An Exploration of the Effect of On-Site 12-Step Meetings on Post-Treatment Outcomes among Polysubstance-Dependent Outpatient Clients

Abstract

Rates of return to active substance use after addiction treatment tend to be high; participation in 12-step fellowships (e.g., Alcoholics Anonymous) reduces relapse rates but many clients do not attend or attend for a short period only. This quasi-experimental study uses repeated measurement to explore the role of presence/absence of on-site 12-step meetings during treatment on post-treatment outcomes. Polysubstance-dependent clients (N = 219) recruited at a program with and one without 12-step on-site, were followed for one year post-treatment. On-site 12-step enhanced 12-step attendance, especially during treatment, and predicted continuous abstinence for the post-treatment year. Holding 12-step meetings on-site is a low-cost strategy that programs should consider to foster post-treatment remission maintenance.

Keywords

12-step treatment recovery self-help

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alcoholics Anonymous. 1990. Comments on AA's triennial surveys. NY: AA World Services. Inc.

Anglin, M.D. , Y. Hser , and C.E. Grella. 1997. Drug addiction and treatment careers among clients in DATOS. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors 11:308-23.

Best, D.W. , J.C. Harris , M. Gossop , V.C. Manning , L.H. Man , J. Marshall , J. Bearn , and J. Strang. 2001. Are the Twelve Steps more acceptable to drug users than to drinkers? A comparison of experiences of and attitudes to Alcoholics Anonymous AA and Narcotics Anonymous NA among 200 substance misusers attending inpatient detoxification. European Addiction Research 72:69-77.

Blomqvist, J. 2002. Recovery with and without treatment: A comparison of resolutions of alcohol and drug problems. Addiction Research and Theory 10:119-58.

Caldwell, P.E. , and H.S. Cutter. 1998. Alcoholics Anonymous affiliation during early recovery. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 15:221-28.

Carroll, K.M. , G.J. Connors , N.L. Cooney , C.C. DiClemente , D.M. Donovan , R.R. Kadden , R.L. Longabaugh , B.J. Rounsaville , P.W. Wirtz , and A. Zweben. 1998. Internal validity of Project MATCH treatments: Discriminability and integrity. Journal of Consulting & Clinical Psychology 662: 290-303.

Chappel, J.N. , and R.L. DuPont. 1999. Twelve-step and mutual-help programs for addictive disorders. Psychiatric Clinics of North America . 22:425-46.

Christo, G. , and C. Franey. 1995. Drug users' spiritual beliefs, locus of control and the disease concept in relation to narcotics anonymous attendance and 6-month outcomes. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 38:51-56.

Cloud, R.N. , C.H. Ziegler , and R.D. Blondell. 2004. What is Alcoholics Anonymous affiliation? Substance Use and Misuse 39:1117-36.

10.

Compton, W.M. , J.B. Stein , E.B. Robertson , D. Pintello , B. Pringle , and N.D. Volkow. 2005. Charting a course for health services research at the National Institute on Drug Abuse. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 293:167-72.

11.

Dennis, M. , C. Scott , R. Funk , and M. Foss. 2005. The duration and correlates of addiction and treatment careers. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 28 S1:51-62.

12.

DeStefano v. Emergency Housing Group, Inc. 2001. 247 F.3d 397, 414-16 2d Cir.2001.

13.

Emrick, C.D. , J.S. Tonigan , H. Montgomery , and L. Little. 1993. Alcoholics Anonymous: What is currently known? In Research on Alcoholics Anonymous: Opportunities and alternatives, edited by B. S. McCrady and W. R. Miller , 41-76. New Brunswick, NJ: Alcohol Research Documentation, Center of Alcohol Studies, Rutgers—The State University of New Jersey.

14.

Etheridge, R.M. , S.G. Craddock , R.L. Hubbard , and J.L. Rounds-Bryant . 1999. The relationship of counseling and self-help participation to patient outcomes in DATOS. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 57:99-112.

15.

Felner, R.D. , M. Ginter , and J. Primavera. 1982 Primary prevention during school transitions: Social support and environmental structure. American Journal of Community Psychology 103:277-90.

16.

