Globally, the mix of private- and public-sector involvement in health care delivery is a focus of political concern. This concern in Canada takes place within the parameters of the federal Canada Health Act. Private for-profit activities in the health care sector in Canadian provinces have moderately shrunk the definition of ‘necessary medical and hospital services’ that must be provided by the public administration system under the federal Canada Health Act. In this article, we argue that the development of new technologies, pharmaceutical innovations, competing (non-health) demands on the federal dollar, and an aging population together create an environment where pressures for economic and political sustainability have led to some erosion of necessary health services in the provinces. Such pressures have, in turn, led to the growth of private commercial-sector health services. Within Canada’s federal system, provincial negotiation of the role of commercial health care organizations has developed in different ways in Ontario and Quebec. Such subnational developments are a significant focus for comparative health policy analysis.
Adams O. ( 2010) Health and Program Spending 1999-2008 and Selected Indicators 2010 Provincial Territorial Budgets. Ottawa, ON: Canadian Medical Association.
2.
Altenstetter C (ed.) (1978) Changing National-Subnational Relations in Health: Opportunities and Constraints . Betheda, MA: Geographic Health Studies and John E. Fogarty International Center for Advanced Study in the Health Sciences.
3.
Beltrame J. ( 2000) To ease crisis in health care, Canadians eye private sector . The Wall Street Journal, 10 April, p. B1.
4.
Berenson A. and Abelson R. ( 2008) Weighing the costs of a CT scan’s look inside the heart. The New York Times, 29 June, p. B1.
5.
Blank R. and Burau V. ( 2004) Comparative Health Policy. New York : Palgrave Macmillan.
6.
Boychuk GW ( 2004) The changing political and economic environment of health care. In: Marchildon GP, McIntosh T and Forest P-G (eds) The Fiscal Sustainability of Health Care in Canada, The Romanow Papers, Volume 1. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 320-39.
7.
Boychuk GW ( 2006) Provincial approaches to funding health services in the post-Chaoulli era. Paper presented at the Canadian Political Science Association Annual Meeting, June, York University, Toronto, ON.
8.
Castonguay C., Marcotte J. and Venne M. ( 2008) Rapport du groupe de travail sur le financement sur le système de santé; en avoir pour notre argent. Québec, QC: Gouvernement du Québec .
9.
CBC News (2006) Alberta’s ‘third way’ could mean health-care showdown with Ottawa. Available at: http.//www.cbc.ca/story/national/2006/02/28/thirdway060228.html (accessed 26 June 2007).
10.
Chodos H. and MacLeod JJ ( 2005) Examining the public/private debate in health care: Demystifying the debate. Available at: http//www.cpsa-acsp.ca/papers (accessed 10 July 2010).
11.
CIHI (Canadian Institute for Health Information) ( 2009) National Health Expenditure Trends, 1975-2009 . Ottawa, ON.
12.
Courchene TJ ( 2007) Quebec and the Canadian Federation: From the 1980 referendum to the summit of the Canadas. In: Murphy M (ed.) Quebec and Canada in the New Century: New Dynamics, New Opportunities. Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 201-32.
13.
Deber RB ( 2002) Delivering Health Care Services: Public, Not-For-Profit or Private? Discussion Paper Number 17. Saskatoon, SK: Commission on the Future of Health Care in Canada.
14.
De Palma A. ( 1999) Ottawa and Provinces (but not Quebec) in pact on national social programmes, The New York Times, 5 May, p. A6.
15.
Dutrisac R. ( 2008) Couillard dit non. Le Devoir , February. Available at: http://www.ledevoir.com/societe/sante/176941/couillard-dit-non (accessed 14 July 2001).
16.
Dutton PV ( 2007) A Comparative History of Health Problems and Solutions in the United States and France. Ithaca, NY: ILR Press.
17.
Evans RG ( 2004) Financing health care: Options, consequences, and objectives . In: Marchildon GP, McIntosh T and Forest P-G (eds) The Fiscal Sustainability of Health Care in Canada. The Romanow Papers, Volume 1. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 139-96.
18.
Forest P-G. and Bergeron KM ( 2005) Les politiques de reforme du système de santé dans cinque fédérations: Une analyse de travaux scientifiques récents. In: Imbeau LM (ed.) Politiques Publiques Comparées dans les États Fédérés: L’Allemagne, l’Australie, le Canada, les États-Unis et la Suisse. Québec, QC: Les Presses de l’Université Laval , 59-90.
19.
Finance Canada ( 2008) Major Federal Transfers: Public Tables. Ottawa, ON.
20.
Finance Canada (2009) Federal Support for Health. Ottawa, ON.
21.
Flood CM, Stabile M. and Tuohy C. ( 2008) Introduction: Seeking the Holy Grail: Financing for quality, accessibility and sustainability in health care systems. In: Flood CM, Stabile M and Tuohy C (eds) Exploring Social Insurance: Can a Dose of Europe Cure Canadian Health Care Finance?Montreal, QC: McGill-Queens University Press, 1-36.
