Recently there has been an intense debate amongst scholars on how to increase the practical relevance of research. Although the notion of ‘relevance’ is frequently mentioned in the literature, it is hardly ever defined and may have different, even contradictory, meanings in different contexts. This article presents a taxonomy of different forms of relevance, based on a textual analysis of the ‘relevance literature’ and of a set of 450 articles in three leading academic management journals that are renowned for their practical relevance. The main categories of this taxonomy are then discussed against the background of different aspects of the social dynamics of science in order to ascertain the forms of relevance that can justifiably be expected from management science.
Astley, W.G., and R.F. Zammuto1992‘Organization science, manager, and language games’ . Organization Science3: 443-460.
5.
Augier, M., and J.G. March2007‘The pursuit of relevance in management education’ . California Management Review94: 129-146.
6.
Babbie, E.2003The practice of social research. Belmont, CA: Thompson Wadsworth.
7.
Bailey, K.D.1997‘The autopoiesis of social systems: Assessing Luhmann’s theory of selfreference’. Systems Research and Behavioral Science14: 83-100.
8.
Barley, S.R., G.W. Meyer, and D.C. Gash1988‘Cultures of culture: Academics, pracititioners and the pragmatics of normative control’. Administrative Science Quarterly33: 24-60.
9.
Barnett, M.L., W.H. Starbuck, and P. Narayan2006‘Which dreams come true? Endogeneity, industry structure, and forecasting accuracy’ in Organizational realities - studies of strategizing and organizing. W. H. Starbuck (ed.), 509-566. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
10.
Bartunek, J.M.2007‘Academic-practitioner collaboration need not require joint or relevant research: Toward a relational scholarship of integration’ . Academy of Management Journal50: 1323-1333.
11.
Bartunek, J.M., J.R. Gordon, and R.P. Weathersby1983‘Developing "complicated" understandings in administrators’. Academy of Management Review8: 273-284.
12.
Bateson, G.1972Steps to an ecology of mind. New York : Ballantine.
13.
Beck, U., and W. Bonß1989‘Verwissenschaftlichung ohne Aufklärung?’ in Weder Sozialtechnologie noch Aufklärung? - Analysen zur Verwendung sozialwissenschaftlicher Wissens. U. Beck and W. Bonß (eds), 7-45. Frankfurt a. M.: Suhrkamp.
14.
Benders, J., and M. van Bijsterveld2000‘Leaning on lean: The reception of a management fashion in Germany’. New Technology, Work and Employment15: 50-64.
15.
Bennis, Waren G., and James O’Toole1983‘How business schools lost their way’. Harvard Business Review83/5: 96-104.
16.
Beyer, J.M., and H.M. Trice1982‘The utilization process: A conceptual framework and synthesis of empirical findings’. Administrative Science Quarterly27: 591-622.
17.
Black, F., and M. Scholes1973‘The pricing of options and corporate liabilities’ . Journal of Political Economy81: 637-654.
18.
Bloomfield, B.P., and A. Danieli1995‘The role of management consultants in the development of information technology: The indissoluble nature of socio-political and technical skills.’ Journal of Management Studies32: 23-46.
19.
Bowman, E.H.1990‘Strategy changes - Possible worlds and actual minds’ in Perspectives on strategic management. J. W. Fredrickson (ed.), 9-37. New York: Harper and Row.
20.
Buckley, M.R.G.R. Ferris, J.H. Bernardin, and M.G. Harvey1998‘The disconnect between the science and practice of management’. Business Horizons41/2: 31-38.
Chia, R., and R. Holt2006‘Strategy as practical coping: A Heideggerian perpective’ . Organization Studies27: 635-655.
23.
Choudhury, N.1986‘In search of relevance in management accounting research’. Accounting and Business Research12: 21-32.
24.
Cohen, D.J.2007‘The very separate worlds of academic and practitioner publications in human resource management: Reasons for the divide and concrete solutions for bridging the gap’. Academy of Management Journal50: 1013-1019.
25.
Conger, J.1991‘Inspiring others: The language of leadership’ . Academy of Management Executive5: 31-45.
26.
Daft, R.L., and A.Y. Lewin1990‘Can organization studies begin to break out of the normal science straitjacket? An editorial essay’. Organization Science1: 1-9.
27.
Davenport, T.H., and M.L. Markus1999‘Rigor vs. relevance revisited: Response to Benbasat and Zmud’. MIS Quarterly23/1: 19-23.
28.
Davenport, T., and C. Prusak1998Working knowledge. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
29.
Davis, M.S.1971‘That’s interesting! - Towards a phenomenology of sociology and a sociology of phenomonology’. Philosophy of the Social Sciences1/4: 309-344.
30.
Desai, P., A. Kalra, and B. Murthi2008‘When old is gold: The role of business longevity in risky situations’. Journal of Marketing72: 95-107.