Fiorentine, R. 1999. After drug treatment: Are 12-step programs effective in maintaining abstinence? American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 25:93-116.

17.

Fiorentine, R. , and M. Hillhouse. 2000. Drug treatment and 12-step program participation: The additive effects of integrated recovery activities. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 181: 65-74.

18.

Gossop, M. , J. Harris , D. Best , L.H. Man , V. Manning , J. Marshall , and J. Strang. 2003. Is attendance at Alcoholics Anonymous meetings after inpatient treatment related to improved outcomes? A 6-month follow-up study. Alcohol and Alcoholism 38:421-26.

19.

Hanson, M. , L. Foreman , W. Tomlin , and Y. Bright. 1994. Facilitating problem drinking clients' transition from inpatient to outpatient care. Health in Social Work 191:23-8.

20.

Hoffmann, N. , P. Harrison , and C. Belille. 1983. Alcoholics Anonymous after treatment: Attendance and abstinence. International Journal of the Addiction 18:311-18.

21.

Horgan, C. , S. Reif , G. Ritter , M. Lee , and G. Strickler. 2003. Who attends self-help following substance abuse treatment? Presented at the 131st Annual Meeting of the American Public Health Association, San Francisco.

22.

Hser, Y. , M. Anglin , C. Grella , D. Longshore , and M. Prendergast. 1997. Drug treatment careers: A conceptual framework and existing research findings. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 14:1-16.

23.

Hser, Y. , V. Joshi , M.D., Anglin , and B. Fletcher. 1999. Predicting post-treatment cocaine abstinence for first-time admissions and treatment repeaters. American Journal of Public Health. 89:666-71.

24.

Hser, Y. , C.E. Grella , S.C. Hsieh , M.D. Anglin , and B.S. Brown. 1999. Prior treatment experience related to process and outcomes in DATOS. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 57:137-50.

25.

Hser, Y. , D. Longshore , and M.D. Anglin. [this issue] . The life-course perspective on drug use: A conceptual framework for understanding drug use trajectory and its management . Evaluation Review.

26.

Humphreys, K. 1991. Factors predicting attendance at self-help groups after substance abuse treatment. Journal of Consulting & Clinical Psychology 594:591-3.

27.

———. 1997. Clinicians' referral and matching of substance abuse patients to self-help groups after treatment. Psychiatric Services 4811:1445-9.

28.

Humphreys, K. , P.D. Huebsch , J.W. Finney , and R.H. Moos. 1999. A comparative evaluation of substance abuse treatment: V. Substance abuse treatment can enhance the effectiveness of self-help groups. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research 233:558-63.

29.

Humphreys, K. , L.A. Kaskutas , and C. Weisner. 1998. The relationship of pre-treatment Alcoholics Anonymous affiliation with problem severity, social resources and treatment history. Drug & Alcohol Dep 49:123-31.

30.

Humphreys K. , and R. Moos. 2001. Can encouraging substance abuse patients to participate in self-help groups reduce demand for health care: A quasi-experimental study. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research 255:711-6.

31.

———. 2007. Encouraging post-treatment self-help group involvement to reduce demand for continuing care services: Two-year clinical and utilization outcomes. Alcohol Clinical and Experimental Research 31:64-8.

32.

Humphreys, K. , R.J. Moos , and C. Cohen. 1997. Social and community resources and long-term recovery from treated and untreated alcoholism. Journal of Studies on Alcohol 58:231-238.

33.

Johnson, N.P. , and J.N. Chappel. 1994. Using AA and other 12-step programs more effectively. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 11:137-42.

34.

Kaskutas, L.A. 1996 Pathways to self-help among women for sobriety. American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 22 (2): 259-80.

35.

Kaskutas, L.A. , L. Ammon , K. Delucchi , R. Room , J. Bond , and C. Weisner. 2005. Alcoholics Anonymous careers: Patterns of AA involvement five years after treatment entry. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research 29 (11): 1983-90.

36.

Kelly, J.F. , and R. Moos. 2003. Dropout from 12-step self-help groups: Prevalence, predictors, and counteracting treatment influences. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 24: 241-50.

37.

