Becoming Restorative: A Mixed-Methods Analysis of Educator and Student Perspectives of Restorative Practices Implementation

Abstract

Background/Context:

Restorative practices have gained traction across the United States, featuring in at least 21 state education codes and numerous district policies. The existing research on its effectiveness underscores the implementation process, particularly fidelity, as a key determinant in whether restorative practices will accomplish their goals of reducing punitive discipline and improving school community.

Purpose/Objective/Research Question/Focus of Study:

This study examines how restorative practices are implemented and scaled, drawing on data from four districts in a state that has mandated their use in discipline decisions. Using cognitive and organizational perspectives on policy implementation, we focus on understanding educator and student perceptions of implementation and identifying the organizational factors, contexts, and conditions that shape the use of the practices. By doing so, we provide novel evidence on how a statewide mandate translates into practice across schools and highlight the contextual dynamics shaping policy enactment.

Research Design:

We employ an explanatory mixed-methods approach, partnering with four districts in one county in Michigan. Data collection includes surveys from 493 educators and 4,805 students, alongside qualitative interviews with 47 staff members across nine schools during the 2022–23 school year. The explanatory design allows us to leverage interview data to explain patterns detected in the survey data.

Conclusions/Recommendations:

Survey results reveal that about half of classroom teachers, particularly at the elementary level, use proactive circles, while less than half of respondents use formal restorative conferences. Students generally report observing educators use restorative practices, with middle school students responding more positively on survey items related to implementation than high school students. However, students are less convinced about the community-building aspects of circles and whether the practices reduce conflict. Interviews indicate that implementation varies based on leadership expectations, alignment with existing practices, and site-specific discipline processes. We conclude with recommendations for policy and practice.

Keywords

discipline restorative practices mixed methods policy implementation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abdou

A. S.

Brady

Griffiths

A. J.

Burrola

vue

(2023). Restorative schools: A consultation case study for moving from theory to practice. Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation, 33(4), 421–448. https://doi.org/10.1080/10474412.2023.2192205

Abry

Rimm-Kaufman

S. E.

Larsen

R. A.

Brewer

A. J.

(2013). The influence of fidelity of implementation on teacher–student interaction quality in the context of a randomized controlled trial of the Responsive Classroom approach. Journal of School Psychology, 51(4), 437–453. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsp.2013.03.001

Acosta

Chinman

Ebener

Malone

P. S.

Phillips

Wilks

(2019). Evaluation of a whole-school change intervention: Findings from a two-year cluster-randomized trial of the restorative practices intervention. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 48(5), 876–890. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10964-019-01013-2

Anfara

V. A.

Evans

K. R.

Lester

J. N.

(2013). Restorative justice in education: What we know so far. Middle School Journal, 44(5), 57–63. https://doi.org/10.1080/00940771.2013.11461873

Anyon

(2016). Taking restorative practices school-wide: Insights from three schools in Denver. Denver School-Based Restorative Practices Partnership. https://socialwork.du.edu/sites/g/files/lmucqz281/files/2018-10/taking_restorative_practices_school-wide.pdf

Augustine

Engberg

Grimm

Lee

Wang

Christianson

Joseph

(2018). Can restorative practices improve school climate and curb suspensions? An evaluation of the impact of restorative practices in a mid-sized urban school district. RAND Corporation. https://doi.org/10.7249/RR2840

Ball

(1994). Education reform. McGraw-Hill Education.

Bridwell-Mitchell

E. N.

(2013). The rationalizing logics of public school reform: How cultural institutions matter for classroom instruction. Journal of Mixed Methods Research, 7(2), 173–196. https://doi.org/10.1177/1558689812468792

Bryk

A. S.

(2016, March 17). Fidelity of implementation: Is it the right concept? Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching. https://www.carnegiefoundation.org/blog/fidelity-of-implementation-is-it-the-right-concept/

10.

Burke

Ashley

(2008). Implementing restorative justice: A guide for schools. Illinois Criminal Justice Information Authority. https://creducation.net/catalog/cat-item-546/

11.

Carter

P. L.

Skiba

Arredondo

M. I.

Pollock

(2017). You can’t fix what you don’t look at: Acknowledging race in addressing racial discipline disparities. Urban Education, 52(2), 207–235. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085916660350

12.