31.
Dubin, R.1976‘Theory building in applied areas’ in Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology. M. D. Dunnette (ed.), 17-39. Chicago: Rand.
32.
Ferraro, F., J. Pfeffer, and R.I. Sutton2005‘Economics language and assumptions: How theories can become self-fulfilling’. Academy of Management Review30: 8-24.
33.
Gergen, K.J.1973‘Social psychology as history’. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology26: 309-320.
34.
Gergen, K.J.1992‘Organization theory in the postmodern era’ in Rethinking organization. M. Reed and M. Hughes (eds), 207-226. London: Sage.
35.
Ghoshal, S.2005‘Bad management theories are destroying good management practices’. Academy of Management Learning and Education4/1: 75-91.
36.
Ghoshal, S., and P. Moran1996‘Bad for practice: A critique of the transaction cost theory’. Academy of Management Review21: 13-47.
37.
Giddens, A.1987Social theory and modern sociology. Cambridge: Polity Press.
38.
Gulati, R.2007‘Tent poles, tribalism, and boundary spanning: The rigor-relevance debate in management research’. Academy of Management Journal50/4: 775-782.
39.
Hayes, R.H., and W.J. Abernathy1980‘Managing our way to economic decline’. Harvard Business Review58/4: 66-77.
40.
Hilgert, R.L.1972‘Business schools fail to communicate with managers: Some proposals for bridging the gap’. Business Horizons15/6: 59-63.
41.
Hodgkinson, G.P., P. Herriot, and N. Anderson2001‘Re-aligning the stakeholders in management research: Lessons from industrial, work and organizational psychology’. British Journal of Management12: 41-48.
42.
Huff, A.S.2000‘Changes in organizational knowledge production’ . Academy of Management Review25: 288-293.
43.
Jarzabkowski, P., and D. Wilson2006‘Actionable strategy knowledge: A practice perspective’ . European Management Journal24: 348-367.
44.
Kieser, A.1997‘Rhetoric and myth in management fashion’. Organization4: 49-74.
45.
Kieser, A.2002‘On communication barriers between management science, consultancies and business companies’ in Critical consulting . T. Clark and R. Fincham (eds), 206-227. Oxford: Blackwell .
46.
Kieser, A., and L. Leiner2009‘Why the rigour-relevance gap in management research is unbridgeable’. Journal of Management Studies46: 516-533.
47.
Kieser, A., and A. Nicolai2002‘Success factor research - overcoming the trade-off between rigor and relevance?’ Journal of Management Inquiry14: 275-279.
48.
Kieser, A., and B. Wellstein2008‘Do activities of consultants and management scientists affect decision making by managers?’ in The Oxford handbook of organizational decision making. Gerard P. Hodgkinson and William H. Starbuck (eds), 493-516. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
49.
Kirsch, W., D. Seidl, and D. van Aaken2007Betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung: Grundlagenfragen und Anwendungsorientierung. Stuttgart: Schäffer-Poeschel.
50.
Knorr, K.D.1977‘Policymakers’ use of social science knowledge - symbolic or instrumental?’ in Using social research in public policy making. C. H. Weiss (ed.), 165-182. Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath.
51.
Krippendorf. K.2004Content analysis: An introduction to its methodology. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
52.
Krohn, W., and G. Küppers1989Die Selbstorganisation der Wissenschaft. Frankfurt a. M .: Suhrkamp.
53.
Krohn, W., and G. Küppers1990‘The self-organization of science - outline of a theoretical model’ in Selforganization: Portait of a scientific revolution. W. Krohn, G. Küppers , and H. Nowotny (eds), 208-222. Dordrecht, Boston, London: Kluwer.
54.
Kuhn, T.S.1962The structure of scientific revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
55.
Lampel, J., and Z. Shapira1995‘Progress and its discontents: Data scarcity and the limits of falsification in strategic management’. Advances in Strategic Management12: 113-150.
56.
Latour, B.1987Science in action. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
57.
Liu, Y.2007‘The long-term impact of loyalty programs on consumer purchase behavior and loyalty’. Journal of Marketing71: 19-35.
58.
Luhmann, N., 1984‘Soziologische Aspekte des Entscheidungsverhaltens’ . Die Betriebswirtschaft44: 591-603.
59.
Luhmann, N.1989Ecological communication. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
60.
Luhmann, N.1993‘Theoretische und praktische Probleme der anwendungsbezogenen Sozialwissenschaften’ in Soziologische Aufklärung 3: Soziales System, Gesellschaft, Organisation. N. Luhmann. (ed.), 321-334. Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag.
61.
Luhmann, N.1994Die Wissenschaft der Gesellschaft. Frankfurt a. M.: Suhrkamp.
62.