Kelly, J. , R. Stout , W. Zywiak , and R. Schneider. 2006. A 3-year study of addiction mutual-help group participation following intensive outpatient treatment. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research 30:1381-92.

38.

Kenny, D.A. , D.A. Kashy , and N. Bolger. 1998. Data analysis in social psychology. In The handbook of social psychology Vol. 1, 4th ed., edited by D. T. Gilbert , S. T. Fiske , and G. Lindzey , 233-65. Boston, MA: McGraw Hill.

39.

Kessler, R.C. , K.D. Mickelson , and S. Zhao. 1997. Patterns and correlates of self-help group membership in the United States. Social Policy 27:27-46.

40.

Kissin, W. , C. McLeod , and J. McKay. 2003. The longitudinal relationship between self-help group attendance and course of recovery. Evaluation and Program Planning 26:311-23.

41.

Klaw, E. , and K. Humphreys. 2000. Life stories of Moderation Management mutual help group members. Contemporary Drug Problems 27:779-803.

42.

Lamb, R. , M. R. Greenlick , and D. McCarty , eds. 1998. Bridging the gap between practice and research: Forging partnerships with community-based drug and alcohol treatment. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.

43.

Laudet, A. 2000. Substance abuse treatment providers' referral to self-help: Review and future empirical directions. International Journal of Self-Help and Self-Care 13:195-207.

44.

———. 2003. Attitudes and beliefs about 12-step groups among addiction treatment clients and clinicians: Toward identifying obstacles to participation . Substance Use and Misuse 38:2017-47.

45.

Laudet, A. , R. Savage , and D. Mahmood. 2002. Pathways to long-term recovery: A preliminary investigation. Journal of Psychoactive Drugs 34:305-11.

46.

Laudet, A. , V. Stanick , J. Carway , and B. Sands. 2004. Perceptions of Narcotics and Alcoholics Anonymous among polysubstance users newly admitted to outpatient treatment . 132nd Annual Meeting of the APHA, Washington DC.

47.

Laudet, A. , and W. White. 2004. An exploration of relapse patterns among former polysubstance users. Presented at the 132nd Annual Meeting of the American. Public Health Association, Washington, DC.

48.

———. 2005. An exploratory investigation of the association between clinicians' attitudes toward twelve-step groups and referral rates. Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly 231:31-45.

49.

Mankowski, E. , K. Humphreys , and R. Moos. 2001. Individual and contextual predictors of involvement in 12-step self-help groups after substance abuse treatment . American Journal of Community Psychology 294:537-63.

50.

Margolis, R. , A. Kilpatrick , and B. Mooney. 2000. A retrospective look at long-term adolescent recover: Clinicians talk to researchers. Journal of Psychoactive Drugs 321:117-25.

51.

Masudomi, I. , K. Isse , M. Uchiyama , and H. Watanabe. 2004. Self-help groups reduce mortality risk: A 5-year follow-up study of alcoholics in the Tokyo metropolitan area. Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences 58:551-7.

52.

McCrady, B.S. 1998. Recent research on twelve step programs. In Principles of addiction medicine. 2nd ed., edited by A. W. Graham , T. K. Schultz , and B. B. Wilford , 707-18. Chevy Chase, MD: American Society of Addiction Medicine, Inc.

53.

McIntire, D. 2000. How well does AA work? An analysis of published AA surveys 1968-1996 and related analyses/comments. Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly 184:1-18.

54.

McKay, J.R. 2001. Effectiveness of continuing care interventions for substance abusers. Evaluation Review 252:211-32.

55.

McKay, J.R. , A.I. Alterman , J.S. Cacciola , M.R. Rutherford , and C.P. O'Brien. 1997. Group counseling versus individualized relapse prevention aftercare following intensive outpatient treatment for cocaine dependence: Initial results. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 65:778-88.

56.

———. 1998. Predictors of participation in aftercare sessions and self-help groups following completion of intensive outpatient treatment for substance abuse. Journal of Studies on Alcohol 59:152-62.

57.

McKay, J.R. , A.I. Alterman , A.T. McLellan , and E.C. Snider. 1994.Treatment goals, continuity of care, and outcome in a day hospital substance abuse rehabilitation program. American Journal of Psychiatry 151:254-9.

