“We're Rags to Riches”: Dual Consciousness of the American Dream in Two Critical History Classrooms

Abstract

Background/Context

Within the United States, wealth disparities are growing and upward social mobility is becoming increasingly difficult to attain. These trends call into question the American Dream ideology that anyone can succeed through hard work. This meritocratic ideal has traditionally been one of the unifying ideologies promoted through the public school curriculum. The topic of economic inequality, on the other hand, is largely absent from most social studies curricula. When teachers do address this issue, they tend to omit discussions of causes or potential policy solutions. Students are thus left with few resources with which to develop positions on policies related to inequality that would help them become more informed voters and contributors to public discourse on this issue.

Purposes

Critical pedagogy is an educational approach that aims to develop students’ sociopolitical consciousness of the world and understanding of the underlying causes of contemporary injustices such as rising economic and social inequality. We investigated whether students in classrooms using critical pedagogy might develop understandings of the roots of contemporary inequality.

Setting and Participants

The study took place in two U.S. History classrooms in culturally diverse public high schools in a midsized city in the Southeast. The classrooms were selected because both teachers demonstrated critical pedagogy by helping students question norms and analyze underlying causes of contemporary social and economic inequalities.

Research Design

We used a critical case study design with ethnographic methods to examine students’ understandings of structural causes of inequality in classrooms where they are most likely to encounter this knowledge, namely critical history classrooms. Data included 10 weeks of observations in both classrooms, classroom artifacts, in-depth interviews with 14 students, and two in-depth interviews with each teacher along with daily informal interviews.

Findings/Results

Students critiqued the notion of the American Dream and described ways in which certain social structures such as the judicial and educational systems reproduce social inequalities. Some pointed out how the “rags to riches” ideology precludes tax structures that might reduce economic inequality. However, many also made comments reflecting a belief that the United States is indeed a meritocracy.

Conclusions/Recommendations

We recommend that teachers explicitly teach the structural causes of economic inequality so that students have the language needed to understand their dual consciousness that both meritocratic elements (e.g., hard work) and non-meritocratic elements (e.g., race, family wealth) play a role in social mobility within the United States.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

J. T.

(1931). The epic of America. Boston, MA: Little, Brown & Co.

Anderson

G. L.

(1989). Critical ethnography in education: Origins, current status, and new directions. Review of Educational Research, 59(3), 249—270.

Apple

M. W.

, Au

, & Gandin

L. A.

(Eds.). (2011). The Routledge international handbook of critical education. New York, NY: Routledge.

Applebaum

(2009). Is teaching for social justice a “liberal bias?” Teachers College Record, 111(2), 376—408.

Barrett

, & Buchanan-Barrow

(2011). Children's understanding of society. In Smith

P. K.

, & Hart

C. H.

(Eds.), The Wiley-Blackwell handbook of children's social development (2nd ed., pp. 584—602). West Sussex, UK: Blackwell Publishing.

Barton

K. C.

(2001). A sociocultural perspective on children's understanding of historical change: Comparative findings from Northern Ireland and the United States. American Educational Research Journal, 38(4), 881—913.

Barton

K. C.

, & Levstik

L. S.

(1998). “It wasn't a good part of history”: National identity and students' explanations of historical significance. Teachers College Record, 99(3), 478—513.

Barton

K. C.

, & Levstik

L. S.

(2004). Teaching history for the common good. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Bedolla

, & Andrade

(2017). The invisible hand of history: Pluralism, power, and inequality. PS: Political Science & Politics, 50(4), 1062—1067.

10.

Bowles

, & Gintis

(1976). Schooling in capitalist America: Educational reform and the contradictions of economic life. New York, NY: Basic Books.

11.

Carspecken

P. F.

(1996). Critical ethnography in educational research: A theoretical and practical guide. New York, NY: Routledge.

12.

Causa

, & Johansson

Å.

(2009, July). Intergenerational social mobility (OECD Economics Department Working Paper No. 707). Paris, France: OECD Publishing.

13.

Chafel

J. A.

, & Neitzel

(2005). Young children's ideas about the nature, causes, justification, and alleviation of poverty. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 20(4), 433—450.

14.

Cornbleth

(2002). Images of America: What youth do know about the United States. American Educational Research Journal, 39(2), 519—552.

