strange

(2009). How might schools influence young people's drug use? Development of theory from qualitative case-study research. Journal of Adolescent Health, 45, 126–132.

32.

Friedkin

N. E.

, & Thomas

S. L.

(1997). Social positions in schooling. Sociology of Education, 70, 239–255.

33.

Gamoran

, Nystrand

, Berends

, & LePore

P. C.

(1995). An organizational analysis of the effects of ability grouping. American Educational Research Journal, 32, 687–715.

34.

Glick

W. H.

(1985). Conceptualizing and measuring organizational and psychological climate: Pitfalls in multilevel research. Academy of Management Review, 10, 601–616.

35.

Goddard

R. D.

, Tschannen-Moran

, & Hoy

W. K.

(2001). A multilevel examination of the distribution and effects of teacher trust in students and parents in urban elementary schools. Elementary School Journal, 102, 3–17.

36.

Goodenow

(1993a). The psychological sense of school membership among adolescents: Scale development and educational correlates. Psychology in the Schools, 30(1), 79–90.

37.

Goodenow

(1993b). Classroom belonging among early adolescent students: Relationships to motivation and achievement. Journal of Early Adolescence, 13, 21–43.

38.

Goodlad

J. I.

(1984). A place called school: Prospects for the future. New York: McGraw-Hill.

39.

Govier

(1992). Distrust as a practical problem. Journal of Social Philosophy, 23, 52–63.

40.

Groenez

(2010). Onderwijsexpansie en democratisering in Vlaanderen [Educational expansion and inequality of educational opportunity in Flanders]. Tijdschrift voor Sociologie, Sociologische lessen over onderwijs, 31(3–4), 199–238.

41.

Hallinan

M. T.

(2008). Teacher influences on students’ attachment to school. Sociology of Education, 81, 271–283.

42.

Hallinan

M. T.

, & Kubitschek

W. N.

(1999). Curriculum differentiation and high school achievement. Social Psychology of Education, 3(1–2), 41–62.

43.

Halpin

A. W.

(1959). The leader behavior of school superintendents. Chicago: Midwest Administrative Center.

44.

Hansen

(1998). The importance of the person in the role of teacher. Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal, 15, 391–405.

45.

Hargreaves

(1992). Cultures of teaching: A focus for change. In Hargreaves

, & Fullan

(Eds.), Understanding teacher development. (pp. 216–240). New York: Teachers College Press.

46.

Hargreaves

D. H.

(1967). Social relations in a secondary school. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

47.

Hargreaves

D. H.

(2001). A capital theory of school effectiveness and improvement. British Educational Research Journal, 27, 487–503.

48.

Hofstede

, Neuijen

, Ohavy

D. D.

, & Sanders

(1990). Measuring organizational cultures—A qualitative and quantitative study across 20 cases. Administrative Science Quarterly, 35, 286–316.

49.

Hoy

W. K.

, & Kupersmith

W. J.

(1985). The meaning and measure of faculty trust. Educational and Psychological Research, 5(1), 1–10.

50.

Hoy

W. K.

, & Tschannen-Moran

(1999). Five faces of trust: An empirical confirmation in urban elementary schools. Journal of School Leadership, 9, 184–208.

51.

Hoy

W. K.

, & Tschannen-Moran

(2003). The conceptualization and measurement of faculty trust in schools: The Omnibus T-Scale. In Hoy

W. K.

, & Miskel

C. G.

(Eds.), Studies in leading and organizing schools. (pp. 181–208). Greenwich, CT: Information Age.

52.

Huisman

(2000). Imputation of missing item responses: Some simple techniques. Quality and Quantity, 34, 331–351.

53.

Ireson

, & Hallam

(2005). Pupils’ liking for school: Ability grouping, self-concept and perceptions of teaching. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 75, 297–311.

54.

Jimerson

, Campos

R. E.

, & Greif

J. L.

(2003). Toward an understanding of definitions and measures of school engagement and related terms. California School Psychologist, 8, 7–27.

55.

Johnson

M. K.

, Crosnoe

, & Elder

G. H.

Jr. (2001). Students’ attachment and academic engagement: The role of race and ethnicity. Sociology of Education, 74, 318–340.

56.

Jones

, & James

(1979). Psychological climate: Dimensions and relationships of individual and aggregated work environment perceptions. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 23, 201–250.

57.

Jones

(1996). Trust as an affective attitude. Ethics, 107, 4–25.