58.

McLellan, A. , H. Kushner , D. Metzger , R. Peters , I. Smith , G. Grissom , H. Pettinatti , T. Hergueta , R. Baker , and G.C. Dunbar. 1992. The fifth edition of the Addiction Severity Index. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 9:199-213.

59.

McLellan, A. , D. Lewis , C. O'Brien , and H. Kleber. 2000. Drug dependence, a chronic medical illness: Implications for treatment, insurance and outcomes evaluation. Journal of the American Medical Association 284:1689-95.

60.

Moos, R.H. , and B.S. Moos. 2005. Paths of entry into Alcoholics Anonymous: Consequences for participation and remission. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research 29: 1858-1868.

61.

———. 2006. Participation in treatment and Alcoholics Anonymous: A 16-year follow-up of initially untreated individuals. Journal of Clinical Psychology 626:735-50.

62.

———. 2007. Protective resources and long-term recovery from alcohol use disorders. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 86:46-54.

63.

Moos R.H. , B.S. Moos , and C. Timko. 2006. Gender, treatment and self-help in remission from alcohol use disorders. Clinical and Medical Research 43:163-74.

64.

Moos, R. , J. Schaefer , J. Andrassy , and B. Moos. 2001. Outpatient mental health care, self-help groups, and patients' one-year treatment outcomes. Journal of Clinical Psychology 573: 273-87.

65.

Morgenstern, J. , D. Bux , E. Labouvie , T. Morgan , K.A. Blanchard , and F. Muench. 2003. Examining mechanisms of action in 12-step community outpatient treatment. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 72:237-47.

66.

Morgenstern, J. , and B.S. McCrady. 1993. Cognitive processes and change in disease-model treatment. In Research on Alcoholics Anonymous: Opportunities and alternatives, edited by B. McCrady and W. R. Miller , 153-66. New Brunswick, NJ: Alcohol Research Documentation, Center of Alcohol Studies, Rutgers—The State University of New Jersey.

67.

Morgenstern, J. , C. Kahler , R. Frey , and E. Labouvie. 1996. Modeling therapeutic responses to 12-step treatment: Optimal responders, non-responders, and partial responders. Journal of Substance Abuse 8:45-59.

68.

Morgenstern, J.E. Labouvie, B.S. McCray, C. W. Kahler , and R.M. Frey. 1997. Affiliation with Alcoholics Anonymous after treatment: A study of its therapeutic effects and mechanisms of action . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 655:768-77.

69.

National Institute on Drug Abuse. 2004. Report of the Blue Ribbon Task Force on Health Services Research at the National Institute on Drug Abuse. www.nida.nih.gov/about/organization/nacda/HSRReport.pdf. Accessed September 29.

70.

Nealon-Woods, M. , J.R. Ferrari , and L.A. Jason. 1995. Twelve-step program use among Oxford House residents: Spirituality or social support in sobriety? Journal of Substance Abuse 73:311-18.

71.

Ouimette, P.C. , R.H. Moos , and J.W. Finney. 1998. Influence of outpatient treatment and 12-step group involvement on one-year substance abuse treatment outcome. Journal of Studies on Alcohol 59:513-22.

72.

Pisani, V.D. , J. Fawcett , D.C. Clark , and M. McGuire. 1993. The relative contributions of medication adherence and AA meeting attendance to abstinent outcome of chronic alcoholics . Journal of Studies on Alcohol 54:115-19.

73.

Powers, K. , and M. Anglin. 1993. Cumulative versus stabilizing effects of methadone maintenance: A quasi-experimental study using longitudinal self-report data. Evaluation Review 17:217-43.

74.

Project MATCH Research Group. 1997. Matching alcoholism treatments to client heterogeneity: Project MATCH Post-treatment drinking outcomes. Journal of Studies on Alcohol 58 (1): 7-29.

75.

———. 1998. Matching alcoholism treatments to client heterogeneity: Project MATCH three-year drinking outcomes. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research 226:1300-11.

76.