15.

Council for Economic Education. (2010). Voluntary national standards for economic education (2nd ed.). Retrieved from http://councilforeconed.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/voluntary-national-content-standards-2010.pdf

16.

Council for Economic Education. (2016). Survey of the states: Economics and personal finance education in our nation's schools. Retrieved from http://councilforeconed.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/sos-16-final.pdf

17.

Creswell

J. W.

, & Miller

D. L.

(2000). Determining validity in qualitative inquiry. Theory Into Practice, 39(3), 124—130.

18.

Darder

, Baltodano

, & Torres

R. D.

(Eds.). (2009). The critical pedagogy reader (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Routledge.

19.

Davies

(2006). Educating citizens for changing economies. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 38(1), 15—30.

20.

Ditto

P. H.

, Scepansky

J. A.

, Munro

G. D.

, Apanovitch

A. M.

, & Lockhart

L. K.

(1998). Motivated sensitivity to preference-inconsistent information. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75(1), 53—69.

21.

Duncan

G. J.

, & Murnane

R. J.

(2014). Meeting the educational challenges of income inequality. Phi Delta Kappan, 95(7), 50—54.

22.

Ellsworth

(1989). Why doesn't this feel empowering? Working through the repressive myths of critical pedagogy. Harvard Educational Review, 59(3), 297—324.

23.

Emerson

R. M.

, Fretz

I , & Shaw

L L.

(1995). Writing ethnographic fieldnotes. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

24.

Epstein

(1998). Deconstructing differences in African-American and European-American adolescents' perspectives on U.S. history. Curriculum Inquiry, 28(4), 397—423.

25.

Epstein

(2000). Adolescents' perspectives on racial diversity in U.S. history: Case studies from an urban classroom. American Educational Research Journal, 37(1), 185—214.

26.

Epstein

(2009). Interpreting national history: Race, identity, and pedagogy in classrooms and communities. New York, NY: Routledge.

27.

Ermisch

, Jäntti

, & Smeeding

T. M.

(2012, May). From parents to children: The intergenerational transmission of advantage. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.

28.

Finerman

W. (Producer)

, Tisch

W. (Producer)

, Starkey

S. (Producer)

, & Zemeckis

R. (Director).

(1994). Forrest Gump [Motion picture]. United States: Paramount Pictures.

29.

Flyvbjerg

(2006). Five misunderstandings about case-study research. Qualitative Inquiry, 12(2), 219—245.

30.

Freedman

E. B.

(2007). Is teaching for social justice undemocratic? Harvard Educational Review, 77(4), 442—473.

31.

Freire

(2008). Pedagogy of the oppressed (30th anniversary ed., Ramos

M. B.

, Trans.). New York, NY: Continuum. (Original work published 1970)

32.

Fryer

R. G.

Jr. (2016). An empirical analysis of racial differences in police use of force (NBER Working Paper No. 22399). Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.

33.

Giroux

(1983). Theories of reproduction and resistance in the new sociology of education: A critical analysis. Harvard Educational Review, 53(3), 257—293.

34.

Gordon

, Holland

, & Lahelma

(2001). Ethnographic research in educational settings. In Atkinson

, Coffey

, Delamont

, Lofland

, & Lofland

(Eds.), Handbook of ethnography (pp. 188—203). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.

35.

Gramsci

(1971). Selections from the prison notebooks ( Hoare

, & Smith

G. N.

, Eds. & Trans.). New York, NY: International Press.

36.

Halik

, & Webley

(2011). Adolescents' understanding of poverty and the poor in rural Malaysia. Journal of Economic Psychology, 32(2), 231—239.

37.

Helmsing

(2014). Virtuous subjects: A critical analysis of the affective substance of social studies education. Theory & Research in Social Education, 42(1), 127—140.

38.

Hochschild

J. L.

(1981). What's fair? American beliefs about distributive justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

39.

Holton

J. A.

(2010). The coding process and its challenges. Grounded Theory Review, 9(1), 21—40.

40.

Howard

T. C.

(2004). “Does race really matter?” Secondary students' constructions of racial dialogue in the social studies. Theory & Research in Social Education, 32(4), 484—502.

41.

