Tissue-mimicking phantoms that are currently available for routine biomedical applications may not be suitable for high-temperature experiments or calibration of thermal modalities. Therefore, design and fabrication of customized thermal phantoms with tailored properties are necessary for thermal therapy studies. A multitude of thermal phantoms have been developed in liquid, solid, and gel forms to simulate biological tissues in thermal therapy experiments. This article is an attempt to outline the various materials and techniques used to prepare thermal phantoms in the gel state. The relevant thermal, electrical, acoustic, and optical properties of these phantoms are presented in detail and the benefits and shortcomings of each type are discussed. This review could assist the researchers in the selection of appropriate phantom recipes for their in vitro study of thermal modalities and highlight the limitations of current phantom recipes that remain to be addressed in further studies.
MadsenELDongFFrankGRGarrasBSWearKAWilsonT. Interlaboratory comparison of ultrasonic backscatter, attenuation, and speed measurements. J Ultrasound Med. 1999;18:615-31.
2.
WearKAStilesTAFrankGRMadsenGLChengFFeleppaEJ. Interlaboratory comparison of ultrasonic backscatter coefficient measurements from 2 to 9 MHz. J Ultrasound Med. 2005;24:1235-50.
3.
AndersonJJHerdMTKingMRHaakAHafezZTSongJ. Interlaboratory comparison of backscatter coefficient estimates for tissue-mimicking phantoms. Ultrason Imaging. 2010;32:48-64.
4.
CraciunescuOIHowleLECleggST. Experimental evaluation of the thermal properties of two tissue equivalent phantom materials. Int J Hyperthermia. 1999;15:509-18.
5.
PrakashPConverseMCMahviDMWebsterJG. Measurement of the specific heat capacity of liver phantom. Physiol Meas. 2006;27:N41-6.
6.
DivkovicGWLieblerMBraunKDreyerTHuberPEJenneJW. Thermal properties and changes of acoustic parameters in an egg white phantom during heating and coagulation by high intensity focused ultrasound. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2007;33:981-6.
7.
LeonardJBFosterKRAthleyTW. Thermal properties of tissue equivalent phantom materials. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 1984;BME-31:533-6.
8.
DavidsonSRSherarMD. Measurement of the thermal conductivity of polyacrylamide tissue-equivalent material. Int J Hyperthermia. 2003;19:551-62.
9.
SarkarSZimmermannKLengWVivekslandPZhangJDornH. Measurement of the thermal conductivity of carbon nanotube–tissue phantom composites with the hot wire probe method. Ann Biomed Eng. 2011;39:1745-58.
10.
BiniMGIgnestiAMillantaLOlmiRRubinoNVanniR. The polyacrylamide as a phantom material for electromagnetic hyperthermia studies. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 1984;31:317-22.
11.
OkawaiHKobayashiKNittaS. An approach to acoustic properties of biological tissues using acoustic micrographs of attenuation constant and sound speed. J Ultrasound Med. 2001;20:891-907.
12.
LafonCKhokhlovaVAKaczkowskiPJBaileyMRSapozhnikovOACrumLA. Use of a bovine eye lens for observation of HIFU-induced lesions in real-time. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2006;32:1731-41.
13.
OrtegaRTéllezALeijaLVeraA. Measurement of ultrasonic properties of muscle and blood biological phantoms. Phys Procedia. 2010;3:627-34.
14.
JohnsonHGrahamM. High Speed Signal Propagation: Advanced Black Magic. New Jersey, NJ: Prentice Hall;2003; pp. 29-120.
15.
LabudaCPChurchCC. Augmentation of HIFU-induced heating with fibers embedded in a phantom. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2011;37:442-9.
16.
CanneyMSKhokhlovaVABessonovaOVBaileyMRCrumLA. Shock-induced heating and millisecond boiling in gels and tissue due to high intensity focused ultrasound. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2010;36:250-67.
17.
