Linearity and Nonlinearity in HIV/STI Transmission

Abstract

A mathematical model of HIV/sexually transmitted infections (STI) transmission was used to examine how linearity or nonlinearity in the relationship between the number of unprotected sex acts (or the number of sex partners) and the risk of acquiring HIV or a highly infectious STI (such as gonorrhea or chlamydia) affects the utility of sexual behavior change measures as indicators of the effectiveness of HIV/STI risk-reduction interventions. Findings indicate that the risk of acquiring HIV through vaginal intercourse is essentially a linear function of the number of unprotected sex acts and is nearly independent of the number of sex partners. Consequently, the number of unprotected sex acts is an excellent marker for the risk of acquiring HIV through vaginal intercourse, whereas the number of sex partners is largely uninformative. In general, the number of unprotected sex acts is not an adequate marker for the risk of acquiring a highly infectious STI due to the highly nonlinear per act transmission dynamics of these STIs. The number of sex partners is a reasonable indicator of STI risk only under highly circumscribed conditions. A theoretical explanation for this pattern of results is provided. The contrasting extent to which HIV and highly infectious STIs deviate from the linearity assumption that underlies sexual behavior outcome measures has important implications for the use of these measures to assess the effectiveness of HIV/STI risk-reduction interventions.

Keywords

outcome evaluation (other than economic evaluation)design and evaluation of programs and policies measurement methodology (if appropriate)

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bowden

F. J.

Garnett

G. P.

2000. “Trichomonas Vaginalis Epidemiology: Parameterising and Analysing a Model of Treatment Interventions.” Sexually Transmitted Infections 76:248–56.

Cates

Jr Hinman

A. R.

1992. “AIDS and Absolutism-The Demand for Perfection in Prevention.” New England Journal of Medicine 327:492–4.

CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention). 2006. Sexually Transmitted Disease Surveillance, 2005, 1–186. Atlanta, GA: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

Chesson

H. W.

Gift

T. L.

2000. “The Increasing Marginal Benefit of Condom Usage.” Annals of Epidemiology 10:154–9.

Fishbein

1996. “Great Expectations, or Do We Ask Too Much from Community-Level Interventions?” American Journal of Public Health 86:1075.

Garnett

G. P.

Aral

S. O.

Hoyle

D. V.

Cates

Anderson

R. M.

1997. “The Natural History of Syphilis: Implications for the Transmission Dynamics and Control of Infection.” Sexually Transmitted Diseases 24:185–200.

Garnett

G. P.

White

P. J.

Ward

2008. “Fewer Partners or More Condoms? Modelling the Effectiveness of STI Prevention Interventions.” Sexually Transmitted Infections 84:ii4–11.

Holmes

K. K.

Johnson

D. W.

Trostle

H. J.

1970. “An Estimate of the risk of Men Acquiring Gonorrhea by Sexual Contact with Infected Females.” American Journal of Epidemiology 91:170–4.

Holtgrave

D. R.

Pinkerton

S. D.

2000. “Consequences of HIV Preventions Interventions and Programs: Spectrum, Selection, and Quality of Outcome Measures.” AIDS 14:S27–33.

10.

Katz

M. H.

Gerberding

J. L.

1998. “The Care of Persons with Recent Sexual Exposure to HIV.” Annals of Internal Medicine 128:306–12.

11.

Katz

R. P.

Caine

V. A.

Jones

R. B.

1990. Estimates of Transmission Probabilities for Chlamydial Infection. Chlamydial Infections: Proceeds of the Seventh International Symposium on Human Chlamydial Infections. New York: Cambridge University Press, 567–70.

12.

Mastro

T. D.

de Vincenzi

1996. “Probabilities of Sexual HIV-1 Transmission.” AIDS 10:S75–82.

13.

Miller

W. C.

Ford

C. A.

Morris

Handcock

M. S.

Schmitz

J. L.

Hobbs

M. M.

Cohen

M. S.

Harris

K. M.

Udry

J. R.

2004. “Prevalence of Chlamydial and Gonococcal Infections among Young Adults in the United States.” Journal of the American Medical Association 291:2229–36.

14.

National Institute of Mental Health Multisite HIV Prevention Trial Group. 1998. “The NIMH Multisite HIV Prevention Trial: Reducing HIV Sexual Risk Behavior.” Science 280:1889–94.

15.

NIMH Multisite HIV Prevention Trial. 1997. “Demographic and Behavioral Predictors of Sexual Risk in a Multisite HIV Prevention Trial.” AIDS 11:S21–7.

16.

Oakley

Fullerton

Holland

1995. “Behavioural Interventions for HIV/AIDS Prevention.” AIDS 9:479–86.

17.

Odets

1994. “AIDS Education and Harm Reduction for Gay Men: Psychological Approaches for the 21st Century.” AIDS & Public Policy Journal 9:3–15.

18.

Peterman

T. A.

Lin

L. S.

Newman

D. R.

Kamb

M. L.

Bolan

Zenilman

Douglas

J. M.

Jr Rogers

Malotte

C. K.

and The Project Respect Study Group. 2000. “Does Measured Behavior Reflect STD Risk? An Analysis of Data from a Randomized Controlled Behavioral Intervention Study.” Sexually Transmitted Diseases 27:446–51.

19.

Pinkerton

S. D.

Abramson

P. R.

1993. “Evaluating the Risks: A Bernoulli Process Model of HIV Infection and Risk Reduction.” Evaluation Review 17:504–28.

20.

Pinkerton

S. D.

Abramson

P. R.

1996. “Occasional Condom use and HIV Risk Reduction.” Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes and Human Retrovirology 13:456–60.

21.

Pinkerton

S. D.

Chesson

H. W.

Layde

P. M.

and NIMH Multisite HIV Prevention Trial Group. 2002. “Utility of Behavioral Changes as Markers of Sexually Transmitted Disease Risk Reduction in Sexually Transmitted Disease/HIV Prevention Trials.” Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes 31:71–9.

22.

Pinkerton

S. D.

Layde

P. M.

DiFranceisco

Chesson

H. W.

and NIMH Multisite HIV Prevention Trial Group. 2003. “All STDs are not Created Equal: An Analysis of the Differential Effects of Sexual Behavior Changes on Different STDs.” International Journal of STD & AIDS 14:320–8.

23.

Pinkerton

S. D.

Layde

P. M.

and NIMH Multisite HIV Prevention Trial Group. 2002. “Using Sexually Transmitted Disease Incidence as a Surrogate Marker for HIV Incidence in Prevention Trials. A Modeling Study.” Sexually Transmitted Diseases 29:298–307.

24.

Royce

R. A.

Seña

Cates

Jr Cohen

M. S.

1997. “Sexual Transmission of HIV.” New England Journal of Medicine 336:1072–8.

25.

Stephenson

J. M.

Imrie

Sutton

S. R.

2000. “Rigorous Trials of Sexual Behaviour Interventions in STD/HIV Prevention: What Can We Learn from them?” AIDS 14:S115–24.

26.

Stone

K. M.

1994. “HIV, Other STDs, and Barriers.” In Barrier Contraceptives: Current Status and Future Prospects, edited by Mauck

C. K.

Cordero

Gabelnick

H. L.

Spieler

J. M.

Rivera

203–12. New York: John Wiley.