Scott, C.K. , M.A. Foss , and M.L. Dennis. 2005. Pathways in the relapse-treatment-recovery cycle over 3 years. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 28:S63-72.

77.

Sheehan, D.V. , Y. Lecrubier , K. Harnett-Sheehan , P. Amorim , J. Janavs , E. Weiller , T. Hergueta , R. Baker , and G. C. Dunbar, G.C. 1998. The Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview M.I.N.I.: The development and validation of a structured diagnostic psychiatric interview. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 59 (Supp. l): 22-33.

78.

Sisson, R.W. and J.H. Mallams. 1981. The use of systematic encouragement and community access procedures to increase attendance at Alcoholic Anonymous and Al-Anon meetings. American Journal of Drug Alcohol Abuse 8:371-376.

79.

Smith, K. and M. Larson. 2003. Quality of life assessments by adult substance abusers receiving publicly funded treatment in Massachusetts. American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 29:323-335.

80.

Sobel, M.E. 1982. Asymptotic intervals for indirect effects in structural equations models. In Sociological methodology 1982, edited by S. Leinhart , 290-312. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

81.

Timko, C. , R. Billow , and A. DeBenedetti. 2006. Determinants of 12-step group affiliation and moderators of the affiliation-abstinence relationship. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 83: 111-121.

82.

Timko, C. , A. Debenedetti and R. Billow. 2006. Intensive referral to 12-Step self-help groups and 6-month substance use disorder outcomes. Addiction 1015:678-88.

83.

Timko, C. , A. Debenedetti , B.S. Moos , and R.H. Moos. 2006. Predictors of 16-year mortality among individuals initiating help-seeking for an alcoholic use disorder. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research 30:1711-1720.

84.

Timko, C. , J. Finney , R. Moos , B. Moos , and D. Steinbaum. 1993. The process of treatment selection among previously untreated help-seeking problem drinkers. Journal of Substance Abuse 53:203-20.

85.

Timko, C. , R.H. Moos , J.W. Finney , and M.D. Lesar. 2000. Long-term outcomes of alcohol use disorders: Comparing untreated individuals with those in Alcoholics Anonymous and formal treatment. Journal of Studies on Alcohol 61:529-40.

86.

Tonigan, J.S. , G.J. Connors and W.R. Miller. 2002. Participation and involvement in Alcoholics Anonymous. In Treatment matching in alcoholism: International research monographs in the addictions, edited by T. F. Babor and F. K. Del Boca, 184-204 Cambridge : Cambridge University Press

87.

Tonigan, J.S. , R. Toscova , and W.R. Miller. 1996. Meta-analysis of the literature on Alcoholics Anonymous: Sample and study characteristics moderate findings. Journal Studies on Alcohol 57:65-72.

88.

Troyer, T.N. , A.P. Acampora , and L.E. O'Connor. 1995. The changing relationship between therapeutic communities and 12-step programs: A survey. Journal of Psychoactive Drugs 27:177-80.

89.

Vaillant, G.E. [1983] 1995. The natural history of alcoholism revisited. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

90.

Walsh, D. , R. Hingson , and D. Merrigan. 1991. A randomized trial of treatment options for alcohol-abusing workers. The New England Journal of Medicine 325:775-82.

91.

Weiss, R.D. , M.L. Griffin , R. Gallop , L. Luborsky , L. Siqueland , A. Frank , L.S. Onken , D.C. Daley , and D.R. Gastfriend . 2000b. Predictors of self-help group attendance in cocaine dependent patients. Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs 61:714-19.

92.

Weiss, R.D. , M.L. Griffin , R.J. Gallop , L.M. Najavits , A. Frank , P. Crits-Christoph , M.E. Thase , J. Blaine , D.R. Gastfriend , D. Daley , and L. Luborsky. 2005. The effect of 12-step self-help group attendance and participation on drug use outcomes among cocaine-dependent patients. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 772:177-84.

93.

Weiss, R.D. , M.L. Griffin , R.J. Gallop , L.S. Onken , D.R. Gastfriend , D. Daley , P. Crits-Christoph , S. Bishop , and J.P. Barber. 2000a. Self-help group attendance and participation among cocaine dependent patients. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 60:169-77.