HariharanPMyersMRBanerjeeRK. HIFU procedures at moderate intensities—effect of large blood vessels. Phys Med Biol. 2007;52:3493-513.
18.
ChoiSYKimYSSeoYJYangJChoiKS. Gas-filled phospholipid nanoparticles conjugated with gadolinium play a role as a potential theragnostics for MR-guided HIFU ablation. PLoS ONE. 2012;7:e34333.
19.
GuyAW. Analyses of electromagnetic fields induced in biological tissues by thermographic studies on equivalent phantom models. IEEE Trans Microw Theory Tech. 1971;16:205-14.
20.
VitkinIAMoriartyJAPetersRDKoliosMCGladmanASChenJC. Magnetic resonance imaging of temperature changes during interstitial microwave heating: a phantom study. Med Phys. 1997;24:269-77.
21.
FaraoneABalzanoQSimunicD. Experimental dosimetry in a sphere of simulated brain tissue near a half-wave dipole antenna. In: IEEE Symposium on Electromagnetic Compatability, (ed. IEEE-EMC Society), Denver, CO, 24-28 August 1998, pp. 906-11.
22.
KandaMYBallenMSalinsSChung-KwangCBalzanoQ. Formulation and characterization of tissue equivalent liquids used for RF densitometry and dosimetry measurements. IEEE Trans Microw Theory Tech. 2004;52:2046-56.
23.
LiZVogelMMaccariniPFStakhurskyVSoherBJCraciunescuOI. Improved hyperthermia treatment control using SAR/temperature simulation and PRFS magnetic resonance thermal imaging. Int J Hyperthermia. 2011;27:86-99.
24.
Bu-LinZBingHSheng-LiKHuangYRongWJiaL. A polyacrylamide gel phantom for radiofrequency ablation. Int J Hyperthermia. 2008;24:568-76.
25.
ScheppsJLFosterKR, The UHF and microwave dielectric properties of normal and tumour tissues. variation in dielectric properties with tissue water content. Phys Med Biol. 1980;25:1149-59.
26.
RobinsonMPRichardsonMJGreenJLPreeceAW. New materials for dielectric simulation of tissues. Phys Med Biol. 1991;36:1565-71.
27.
GabrielSLauRWGabrielC. The dielectric properties of biological tissues: III. Parametric models for the dielectric spectrum of tissues. Phys Med Biol. 1996;41:2271-93.
28.
LazebnikMMadsenELFrankGRHagnessSC. Tissue-mimicking phantom materials for narrowband and ultrawideband microwave applications. Phys Med Biol. 2005;50:4245-58.
29.
OzenSKoyluH. Phantom model of human brain tissue for cellular phone frequencies in electromagnetic field radiation absorption studies. GU J Sci. 2005;18:193-200.
30.
GabrielCGabrielSCorthoutE. The dielectric properties of biological tissues: I. Literature survey. Phys Med Biol. 1996;41:2231-49.
31.
PogueBWPattersonMS. Review of tissue simulating phantoms for optical spectroscopy, imaging and dosimetry. J Biomed Opt. 2006;11:041102.
32.
CheongWFPrahlSAWelchAJ. A review of the optical properties of biological tissues. IEEE J Quant Electron. 1990;26:2166-85.
33.
VogelAVenugopalanV. Mechanisms of pulsed laser ablation of biological tissues. Chem Rev. 2003;103:577-644.
34.
ElliottAMStaffordRJSchwartzJWangJShettyAMBourgoyneC. Laser-induced thermal response and characterization of nanoparticles for cancer treatment using magnetic resonance thermal imaging. Med Phys. 2007;34:3102-8.
35.
IizukaMNVitkinIAKoliosMCSherarMD. The effects of dynamic optical properties during interstitial laser photocoagulation. Phys Med Biol. 2000;45:1335-57.
36.
MatvienkoAMandelisAAbramsS. Robust multiparameter method of evaluating the optical and thermal properties of a layered tissue structure using photothermal radiometry. Appl Opt. 2009;48:3192-203.