Luhmann, N.2000Organisation und Entscheidung. Opladen : Westdeutscher Verlag.
63.
Luhmann, N.2005a ‘The paradox of decision making’ in Niklas Luhmann and organization studies. D. Seidl and K. Becker (eds), 83-104. Copenhagen : Copenhagen Business School Press.
64.
Luhmann, N.2005b ‘Communication barriers in management consulting’ in Niklas Luhmann and organization studies. D. Seidl and K. H. Becker (eds), 351-364. Copenhagen: Copenhagen Business School Press.
65.
McCabe, D.L., and L.K. Trevino1996‘What we know about cheating in college: Longitudinal trends and recent development’. Change28: 29-33.
66.
MacKenzie, D., and Y. Millo2003‘Negotiating a market, performing theory: The historical sociology of a financial derivatives exchange’. American Journal of Sociology109: 107-145.
67.
March, J.G.1991Decisions and organizations. New York : Wiley-Blackwell.
68.
March, J.G.1999The pursuit of organizational intelligence. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
69.
March, J.G., and R.I. Sutton1997‘Organizational performance as a dependent variable’ . Organization Science6: 698-706.
70.
Marcus, A.A., R.S. Goodman, and D.N. Grazman1995‘The diffusion of strategic management frameworks’ . Advances in Strategic Management12B: 115-145.
71.
Mayer, T.1993Truth versus precision in economics. Aldershot: Edward Elgar.
Merton, R.K.1957Social theory and social structure. Glencoe, IL: Free Press.
74.
Miles, M., and M. Huberman.1994Qualitative data analysis: An expanded sourcebook. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
75.
Miles, R.E., and C.C. Snow1978Organizational strategy, structure, and process. New York : McGraw-Hill.
76.
Mintzberg, H.2004Managers not MBAs: A hard look at the soft practice of managing and management development. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler .
77.
Mohrman, S.A., C.B. Gibson, and A.M. Mohrman2001‘Doing research that is useful for practice: A model and empirical exploration’. Academy of Management Journal44/2: 357-375.
78.
Mulkay, M., T. Pinch, and M. Ashmore1987‘Colonizing the mind: Dilemmas in the application of social science’. Social Studies of Science17: 231-256.
79.
Nicolai, A.T.2004‘The bridge to the "real world": Applied science or a "schizophrenic tour de force"?’ Journal of Management Studies41: 951-976.
80.
Nienhüser, W.1989Die praktische Nutzung theoretischer Erkenntnisse in der Betriebswirtschaftslehre. Stuttgart: Poeschel Verlag.
81.
O’Neill, H.M., R.W. Pouder, and A.K. Buchholtz1998‘Patterns in the diffusion of strategies across organizations: Insights from the innovation diffusion literature’. Academy of Management Review23: 98-114.
82.
Orth, U.R., and K. Malkewitz2008‘Holistic package design and consumer brand impressions’ . Journal of Marketing72: 64-81.
83.
Oviatt, B. and W.D. Miller1989‘Irrelevance, intransigence, and business professors’ . The Academy of Management Executive3/4: 304-312.
84.
Oxford English Dictionary 1989 OED, 2nd edn, Vol. 8: 561. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
85.
Pelz, D.C.1978‘Some expanded perspectives on use of social science in public policy’ in Major social issues - a multidisciplinary view. J. M. Yinger and S. J. Cutler (eds), 346-357. New York, London : The Free Press.
86.
Pfeffer, J.2005‘Why do bad management theories persist? A comment to Goshal’. Academy of Mangement Learning and Education4: 96-100.
87.
Pfeffer, J., and C.T. Fong2004‘The business school "business": Some lessons from the US experience’. Journal of Management Studies41: 1501-1520.
88.
Porter. L.W., and L.E. McKibbin.1988Management education and development: Drift or thrust into the 21st century?. New York: McGraw-Hill.
89.
Price, D.S.1963Little science, big science. New York : Columbia University Press.
90.
Ramani, G., and V. Kurmar2008‘Interaction orientation and firm performance’ . Journal of Marketing73: 27-45.
91.
Rich, R.F.1977‘Uses of social science information by federal bureaucrats - knowledge for action vs. knowledge for understanding’ in Using social research in public policy making. C. H. Weiss (ed.), 199-211. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
92.
Rittel, H.W., and M. Weber1973‘Dilemmas in a general theory of planning’ . Policy Sciences4: 155-169.
93.
Röbken, H.2004Inside the ‘knowledge factory’ - organizational change in business schools from a neo-institutional perspective. Wiesbaden: DUV.
94.
Ryals, L.2005‘Making customer relationship management work: The measurement and profitable management of customer relationships’. Journal of Marketing69: 252-262.
95.
