Estimation of Trabecular Thickness Using Ultrasonic Backcatter

Abstract

We present a method to estimate trabecular thickness (Tb.Th) in trabecular bones from ultrasound backscatter measurements. The estimation scheme is based on a nonlinear adjustment of predictions from a model to experimental data. The model assumes weak scattering from bone, where scattering is assumed to arise from the elastic solid trabeculae. The fluctuations of acoustical properties between bone tissue and the saturating fluid are assumed to be random and are described by the 3-D spatial autocorrelation function of the medium. In this paper, a Gaussian autocorrelation function is used. The inversion procedure is applied to a set of data measured on 33 femoral bone specimens. Results show that the model can predict both the magnitude and the frequency-dependence of the backscatter coefficient (root mean square error RMSE = 1 dB). The estimated trabecular thickness values are compared to the true trabecular thickness measured on high resolution microcomputed tomography 3-D reconstruction of bones microarchitecture. A close agreement is obtained on average over the group of specimens between predictions and the reference values: true Tb.Th is 132 ± 12 μm and estimated Tb.Th is 134 ± 15 μm. However, a moderate correlation between actual and estimated Tb.Th values is found (R² = 0.44, p<10⁻⁴, RMSE = 8.7 μm) suggesting a modest predictability at the individual level. Sources for the variability of the estimator are studied. Using synthetic rf signals, we demonstrate that the fundamental limitation of the estimator due to speckle noise is approximately 5 μm. Taking into account the measurement errors, the total uncertainty on Tb.Th estimates is of the order of 7 μm. The influence of the attenuation compensation function used to derive the backscatter coefficient is studied. In particular, we demonstrate the necessity of compensating for the effect of the gating time window. The results are discussed with respect to their meaningful clinical value. The requirements to be fulfilled by the performance of the technique change with regard to the question being posed. Two different strategies are examined: 1. characterize trabecular thickness without consideration of bone quantity (or bone mineral density) and 2. estimate trabecular thickness after adjustment for BMD. Considering the first strategy, a comparison between the precision of our estimator and the biological variability leads us to the conclusion that our estimator should only permit to distinguish between micro-architectures characterized by extreme values of trabecular thickness (i.e., very thin or very thick trabecular thickness). In this respect, it would be interesting to test whether the estimator is able to discriminate between rod-like (thin) and plate-like (thick) structures that are known to influence differently bone strength. The second strategy is more demanding in terms of technique performance and our estimator is not able yet to catch small differences in Tb.Th values expected after adjustment to bone density. Progress in the field will require a significant reduction in speckle noise and measurement errors and/or the development of other and more efficient microstructural estimators.

Keywords

Backscatter cancellous bone femur microarchitecture quantitative ultrasound (qus)trabecular thickness

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Lizzi

Greenebaum

Feleppa

Elbaum

Coleman

. Theoretical framework for spectrum analysis in ultrasonic tissue characterization, J Acoust Soc Am 73, 1366–73 (1983).

Lizzi

Ostromogilsky

Feleppa

Rorke

Yaremko

. Relationship of ultrasonic spectral parameters to features of tissue microstructure, IEEE Trans Ultrason Ferroelect Freq Contr 34, 319–29 (1986).

Ursea

Coleman

Silverman

Correlation of high-frequency ultrasound backscatter with tumor microstructure in iris melanoma, Ophthalmology 105, 906–12 (1998).

Coleman

Rondeau

Silverman

Correlation of microcirculation architecture with ultrasound backscatter parameters of uveal melanoma, Eur J Ophthalmol 5, 96–106 (1995).

Feleppa

Kalisz

Sokil-Melgar

Typing of prostate tissue by ultrasonic spectrum analysis, IEEE Trans Ultrason Ferroelect Freq Control 43, 609–19 (1996).

Lizzi

King

Rorke

Comparison of theoretical scattering results and ultrasonic data from clinical liver examinations, Ultrasound Med Biol 14, 377–85 (1988).