37.
MadsenSJPattersonMSWilsonBC. The use of India ink as an optical absorber in tissue-simulating phantoms. Phys Med Biol. 1992;37:985-93.
38.
DimofteAFinlayJCZhuTC. A method for determination of the absorption and scattering properties interstitially in turbid media. Phys Med Biol. 2005;50:2291-311.
39.
van DongenKWVerweijMD. A feasibility study for non-invasive thermometry using non-linear ultrasound. Int J Hyperthermia. 2011;27:612-24.
40.
CuljatMOGoldenbergDTewariPSinghRS. A review of tissue substitutes for ultrasound imaging. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2010;36:861-73.
41.
BraceCL. Radiofrequency and microwave ablation of the liver, lung, kidney, and bone: what are the differences?Curr Probl Diagn Radiol. 2009;38:135-43.
42.
EdwardsDW. U.S. Patent 3653996. Houston, TX: Atlas Chemicals Industries; 1972.
43.
CheungAYKoopmanDW. Experimental development of simulated biomaterials for dosimetry studies of hazardous microwave radiation (Short Papers). IEEE Trans Microw Theory Tech. 1976;24:669-73.
44.
ChouCKChenGWGuyAWLukKH. Formulas for preparing phantom muscle tissue at various radiofrequencies. Bioelectromagnetics. 1984;5:435-41.
45.
JohnsonDZdericV. Design and construction of a flow phantom for HIFU research. In: IEEE Ultrasonics Symposium (ed. YuhasMP) New York, NY, 28-31 October 2007, pp. 1294-6.
46.
HuangJHoltRGClevelandRORoyRA. Experimental validation of a tractable numerical model for focused ultrasound heating in flow-through tissue phantoms. J Acoust Soc Am. 2004;116:2451.
47.
IshidaTKatoH. Muscle equivalent agar phantom for 13.56MHz RF-induced hyperthermia. Shimane J Med Sci. 1980;4:134-40.
48.
ItoKFuruyaKOkanoYHamadaL. Development and characteristics of a biological tissue-equivalent phantom for microwaves. Electron Comm Jpn (Part I). 2001;84:67-77.
49.
TakimotoTOnishiTSaitoKTakahashiMUebayashiSItoK. Evaluation on biological tissue equivalent agar-based solid phantoms up to 10 GHz—aiming at measurement of characteristics of antenna for UWB communications. In: Proceedings of ISAP (ed. IEICE), Seoul, South Korea, 3-5 August 2005, pp. 483-6.
50.
KatoHHiraokaMIshidaT. An agar phantom for hyperthermia. Med Phys. 1986;13:396-8.
51.
KatoHIshidaT. Development of an agar phantom adaptable for simulation of various tissues in the range 5-40 MHz. Phys Med Biol. 1987;32:221-6.
52.
ZhouTMeaneyPMFanningMWGeimerSDPaulsenKD. Integrated microwave thermal imaging system with mechanically steerable HIFU therapy device. In: Proceedings of SPIE, Energy-Based Treatment of Tissue and Assessment V (ed. RyanTP) San Jose, CA, 25-26 January 2009, p. 71810J.
53.
KaoTJSaulnierGJIsaacsonDSzaboTLNewellJC. A versatile high-permittivity phantom for EIT. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 2008;55:2601-7.
54.
BurlewMMMadsenELZagzebskiJABanjavicRASumSW. A new ultrasound tissue-equivalent material. Radiol. 1980;134:517-20.
55.
HoltRGRoyRA. Measurements of bubble-enhanced heating from focused, MHz-frequency ultrasound in a tissue-mimicking material. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2001;27:1399-412.
56.
FarnyCHHoltRGRoyRA. The correlation between bubble-enhanced HIFU heating and cavitation power. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 2010;57:175-84.
57.
RickeyDWPicotPAChristopherDAFensterA. A wall-less vessel phantom for Doppler ultrasound studies. Ultrasound Med Biol. 1995;21:1163-76.
