The Dewey School as Triumph,Tragedy,and Misunderstood: Exploring the Myths and Historiography of the University of Chicago Laboratory School

Abstract

Background/Context

Over the last century, perhaps no school in American history has been studied more than John Dewey's Laboratory School at the University of Chicago (1896–1904). Scholars have published dozens of articles, books, essays, and assessments of a school that existed for only seven and a half years.

Purpose/Objective/Research Question/Focus of Study

This article reviews the extensive firsthand accounts and historiography of the famed school. In the first section, the authors trace the published accounts of those who experienced the Dewey School firsthand between 1895 and 1904. In the second section, the authors review accounts of the school by contemporaries, reformers, and historians between 1904 and 2014, focusing on three historiographical areas: the events surrounding the closing of the school, the rationale underlying its curriculum, and the impact of the experiment on U.S. schools. In the third section, the authors argue that most accounts of the Dewey School convey one of three historiographical myths: the Dewey School as misunderstood; the Dewey School as triumph, and/or the Dewey School as tragedy.

Research Design

A historiographical essay is a narrative and analytical account of what has been written on a particular historical topic. Following this methodology, the authors are less concerned with establishing what happened at the Dewey School, than they were with how the school was analyzed and interpreted by contemporaries and historians over the past 120 years.

Conclusions/Recommendations

The authors analyze each myth to conclude that Dewey only subscribed to the myth of the Dewey School as misunderstood, while the other two were historiographical constructions created by Dewey's contemporaries and historians.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bagley

W. C.

(1915). Educational survey. School and Home Education 35, 3—5.

Bailyn

(1960). Education in the forming of American society: needs and opportunities for study. New York, NY: Norton.

Brown

G. P.

(1897, June). Dr. John Dewey's educational experiment. Public School Journal, 16(10), 533—37.

Brown

G. P.

(1897, 1899). The university elementary school. School and Home Education, 19, 98—99.

Butchart

R. E.

(1988). “Outthinking and outflanking the owners of the world”: A historiography of the African American struggle for education. History of Education Quarterly, 28(3), 333—366.

Chase

(1980). The Chicago laboratory schools: Retrospect and prospect. UCLA Educator, 21(2), 38—44.

Clippinger

G. M.

(1901, March). A visit to the sub-primary class of Dr. Dewey's school. Kindergarten Review, 11(7), 424—426.

Cremin

L. A.

(1955). The recent development of the history of education as a field of study in the United States. History of Education Journal, 7(1), 1—35.

Cremin

L. A.

(1961). The transformation of the school: Progressivism in American education, 1876–1957. New York, NY: Vintage.

10.

Cremin

L. A.

(1965). The wonderful world of Ellwood Patterson Cubberley: An essay on the historiography of American education. New York, NY: Bureau of Publications, Teachers College, Columbia University.

11.

Cremin

L. A.

(1974). The family as educator: Some comments on the recent historiography. Teachers College Record, 76(2), 250—265.

12.

Cremin

L. A.

(1978). Family–community linkages in American education: Some comments on the recent historiography. Teachers College Record, 79(4), 683—704.

13.

DePencier

I. B.

(1967). The history of the Laboratory Schools: The University of Chicago, 1896–1965. Chicago, IL: Quadrangle Books.

14.

Dewey

(1896, June). A pedagogical experiment. Kindergarten Magazine, 8(10), 739—741.

15.

Dewey

(1956). The child and the curriculum and The school and society (2nd ed.). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. (Original works published 1902 and 1899)

16.

Dewey

(1972a). My pedagogic creed. In Boydston

J. A.

(Ed.), The early works, 1882–1898: Vol. 5. 1895–1898, Essays (pp. 84—95). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. (Original work published 1897)

17.

Dewey

(1972b). Plan of organization of university primary school. In Boydston

J. A.

(Ed.), The early works, 1882–1898: Vol. 5. 1895–1898 (pp. 224—243). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. (Original work published 1895)

18.

Dewey

(1976). The university elementary school. In Boydston

J. A.

(Ed.), The middle works, 1899–1924: Vol. 1. 1899–1901 (pp. 317—320). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. (Original work published 1899)

19.

Dewey

(1983). Individuality in education. In Boydston

J. A.

(Ed.), The middle works, 1899–1924: Vol. 15. 1923–1924 (pp. 170—179). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. (Original work published 1923)

20.

Dewey

(1985). Why have progressive schools? In Boydston

J. A.

(Ed.), The later works, 1925–1953: Vol. 9. 1933–1934 (pp. 147—157). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. (Original work published 1933)

21.

Dewey

(1997a). Democracy and education: An introduction to the philosophy of education. New York, NY: Free Press. (Original work published 1916)

22.

Dewey

(1997b). How we think. Mineola, NY: Dover Publications. (Original work published 1910)

23.

Dewey

(2007). Experience and education. New York, NY: Touchstone. (Original work published 1938)

24.

Dewey

, & Dewey

(2008). Schools of to-morrow. Mineola, NY: Dover Publications. (Original work published 1915)

25.