Hall

Insana

Harrison

Cox

. Ultrasonic measureemnt of glomerular diameters in normal adult humans, Ultrasound Med Biol 22, 987–997 (1996).

Ossant

Lebertre

Pourcelot

Patat

Ultrasonic characterization of maturation of fetal lung microstructure: an animal study, Ultrasound Med Biol 27, 157–69 (2001).

Oelze

O'Brien

Jr. Blue

Zachary

. Differentiation and characterization of rat mammary fibroadenomas and 4T1 mouse carcinomas using quantitative ultrasound imaging, IEEE Trans Med Imaging 23, 764–71 (2004).

10.

Jenson

Padilla

Laugier

Prediction of frequency-dependent ultrasonic backscatter in cancellous bone using statistical weak scattering model, Ultrasound Med Biol 29, 455–64 (2003).

11.

Consensus development conference: diagnosis, prophylaxis, and treatment of osteoporosis, Am J Med 94, 646–50 (1993).

12.

Steiniche

Christiansen

Vesterby

Marked changes in iliac crest bone structure in postmenopausal osteoporotic patients without any signs of disturbed bone remodeling or balance, Bone 15, 73–9 (1994).

13.

Parfit

Mathews

CHE

Villanueva

Relationships between surface, volume and thickness of iliac trabecular bone in aging and in osteoporosis, J Clin Invest 72, 1396–1409 (1983).

14.

Hudelmaier

Kollstedt

Lochmuller

Gender differences in trabecular bone architecture of the distal radius assessed with magnetic resonance imaging and implications for mechanical competence, Osteoporosis Int 16, 1124–33 (2005).

15.

Chaffai

Peyrin

Nuzzo

Ultrasonic characterization of human cancellous bone using transmission and backscatter measurements: relationships to density and microstructure, Bone 30, 229–37 (2002).

16.

Hans

Arlot

Schott

Do ultrasound measurements on the os calcis reflect more the bone microarchitecture than the bone mass?: a two-dimensional histomorphometric study, Bone 16, 295–300 (1995).

17.

Nicholson

Muller

Lowet

Do quantitative ultrasound measurements reflect structure independently of density in human vertebral cancellous bone?

Bone 23, 425–31 (1998).

18.

Njeh

Hans

Fuerst

Gluer

Genant

. Quantitative Ultrasound: Assessment of Osteoporosis and Bone Status (Martin Dunitz Ltd, London, 1999).

19.

Litniewski

Determination of the elasticity coefficient for a single trabecula of a cancellous bone: scanning acoustic microscopy approach, Ultrasound Med Biol 31, 1361–6 (2005).

20.

Wear

Garra

. Assessment of bone density using ultrasonic backscatter. Ultrasound Med Biol 24, 689–695 (1998).

21.

Roux

Robergeot

Porcher

Ultrasonic backscatter and transmission parameters at the os calcis in postmenauposal osteoporosis, J Bone Miner Res 16, 1353–1362 (2001).

22.

Wear

. Frequency dependence of ultrasonic backscatter from human trabecular bone: theory and experiment, J Acoust Soc Am 106, 3659–3664 (1999).

23.

Chaffai

Roberjot

Peyrin

Berger

Laugier

Frequency dependence of ultrasonic backscattering in cancellous bone: autocorrelation model and experimental results, J Acoust Soc Am 108, 2403–11 (2000).

24.

Faran

. Sound scattering by solid cylinders and spheres, J Acoust Soc Am 23, 405–418 (1951).

25.

Padilla

Peyrin

Laugier

Prediction of backscatter coefficient in trabecular bones using a numerical model of three-dimensional microstructure, J Acoust Soc Am 113, 1122–9 (2003).

26.

Mamou

Oelze

O'Brien

Jr. Zachary

. Identifying ultrasonic scattering sites from three-dimensional impedance maps, J Acoust Soc Am 117, 413–23 (2005).

27.

Insana

Wagner

Brown

Hall

. Describing small-scale structure in random media using pulse-echo ultrasound, J Acoust Soc Am 87, 179–192 (1990).

28.