Coburn

C. E.

(2001). Collective sensemaking about reading: How teachers mediate reading policy in their professional communities. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 23(2), 145–170. https://doi.org/10.3102/01623737023002145

13.

Coburn

C. E.

(2003). Rethinking scale: Moving beyond numbers to deep and lasting change. Educational Researcher, 32(6), Article 6. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X032006003

14.

Coburn

C. E.

(2004). Beyond decoupling: Rethinking the relationship between the institutional environment and the classroom. Sociology of Education, 77(3), 211–244. https://doi.org/10.1177/003804070407700302

15.

Coburn

C. E.

(2005). Shaping teacher sensemaking: School leaders and the enactment of reading policy. Educational Policy, 19(3), 476–509. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904805276143

16.

Creswell

J. W.

Plano Clark

V. L.

(2018). Designing and conducting mixed methods research (3rd ed.). Sage.

17.

Darling-Hammond

Fronius

(2022). Restorative practices in schools. In Sabornie

E. J.

Espelage

D. L.

(Eds.), Handbook of classroom management (3rd ed., pp. 54–73). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003275312

18.

Darling-Hammond

Fronius

T. A.

Sutherland

Guckenburg

Petrosino

Hurley

(2020). Effectiveness of restorative justice in US K–12 schools: A review of quantitative research. Contemporary School Psychology, 24(3), Article 3. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40688-020-00290-0

19.

Datnow

Castellano

(2000). Teachers’ responses to success for all: How beliefs, experiences, and adaptations shape implementation. American Educational Research Journal, 37(3), 775–799. https://doi.org/10.3102/00028312037003775

20.

Datnow

Guerra

A. W.

Cohen

S. R.

Kennedy

B. C.

Lee

(2023). Teacher sensemaking in an early education research–practice partnership. Teachers College Record, 125(2), 66–98.

21.

Dhaliwal

T. K.

Daramola

E. J.

Alonso

J. D.

Marsh

J. A.

(2023). Educators’ beliefs and perceptions of implementing restorative practices. Education and Urban Society, 55(1), Article 1. https://doi.org/10.1177/00131245211048439

22.

Diehl

D. K.

Golann

J. W.

(2023). An integrated framework for studying how schools respond to external pressures. Educational Researcher, 52(5), 296–305. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189x231159599

23.

Fronius

Persson

Guckenburg

Hurley

Petrosino

(2016). Restorative justice in U.S. schools: A research review. WestEd. https://www.wested.org/resource/restorative-justice-research-review/

24.

Georgetown Law Center. (2020). School-based restorative justice: State-by-state analysis. The Center on Gender Justice and Opportunity at Georgetown Law. https://genderjusticeandopportunity.georgetown.edu/restorative-justice-practices/rj-trends/

25.

Grant

A. A.

Mac Iver

D. J.

Byrnes

Clark

Balfanz

Lofton

(2023). Combining restorative practices with diplomas now: Impacts on practices, problems, suspensions, and chronic absenteeism. Journal of Education for Students Placed at Risk (JESPAR), 30(1), 49–73. https://doi.org/10.1080/10824669.2023.2278047

26.

Gregory

Clawson

Davis

Gerewitz

(2016). The promise of restorative practices to transform teacher–student relationships and achieve equity in school discipline. Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation, 26(4), 325–353. https://doi.org/10.1080/10474412.2014.929950

27.

Gregory

Evans

K. R.

(2020). The starts and stumbles of restorative justice in education: Where do we go from here? National Education Policy Center.

28.

Gregory

Huang

Ward-Seidel

A. R.

(2022). Evaluation of the whole school restorative practices project: One-year impact on discipline incidents. Journal of School Psychology, 95, 58–71.

29.

Guckenburg

Hurley

Persson

Fronius

Petrosino

(2016). Restorative justice in U.S. schools: Practitioners’ perspectives. The WestEd Justice & Prevention Research Center. https://www.wested.org/resources/restorative-justice-practitioners-perspectives/

30.

Hall

B. A.

Keeney

A. J.

Engstrom

D. W.

Brazzel

(2021). Confronting the traditional system: A qualitative study on the challenges to school based restorative practices policy implementation. Contemporary Justice Review, 24(3), 361–383. https://doi.org/10.1080/10282580.2021.1931844

31.

Honig

M. I.

(Ed.). (2006). New directions in education policy implementation: Confronting complexity. State University of New York Press.