22.
Gaumer B. and Fleury M-J. ( 2009) CLSCs in Quebec: Thirty years of community action . In: Palley HA (ed.) Community-Based Programs and Policies: Contributions to Social Policy Development in Health Care and Health Care-Related Services. Abingdon, UK, and New York, NY: Routledge , 87-104.
23.
Gilmour JM ( 2003) Regulation of free-standing health facilities: An entrée for privatization and for-profit delivery of health care . Health Care Journal. Special Edition: Health Law in the 21st Century: 131-52.
24.
Health Canada (2010) Wealth care system: Wait times in Canada. Available at: http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/hcs-sss/qual/access/wait-attente/index-eng.php (accessed 14 July 2010).
25.
Heisler MO and Peters GB ( 1977) Towards a multidimensional framework for the analysis of social policy. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences434(November): 60-9.
26.
Heuglin TO ( 1986) Federalism and Fragmentation: A Comparative View of Political Accommodation. Kingston, ON: Institute of Government, Queen’s University.
27.
Heuglin TO ( 2003) Federalism at the crossroads: Old meanings, new significance . Canadian Journal of Political Science36(June): 275-94.
28.
Janigan M. ( 2000) Stretching the Medicare envelope. Maclean’s47(April): 45-7.
29.
Jansen JL and Rodgers R. ( 2001) Cumulating the intellectual gold of case study research . Public Administration Review61(March/April): 235-46.
30.
Klein R. ( 2005) Speaking notes: Canadian club of Ottawa. Office of the Premier, Government of Alberta , 21 November, Edmonton, AB. Available at: http://www.canadianclubottawa.ca/en/events/archives/speeches/05/klein/html (accessed 14 July 2010).
31.
Krauss C. ( 2006) Canada’s private clinics surge as public system falters. The New York Times, 28 February, p. A3.
32.
Lee M. ( 2006) Is BC’s Health Care System Sustainable: A Closer Look at the Costs of Aging and Technology. Ottawa, ON: Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives.
33.
Leland J. ( 2008) Fast forwarding to age 85, with lessons on offering better care for elderly. The New York Times, 3 August, p. 18.
34.
Lévesque K. ( 2007) Un premier bloc opératoire privé s’ouvre à Montréal. Le Devoir, 22 Janvier.
35.
Mackie R. ( 2001) Romanow promises to look at private care. The Globe and Mail, 2 May, p. A4.
36.
Mackie R. ( 2004) Ontario boosts public system of MRI clinics; for-profit centres out, McGuinty says. The Globe and Mail, 25 September, p. A11.
37.
Minow M. ( 2003) Public and private partnerships: Accounting for the new religion. Harvard Law Review116(March): 1229-70.
38.
Monsebraaten L. and Orwen P. ( 1999) Series on welfare. Toronto Star .
39.
MSSS (Ministère de la Santé et des Services Sociaux) (2006) Guaranteeing Access: Meeting the Challenges of Equity, Efficiency and Quality. Québec, QC.
40.
Nagamine M., Jiang HJ and Merrill CT ( 2006) Trends in elderly hospitalizations, 1997-2004, statistical brief #14. Health Care Cost and Utilization Project: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality October: 6-8.
41.
Nathanson CA ( 2007) Disease Prevention as Social Change: The State, Society, and Public Health in the United States, France, Great Britain, and Canada . New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
42.
Noël A. ( 2009) Carte soleil ou carte de crédit?La Presse, 13 February.
43.
OECD (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development) (2005) Long-term Care for Older People . Paris, France: OECD.
44.
Official Gazette Du Québec Projet de règlement Loi sur les services de santé et les services sociaux (2007) (L.R.Q., c. S-4.2) 139e année, no 46 4493, 14 November.
45.
Ontario Association of Community Care Access Centers ( 2009) Current services and contracts. Available at: http://www.oaccac.on.ca (accessed 20 April 2009).
46.
Ontario Long Term Care Association (OLTCA) ( 2008) Telephone interview, January 28, Markham, ON.
47.
Ontario Ministry of Finance (1999) 1999 Ontario Budget: Budget Papers - Foundations for Prosperity. Toronto, ON: Ontario Ministry of Finance .
48.
Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care ( 2007) Challenges and Pressures Facing the Health Care System . Toronto, ON.
49.
Palley HA ( 2000) An essay review comparing the US and Canadian health care systems. Journal of Health and Social Policy11(3): 79-85.
50.
Palley HA and Forest P.-G (2004) Canadian fiscal federalism, regionalization, and the development of Quebec’s health care delivery system. New Global Development: Journal of International and Comparative Social Welfare20(2): 87-96.
51.
Payne G., LaPorte A., Deber R. and Coyte PC ( 2007) Counting backward to health care’s future: Using time-to-death modeling to identify changes in end-of-life mortality and the impact of aging on health care expenditures. The Milbank Quarterly85(2): 213-57.