Wear

Laib

The dependence of ultrasonic backscatter on trabecular thickness in human calcaneus: theoretical and experimental results, IEEE Trans Ultrason Ferroelectr Freq Contr 50, 979–86 (2003).

29.

Lizzi

Feleppa

Astor

Kalisz

Statistics of ultrasonic spectral parameters for prostate and liver examinations, IEEE Trans Ultrason Ferroelect Freq Contr 44, 935–42 (1997).

30.

Wear

, Fundamental precision limitations for measurements of frequency dependence of backscatter: applications in tissue-mimicking phantoms and trabecular bone, J Acoust Soc Am 110, 3275–82 (2001).

31.

Borah

Dufresne

Chmielewski

PAJ

Risedronate preserves bone architecture in postmenopausal women with osteoporosis as measured by three-dimensional microcomputed tomography, Bone 34, 736–46 (2004).

32.

Ulrich

Van Rietbergen

Laib

Ruegsegger

The ability of three-dimensional structural indices to reflect mechanical aspects of trabecular bone, Bone 25, 55–60 (1999).

33.

Bigelow

Oelze

O'Brien

Jr.

Estimation of total attenuation and scatterer size from backscattered ultrasound waveforms. J Acoust Soc Am 117, 1431–9 (2005).

34.

O'Donnel

Miller

. Quantitative broadband ultrasonic backscatter: An approach to non-destructive evaluation in acoustically inhomogeneous materials, J Applied Phys 52, 1056–1065 (1981).

35.

Oelze

O'Brien

Jr.

Frequency-dependent attenuation-compensation functions for ultrasonic signals backscattered from random media, J Acoust Soc Am 111, 2308–19 (2002).

36.

Laugier

Droin

Laval-Jeantet

Berger

In vitro assessment of the relationship between acoustic properties and bone mass density of the calcaneus by comparison of ultrasound parametric imaging and QCT, Bone 20, 157–165 (1997).

37.

Tuthill

Sperry

Parker

. Deviations from Rayleigh statistics in ultrasonic speckle. Ultrason Imaging 10, 81–9 (1988).

38.

Chaturvedi

Insana

. Error bounds on ultrasonic scatterer size estimates, J Acoust Soc Am 100, 392–9 (1996).

39.

Chaffai

Padilla

Berger

Laugier

In vitro measurement of the frequency dependent attenuation in cancellous bone between 0,2 − 2 MHz. J Acoust Soc Am 108, 1281–1289 (2000).

40.

Sigelmann

Reid

. Analysis and measurements of ultrasound backscattering from an ensemble of scatterers excited by sine-wave bursts, J Acoust Soc Am 53, 1351–1355 (1973).

41.

Jenson

Padilla

Bousson

In vitro ultrasonic characterization of human cancellous femoral bone using transmission and backscatter measurements: relationships to bone mineral density, J Acoust Soc Am 119, 654–63 (2006).

42.

Padilla

Jenson

Laugier

Statistical properties of ultrasound signal backscattered by human trabecular bones. in Proc 18th International Congress on Acoustics ICA 2004. (Kyoto, Japan).

43.

Wear

. Anisotropy of ultrasonic backscatter and attenuation from human calcaneus: Implications for relative roles of absorption and scattering in determining attenuation, J Acoust Soc Am 107, 3474–3479 (2000).

44.

Bland

Altman

Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement, Lancet 1(8476), 307–310 (1986).

45.

Lizzi

Rorke

King

Feleppa

. Simulation studies of ultrasonic backscattering and B-mode images of liver using acoustic microscopy data, IEEE Trans Ultrason Ferroelectr Freq Control 39, 212–226 (1992).

46.

Chappard

Laugier

Fournier

Roux

Berger

Assessment of the relationship between broadband ultrasound attenuation and bone mineral density at the calcaneus using BUA imaging and DXA, Osteoporosis Int 7, 316–322 (1997).

47.

Evans

Tavakoli

. Ultrasonic attenuation and velocity in bone. Phys Med Biol 35, 1387–1396 (1990).