32.

Honig

M. I.

Hatch

T. C.

(2004). Crafting coherence: How schools strategically manage multiple, external demands. Educational Researcher, 33(8), 16–30. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X033008016

33.

Joseph

Hnilica

R. J.

Hanson

(2021). Using restorative practices to reduce racially disproportionate school suspensions: The barriers school leaders should consider during the first year of implementation. Taboo: The Journal of Culture and Education, 20(2), 6.

34.

Joseph-McCatty

A. A.

Hnilica

R. J.

(2023). Restorative practices: The application of restorative circles in a case study school. Teaching and Teacher Education, 121, 103935.

35.

Kline

D. M. S.

(2016). Can restorative practices help to reduce disparities in school discipline data? A review of the literature. Multicultural Perspectives, 18(2), 97–102. https://doi.org/10.1080/15210960.2016.1159099

36.

Liberman

Katz

(2021). Fidelity in implementing school-based restorative justice conferences. Justice Evaluation Journal, 4(2), 197–216. https://doi.org/10.1080/24751979.2020.1836996

37.

Lodi

Perrella

Lepri

G. L.

Scarpa

M. L.

Patrizi

(2022). Use of restorative justice and restorative practices at school: A systematic literature review. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(1), 96. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph19010096

38.

Losen

D. J.

(2014). Nationwide survey of state education agencies’ online school disciplinary data for students with disabilities. https://escholarship.org/uc/item/0wq1s982

39.

Lustick

(2022). Schoolwide critical restorative justice. Journal of Peace Education, 19(1), 1–24. https://doi.org/10.1080/17400201.2021.2003763

40.

Lustick

Hakouz

Ward-Seidel

Gaias

(2024). What makes restorative justice equitable? “It’s a practice, not a program.” Journal of Educational Administration, 62(4), 403–416. https://doi.org/10.1108/jea-05-2023-0122

41.

Marsh

(2019). Honoring the global indigenous roots of restorative justice: Potential restorative approaches for child welfare. Center for the Study of Social Policy. https://cssp.org/2019/11/honoring-the-global-indigenous-roots-of-restorative-justice/

42.

Mayworm

A. M.

Sharkey

J. D.

Hunnicutt

K. L.

Schiedel

K. C.

(2016). Teacher consultation to enhance implementation of school-based restorative justice. Journal of Educational & Psychological Consultation, 26(4), 385–412. https://doi.org/10.1080/10474412.2016.1196364

43.

McLaughlin

(1987). Learning from experience: Lessons from policy implementation. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 9(2), Article 2. https://doi.org/10.3102/01623737009002171

44.

Miles

M. B.

Huberman

A. M.

Saldaña

(2014). Qualitative data analysis: A methods sourcebook (3rd ed.). Sage.

45.

Morrison

Blood

Thorsborne

(2005). Practicing restorative justice in school communities: Addressing the challenge of culture change. Public Organization Review, 5(4), 335–357. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11115-005-5095-6

46.

Nessel

(2021, Oct. 31). Restorative practices for students. State of Michigan. https://www.michigan.gov/ag/-/media/Project/Websites/AG/restorative-practices/restorative-practices-for-students.pdf

47.

Powell

W. W.

DiMaggio

(Eds.). (1991). The new institutionalism in organizational analysis. University of Chicago Press.

48.

Proctor

Silmere

Raghavan

Hovmand

Aarons

Bunger

Griffey

Hensley

(2011). Outcomes for implementation research: Conceptual distinctions, measurement challenges, and research agenda. Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research, 38(2), 65–76. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10488-010-0319-7

49.

Resnick

(1991). Shared cognition: Thinking as social practice. In Levine

Teasley

(Eds.), Perspectives on socially shared cognition (pp. 1–20). American Psychological Association. https://doi.org/10.1037/10096-018

50.

Rigby

J. G.

(2015). Principals’ sensemaking and enactment of teacher evaluation. Journal of Educational Administration, 53(3), 374–392. https://doi.org/10.1108/JEA-04-2014-0051

51.

Ryan

T. G.

Goodram

(2013). The impact of exclusionary discipline on students. International Journal of Progressive Education, 9(3), Article 3.

52.

Sadler

(2021). No-excuses in restorative justice clothing: The effects of adopting restorative justice in a no-excuses setting [Ph.D. thesis, The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill]. https://www-proquest-com-s.web.bisu.edu.cn/docview/2545953928/abstract/896C933BF99643EFPQ/1

53.