58.
MadsenELFrankGRDongF. Liquid or solid ultrasonically tissue-mimicking materials with very low scatter. Ultrasound Med Biol. 1998;24:535-42.
59.
LaiCYKruseDECaskeyCFStephensDNSutcliffePLFerraraKW. Noninvasive thermometry assisted by a dual-function ultrasound transducer for mild hyperthermia. IEEE Trans Ultrason Ferroelectr Freq Control. 2010;57:2671-84.
60.
PoeppingTLNikolovHNRankinRNLeeMHoldsworthDW. An in vitro system for Doppler ultrasound flow studies in the stenosed carotid artery bifurcation. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2002;28:495-506.
61.
CubedduRPifferiATaroniPTorricelliAValentiniG. A solid tissue phantom for photon migration studies. Phys Med Biol. 1997;42:1971-9.
62.
ElliottAMShettyAMWangJHazleJDJason StaffordR. Use of gold nanoshells to constrain and enhance laser thermal therapy of metastatic liver tumours. Int J Hyperthermia. 2010;26:434-40.
63.
IizukaMNSherarMDVitkinIA. Optical phantom materials for near infrared laser photocoagulation studies. Lasers Surg Med. 1999;25:159-69.
64.
SiddiqiAKChoSH. Agar-based heat-sensitive gel with linear thermal response over 65–80 °C. J Therm Anal Calorim. 2013;111:1805-9.
65.
SolazzoSALiuZLoboSMAhmedMHines-PeraltaAULenkinskiRE. Radiofrequency ablation: importance of background tissue electrical conductivity—an agar phantom and computer modeling study. Radiol. 2005;236:495-502.
66.
LiuZAhmedMWeinsteinYYiMMahajanRLGoldbergSN. Characterization of the RF ablation-induced “oven effect”: the importance of background tissue thermal conductivity on tissue heating. Int J Hyperthermia. 2006;22:327-42.
67.
Ortega-PalaciosRLeijaLVeraACepedaMFJ. Measurement of breast - tumor phantom dielectric properties for microwave breast cancer treatment evaluation. In: 7th International Conference on Electrical Engineering Computing Science and Automatic Control (CCE) (eds. CadenasJAMCoelloCAGorbatchAP), Chiapas, Mexico, 8-10 September, pp. 216-9.
68.
AndreuccettiDBiniMIgnestiAOlmiRRubinoNVanniR. Use of polyacrylamide as a tissue-equivalent material in the microwave range. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 1988;35:275-7.
69.
SurowiecAShrivastavaPNAstrahanMPetrovichZ. Utilization of a multilayer polyacrylamide phantom for evaluation of hyperthermia applicators. Int J Hyperthermia. 1992;8:795-807.
70.
McDonaldMLochheadSChopraRBronskillMJ. Multi-modality tissue-mimicking phantom for thermal therapy. Phys Med Biol. 2004;49:2767-78.
71.
ParkSKGunturSRLeeKIPaengD-GChoiMJ. Reusable ultrasonic tissue mimicking hydrogels containing nonionic surface-active agents for visualizing thermal lesions. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 2010;57:194-202.
72.
BazrafshanBHubnerFFarshidPLarsonMCVogelVMänteleW. A liver-mimicking MRI phantom for thermal ablation experiments. Med Phys. 2011;38:2674-84.
73.
BouchardLSBronskillMJ. Magnetic resonance imaging of thermal coagulation effects in a phantom for calibrating thermal therapy devices. Med Phys. 2000;27:1141-5.
74.
LafonCZdericVNobleMLYuenJCKaczkowskiPJSapozhnikovOA. Gel phantom for use in high-intensity focused ultrasound dosimetry. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2005;31:1383-9.
75.
AroraMArvanitisCCoxECoussiosCC. Localization and enhancement of cavitation and heating during HIFU exposure using microparticles of high surface roughness. J Acoust Soc Am. 2008;123:2997.