58.

Jussim

(1986). Self-fulfilling prophecies: A theoretical and integrative review. Psychological Review, 93, 429–445.

59.

Kelly

(2008). What types of students’ effort are rewarded with high marks? Sociology of Education, 81, 32–52.

60.

Lacey

(1970). Hightown grammar: The school as a social system. Manchester, England: Manchester University Press.

61.

Leana

C. R.

, & Van Buren

H. J.

III (1999). Organizational social capital and employment practices. Academy of Management Review, 24, 538–555.

62.

Libbey

H. P.

(2004). Measuring student relationships to school: Attachment, bonding, connectedness, and engagement. Journal of School Health, 74, 274–283.

63.

(2003). Sense of belonging to school: Can schools make a difference? Journal of Educational Research, 96, 340–349.

64.

McAllister

D. J.

(1995). Affect- and cognition-based trust as foundations for interpersonal cooperation in organizations. Academy of Management Journal, 38, 24–59.

65.

McLaughlin

M. W.

(1993). What matters most in teachers’ workplace context? In Little

J. W.

, & McLaughlin

M. W.

(Eds.), Teachers’ work: Individuals, colleagues, and contexts. (pp. 79–103). New York: Teachers College Press.

66.

McMahon

S. D.

, Wernsman

, & Rose

D. S.

(2009). The relation of classroom environment and school belonging to academic self-efficacy among urban fourth- and fifth-grade students. Elementary School Journal, 109, 267–281.

67.

McNeely

C. A.

, Nonnemaker

J. M.

, & Blum

R. W.

(2002). Promoting school connectedness: Evidence from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health. Journal of School Health, 72, 138–146.

68.

Metz

M. H.

(1978). Classrooms and corridors: The crisis of authority in desegregated secondary schools. Berkeley: University of California Press.

69.

Metz

M. H.

(1993). Teachers’ ultimate dependence on their students. In Little

J. W.

, & McLaughlin

M. W.

(Eds.), Teachers’ work: Individuals, colleagues, and contexts. (pp. 104–136). New York: Teachers College Press.

70.

Midgley

, Feldlaufer

, & Eccles

J. S.

(1988). The transition to junior high school: B Beliefs of pre- and post-transition teachers. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 17, 543–562.

71.

Murphy

, & Hallinger

(1989). Equity as access to learning: Curricular and instructional treatment differences. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 21, 129–149.

72.

Oakes

(1985). Keeping track: How schools structure inequality. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

73.

Osterman

K. F.

(2000). Students’ need for belonging in the school community. Review of Educational Research, 70, 323–367.

74.

Page

(1991). Lower track classrooms: A curricular and cultural perspective. New York: Teachers College Press.

75.

Pelleriaux

(2001). Demotie en Burgerschap. De Culturele Constructie van Ongelijkheid in de Kennismaatschappij.[Demotion and citizenship: The cultural construction of inequality in the information society]. Brussels, Belgium: VUBPRESS.

76.

Persell

C. H.

(1977). Education and inequality: The roots and results of stratification in America's schools. New York: Free Press.

77.

Rosenbaum

J. E.

(1976). Making inequality: The hidden curriculum of high school tracking. New York: Wiley.

78.

Rousseau

D. M.

, Sitkin

S. B.

, Burt

R. S.

, & Camerer

(1998). Not so different after all: A cross-discipline view of trust. Academy of Management Review, 23, 393–404.

79.

Schofield

J. W.

(2006). Migration background, minority-group membership and academic achievement research evidence from social, educational, and developmental psychology. AKI Research Review. 5. Retrieved from http://www2000.wzb.eu/alt/aki/files/aki_research_review_5_summary.pdf

80.

Schwartz

(1981). Supporting or subverting learning: Peer group patterns in four tracked schools. Anthropology and Education Quarterly, 12, 99–121.

81.

Shamir

, & Lapidot

(2003). Trust in organizational supervisors: Systemic and collective considerations. Organization Studies, 24, 463–491.

82.

Shrout

P. E.

, & Fleiss

J. L.

(1979). Intraclass correlations: Uses in assessing rater reliability. Psychological Bulletin, 86, 420–428.

83.

Smerdon

B. A.

(2002). Students’ perceptions of membership in their high schools. Sociology of Education, 75, 287–305.

84.

Smith

P. A.

, Hoy

W. K.

, & Sweetland

S. R.

(2001). Organizational health of high schools and dimensions of faculty trust. Journal of School Leadership, 11, 135–151.