Kluegel

J. R.

, & Smith

E. R.

(1986). Beliefs about inequality: Americans' views of what is and what ought to be. Piscataway, NJ: Transaction Publishers.

42.

Lakoff

(2008). The political mind: A cognitive scientist's guide to your brain and its politics. New York, NY: Viking.

43.

Leahy

R. L.

(1983). Development of conception of economic inequality: Explanations, justifications, and concepts of social mobility and change. Developmental Psychology, 19(1), 111—125.

44.

Lee

, & Walsh

(2015). Teaching (in)justice: One teacher's work with immigrant English learners. Urban Review, 47(1), 45—66.

45.

Lopez

G. E.

, Gurin

, & Nagda

B. A.

(1998). Education and understanding structural causes for group inequalities. Political Psychology, 19(2), 305—329.

46.

Martell

C. C.

(2013). Race and histories: Examining culturally relevant teaching in the U.S. history classroom. Theory and Research in Social Education, 41(1), 65—88. 10.1080/00933104.2013.755745

47.

Maxwell

J. A.

(2013). Qualitative research design: An interactive approach. Los Angeles, CA: SAGE Publications.

48.

McLaren

(1989). Life in schools: An introduction to critical pedagogy in the foundations of education (5th ed.). Los Angeles, CA: Pearson.

49.

McLaren

(2009). Critical pedagogy: A look at the major concepts. In Darder

, Baltodano

, & Torres

R. D.

(Eds.), The critical pedagogy reader (2nd ed., pp. 61—83). New York, NY: Routledge.

50.

McLaren

, & Torres

(1999). Racism and multicultural education: Rethinking “race” and “whiteness” in late capitalism. In May

(Ed.), Critical multiculturalism: Rethinking multicultural and antiracist education (pp. 42—76). London, UK: Falmer Press.

51.

McNamee

S. J.

, & Miller

R. K.

(2009). The meritocracy myth. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

52.

Miles

M. B.

, & Huberman

A. M.

(1994). Qualitative data analysis: An expanded sourcebook (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.

53.

Mosborg

(2002). Speaking of history: How adolescents use their knowledge of history in reading the daily news. Cognition and Instruction, 20(3), 323—358.

54.

National Council for the Social Studies. (2010). National curriculum standards for social studies: A framework for teaching, learning, and assessment. Silver Spring, MD: Author.

55.

National Council for the Social Studies. (2013). College, career, and civic life (C3) framework for social studies state standards: Guidance for enhancing the rigor of K–12 civics, economics, geography, and history. Silver Spring, MD: Author.

56.

Niederjohn

M. S.

, & Schug

M. C.

(2008). Can students learn economics in US history? Journal of Private Enterprise, 23(2), 167—176.

57.

Parkhouse

(2018a). Fostering democratic patriotism through critical pedagogy. Bank Street Occasional Paper Series, 2018 (40). https://educate.bankstreet.edu/occasional-paper-series/vol2018/iss40/6

58.

Parkhouse

(2018b). Pedagogies of Naming, Questioning, and Demystification: A Study of Two Critical US History Classrooms. Theory & Research in Social Education, 46(2), 277—317.

59.

Pew Charitable Trusts. (2013, November). Moving on up: Why do some Americans leave the bottom of the economic ladder, but not others? Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved from http://www.pewtrusts.org/∼/media/assets/2013/11/01/movingonuppdf.pdf

60.

Pew Research Center. (2012, March). For the public, it's not about class warfare, but fairness: Poll analysis. Retrieved from http://www.people-press.org/2012/03/02/for-the-public-its-not-about-class-warfare-but-fairness/

61.

Piketty

(2014). Capital in the twenty-first century ( Goldhammer

, Trans.). Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press.

62.

Porat

D. A.

(2004). It's not written here, but this is what happened: Students' cultural comprehension of textbook narratives on the Israeli-Arab conflict. American Educational Research Journal, 41(4), 963—996.

63.

Ramirez

P. C.

, Ross

, & Jimenez-Silva

(2016). The intersectionality of border pedagogy and Latino/a youth: Enacting border pedagogy in multiple spaces. High School Journal, 99(4), 302—321.

64.

Rawls

(1971). A theory of justice. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press.

65.