76.
ZhangPPorterT. An in vitro study of a phase-shift nanoemulsion: a potential nucleation agent for bubble-enhanced HIFU tumor ablation. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2010;36:1856-66.
77.
KhokhlovaVABaileyMRReedJACunitzBWKaczkowskiPJCrumLA. Effects of nonlinear propagation, cavitation, and boiling in lesion formation by high intensity focused ultrasound in a gel phantom. J Acoust Soc Am. 2006;119:1834-48.
78.
ChoiMJGunturSRLeeKIPaengDGColemanA. A tissue mimicking polyacrylamide hydrogel phantom for visualizing thermal lesions generated by high intensity focused ultrasound. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2013;39:439-48.
79.
LafonCKaczkowskiPJVaezySNobleMSapozhnikovOA. Development and characterization of an innovative synthetic tissue-mimicking material for high intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) exposures. In: IEEE Ultrasonics Symposium (eds. YuhasDESchneiderSC), Atlanta, GA, 7-10 October 2001, pp. 1295-8.
80.
TakegamiKKanekoYWatanabeTMaruyamaTMatsumotoYNagawaH. Polyacrylamide gel containing egg white as new model for irradiation experiments using focused ultrasound. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2004;30:1419-22.
81.
MiyakawaMTakahashiNHoshinaS. A method for observing the three-dimensional patterns of electromagnetic power absorbed by the human body-the gel phantom of the human body used to study the electromagnetic environmental problem. Electron Comm Jpn (Part I). 1995;78:99-112.
82.
MiyakawaMHoshinaSKanaiY. Visualization and 3-D measurement of local SAR using a gel phantom. In: IEEE Symposium on Electromagnetic Compatibility, (ed. IEEE-EMC Society), Denver, CO, 24-28 August 1998, pp. 751-6.
83.
DabbaghAAbdullahBJJAbu KasimNHRamasindarumC. Reusable heat-sensitive phantom for precise estimation of thermal profile in hyperthermia application. Int J Hyperthermia. 2014;30:66-74.
84.
JiangCWuMCWuYS. Inducing occlusion effect in Y-shaped vessels using high-intensity focused ultrasound: finite element analysis and phantom validation. Comput Methods Biomech Biomed Engin. 2012;15:323-32.
85.
KamelSAliNJahangirKShahSMEl-GendyAA. Pharmaceutical significance of cellulose: a review. Express Polym Lett. 2008;2:758-78.
StaufferPRRossettoFPrakashMNeumanDGLeeT. Phantom and animal tissues for modelling the electrical properties of human liver. Int J Hyperthermia. 2003;19:89-101.
88.
YamamotoMIkadaYTabataY. Controlled release of growth factors based on biodegradation of gelatin hydrogel. J Biomater Sci Polym Ed. 2001;12:77-88.
89.
BigiACojazziGPanzavoltaSRoveriNRubiniK. Stabilization of gelatin films by crosslinking with genipin. Biomaterials. 2002;23:4827-32.
90.
ZhangYZVenugopalJHuangZMLimCTRamakrishnaS. Crosslinking of the electrospun gelatin nanofibers. Polymer. 2006;47:2911-7.
91.
MarchalCNadiMTosserAJRousseyCGaulardML. Dielectric properties of gelatine phantoms used for simulations of biological tissues between 10 and 50 MHz. Int J Hyperthermia. 1989;5:725-32.
92.
NadiMMarchalCRouaneAHedjiedjAKourticheDPrieurG. Effect of temperature variations on the dielectric properties of a radiofrequency, gelatin water phantom. In: 14th International IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society Conference (eds. MorucciJPPlonseyR.CoatrieuxJLLaxminarayanS), Paris, France, 29 October 1992, pp. 268-9.
93.