85.

Smyth

(2004). Social capital and the “socially just school.” British Journal of Sociology of Education, 25, 19–33.

86.

Stanton-Salazar

R. D.

(1997). A social capital framework for understanding the socialization of racial minority children and youths. Harvard Educational Review, 67, 1–40.

87.

Stanton-Salazar

R. D.

, & Dornbusch

S. M.

(1995). Social capital and the reproduction of inequality: Information networks among Mexican-origin high school students. Sociology of Education, 68, 116–135.

88.

Stevens

P. A. J.

(2007). Exploring the importance of teachers’ institutional structure on the development of teachers’ standards of assessment in Belgium. Sociology of Education, 80, 314–329.

89.

Stevens

P. A. J.

(2008). Exploring pupils’ perceptions of teacher racism in their context: A case study of Turkish and Belgian vocational education pupils in a Belgian school. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 29, 175–187.

90.

Stevens

P. A. J.

, & Vermeersch

(2010). Streaming in Flemish secondary schools: Exploring teachers’ perceptions of and adaptations to students in different streams. Oxford Review of Education, 36, 267–284.

91.

Tan

(1998). Blijvende sociale ongelijkheden in het Vlaamse onderwijs [Persistent social inequalities in Flemish education]. Tijdschrift voor Sociologie, 19, 169–197.

92.

Thomas

, & Thomas

(1928). The child in America: Behavior problems and programs. New York: Knopf.

93.

Timmerman

, Hermans

, & Hoornaert

(2002). Allochtone jongeren in het onderwijs. Een multidisciplinair perspectief.[Allochthonous youngsters in education: A multidisciplinary perspective]. Leuven-Apeldoorn, The Netherlands: Garant.

94.

Tschannen-Moran

(2004). Trust matters: Leadership for successful schools. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

95.

Tschannen-Moran

, & Hoy

W.K.

(2000). A multidisciplinary analysis of the nature, meaning, and measurement of trust. Review of Educational Research, 70, 547–593.

96.

Van de Gaer

, Pustjes

, Van Damme

, & De Munter

(2006). Tracking and the effects of school-related attitudes on the language achievement of boys and girls. British Journal of Sociology of Education. 27, 293–309.

97.

Van Houtte

(2004). Tracking effects on school achievement: A quantitative explanation in terms of the academic culture of school staff. American Journal of Education, 110, 354–388.

98.

Van Houtte

(2006a). School type and academic culture: Quantitative evidence for the differentiation-polarisation theory. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 38, 273–292.

99.

Van Houtte

(2006b). Tracking and teacher satisfaction: The role of study culture and trust. Journal of Educational Research, 99, 247–254.

100.

Van Houtte

, & Stevens

P. A. J.

(2009a). Study involvement of academic and vocational students: Does between-school tracking sharpen the difference? American Educational Research Journal, 46, 943–973.

101.

Van Houtte

, & Stevens

P. A. J.

(2009b). School ethnic composition and students’ integration outside and inside schools in Belgium. Sociology of Education, 82, 217–239.

102.

Van Houtte

, Stevens

P. A. J.

, Sels

, Soens

, & Van Rossem

(2005). De invloed van structurele en compositorische schoolkenmerken op prestaties en welbevinden van leerlingen in het secundair onderwijs. Een verklaring via cultuur. Eerste verslag verloop en stand onderzoek (niet gepubliceerd) [The influence of structural and compositional school features on achievement and well-being of secondary school students. An explanation through culture. First progress report on research (unpublished)]. Ghent, Belgium: Department of Sociology, Research Group Youth, Education, and Gender, Ghent University.

103.

Van Maele

, & Van Houtte

(2009). Faculty trust and organizational school characteristics: An exploration across secondary schools in Flanders. Educational Administration Quarterly, 45, 556–589.

104.

Van Petegem

, Aelterman

, Van Keer

, & Rosseel

(2008). The influence of student characteristics and interpersonal teacher behaviour in the classroom on students’ wellbeing. Social Indicators Research, 85, 279–291.

105.

Goodenow

(1993a). The psychological sense of school membership among adolescents: Scale development and educational correlates. Psychology in the Schools, 30(1), 79–90.

106.

Hoy

W. K.

, & Tschannen-Moran

(1999). Five faces of trust: An empirical confirmation in urban elementary schools. Journal of School Leadership, 9, 184–208.