Reynolds

, & Xian

(2014). Perceptions of meritocracy in the land of opportunity. Research in Social Stratification and Mobility, 36, 121—137.

66.

Rich

W. C.

(2013). The post-racial society is here: Recognition, critics and the nation-state. New York, NY: Routledge.

67.

Rogers

, & Westheimer

(2015). Learning inequality? A conceptual framework for examining how inequality is addressed in curricular frameworks. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Chicago, IL.

68.

Rogers

, & Westheimer

(2017). Teaching about economic inequality. In Wright-Maley

, & Davis

(Eds.), Teaching for democracy in an age of economic disparity (pp. 61—78). New York, NY: Routledge.

69.

Rosenzweig

, & Thelen

D. P.

(1998). The presence of the past: Popular uses of history in American life. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

70.

Saez

(2013). Striking it richer: The evolution of top incomes in the United States (updated with 2012 preliminary estimates). UC Berkeley Department of Economics. Retrieved from http://eml.berkeley.edu/∼saez/saez-UStopincomes-2012.pdf

71.

Seixas

P. C.

(1994). Students' understanding of historical significance. Theory and Research in Social Education, 22(3), 281—304.

72.

Sensoy

Ö.

(2011). Picturing oppression: Seventh graders' photo essays on racism, classism, and sexism. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 24(3), 323—342.

73.

Shor

(1992). Empowering education: Critical teaching for social change. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

74.

Sibbett

L. A.

(2016). Toward a transformative criticality for democratic citizenship education. Democracy & Education, 24(2), 1—11.

75.

Sober

T. L.

(2017a). Teaching about economics and moneyed interests in twenty-first-century democracy. In Wright-Maley

, & Davis

(Eds.), Teaching for democracy in an age of economic disparity (pp. 79—94). New York, NY: Routledge.

76.

Sober

T. L.

(2017b). Wise choices? The economics discourse of a high school economics and personal finance course (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, VA.

77.

Stiglitz

J. E.

(2013). The price of inequality: How today's divided society endangers our future. New York, NY: W.W. Norton.

78.

Thomas

D. R.

(2006). A general inductive approach for analyzing qualitative evaluation data. American Journal of Evaluation, 27(2), 237—246.

79.

Thomas

(1993). Doing critical ethnography. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE Publications.

80.

Tyson

C. A.

(2002). “Get up offa that thing”: African American middle school students respond to literature to develop a framework for understanding social action. Theory & Research in Social Education, 30(1), 42—65.

81.

VanSledright

(2008). Narratives of nation-state, historical knowledge, and school history education. Review of Research in Education, 32, 109—146.

82.

Webley

(2005). Children's understanding of economics. In Barrett

, & Buchanan-Barrow

(Eds.), Children's understanding of society (pp. 43—67). New York, NY: Psychology Press.

83.

Weinger

(1998). Poor children “know their place”: Perceptions of poverty, class, and public messages. Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare, 25(2), 100—118.

84.

Weinger

(2000). Economic status: Middle class and poor children's views. Children & Society, 14(2), 135—146.

85.

Westheimer

, Rogers

, & Kahne

(2017). Introduction to symposium: The politics and pedagogy of economic inequality. PS: Political Science & Politics, 50(4), 1043—1048.

86.

Wills

J. S.

(1996). Who needs multicultural education? White students, U.S. history, and the construction of a usable past. Anthropology & Education Quarterly, 27(3), 365—389.

87.

Wineburg

S. S.

, Mosborg

, Porat

, & Duncan

(2007). Common belief and the cultural curriculum: An intergenerational study of historical consciousness. American Educational Research Journal, 44(1), 40—76.

88.

Woodson

A. N.

(2016). We're just ordinary people: Messianic master narratives and black youths' civic agency. Theory and Research in Social Education, 44(2), 184—210.

89.

Wright-Maley

, & Davis

(2017). Introduction. In Wright-Maley

, & Davis

(Eds.), Teaching for democracy in an age of economic disparity (pp. 1—10). New York, NY: Routledge.

90.

Young

(1958). The rise of the meritocracy, 1870–2033: An essay on education and society. London, UK: Thames and Hudson.

91.

Zirkel

(2008). The influence of multicultural educational practices on student outcomes and intergroup relations. Teachers College Record, 110(6), 1147—1181.