YuanYWyattCMaccariniPStaufferPCraciunescuOMacfallJ. A heterogeneous human tissue mimicking phantom for RF heating and MRI thermal monitoring verification. Phys Med Biol. 2012;57:2021-37.
94.
MadsenELFrankGRKrouskopTAVargheseTKallelFOphirJ. Tissue-mimicking oil-in-gelatin dispersions for use in heterogeneous elastography phantoms. Ultrason Imaging. 2003;25:17-38.
95.
LindnerULawrentschukNWeersinkRARazOHlasnyESussmanMS. Construction and evaluation of an anatomically correct multi-image modality compatible phantom for prostate cancer focal ablation. J Urol. 2010;184:352-7.
96.
BaldockCBurfordRPBillinghamNWagnerGSPatvalSBadawiRD. Experimental procedure for the manufacture and calibration of polyacrylamide gel (PAG) for magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) radiation dosimetry. Phys Med Biol. 1998;43:695-702.
97.
SunagaTIkehiraHFurukawaSTamuraMYoshitomeEObataT. Development of a dielectric equivalent gel for better impedance matching for human skin. Bioelectromagnetics. 2003;24:214-7.
98.
AndersonPGRouzeNCPalmeriML. Effect of graphite concentration on shear-wave speed in gelatin-based tissue-mimicking phantoms. Ultrason Imaging. 2011;33:134-42.
99.
KurodaMKatoHHanamotoKShimamuraKUchidaTWangY. Development of a new hybrid gel phantom using carrageenan and gellan gum for visualizing three-dimensional temperature distribution during hyperthermia and radiofrequency ablation. Int J Oncol. 2005;27:175-84.
100.
CaggioniMSpicerPTBlairDLLindbergSEWeitzDA. Rheology and microrheology of a microstructured fluid: the gellan gum case. J Rheol. 2007;51:851-65.
101.
KingRLHermanBAMaruvadaSWearKAHarrisGR. Development of a HIFU phantom. In: AIP, 6th International Symposium on Therapeutic Ultrasound (eds. CoussiosC-Cter HaarG), Oxford, UK, 30 August- 2 September 2006, pp. 351-6.
102.
YoshimuraKKatoHKurodaMYoshidaAHanamotoKTanakaA. Development of a tissue-equivalent MRI phantom using carrageenan gel. Magn Reson Med. 2003;50:1011-7.
103.
YoshidaAKatoHKurodaMHanamotoKYoshimuraKShibyaK. Development of a phantom compatible for MRI and hyperthermia using carrageenan gel-relationship between T1 and T2 values and NaCl concentration. Int J Hyperthermia. 2004;20:803-14.
104.
KatoHYoshimuraKKurodaMYoshidaAHanamotoKKawasakiS. Development of a phantom compatible for MRI and hyperthermia using carrageenan gel—relationship between dielectric properties and NaCl concentration. Int J Hyperthermia. 2004;20:529-38.
105.
KellomakiMTormalaP. Processing of resorbable poly-α-hydroxy acids for use as tissue-engineering scaffolds. Methods Mol Biol. 2004;238:1-10.
106.
FisherJWRylanderMN. Effective cancer laser-therapy design through the integration of nanotechnology and computational treatment planning models. In: SPIE, Plasmonics in Biology and Medicine V Vol. 6869 (eds. Vo-DinhTLakowiczosephJR), San Jose, CA, 21-22 January 2008, p. 68690D.
107.
SarkarSGurjarpadhyeAARylanderCGNichole RylanderM. Optical properties of breast tumor phantoms containing carbon nanotubes and nanohorns. J Biomed Opt. 2011;16:051304.
108.
KuoCKMaPX. Ionically crosslinked alginate hydrogels as scaffolds for tissue engineering: part 1. structure, gelation rate and mechanical properties. Biomaterials. 2001;22:511-21.
109.
ZellKSperlJVogelMNiessnerRHaischC. Acoustical properties of selected tissue phantom materials for ultrasound imaging. Phys Med Biol. 2007;52:N475-84.