Rynes, S.L., J.M. Bartunek, and R.D. Daft2001‘Across the great divide: Knowledge creation and transfer between practitioners and academics’. Academy of Management Journal44: 340-355.
96.
Rynes, S., T. Giluk, and K. Brown2007‘The very separate world of academic and practitioner periodicals in human resource management: Implications for evidence-based management’. Academy of Management Journal50: 987-1008.
97.
Scharff, R.C., and V. Dusek2003Philosophy of technology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
98.
Scherer, A.G.1998‘Introduction to the Special Issue: Theory pluralism and incommensurability in strategic management and organization theory: A problem in search of a solution’. Organization, Special Issue, 5: 147-168.
99.
Scherer, A.G., and M.J. Dowling1995‘Towards a reconciliation of the theory-pluralism in strategic management - incommensurability and the constructivist approach of the Erlangen school’. Advances in Strategic Management12A: 195-247.
100.
Scherer, A.G., and H. Steinmann1999‘Some remarks on the problem of incommensurability’ . Organization Studies20: 519-544.
101.
Seidl, D.2007‘General strategy concepts and the ecology of strategy discourses: A systemic-discursive perspective’. Organization Studies28: 197-218.
102.
Shapin, S.1995‘Here and everywhere: Sociology of scientific knowledge’ . Annual Review of Sociology21: 289-321.
103.
Shove, E., and A. Rip2000‘Users and unicorns: A discussion of mythical beasts in interactive science’. Science and Public Policy27: 175-182.
104.
Shrivastava, P.1987‘Rigor and practical usefulness of research in strategic management’. Strategic Management Journal8: 77-92.
105.
Starkey, K., and P. Madan2001‘Bridging the relevance gap: Aligning stakeholders in the future of management research’. British Journal of Management12: 3-26.
106.
Stehr, N.1992Practical knowledge: Applying the social sciences. London: Sage.
107.
Stichweh, R.1994Wissenschaft, Universität, Professionen - soziologische Analysen. Frankfurt a. M.: Suhrkamp .
108.
Strauss, A., and J. Corbin1998Basics of qualitative research: Techniques and procedures for developing grounded theory. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
109.
Teece, David J.1990‘Contributions and impediments of economic analysis to the study of strategic managent’ in Perspectives on strategic management . James W. Fredrickson (ed.), 39-79. New York: Harper Business.
110.
Thompson, J.D.1956‘On building an administrative science’. Administrative Science Quarterly1: 102-111.
111.
Tushman, M.L., C.A. O’Reilly, A. Fenollosa, A.M. Kleinbaum, and D. McGrath.2007‘Relevance and rigor: Executive education as a lever in shaping practice and research’. Academy of Management Learning and Education6/3: 345-362.
112.
Van Aken, J.E.2001Improving the relevance of management research by developing tested and grounded technological rules. Eindhoven: Eindhoven Centre for Innovation Studies.
113.
Van Aken, J.E.2005‘Management research as a design science: Articulating the research products of Mode 2 knowledge production in management’ . British Journal of Management16:19-36.
114.
Van de Ven, A.2000‘Professional science for a professional school - action science and normal science’ in Breaking the code of change. M. Beer and N. Nohria (eds), 391-446. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
115.
Van de Ven, A.2007Engaged scholarship: A guide for organizational and social research. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
116.
Weber, R.P.1990Basic content analysis. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
117.
Weick, K.E.1999‘That’s moving!’Journal of Management Inquiry8: 134-142.
118.
Weick, K.E.2007‘That’s moving!’Journal of Management Education31: 5-16.
Wensley, Robin2002‘A bridge over troubled water?’ European Journal of Management36/2: 391-400.
121.
Whitley, R.1984a ‘The scientific status of management research as a practically-oriented social science’. Journal of Management Studies21/4: 369-390.
122.
Whitley, R.1984b ‘The fragmented state of management studies: Reasons and consequences’. Journal of Management Studies21/3: 331-348.
123.
Whitley, R.1985‘Knowledge producers and knowledge acquirers: Popularisation as a relation between scientific fields and their publics’ in Expository science: Forms and functions of popularisation. Sociology of sciences. T. Shinn and R. Whitley (eds), 3-28. New York: Kluwer Academic.
Whitley, R.1995‘Academic knowledge and work jurisdiction in management’ . Organization Studies16: 81-105.
126.
Wren, D.A., M.R. Buckley, and L.K. Michaelsen1994‘The theory/applications balance in management pedagogy: Where do we stand?’ Journal of Management20: 141-157.
127.
Zell, D.2001‘The market-driven business school: Has the pendulum swung too far?’ Journal of Management Inquiry10: 324-328.
128.
Zinkhan, G.M., and R. Hirschheim, 1992‘Truth in marketing theory and research: An alternative perspective’. Journal of Marketing56/2: 80-88.