Dewey's labs. (1963, June 3). Newsweek, 61, 75.

26.

Durst

(2005). “The union of intellectual freedom and cooperation”: Learning from the University of Chicago's Laboratory School community, 1896–1904. Teachers College Record, 107(5), 958—984.

27.

Durst

(2010a). “Venturing in education”: Teaching at the University of Chicago's Laboratory School, 1896–1904. History of Education, 39(1), 55—73.

28.

Durst

(2010b). Women educators in the progressive era: The women behind Dewey's Laboratory School. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.

29.

Dykhuizen

(1973). The life and mind of John Dewey. Boydston

J. A.

(Ed.). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press.

30.

Eastman

(1941, December). John Dewey. The Atlantic Monthly, 168, 671—685.

31.

Eisele

(1984). The Dewey School: A record of success and a reality of failure. Journal of the Midwest History of Education Society, 12, 29—39.

32.

Fallace

T. D.

(2009). Repeating the race experience: John Dewey and the history curriculum at the University of Chicago laboratory school. Curriculum Inquiry, 39(3), 381—405.

33.

Fallace

T. D.

(2011). Dewey and the dilemma of race: An intellectual history, 1895-1922. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.

34.

Fallace

T. D.

, & Fantozzi

V. B.

(2015). A century of John and Evelyn Dewey's “Schools of To-morrow”: Rousseau, recorded knowledge, and race in the philosopher's most problematic text. Educational Studies, 51(2), 129—152.

35.

Feffer

(1993). The Chicago Pragmatists and American progressivism. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

36.

Farrand

H. A.

(1898). Dr. Dewey's university elementary school: An experiment in education. Journal of Education, 48(10), 172.

37.

Finkelstein

(1992). Education historians as mythmakers. Review of Research in Education, 18, 255—297.

38.

Foster

O. H.

(1900, June 3 & 17). An experiment in education: Professor John Dewey's theories and methods as exemplified in a school conducted by the pedagogy department of the University of Chicago, Chicago Times-Herald, 1—3.

39.

Harms

, & DePencier

(1996). Experiencing education: 100 years of learning at the University of Chicago Laboratory Schools. Orland Park, IL: Alpha Beta Press.

40.

Hickman

(Ed.). (2005). The correspondence of John Dewey: Vol. 1. 1871—1918 (3rd ed., CD-ROM version). Charlottesville, VA: InteLexe.

41.

Hirsch

E. D.

(1987). Cultural literacy: What every American needs to know. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin.

42.

Hodgeman

H. M.

(1900, December). A new departure in education. Education: A Monthly Magazine, 21, 232—39.

43.

Hofstadter

(1963). Anti-intellectualism in American life. New York, NY: Vintage.

44.

Hook

(1939). John Dewey: An intellectual portrait. New York, NY: John Day Company.

45.

Jackson

P. W.

(1998a). John Dewey and the lessons of art. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

46.

Jackson

P. W.

(1998b). John Dewey's School and Society revisited. Elementary School Journal, 98(5), 415—426.

47.

Johnston

J. S.

(2006). Inquiry and education: John Dewey and the quest for democracy. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.

48.

Karier

C. J.

(1973). Liberal ideology and the quest for orderly change. In Karier

C. J.

, Violas

, & Spring

(Eds.), Roots of crisis: American education in the twentieth century (pp. 84—107). Chicago, IL: Rand McNally.

49.

Kilpatrick

W. H.

(1939). Dewey's influence on education. In Schlipp

(Ed.), The philosophy of John Dewey (pp. 445—473). Chicago, IL: Northwestern University Press.

50.

Kliebard

(2004). The struggle for the American curriculum, 1893–1958. 3rd ed. New York, NY: Routledge.

51.

Knoll

(2015a). John Dewey as administrator: The inglorious end of the Laboratory School in Chicago. Journal of Curriculum Studies, (August), 1—50.

52.

Knoll

(2015b). Laboratory School, University of Chicago. In Phillips

D. C.

(Ed.). Encyclopedia of educational theory and philosophy (pp. 455—458). Los Angeles, CA: SAGE.

53.

Lagemann

E. C.

(1996). Experimenting with education: John Dewey and Ella Flagg Young at the University of Chicago. American Journal of Education, 104(3), 171—185.

54.

Lasch

(1965). The new radicalism in America: The intellectual as social type, 1889–1963. New York, NY: Norton.

55.

Levine

(2013). Works about John Dewey, 1886–2012. Carbondale, IL: Center for Dewey Studies, Southern Illinois University Press.

56.

Martin

(2002). The education of John Dewey: A biography. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

57.

Maxson

(1976). Dewey's school: No playground but a structured laboratory. In Davis

O. L.

Jr. (Ed.), Perspectives on curriculum development, 1776–1976 (pp. 133—134). Washington, DC: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.

58.

Mayhew

K. C.

, & Edwards

A. C.

(2007). The Dewey School: The Laboratory School of the University of Chicago, 1896–1903. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers. (Original work published 1936)

59.