Saldaña

(2013). The coding manual for qualitative researchers (2nd ed.). Sage.

54.

Schweigert

F. J.

(2002). Moral and philosophical foundations of restorative justice. In Perry

(Ed.), Repairing communities through restorative justice (pp. 19–37). American Correctional Association.

55.

Scott

W. R.

Meyer

J. W.

(1994). Institutional environments and organizations: Structural complexity and individualism. Sage.

56.

Skiba

R. J.

Chung

C.-G.

Trachok

Baker

T. L.

Sheya

Hughes

R. L.

(2014). Parsing disciplinary disproportionality: Contributions of infraction, student, and school characteristics to out-of-school suspension and expulsion. American Educational Research Journal, 51(4), 640–670. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831214541670

57.

Smith

M. S.

O’Day

(1990). Systemic school reform. Journal of Education Policy, 5(5), 233–267. https://doi.org/10.1080/02680939008549074

58.

Spillane

J. P.

Jennings

N. E.

(1997). Aligned instructional policy and ambitious pedagogy: Exploring instructional reform from the classroom perspective. Teachers College Record, 98(3), 449–481.

59.

Spillane

J. P.

Reiser

B. J.

Reimer

(2002). Policy implementation and cognition: Reframing and refocusing implementation research. Review of Educational Research, 72(3), Article 3. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543072003387

60.

Sprague

Tobin

(2017). Aligning positive behavioral interventions and supports and restorative practices: An implementation fidelity manual (Draft). University of Oregon, Institute on Violence and Destructive Behavior.

61.

Stake

R. E.

(2005). Qualitative case studies. In Denzin

N. K.

Lincoln

Y. S.

(Eds.), The SAGE handbook of qualitative research (3rd ed., pp. 443–466). Sage.

62.

Sugai

Horner

R. H.

Dunlap

Hieneman

Lewis

T. J.

Nelson

C. M.

Scott

Liaupsin

Sailor

Turnbull

A. P.

Turnbull

H. R.

III Wickham

Reuf

Wilcox

(2000). Applying positive behavioral support and functional behavioral assessment in schools. Journal of Positive Behavioral Interventions, 2, 131–143.

63.

Sumner

M. D.

Silverman

C. J.

Frampton

M. L.

(2010). School-based restorative justice as an alternative to zero-tolerance policies: Lessons from West Oakland. Thelton E. Henderson Center for Social Justice, University of California, Berkeley, School of Law. https://www.law.berkeley.edu/files/thcsj/10-2010_School-based_Restorative_Justice_As_an_Alternative_to_Zero-Tolerance_Policies.pdf

64.

Wang

E. L.

Lee

(2019). The use of responsive circles in schools: An exploratory study. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 21(3), 181–194.

65.

Weick

K. E.

(1995). Sensemaking in organizations. Sage.

66.

Wong

D. S. W.

Cheng

C. H. K.

Ngan

R. M. H.

S. K.

(2011). Program effectiveness of a restorative whole-school approach for tackling school bullying in Hong Kong. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 55(6), 846–862. https://doi.org/10.1177/0306624X10374638

67.

Woulfin

S. L.

Rigby

J. G.

(2017). Coaching for coherence: How instructional coaches lead change in the evaluation era. Educational Researcher, 46(6), 323–328. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X17725525

68.

Yin

R. K.

(2018). Case study research and applications: Design and methods. Sage.

69.

Yoshizawa

(2025). Sensemaking, sensegiving, and the challenges of making school changes for students’ socioemotional wellbeing. Educational Administration Quarterly. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013161X251316587

70.

Zakszeski

Rutherford

(2021). Mind the gap: A systematic review of research on restorative practices in schools. School Psychology Review, 50(2–3), 371–387. https://doi.org/10.1080/2372966X.2020.1852056

71.

Zehr

(2002). The little book of restorative justice (1st ed.). Good Books.

72.

Zerubavel

(2000). Social mindscapes: An invitation to cognitive sociology. Harvard University Press.

73.

Zinsser

K. M.

Silver

H. C.

Shenberger

E. R.

Jackson

(2022). A systematic review of early childhood exclusionary discipline. Review of Educational Research, 92(5), 743–785. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543211070047