52.
Picard A. ( 1999) Wide-open competition saves money, but draws fire: One-stop access centres simplify funding services. The Globe and Mail, 24 May.
53.
Pinker S. ( 2000) Montrealers ante up for private surgery. Canadian Medical Association Journal September: 163.
54.
Prémont M-C ( 2005) Le régime public universel de santé du Québec: D’agir suite au jugement de la Cour SuprêmeLe Devoir. Available at: http://www.healthcoalition.ca/chamcp.pdf (accessed 20 January 2007).
55.
Provincial-Territorial Ministers of Health ( 2000) Understanding Canada’s health care costs: Final report. Presentation to the 41st annual Premiers Conference, Canadian Intergovernmental Conference Secretariat, August, Winnipeg, MB. Available at: http://www./scics.gc.ca/pdf/850080012.e.pdf (accessed 14 July 2010).
56.
Provincial-Territorial Finance Ministers ( 2001) Addressing fiscal imbalance: Report of provincial and territorial ministers. Presentation to the 42nd annual Premier’s Conference, Canadian Intergovernental Secretariat, August, Victoria, BC. Available at: http://www.gov.bc.ca/igrs/en/fisca_imbalance_website_version_english.pdf (accessed 14 July 2010).
57.
Québec government (2008) Des suites au Rapport Castonguay - Des mesures immédiates afin d’améliorer la productivité et la performance du réseau de santé et des services sociaux. Press release, 11 March. Available at: http://communiques.gouv.qc.ca/gouvqc/communiques/GPQF/Mars2008/11/c2874.html (accessed 30 January 2009).
58.
Reinhardt UE ( 2003) Does aging of the population really drive the demand for health care? Health Affairs22(6): 27-39.
59.
Reinhardt UE ( 2004) The Swiss health system: Regulated competition without managed care. Journal of the American Medical Association292(10): 1227-31.
60.
Rosenau PV and Lako C. ( 2008) An experiment with regulated competition and individual mandates for universal health care: The new Dutch system. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law33(6): 1031-55.
61.
Safran DG, Newman P., Schoen, C. et al. (2005) Prescription drug coverage and seniors: Findings from a 2003 national survey. Health Affairs Web Exclusives at W5-152-166. Available at: www.healthaffairs.org
62.
Sansfaçon J-R. ( 2007) M. Couillard ‘doit intervenir’. Le Devoir, January.
63.
Sheppard R. ( 1999) The Harris factor. MacLean’s112(20): 18-23.
64.
Soderstrom L., Tousignant P. and Kaufman T. ( 1999) The health and cost effects of substituting home care for inpatient acute care: A review of the evidence. Canadian Medical Association Journal160(April): 1151-5.
65.
Solomon S. ( 2007) Chaoulli copycat cases crop up across country. Policy and Politics, 15 January.
66.
Statistics Canada (2005) Population by religion, by province and territory, 2001 Census of Population . Last modified: 2005-01-25. Accessed 8 March 2008.
67.
Statistics Canada (2007a) Population by knowledge of official language, by province and territory, 2006 census of population. Last modified: 2007-12-11. Accessed 8 March 2008.
68.
Statistics Canada (2007b) Population by year, by province and territory, 2006 census of population. Last modified2007-11-29. Accessed 8 March 2008 .
69.
Steinbrook R. ( 2006) Private health care in Canada. The New England Journal of Medicine354(16): 1661-4.
70.
Steward G. ( 2008) Alberta’s latest health makeover. The Toronto Star, 22 June, p. A17.
71.
Sullivan T. ( 2008) Between the dream and sleepwalking: Pragmatic possibilities for Canada. In: Flood CM, Stabile M and Tuohy C (eds) Can a Dose of Europe Cure Canadian Health Care Finance . Montreal, QC: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 221-31.
72.
Supreme Court of Canada (2005) Chaoulli v. Quebec (Attorney General), 2005 SCC 35, [2005] 1 S.C.R. 791, 9 June. Available at: http://scc.lexum.umontreal.ca/en/2005/2005scc35/2005scc35.html (accessed 20 January 2006).
73.
The Toronto Star (2008) Time to rethink on home care (editorial), January 24, p. A4.
74.
Tory J. ( 2007) John Tory’s plan to improve long-term care . National Post, 11 August, p. A19.
75.
Tuohy CH(2009) Single payers, multiple systems: The scope and limits of subnational variation under a federal health policy framework. Journal of Health Politics , Policy and Law34(4): 453-96.
76.
Williams AP, Barnsley J., Leggat S., Deber R. and Baranek P. ( 1999) Long-term care goes to the market: Managed competition and Ontario’s reform of community-based services. Canadian Journal on Aging18(2): 125-53.
77.
Winsor H. ( 1999) Ontario health-care expert cuts to the chase. The Globe and Mail, May 10.