McCaul

R. L.

(1961a). Dewey and the University of Chicago: Part I. July, 1894–March, 1902. School and Society, 89, 152—157.

60.

McCaul

R. L.

(1961b). Dewey and the University of Chicago: Part II. April, 1902–May, 1903. School and Society, 89, 179—183.

61.

McCaul

R. L.

(1961c). Dewey and the University of Chicago: Part III. September, 1903–June, 1904. School and Society, 89, 202—206.

62.

Menand

(2001). The metaphysical club: A story of ideas in America. New York, NY: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux.

63.

The model school. (1896, January 16). University of Chicago Weekly, p. 707.

64.

Moncreiff

W. F.

(1900a). The University of Chicago and its work: Part II. Department of pedagogy. Southern Educational Journal, 13(6), 229—231.

65.

Moncreiff

W. F.

(1900b). The University of Chicago and its work: Part III. The university elementary school. Southern Educational Journal, 13(8), 305—309.

66.

Moroney

(1999). Birth of a canon: The historiography of early republican education thought. History of Education Quarterly, 39(4), 476—491.

67.

O'Connor

N. J.

(1904). The educational side of the Parents' Association of the Laboratory School: From a parent's point of view. Elementary School Teacher, 4(7), 532—535.

68.

Provenzoi

E. F.

Jr. (1979). History as experiment: The role of the Laboratory School in the development of John Dewey's philosophy of history. History Teacher, 12(3), 373—382.

69.

Ravitch

(2001). Left back: A century of battles over school reform. New York, NY: Touchstone.

70.

Reese

W. J.

, & Rury

J. L.

(Eds.). (2008). Rethinking the history of American education. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.

71.

Rockefeller

S. C.

(1991). John Dewey: Religious faith and democratic humanism. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

72.

Rugg

H. O.

(1947). Foundations for American education. Yonkers-on-Hudson, NY: World Book Company.

73.

Rugg

H. O.

, & Shumaker

(1928). The child-centered school: An appraisal of the new education. New York, NY: Arno Press.

74.

Runyon

(1900a). A day with the new education. Chautauquan: Organ of the Chautauqua Literacy and Science Circle, 30, 589—90.

75.

Runyon

(Ed.). (1900b). The elementary school record. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

76.

Ryan

(1995). John Dewey and the high tide of American liberalism. New York, NY: W. W. Norton & Company.

77.

San Miguel

Jr. (1986). Status of the historiography of Chicano education: A preliminary analysis. History of Education Quarterly, 26(4), 523—536.

78.

Sarason

S. B.

(1982). The culture of the school and the problem of change. Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon.

79.

Scott

C. A.

(1908). Social education. New York, NY: Ginn & Company.

80.

Seigfried

C. H.

(1996). Pragmatism and feminism: Reweaving the social fabric. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

81.

Shiraishi

(1995). Music education at the Dewey School, 1896–1904. Bulletin of Historical Research in Music Education, 17(1), 1—18.

82.

Smith

J. K.

(1979). Ella Flagg Young: Portrait of a leader. Ames, IA: Educational Studies Press.

83.

Strickland

C. E.

(1967). The child, the community, and Clio: The uses of cultural history in elementary school experiments of the eighteen-nineties. History of Education Quarterly, 7(4), 474—492.

84.

Tamura

E. H.

(2001). Asian Americans in the history of education: An historiographical essay. History of Education Quarterly, 41(1), 58—71.

85.

Tanner

L. N.

(1991). The meaning of curriculum in Dewey's laboratory school (1896–1904). Journal of Curriculum Studies, 23(2), 101—117.

86.

Tanner

L. N.

(1997). Dewey's Laboratory School: Lessons for today. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.

87.

The elementary school record. (1900, April). Inland Educator: A Journal for the Progressive Educator, 10(3), 139—140.

88.

Tyack

D. B.

(1970). New perspectives on the history of American education. In Bass

H. J.

(Ed.), The state of American history (pp. 22—42). Chicago, IL: Quadrangle Books.

89.

Weiler

(2006). The historiography of gender and progressive education in the United States. Paedagogica Historica, 42(1–2), 161—176.

90.

Westbrook

R. B.

(1991). John Dewey and American democracy. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

91.

Westbrook

R. B.

(1992). Schools for industrial democrats: The social origins of John Dewey's philosophy of education. American Journal of Education, 100(4), 401—419.

92.

Wirth

A. G.

(1966a). John Dewey as educator: His design for work in education (1894–1904). New York, NY: John Wiley and Sons.

93.

Wirth

A. G.

(1966b). The psychological theory for experimentation in education at John Dewey's Laboratory School, the University of Chicago, 1896–1904. Educational Theory, 16(3), 271—280.

94.

Wood

(1981). The Dewey School revisited. Childhood Education, 58(2), 99—101.

95.

Wraga

W. G.

(2014). Condescension and critical sympathy: Historians of education on progressive education in the United States and England. Paedagogica Historica, 50(1–2), 59—75.

96.

Zilversmit

(1993). Changing schools: Progressive education and practice, 1930-1960. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago.